r/unity • • Sep 18 '23

Unity.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

42

u/Living-Row-179 Sep 18 '23

Fuck Unity, I'll never forgive them.

Even if they back down now (and it looks like they might, most big mobile gaming companies dropped their shitty ad service lololol) make no mistake, it IS coming back

6

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Yup, I have used the engine for 13 years, fully uninstalled and I am learning godot to fill the niche that Unity held - no trust in the company, game over.

2

u/will_rate_your_pics Sep 18 '23

Who dropped their ads?

4

u/Living-Row-179 Sep 18 '23

Many mobile games dev came together and are boycotting Unity's ad platform until they remove that runtime installation BS

1

u/MobilePenguins Sep 18 '23

100% headfirst into learning Godot and proceeding with no royalties owed to anyone

15

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

What scares me is that even if they completely walk back on this another company will try something similar and more subtle. It's how we got microtransactions in video games.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Unreal is owned by Tim Sweeney who appears to be a pretty solid bloke, similarly the godot people seem to have something of moral compass.

1

u/Worth_Bug411 Sep 19 '23

I'll probably eat some downvotes for this, but I don't mind micro transactions when they're done right. They make the game free to play and my friend group (many are very casual at gaming) has been able to play a ton of things that they wouldn't have tried if there was a paywall

What unity is doing has no silver lining lol

1

u/KyriadosX Sep 20 '23

Exactly. MTX that don't give a single drop of a competitive edge, and don't enforce FOMO, are fine imho

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '23

We got microtransactions in video games because companies needed to protect their profits. They were invented during the worst economic time in world history since the Great Depression, coincidence? I think not.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

[deleted]

1

u/MrBanditFleshpound Sep 18 '23

He wanted to extend microtransactions to worst possibilities.

Another wanted to implement it on mass scale on all products.

Neither worth much

1

u/UTSansGamerYT Sep 18 '23

Funfact: this ex EA CEO wanted to charge players a dollar each time they reloaded their gun in battlefield

1

u/Exciting-Ad-5705 Sep 18 '23

Source?

1

u/MrBanditFleshpound Sep 18 '23

Lemme find one with Emperor theme.

https://youtu.be/ZR6-u8OIJTE?si=lYX6_J08VWwm-zhp here is the fragment with the appropriate theme

1

u/UTSansGamerYT Sep 21 '23

Scratch that. I was wrong. It wasnt in just battlefield. He wanted that dollar per reload/bullet in every single god damn gun game that EA has released in recent times

1

u/NerdElert Sep 19 '23

Yea the ceo wanted to charge us a dollar to reload in battlefield…

38

u/sacredbrood Sep 18 '23

I started using Godot last night and it rocks. Took me an hour to spin up a tutorial project that would've taken a day learning Unity, and the app itself is crazy compact. And there's rust bindings ...

8

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Rust as well? Ok, I GOT to try it now.

6

u/pmmemilftiddiez Sep 18 '23

Yeah but we hear you

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

I tried loading a simple model 😑 Godot is made by weird aliens it's nice optimized and all but that's the final product. The gamedevs 😑 will have nightmares of hierarchy , etc

1

u/19412 Sep 20 '23

If you're talking about .fbx files, Godot is not the one to blame.

9

u/MantraMuse Sep 18 '23

I don't think the insider trading thing applies, at least for John, as he owns 3.2 million shares. I think he genuinely thought this would be a net win for Unity. But I like this post regardless.

10

u/therealpygon Sep 18 '23

Any way we can get a tag for meme posts like this? Everyone gets the joke...again.

0

u/ArtOfWarfare Sep 18 '23

I agree. I initially mistook this for a real update from Unity. I figured out it was fake about halfway through when it got to the CEO selling shares.

5

u/BlunterCarcass5 Sep 18 '23

I've spent the last 3 days learning godot, it's fantastic and I recommend any other novice game devs do the same

8

u/slaczky Sep 18 '23

2000 shares is nothing compared to that how much he have. You also can't sell shares just like that, it needs to be anounenced in advance, this month sell was anounenced last year. The amount of false information these kids spreading is insane. Do your own research before posting false shit.

2

u/Storyteller-Hero Sep 18 '23

It's been a lot more than 2000 shares if counting the past year but that's not important since they have many more shares than they sold so far.

By driving down the stock price of Unity however, they can attract a buyer and unload their shares altogether, which are worthless to them if not sold to begin with, especially since Unity has been losing money the past several years.

Not being able to sell a lot of shares is partly why they would want to get someone to buy them out sooner than later.

2

u/apelikecoding Sep 19 '23

^^^

While the sale was scheduled last year, the announcement could absolutely have been timed post sale which may still qualify for insider trading.

The more important point is that manipulation of stock price in order to trigger an event that would allow for a conversion of stock outside of the normal, contractually limited sale, schedule is absolutely a possibility. I've worked for companies that made decisions that resulted in a significant drop in stock price followed by a buyout where the execs made an insane amount on their stock conversion and the board was able to extract cash and offload debt from other holdings onto the target company / division.

