r/urbanplanning • • Aug 26 '24

Discussion "Rents in Minneapolis need to grow 15-20% to justify the cost of new construction. You won't see many new buildings in the city until that happens. Not an opinion. Just math."

75 Upvotes

I found this comment by chance on Twitter from some "small developer" in the Twin Cities Metro area named Sean Sweeney, and his tweet even got the former economist from RealPage to interact with his tweet (where he basically agreed with his thesis) and I don't know how to process this other than expressing pure schadenfreude. As a Leftist Urbanist, I don't see how some random developer expressing sentiment like this saying the quiet part out loud in one of the YIMBY "success story" cities mind you, doesn't massively embarrass the movement and even more broadly discredit the main thesis of Market Urbanist dogma in general.

Potential counterarguments:

A. Minneapolis enacted rent control- Their rent control law only applies to units built before 1995, it doesn't affect new builds

B. "Interest rates"- The FED has literally signaled that it's going to cut interest rates, this news should activate a critical mass of new financing for projects/permits, yet, I highly doubt this will happen because (say it with me Capitalists:) any Capitalist with a valuable inelastic asset has an interest in keeping his asset's price as high as possible, otherwise he's a bad Capitalist.

C. "But Austin!"- Permits are down by 10% in Austin when compared to a year ago. This is also true for International YIMBY "success story cities" like Auckland which is down 23% year on year

D. "More deregulation will solve this!"- See below

Why I give a damn:

I'm mainly bringing this point up because two months ago I literally theorized this exact same phenomenon would happen (I called it the "Yo-Yo effect") and literally every YIMBY/Market Urbanist on the sub downvoted me and suggested that my post was stupid/not real/Marxist nonsense. But yet....... here we are. If anyone in the near future finds a whitepaper, article, or book with the term "Yo-Yo effect" in it, I'll give you a hundred dollars if you send it to me (and I'm completely serious).

I'm not gonna lie, a Leftist having the last laugh on a matter related to Capitalism is incredibly on brand.

If anyone wants me to make any other predictions, I'm all for it, I'll start off by giving a free one: There's a 50-50 chance in the near future that either the city of Detroit will be split into several different cities, or, Metro Detroit (Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and Essex counties, Essex will come a lot later though) will combine into one consolidated municipality with the largest city council in the Anglophone world.


r/urbanplanning • • Dec 21 '24

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: People will continue to prefer suburbs

8 Upvotes

The reality is that most of the pro-urbanism people are people who are young and don't have children.

For the rest of America, the desire to live in a suburb has actually *increased*: https://www.homeinspector.org/Newsroom/Articles/Pros-and-Cons-of-City-Living-vs-Life-in-Suburbia/15880/Article

The average person looks at the crime and homelessness in places like SF and thinks "yikes".

This situation won't change until the real problems are addressed:

  1. Bad schools in the cities

  2. Visible homelessness- it doesn't matter if you point to murder statistics, it makes people *feel* unsafe, and frankly a lot of property crime goes unreported.

  3. Public transit sucks due to low buildout and crime, which makes people use cars, which suck in cities

  4. High housing prices

  5. High prices in general in cities

To be clear, I think that cities can be awesome, but I think that there's a huge amount of groupthink in urbanism circles and a perception that anyone who prefers suburbs is obviously dumb, which just isn't true.


r/urbanplanning • • Feb 26 '24

Other "Today's luxury housing is tomorrow's affordable housing" is a common urbanist saying that I disagree with

4 Upvotes

I see a lot of people in YIMBY spaces claim that "today's luxury is tomorrow's affordable housing" and I find that to be a generalization that is quite often not true. For instance, there are loads of prewar buildings that were for the rich back then, and still are today. The Dakota was built in 1884 and is one of the most exclusive properties in the whole city.

Often, buildings do the opposite of become more affordable with age! Many 1800s tenements in Manhattan have been renovated and have wealthy people living in them. Brownstones went through a transformation of being built for people with means, then becoming less desirable over time, to now being exorbitantly expensive.

And these days, there are obvious signs of apartments actually being "luxury" rather than just new. Indoor pools, indoor rock climbing, giant apartments, etc. and rents way above average market rate, are features that cater to the luxury market and aren't just standard amenities of new apartments.

Overall, it seems that apartments can go in either direction and become more/less desirable with age. Location is generally the biggest factor in how much an apartment costs, hence luxury apartments in Midwestern cities going for less than shoebox walkup apartments in Manhattan.

I am NOT against building luxury housing, provided that it's not some wasteful project that results in a net loss in units. And in some markets, the luxury apartments are actually pretty reasonably priced (not NYC or LA obviously).

