Thomas Muller’s recent comments have once again gotten US Soccer social media buzzing with demands for pro/rel. I’ll return to the irony of Thomas Muller making these comments but first:
Of all the "Europe does it so it has to be right..." delusions US Soccer fans throw around, "Pro/Rel is the key to unlocking the game in the US" is by far the most popular and most absurd. We need to get over it for the following reasons:
it doesn't make bottom table teams better
it doesn't make players or fans take the game more seriously
it doesn't make the league more interesting or competitive
it isn't the proven model for the most successful leagues
it won't grow the game in USA
Europeans only believe in it in theory, not in practice.
It doesn't make bottom teams better.
The argument always goes: if there's a risk of relegation, players play harder and owners invest more because there is so much at stake.
This makes intuitive sense, but it doesn't play out in practice. Man City didn't break spending rules out of fear of relegation. PSG didn't become the best club in Europe thanks to hard-learned lessons from surviving relegation. ManU isn't in the relegation zone because of a lack of ambition or spending.
The best teams in Europe face no risk of relegation, yet they get the best players, they spend the most money, they have the biggest fan bases. Regardless of how many teams "fight for their lives", the same number of teams get relegated every year. It’s hard to really claim pro/rel produces success and rewards complacency when it punishes teams that try, and the teams that thrive were never in the conversation.
Those relegated teams have to sell off players, making them worse. The teams that get promoted have to buy new players (they can't afford), and often have to sell the very players that got them promoted. Maybe they stay up for a year or two, maybe they don't, but the same crop of teams bounce between promotion and relegation for decades, continuing to “fight for their lives” and the process never improves them to the point of competing with the big clubs (who aren’t fighting for thier lives).
“Teams at the bottom need to be punished to play better,” is the sports equivalent of CEOs saying, “employees don’t need better pay, they just need to work harder.”
2) It doesn’t make players and fans take the game more seriously.
American sports have never had pro/rel, and we are the most successful and sports-obsessed nation on the planet. Texas HS’s dont need pro/rel or even pay for the local HS Football team to go out and “fight for their lives” every week, because slugging it out on the gridiron is part of the culture and has been for generations. Without pro/rel, college football was taken so seriously it did more to integrate schools in the south than Brown v. Board.
Athletes put their all into sports or other pursuits because they view it as an extension of themselves. They define themselves by how they succeed. Americans have committed themselves wholly and completely to being Olympians, Baseballers, Basketballers, Hockey players, without ever needing the threat of relegation to make them work harder.
Pro/rel is something that developed organically in ENGLISH sporting culture. As they spread the game, they spread the idea that pro/rel is inherent to the game. Making Soccer a serious part of American culture doesn’t require making the game LESS American. Particularly, since the leagues held up as the justification for Pro/rel aren’t more successful than American sports leagues.
3) It doesn't make the league more interesting or competitive.
One of the greatest moments in US sports occurred in 2001 when a 6th-round pick named Tom Brady came on for the injured Drew Bledsoe and led the Patriots to the first of several Super Bowls. Most people forget that in 2000, the Pats had finished last in the AFC East. The year before, in 1999, the St. Louis Rams, the "Greatest Show on Turf" won the Superbowl, a year after finishing 4-12 and also being last in their division.
These worst-to-first stories are one of the greatest things in US Sports. The ultimate one occurred in 2007 when the Celtics, having finished last in the East Conference, brought in Kevin Garnett and Ray Allen, who led the Celtics to a championship the next year.
Pro/Rel is SPECIFICALLY designed to prevent these stories from happening. The closest European Soccer has is 2015-16 Liechester City, who did what the system was designed to prevent: they won the league only their second season after promotion.
In a pro/rel world, rather than aquire the "Boston Three Party" in 2007, the relegated Celtics would have sold Paul Pierce, likely to the Pistons or Mavs or another team that was already on top, and it would been years before they were relevant again (from relegation to Champion, Liechester's "worst to first" story took twelve years).
That's the true outcome of pro/rel: the "have-nots" sell players they can't afford, to clubs who don't need them. The ultimate result is a less competitive league.
In the last 20 years, the following number of different teams have each won a championship:
NFL, NHL, MLS: 13
MLB, NBA: 12
Ligue 1: 7
EPL: 6
Bundesliga: 5
Serie A: 4
La Liga: 3
American sports function on an "even playing field" model. Pro/rel is an "enrich the aristocrats while the peasantry canibalize themselves" model.
4) It isn't the proven model for the most successful leagues
In 2024-25, the big 5 made approximately:
EPL: $9.2B
Bundesliga: $5.62B
LaLiga: $5.3B
Serie A: $3.9B
Ligue 1: $2.88B
Total: $24.6B
In 2025, the American leagues made:
NFL: $23.5B
NBA: $14.5B
MLB: $13.2B
NHL: $8.3B
EPL made slightly more than the NHL while every other soccer league in the world made less. The NFL made almost as much as the top 5 european leagues combined, despite 90-95% of NFL costumers being domestic, and roughly 70% of EPL viewership being international. America runs a better business in a mono-national sport than the Europeans leagues in the world’s most popular sport. Yet people claim making the league less American, will grow the league?
5) It won't grow the game in USA
The thing that grows Soccer in the USA is USMNT success. The most important thing MLS does and can do to grow the game is develop players who can go on to succeed at the highest level. MLS’s commitment to youth development has grown spectacularly over the last decade and teenagers set records all over the league this season. Pro/rel would actively undermine that because teams in relegation battles don’t play the kids.
Last season Ajax and Twente led the Erdivise in minutes for players under 20, the two teams that got relegated gave a combined total of 6 minutes to teenages. In the Bundesliga, RB Leipzig led the league in U-20 minutes, while last-place St. Pauli gave 0 mins.
Pro/rel-fetishists complain “bottom table teams have nothing to play for at the end of the year.” They have one thing to play for, and it’s the only thing that will have long-term impact on the growth of the game in America: giving young players experience.
6) Europeans believe in pro/rel in theory, not in practice.
People are pointing to Thomas Muller, a man who has won practically everything in the sport, as a man who knows how to succeed in this game, so his statement must be right… except, Muller has never faced a relegation battle. Leo Messi, Christiano Ronaldo, Kylian Mbappe, Harry Kane, not a single relegation battle between them. Yet they are arguably the greatest players their nations have ever produced.
Julian Naglesman wasn’t so impressed by the Wolfsburg’s “fighting spirit” avoiding relegation that he called a bunch of Wolves up for the WC (for a squad that lacked fighting spirit). England, France, Spain, aren’t looking to relegation survivors when putting their NTs together. They exclusively look at clubs that only compete for glory, never out of fear.
The Super League was literally an effort by the best clubs in the world to create a competition that had the top teams locked in. When the Premier League was created in the 90s, they had no intention of having Pro/rel. Only after the EFA refused to recognize the league, thereby denying them access to European competition, did they begrudgingly create a pro/rel agreement with the EFL.
Pro/rel doesnt make the league better, it doesn’t improve performance and even the european clubs and managers don’t actually believe in it. Stop fetishizing what England does, and start thinking about how to make Soccer more a part of AMERICAN culture.