r/underlords • • Nov 17 '19

Complaint Please, swallow your pride and revert some changes.

5 Upvotes

I played autochess and underlods after with a decent rank in both games, Queen and Spire so I guess I understand the basics of the games, despite I was a real casual gamer.

I always tried to invite friends to play, the reasoning was that it was easy to learn and really casual. Still it offered the good amount of skill in the game if you wanted to become good.

The latest patch have some good Ideas, Duo is supergood I enjoy playing it with friends, Prison is a Decent idea, to change the meta. But the Underlords ruins the game, they add nothing except a pre-game choice. They make the game less casual when you are force to play to unlock skills, they are superhard to explain why and what skill you should pick up, and if/when you learn it, they still add nothing to the game. I must also say the UI is SHIT, the old one was clean and easy to explain, now everything is just smalll and NOT clean.

I've notice without thinking about it I've stopped playing the game, I've also stopped recommend it to friends. If valve want this game to grew they have to start with admitting their misstakes and revert bad changes.


r/underlords • • Apr 24 '20

Complaint Two weeks just for crappy updates.. Hays.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/underlords • • Oct 24 '19

Complaint This UI will definitely kill the game

9 Upvotes

I love Underlords, have spent over 1k hours on it, was very hyped for this big update, but the new UI is so ugly that I can't look at it (I just literally closed the game, it was too frustrating), and if it's so disappointing and confusing for me can't imagine for new players trying out the game for the first time.

Everything is ultra small for what, adding two useless animated Underlords that steal 1/3 of the space, it's really hard to understand what's going on on screen.

Old UI was so good compared, with a simple and minimalistic style (health and mana bars, heroes stars, icons, shop, opponents and pairings).

There are for sure many new and cool stuffs in this update, but I don't think I will give them a shot, they never mentioned they were going to drastically change the UI making the gameplay experience sunddenly this bad...

I dunno, maybe it's me having a problem, but I think this is a big fiasco.


r/underlords • • Oct 16 '20

Discussion I'm probably just never going to play another game by valve

6 Upvotes

Their history of abandoning games is just...too heartbreaking for me. I think that this one is the final straw for me. They come up with some incredibly fun games, but it's hard to invest into learning their games when I don't have confidence that it'll stay around.


r/underlords • • Jul 26 '20

Two Simple Steps to Revive Underlords

25 Upvotes

Revert everything starting from “The Big Update” where underlords and the newer hideous UI were introduced. Re add underlords as simple sideliners with a unique ability, like Hearthstone Battlegrounds heroes. That’s it: you will then have the best auto battler on the market again. Swallow your pride and admit your mistakes.


r/underlords • • Oct 18 '19

Please Valve, name "Insects" group into something else. "Creepy crawlies" or "Nasties" or whatever. Spiders are not insects, even this kids website can tell you that.

Thumbnail
kidzone.ws
2 Upvotes

r/underlords • • Jul 31 '19

Discussion What is bad in "snapshot money before the fight" interest and why it should be fixed

0 Upvotes

I think enough time has passed to see that this system is clearly inferrior to original DAC. The main disadvantages are:

For newer players: it's confusing and counter-intuitive.

It's even hard to explain in words. So, you get 1 interest gold for every 10 gold in your pocket, capped at 5 gold for 50+. But that's not based on the gold you have, it's the gold you had when the fight began, so you can spend it after that. Except it's not even that, since if you win the fight, it's +1 gold to that. But if you get other end-of-the-round gold (from Scrappy perk, for example), those don't count. And it'll be even more confusion if they bring back Silver Lining.

That's not how you want one of your main mechanics to sound.

For experienced players: it's tedious to use to your advantage.

With this kind of economy, you have to buy everything from the shop before the round ends, especially in the early game. Fill your bench, overflow your board, whatever, there is just no reason not to do that. Yes, 99% of the time you'll sell it all back, but still, sometimes you'll get an unexpected 2-star that will be a decent temporary addition to your army.

The problem is, it's a lot of necessary actions, especially on mobile. Especially in earlygame-snowball meta like nowadays.

For competitive players: it partially removes strategy.

There were a lot of strategic decisions in DAC in this regard: "I have 12 gold, so I could buy something. Do I buy a 2-cost or a pair of 1-costs? Should I go below 10 gold if the units are that good or should I lock?".

Here, you just buy everything every time. No decisions.

Overall: not consistent in what it tries to improve.

Obviously, the idea was that you'll have more time to reroll without losing interest. The problem is - you'll rarely benefit from that. A lot of the time you'd still wait for the round to end before starting to reroll: because you need to get the 1xp for the next level and better rolls; or because you need to know which perk you'll get from creeps, etc.