But I wish urbanists would stop pretending that the concept of "luxury housing" doesn't exist.


r/urbanplanning • • Apr 09 '24

Discussion Are all/most planners anti-graffiti or are cities changing their perspectives?

0 Upvotes

I know graffiti is seen as “vandalism” but what room can we make in our cities to accommodate those activities?


r/urbanplanning • • Mar 15 '24

Urban Design Why does the Neatherlands use brick for streets instead of asphalt? How does this negatively impact Dutch society?

2 Upvotes

I've been exploring the country on Google maps. In any city, you will find the streets are brick, and the collectors, arterials, and highways are asphalt.

There is a lot of discussion about the positives of brick streets that I have read. I live in a city in the United States with poor asphalt streets; many pot holes that the city has a hard time fixing, and overall poor maintenance of the street. However, before I want to start possibly advocating for brick streets as a solution to the problems with our streets, I want to understand the problems with brick streets.

Some problems I have heard are handicap accessibility, unpleasant surface to drive or bike on compared to asphalt, high cost, and maintenance. In a country utilizing brick for street infrastructure, the Neatherlands must face these problems on a huge scale

So, how have these negatives affected Dutch society as a whole? How do these effects compare to the effects of asphalt streets in a country like the United States?

Let's start a discussion!


r/urbanplanning • • Dec 30 '23

Discussion Am I stupid? Are mega skyscrapers that are self contained cities a good idea? For there to be absolutely no roads and for them to be 10km apart and supplied by hydrogen airships?

0 Upvotes

Just a stupid argument I'm having with a "friend". Apparently every super building is 600m tall and 100m diameter at the top and 200m at the bottom. More or less 10,000 people and there is only wilderness inbetween. Not a fucking Road in sight. Because that's a good idea. He is also against trains and busses and claims that single seater electric cars would be more efficient :). These gigantic behemoths should also somehow be powered by "renewable" energy (e.g. solar and wind) whilst still containing some sort of means of production. Please. I beg of you. Tell me I'm not stupid. Am I stupid? Would such a world be possible? Would it solve the "space" problem? Is it more space efficient.


r/urbanplanning • • Apr 09 '24

Public Health America's Urban Crime Problem

0 Upvotes

I would preface this post by saying that planners don't really have much control over crime in urban areas, but I feel the issue is relevant. So while crime may not be directly planning related, it is urbanism related similar to the issue of urban vs. suburban schools.

All that said I believe that urban crime is a problem that should be taken more seriously. While I do think people often use the issue for purposes of rhetoric that aren't very useful, it's still something needs addressing. I believe substantially higher than average crime rates are major barrier to many places making a comeback. Alongside inferior schools, high urban crime rates encourage wealthier and middle class residents to migrate to the suburbs. Plus the crime problem affects schools to a large degree. The people who bear the brunt of its affects are lower in income because they have less ability to move.

It doesn't make sense to pick on particular cities, since all of them have a crime problem. We see a trend of substantially higher than average homicide rates across major US cities, both older and newer.

The cities that seem do the best, at least larger cities are NYC and San Diego.

San Diego has a homicide rate ranging from 2 - 4 per 100,000

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/ca/san-diego/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

NYC murders peaked in 1990 at 30 per 100,000, similar to where Chicago is today, but we're able to successfully get that down to 5 - 6 per 100,000, which is in line with national averages. Conincedentally the 90s is when the city seemed to turn around.

https://www.vitalcitynyc.org/articles/2023-crime-trends

Outside the US, Toronto has a homicide rate ranging from 1.5 - 3 per 100,000

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1317685/homicide-rate-toronto-canada/

Chicago does get picked on a lot, but it has a homicide rate ranging from 15 - 30 per 100,000 depending on the year. Philadelphia is similar. 30 per 100,000 is roughly 6 times higher than NYC and the national average and 10 times higher than San Diego or Toronto.

https://marroninstitute.nyu.edu/blog/the-chicago-ceasefire

https://news.wttw.com/2022/12/17/u-c-crime-lab-director-what-data-says-about-chicago-s-crime-rate-2022

Milwaukee ranges from 15 - 25 per 100,000, which puts in line with Sunbelt cities

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/wi/milwaukee/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

Detroit ranges from 35 - 40 per 100,000

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/mi/detroit/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

St Louis is among the worst at 20 - 65 per 100,000

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/mo/st-louis/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

New Orleans ranges from 30 to a whopping 90 per 100,000

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/la/new-orleans/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

Baltimore does very poorly with a homicide rate ranging from 30 - 51 per 100,000

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/md/baltimore/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

Atlanta ranges from 17 - 35 per 100,000, putting in line with declining rust belt cities

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/ga/atlanta/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

Houston ranges from 11 - 20 per 100,000 making it similar to Chicago, Milwaukee and Philadelphia. Putting it roughly 2 - 4 times above the national average.

