r/unsong • • Jun 28 '16

I thought Unsong was meant to be lighthearted and humorous, and I'm not sure if it can be that after the Broadcast chapter

4 Upvotes

So here's what Scott Alexander said in the beginning of the book.

I am constantly boggled by people who have read my previous stories still being surprised that I like humor in fiction.

But I am trying to make the book able to stand on its own aside from the humor (sort of like HPMoR or Discworld, which both included humor but weren't about humor), so I hope you'll stick around anyway.

I thought I had finally found a piece of rational fiction that's mostly just fun and doesn't include that much death and torture so I was a bit disappointed by the Broadcast chapter. I've read and watched my share of grimdark fiction like that. The violence grabs your attention and makes the story more intense and seemingly more meaningful with more at stake. But does it really make it better or is it just a cheap trick?

So here's my feelings on the subject and why the excessive use of torture bothers me in fiction (note, feelings, not the objective truth)

  • Torture and violence are things that happen a lot in the real world even now in the year 2016. I just begin to think what the victims would think about if they saw it used in fiction, and whether they'd consider it disrespectful.

  • It somehow disturbs me that people are devising imaginative ways to cause misery and torture people, even if it's only fictional. It's especially disturbing when you acknowledge that torture is something that has happened a lot throughout human history. It kind of affirms that even ordinary people are capable of this kind of cruelty and it's part of human nature. It probably is, since dominating and bullying other people is so common.

  • It's a kind of superstimuli. "Torture porn" is a word for a reason. Like many other types of superstimuli, consuming it and enjoying it makes me feel dirty somehow. And since it's superstimuli, creators will probably try to make it more and more horrifying to make it have the same effect on consumers of fiction as the previous depictions of violence have had. This seems to be a trend in fiction, seeing how bland some earlier forms of fiction were in this regard.

  • The world itself dark enough in itself. Even if the world is a better place than in the past, the lives of happy people still contain a lot of conflict, suffering and death.

  • I wonder if it's a sign of privilege to enjoy fiction with a lot torture and violence. This is after all one of the longest periods without war in the western world in recent history. I don't think people who've gone through war would like to see the same thing in the fiction they consume. For example the Golden Age of Comic Books wasn't nearly as dark as some of the popular fiction nowadays.

  • I become afraid if I will see something like this in the future if a war or some other kind of conflict breaks out, or the world becomes a worse place in some other way. It's harder to enjoy it if you fear it might become reality.


r/unsong • • Apr 12 '20

[Twitter] A Facebook friend left their kid's chocolate Easter Bunny in the car a little too long and, uh

Thumbnail
twitter.com
5 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Jan 01 '19

hey 🅱eter

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Oct 23 '18

Hey 🅱️eter

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Jul 21 '23

Alan Graham gets it

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Jun 19 '17

Unsong!Battle Hymn of the Republic (spoilers for everything) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Mine eyes have seen the Glory of the incanting of the Name;

The Comet King was Falling to where Thamiel reigns and scours;

He loosed the fervent wish and fearsome joy and the Resh the Tav:

He became the Other King.

(Chorus)

Glory, Glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Not two Kings but One.

I saw the Name writ in sky in fires of a hundred ICKMs,

He gave his soul to Evil Good, that his true love's soul redeemed;

Where each Epic failed he did not lose he gave his very being:

His Day has just begun.

(Chorus)

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

The Day has just begun.

I have read the fiery SCABMOM retconned in burnished rows of Names:

A final plan ineffable, Adam Kadmon formed anew;

Let the Adam, born of seven, free the Left Hand with his 'dent,

Theodicy revealed.

(Chorus)

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

The offer made and sealed.

He was sifting out the sum of Good and Bad before His judgment-seat;

In the Garden of all Worlds on the edge of what is Good and True;

Oh, Adam Kadmon, will you Be - or nought but sit on your terrible Golden Throne?

Our Choice is marching on.

(Chorus)

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Glory, glory, hallelujah!

Our Choice is marching on.


r/unsong • • May 13 '18

Dark Side of the Rainbow

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
3 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Mar 15 '18

I just found a cute girl in Tinder with a name "אנה", which means "Anna". What is a kaballistic meaning of the name, that could serve as an icebreaker?

7 Upvotes

r/unsong • • May 31 '17

All My Heart (OC fan art)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
8 Upvotes

r/unsong • • May 24 '17

EPUB version?

4 Upvotes

Has anyone assembled an EPUB version of UNSONG, now that it's finished? I've dug around but can't find any links.


r/unsong • • Jul 23 '23

Barbie = Bet Resh Bet

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Dec 24 '22

In a perfect world, men like me would not exist

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Aug 27 '17

comment_king_irl

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/unsong • • May 25 '20

I just realized something about our own world Spoiler

8 Upvotes

The world in the book resembles ours, but it isn't actually our world.

How do I know? Because the events that happened in the book didn't happen by us. Our own world must be one of the better worlds of the multiverse.

How, then, is our world so similar to the world in the book?

Coincidence.


r/unsong • • May 27 '23

If UNSONG was written today instead of in 2017, what would the Kabbalistic analysis of Joe Biden's name be?

8 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Apr 26 '23

Kanye West Is The Comet King

Thumbnail
skunkledger.substack.com
17 Upvotes

r/unsong • • Nov 05 '19

Bald Eagles Circling Above Andrew Yang's Rally in Seattle - TINAC BNIEAC

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/unsong • • May 07 '17

Sohu

2 Upvotes

Sohu is Tsav-Heh-Vav. תהו. As in Genesis 1:2.

Why is Sohu Sohu?

Edit:

Also, who or what, then, is Bohu/Vohu, and to what end?


r/unsong • • May 25 '17

Teeheehee

2 Upvotes

Proof that HHR is the OTP:

The lightning bolt on HP's head is actually Hebrew Lamed and not Elder Futhark Sowilo. The character for Lamed is probably a pictograph of a shepherd's staff/goad. This represent HP's leadership of his populace that is sheeplike.

The scar is on the forehead, where the head-tefilin is placed, which is tied in place with a knot shaped like a yud. The number-value of yud is 10, and lamed is 30. 10+30 = 40. Forty is mem, which is equivalent to 'M', which is Mione which is Hermione. Furthermore, as the verse states "You shall teach them... and you shall place them ... and on between your eyes". Hermione is a learner and a teacher, thus she is placed between HP's eyes. This is not a coincidence because nothing is ever a coincidence. HHR is the OTP.

lol


r/unsong • • May 18 '17

What are the themes of this story?

2 Upvotes

"Nothing is a coincidence" is a motif, but what is the thematic idea behind this? Perhaps it's just fun to imagine a world that plays to our pareidolia?

Theodicy is an obvious major theme. Do you think Unsong uses theodicy as a way of exploring the idea that evil can enhance good?

What other major themes do you see in Unsong?


r/unsong • • Apr 30 '17

Theodicy is an epic?

3 Upvotes

The Odyssey is an epic.

UNSONG is an epic about theodicy.

Theodicy is an epic?


r/unsong • • Jun 16 '17

TC

3 Upvotes

Actual confusion when I first started internetting, long, long ago:

I was baffled as to why, on the gamefaqs forums, people kept referring to the Tanna Kamma.

It took minime an embarrassingly long time to reach the amusing observation that:

TC = Topic Creator ~ Tanna Kamma = TK

Where '~' here means 'approximates'.


r/unsong • • Nov 09 '20

Dave Wasserman hiding his election call in a klipah

Post image
14 Upvotes