r/unsong • u/Xenograteful • Jun 28 '16
I thought Unsong was meant to be lighthearted and humorous, and I'm not sure if it can be that after the Broadcast chapter
So here's what Scott Alexander said in the beginning of the book.
I am constantly boggled by people who have read my previous stories still being surprised that I like humor in fiction.
But I am trying to make the book able to stand on its own aside from the humor (sort of like HPMoR or Discworld, which both included humor but weren't about humor), so I hope you'll stick around anyway.
I thought I had finally found a piece of rational fiction that's mostly just fun and doesn't include that much death and torture so I was a bit disappointed by the Broadcast chapter. I've read and watched my share of grimdark fiction like that. The violence grabs your attention and makes the story more intense and seemingly more meaningful with more at stake. But does it really make it better or is it just a cheap trick?
So here's my feelings on the subject and why the excessive use of torture bothers me in fiction (note, feelings, not the objective truth)
Torture and violence are things that happen a lot in the real world even now in the year 2016. I just begin to think what the victims would think about if they saw it used in fiction, and whether they'd consider it disrespectful.
It somehow disturbs me that people are devising imaginative ways to cause misery and torture people, even if it's only fictional. It's especially disturbing when you acknowledge that torture is something that has happened a lot throughout human history. It kind of affirms that even ordinary people are capable of this kind of cruelty and it's part of human nature. It probably is, since dominating and bullying other people is so common.
It's a kind of superstimuli. "Torture porn" is a word for a reason. Like many other types of superstimuli, consuming it and enjoying it makes me feel dirty somehow. And since it's superstimuli, creators will probably try to make it more and more horrifying to make it have the same effect on consumers of fiction as the previous depictions of violence have had. This seems to be a trend in fiction, seeing how bland some earlier forms of fiction were in this regard.
The world itself dark enough in itself. Even if the world is a better place than in the past, the lives of happy people still contain a lot of conflict, suffering and death.
I wonder if it's a sign of privilege to enjoy fiction with a lot torture and violence. This is after all one of the longest periods without war in the western world in recent history. I don't think people who've gone through war would like to see the same thing in the fiction they consume. For example the Golden Age of Comic Books wasn't nearly as dark as some of the popular fiction nowadays.
I become afraid if I will see something like this in the future if a war or some other kind of conflict breaks out, or the world becomes a worse place in some other way. It's harder to enjoy it if you fear it might become reality.