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/tx/houston/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

Dallas does slightly better than Houston with a low of 8 per 100,000 and a high of 20 per 100,000.

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/tx/dallas/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

As Vegas does a little better with a low of 5 and a high of 12 per 100,000, but it hasn't maintained that low and remained in the 12 zone. This puts it at roughly 2 times the national average

https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/cities/us/nv/las-vegas/murder-homicide-rate-statistics

I could go on forever, but American cities are much more dangerous than their counterparts in other developed countries. There isn't a simple and easy fix to it either, but I don't think it's unsolvable.

Some ideas:

  1. Try to reduce to police turnover and ensure a fully staffed police force. Major cities often have a problem with police turnover/vacancies and thus existing officers become much more burdened. Having less staff makes it harder for them to respond to crime.

https://www.city-journal.org/article/police-are-stretched-thin

2. Having district attorneys (da's) that will prosecute.

3. Further implementation of improved policing tactics such as hotspots policing, problem oriented policing and focused deterrence strategies. See more info here: https://cebcp.org/evidence-based-policing/what-works-in-policing/seattle-police-case-study/

4. Broken windows policing seems to have mixed success and the issue remains contentious, but some strategies seem effective while others are not. It's likely there broken windows strategies that work and ones that don't. See more info here: https://cebcp.org/evidence-based-policing/what-works-in-policing/research-evidence-review/broken-windows-policing/

5. Community policing also seems to have varying degrees of success. It's application is probably best done on a case by case basis. See here: https://cebcp.org/evidence-based-policing/what-works-in-policing/research-evidence-review/community-policing/

6. Newark, NJ has taken an innovative approach by having police, non-profits and the community work together to help address crime. https://www.gih.org/views-from-the-field/the-gun-violence-epidemic-lessons-from-newark-new-jersey/


r/urbanplanning • • Feb 12 '25

Land Use How Progressives Froze the American Dream

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
5 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • Mar 28 '24

Discussion If planners' personal lifestyles lack racial, gender, and class diversity, can they be relied upon to embed equity into their planning processes effectively?

27 Upvotes

I work with planners who have told me I’m the only non-white person they know in/out of work. Mind you, we work in the NYC tri state. Does that take away from their work? Part of me finds it hard to take them seriously when they discuss equitable zoning or public engagement.


r/urbanplanning • • Jun 27 '26 Bravo

Economic Dev The High Cost of New York’s Rent Freeze

Thumbnail
cityjournal.substack.com
33 Upvotes

Submission statement: New York City’s Rent Guidelines Board approved a rent freeze for rent-stabilized apartments, aligning with a first-generation rent-control model. While this provides short-term relief for tenants, it poses long-term risks to the city’s housing market. The freeze could lead to deteriorating building conditions, reduced investment in housing quality, and a two-tier housing system that disadvantages newcomers and those needing to relocate.


r/urbanplanning • • Feb 20 '24

Discussion Aren't busways superior to light rail most of the time?

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about this after seeing a sparsely used train yet again on a dedicated ROW. It should have been built as a busway.

Advantages: Cheaper Faster to build More flexibility (busses can spread out from the ROW)

But with light rail you have to switch from a bus to a train and vice versa. If we're talking about a high demand line that's one thing, but most north American light rail lines don't seem to be at capacity.

As far as I can tell we're building light rail because of the lack of local pollution to the detriment of actual transportation benefits.


r/urbanplanning • • Nov 06 '23

Urban Design Why can't we develop underneath highways that cut through cities?

0 Upvotes

A lot of people are againstt highways "cutting" through cities, and "dividing" parts of town.

Why not develop under and besides highways so it doesn't feel like it abruptly divides communities? And also make it walkable?

Every city-cutting highway in America/Canada I have seen is always empty right underneath it in such a way that it divides communities. But I don't see why it has to be that way.


r/urbanplanning • • Jul 08 '23

Land Use why do americans fail at urban parks?

31 Upvotes

all the money in the world but there are no retiro, english garden, or hyde park in similar size cities in america (dallas, houston, atlanta, miami, kansas city, phoenix). maybe older places like nyc, st louis, sf, chicago. even mid size euro cities like stockholm and zaragoza seems to do better.


r/urbanplanning • • Aug 08 '24

Discussion Why is there no movement among urbanists/planners to end the de facto idea of "cities being creatures of the state"?

4 Upvotes

For most progressive liberals and radicals in the orbit of urban issues or the field of urban planning in general, one of the main retorts that we come across is the idea that "X would be a good policy, but, the state has the power to state has all the power to stop X".