Also, it's still close to impossible to efficiently spend 50 gold in one round even with this additional time (definitely not on the phone and definitely not with casual APM). So it's still better to start rolling way before you are in a 1-shot range.

So, overall, I don't think there is any good reason to keep the current system.


r/underlords • • Apr 11 '20

Discussion The game is NOT in a good shape, we have to accept it.

2 Upvotes

I know I am going to get downvoted heavily for this one (since most of the people left here are in complete delusion about the state of the game). But here we are: just in 1 month we are almost back to pre-release online numbers of 10.000 average. Most of the original playerbase is gone (and no, its NOT only because they got "tired of the genre": look how HS and TFT are still alive and kicking).

What should/could be done is totally different topic of discussion. But before we find a solution we have to accept reality:

  1. The game is dying.

  2. Valve has very little experience in the genre, and that is why underlords devs are so "communicative" unlike other Valve departments - they just have a very little understanding of the way they wanna take this game forwards, thus asking for our wishes and ideas.

  3. The game is not as addictive and less complex/deep than original Dota Auto Chess, maybe that's why the latter is still more popular than Underlords, reaching 50-60k peaks daily.

  4. While almost ALL other games on steam are booming due to COVID-19, we are LOOSING players.

This Sub, unfortunately, lately has been in a state of total denial about all of this. I think its time to stop, accept the facts and have a discussion about how we can save the game from going into below pathetic 10k online average.


r/underlords • • Sep 07 '19

Spirit Bear should have a CD on its proc. It's really frustrating watching it perma stun a hero for the entire fight.

3 Upvotes

r/underlords • • Oct 29 '19

Suggestion Remove first 3 rounds, please.

0 Upvotes

We are all just losing time with those rounds. Have a pre game rounds, where we just have the shop buy time, and item choice.

There's zero interest in looking and taking time at this first combats.

The game could start with a items choice one after the other. 5 money, and a (or 2) free reroll, then, first round is against an opponent.

There's something pulling me away from the game right now. And it's just the duration. MAny times I can't commit +40 minutes.

Another drastic suggestion I have, would be for the devs to test a fast game mode, where combat is entirely skipped. It just shows us how much damage we took, and ready for next round. (I know this have many implications on the gameplay, but could be tested.)


r/underlords • • Dec 17 '19

Discussion I know Twitch numbers don’t matter...but the game just had 92 total viewers...wow

3 Upvotes

I was just surprised the numbers were that low...


r/underlords • • Nov 16 '19

Suggestion Game is on the sad path to get Artifact'd

3 Upvotes

Firstly - don't get me wrong. I love Underlords, I love devs' work. Surely you guys have passion for the game and would like to make it best (weekly patches are very cool, listening to community is great) But game has some terrible problems at the moment and I'm not talking about "X hero is OP game unplayable volvo die". Game has much more serious problems than simple balance.
1.Jail is simply the worst design ever. I understand the idea behind it but it doesn't work. It completely destroys some alliances and makes them unplayable while big alliances don't have any problems because they have 8 heroes in it. Not only it makes the game boring as there is no variety, it also actively discourages many people from playing which is UNACCEPTABLE. Being creative should be rewarded not punished.
2.Speaking of being creative...it's impossible here. Of course every online game has "meta" of some sort but in Underlords meta gets stale 1 day after patch, for example now it is:

Pick Annesix -> Get items which do not suck (Chainmail, gloves) -> Get strong early heroes like Tiny, drow/pudge -> Get more items which dont suck (Relic, Deadelus, Moonshard etc) ->Get lvl 8 or 9 -> Build Assassins/Warriors/Hunters ->Fill it with good stuff -> Win (or lose if you weren't lucky).

Imagine going brawnies, bloodbounds or savages. You play always in disadvantage as brawnies are heavily based on RNG (no blademail, no snowball, no quick Axe/BM = lose), BB is meme and savages are useless in late and you will have no chance. All of these builds could be fun right? They create cool opportunities and strategies. But no, don't do that or you lose. Pick warriors and goodstuff.

I remember when I was playing Dota2, pretty much every hero was valid and even if was considered "bad" he could be still situationally picked and it could work. LC was my main and I played her most of the games, even if I was losing I had great time. She had her strenghts and weaknesses, now look at Underlords' LC.Lul, no comment. Underlords is sadly complete opposite of creative game.
3. Speaking of why going different is not valid...items could help in that actually. They could give you opportunity to do some crazy and maybe viable stuff Well its not possible. And RNG part is even worse. Guess why brawnies or bloodbounds are bad? Because you can't reliably get blademail/BBC. I heard in TFT you can "build" items which would be much better design. Items 2.0 are coming some time so maybe things will get better

4. Game is too long. Yeah round damage is not that much, why we can't get rid of these useless Rounds 1-3? Or decrease timer? PLEASE. It's as simple as that.