There are some very smart people who engineer these vulture capital schemes where solid companies with stable products suddenly tank and everyone loses except the ones with the preferred stock.

Private capital firms are the primary motivator for this sort of thing since they have complex portfolios that span many companies and the scheme isn't fully visible until well after the dust settles. Since the entities with the majority of the stock are usually in on the scam it makes a class action suit by the hoi polloi of shareholders extremely unlikely even when it's obvious that they got fleeced.

1

u/slaczky Sep 19 '23

Well said. I'm hoping for Microsoft buying them out.

8

u/VanilIae Sep 18 '23

Some would suggest this is insider trading, and they’d likely have zero knowledge on the subject they’re raging over(also they’re probably wrong). Unity has roughly 375,000,000 shares outstanding at roughly $36USD a share, with John Riccitiello owning 3.2million shares.. he has sold a total of 2% of his shares throughout the entire year, and .0625% of his stock the week before. Maybe they’re rich because they have a fundamental understanding of money and don’t spend their days reading rage bait!

Go and look at what they posted themselves, actually do a little bit of math so you can really understand. Being a part of the loud majority doesn’t automatically make you correct.

4

u/random_actuary Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

There is a De Minimus threshold of $10,000 for one transaction or $30,000 for multiple transactions. Would that apply here?

One popular example, Martha Stewart went to prison for selling about $230,000 worth of shares out of her $591M holdings, or about 0.03% if my math is correct.

Not a lawyer or offering legal advice.

4

u/VanilIae Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

I believe she went to prison for colluding with her broker and lying to the investigators, obstruction of justice and conspiracy, not how much money she pulled.

I also believe the De Minimus threshold is used to determine how income is classified when reported, where it’s considered to be De Minimus if it’s under 10,000 a transaction. If the aggregate funds exceed 30,000 within two quarters, they’re exempt for the next one, at which point they’re considered ordinary income and taxed higher than if it was De Minimus, where it’d be taxed as capital gains.

Apologies of explained poorly, I’m also not a lawyer, but in school for business and it’s a very interesting topic to me!

Edit: I forgot to add that the crime related to the threshold would be falsely or not reporting the income to avoid the taxes, which still isn’t insider trading as claimed in the post.

2

u/uritarded Sep 18 '23

I am confused about the people at the top selling off loads of stock before implementing new product destroying policy. How do they benefit from Unity going down? They could have just continued to sell their stock without all this. It’s not like they did something to pump the stock and then sell it. Unless this new policy was forced on them from the Ironsource merger and they are just getting ahead of the sinking ship

2

u/blueheartglacier Sep 18 '23

They're not "selling off loads of stock", people who know nothing about the world are just assuming conspiracies. Executives who are paid bonuses in shares implement long-term plans (that they have to announce years in advance mind you) to sell off a small portion of those shares continuously over time as having the cash is more useful than having their entire wealth be tied up in just a few companies. They're not allowed to sell in reaction to news (this gets you in trouble for insider trading) and they're not selling any level of shares that'll impact the price at all - they're executing the same long term plan any executive in their position also does.

1

u/uritarded Sep 18 '23

Gotcha, there have been some commentators who have tried to make the selling of stock some sort of point but I didn’t get it

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Marcus Lincinius Crassus (the richest and greediest man of his era) died getting liquid gold poured down his throat. Men who have been consumed by greed are irredeemable, it is the one ailment that can never be cured.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Get in

Write "Too long, don't read"

Reject to argue

Get out

1

u/Storyteller-Hero Sep 18 '23

The important part is that they couldn't sell much more than a small fraction of their total owned shares.

That's a potential motivation to drive down the stock value of Unity, in which case they can attract a buyout and unload the bulk of their shares sooner than later.

1

u/henrythedog64 Sep 19 '23

The shares means very little.. not saying in support of unity just is something people think is a big gotcha.

1

u/OkScience3587 Sep 19 '23

Stop saying the inside trading plz. Comparing to how many shares they own, its really means nothing. the origin ironsource CEO own about 6million shares.trust me, he is the least person that want unitys stock price go down to 0. They are just greedy want to get more and fucked up.

1

u/_Deadshot_ Sep 19 '23

Nicely memed

1

u/RegionalLimbo Sep 20 '23

It's a real pity, because that means the support of a lot of great games will be discontinued

1

u/AdvancedLet6528 Sep 22 '23

fuck that shit, not reading it

1

u/David548K Sep 18 '23

I think this is fake

0

u/DevilGuy Sep 18 '23

To be fair if godot had won it's bid to buy out unity they probably would have tried to lock themselves in as the only monetization option as well, the probably just wouldn't have done it in the stupidest way possible.

-2

u/Arrakis_Surfer Sep 18 '23

u/spez this is what giving a F looks like ...