To me, this line of thinking is defeatist. Cities are economic engines no matter if you live in a conservative or liberal state, pushing the state government to give cities autonomy over urban affairs should be the goal of everyone within the orbit of the urbanist movement, especially in places where anti-urban laws are passed. But, we don't see any big push for this, why do you think this is?


r/urbanplanning • • Nov 27 '19

Housing AOC goes full NIMBY against new housing in Queens.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
15 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • Aug 20 '22

Land Use California Needs More Housing. Unions Might Stand in the Way.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • May 30 '15

7 reasons why high-rises kill livability

Thumbnail
sustainablecitiescollective.com
3 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • Aug 23 '24

Economic Dev If "gentrification" is the process of a city/neighborhood becoming more upper class and "urban decline" is the process of a city/neighborhood becoming more lower class, what is the process of a city/neighborhood becoming more "middle class"? And how/when does it happen?

0 Upvotes

Let me provide some definitions real quick so that this conversation doesn't devolve into quibbling over definitions:

What I mean by "Gentrification" is the upgrading of derelict urban neighborhoods when upper class singles and young married couples place value in cities/actually move to cities (can also refer to: urban regeneration, inner city revitalization, neighborhood renewal and rehabilitation, neighborhood reinvestment, back to the city, and urban resettlement)

What I mean by "Middle Class" (since most people consider themselves middle class) is an individual or families who's income from either their own labor or some other form of assets allows them to occupy the median strata for incomes depending on their location


r/urbanplanning • • Sep 22 '15

American school bus V.S. Dutch school bus (Carfreeday)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • Feb 22 '15

Only 2 Ways to Fight Gentrification (you’re not going to like one of them)

Thumbnail
marketurbanism.com
0 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • Feb 27 '23

Transportation Unpopular Opinion: Paint on the road DOES protect bicyclists.

58 Upvotes

Context: I'm a professional engineer who works on street projects in small-ish urban areas in the northern US.

I often see people on this sub and similar ones saying that bike lanes aren't good enough, and there needs to be a physical barrier between vehicle lanes and bike lanes/sidewalks/etc.

I think physical barriers are wonderful (especially when I'm pulling my child in a bike trailer) but they aren't always practical. Paint on the other hand, is almost ALWAYS practical, and it does offer a great degree of protection. Yes, it can be driven over, but if it's used correctly it rarely is. When driving on a country road, paint is the only thing separating 2 oncoming cars that zip past each other each going 60+ mph (100+ kph). Paint almost entirely dictates what drivers on a road do. Everything a driver does with the steering wheel is subconsciously determined by how pavement markings are applied to the street.

Paint can be as thick or thin as needed - I recently worked on a project with a bike lane stripe that was one foot wide (30cm). And I've designed bike lanes with painted buffers 2+ feet wide to keep the cars as far as possible from bike lanes.

Also, paint can be scraped up and redone much more easily than physical barriers, especially concrete curb.

TL;DR paint is fuckin awesome and I love it, stop saying it's worthless.


r/urbanplanning • • May 31 '23

Discussion Why do people act like Vienna is perfect?

0 Upvotes

Why does this sub act like Vienna is perfect and glorifies renting or public housing? These buildings just look nice outside but are small inside and have awful utilities. Plus other cities and countries like Hong Kong and Singapore try similar policies and yet cost to rent are far higher. Not to mention actually buying is virtually impossible. I don’t see why this is a good thing just because the city looks pretty.


r/urbanplanning • • May 17 '25

Land Use All levels of density are valid

2 Upvotes

I've been wondering for a while why I preferred either the inner city or the countryside and not the low density suburbs (Australia here). Initially when learning about city planning, I began to think that there was a density dead zone where it is an inherently worse experience to be in outer suburbs.

Australians enjoy having large properties in the suburbs and I'm sure many cultures would prefer to do that if it was economical.

If we had more mixed-use zoning, that would liven up our suburbs quite a bit with more places and shops to walk to. We can also make our suburbs less dependent on cars and safer if we design them differently.

There is a lot we can do to improve the dream of having a big house while maintaining a sense of place and community.


r/urbanplanning • • Aug 24 '23

Land Use Britain should scrap its green belt

Thumbnail
economist.com
1 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • Nov 11 '24

Discussion Urbanism could be the Democrats new message

0 Upvotes

Urbanism is policy. Personally I think the Democrats lost this election cycle partly because there was no clear coherent message. I think urbanism addresses many of the current issues such as housing costs, cost of living(with a car), climate change and the freedom to get around how you want.

While it’s disappointing that we have a president completely against the goals above, maybe this is a chance for a new movement to form? Curious if other people feel the same way.