Honestly, I'm fan of Valve games, I played 5k hours in Dota, something like 400 hours in Artifact and I play Underlords but if I recall well, I have played like 2-3 games daily before Big patch. After big patch I play 2-3 games per week..reading Reddit I feel like I'm not alone. Beta is not an excuse, every day more and more players leave because they can't have fun games with their favoure comps and they don't want to play 45 minutes matches especially if they are mobile casuals (speaking of them, they have especially hard time playing judging from daily "can't play game" posts). Something has to be done. Game has such great potential. As I said I love that devs actually work and listen to community but more work needs to be done.
Rant over.


r/underlords • • Sep 28 '22

Video I get 6 3* units in my brawny comp

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/underlords • • Jul 28 '19

Discussion Did I just suddenly get tired of the game or is it just not good anymore?

17 Upvotes

It just feels like the ebb and flow of the game has changed so much that it's just not fun. I often end up not completing anything because games are so fast without increasing drop percentages, so I end up in a bad position with a half-assed comp.

I find myself logging in, play one game and log back out. Is it just me who grew tired or is the current state of the game just not fun for most people?


r/underlords • • Dec 27 '19

The game is very confusing right now

10 Upvotes

Original Dota Auto Chess was simple. Abilities usually did one thing and that thing was usually doing damage or a stun, sometimes armor reduction or silence. Life was simple, life was good.

Now several abilities do lots of small stuff like Spin Web or Insect Alliance bonus, this generates 2 problems: First, it's hard to know if the effect is having any impact and second it's hard to remember what the ability does. How many people remember Broodmother Spin Web reduces CAST SPEED?

The original abilities had impact. Tiny Toss, Sniper Assassinate, Lone Druid bear... now we have Nyx Break which may or may not be working as far as I am concerned.

I know by experience some effects are good, but it's based on experience, not on observation. Effects like Brute are subtle and because the enemy may have items and alliance bonuses it's hard to know if they are working or not.

The game is so hard to read sometimes an ability is not working and people simply don't notice it.

Here hoping the game gets simpler in the future.


r/underlords • • Aug 17 '19

Discussion Free Reroll changed the essence of the game

2 Upvotes

I feel that with the new reroll(i know i'm quite late) the game has changed alot. Right now there are more 3 stars than ever, people are getting their pieces more. As good as this sounds, i feel that the creative aspect and individualistic idea of crafting your own builds and compete for whos best is significantly lower.

I'm currently a BB(Big Boss) Player that came from palying alot of DAC(Dota AutoChess). As of now i feel that people can go online and search for the ebst build and force it early game. it takes away the creativity and what i find fun of the game which is the struggle.

Stuggling how to change my builds to fight off other people while having to decide what to keep instead of getting all my pieces and if i just chose wrong i lose? or if i have lesser three stars i lose? which is fine and fair.

Maybe they can make the free reroll have abit more punishment like 1 cost like some other threads suggested.

The difficulty of the game significantly dropped to cater to more and newer players but right now it seems to be who can force the better build and the right coutners and whoever grinds more gets to the top.

i really like the game so far dont get me wrong, i like how active the devs are.

i jsut thought to point this out to maybe reach out to the older players and see if their thoughts are similar or to players struggling right now and not realising that this might be why

sorry for long post, thoughts?


r/underlords • • Apr 26 '20

Discussion Scaled is so useless against mages/spirits, that there is more incentive to NOT go scaled because the units will just reduce your chance of winning.

1 Upvotes

Pretty much title. Scaled might as well not exist. In fact, I'd say even slotting in scaled units to help against mages/spirits is a trap, because the units are so trash against the magic damage comps.

Tide? What are you stunning, their front line tanks? Tide ain't reaching those mages, and spirits don't care about him.

Slardar? Not even going to waste time talking about trashdar. Don't tell me a story about how he carried you to late game - unit is literal garbage.

Slark? If you're going 4 scaled you are losing. Slark is that all star in assassins tho, shout out to the boy, Slark.

Medusa? The best scaled unit...but you aren't exactly just 'making room' for a Medusa, cause chances are your comp will suffer for it. Granted, if you have a baller dps item she'll carry you. Oh, and Dusa loses to an item called barricade, so there is that too.

Venomancer? I'll shit my pants if Venomancer becomes good again. The worst summoner, and you know why? Because of that scaled alliance.

I MUST be forgetting one...hmmm....OH YEA, SVEN.

anyway, please buff scaled alliance, so it can actually matter against mages and spirits.


r/underlords • • Nov 21 '19

Shoutout This game is actually GREAT!

8 Upvotes

First of all, thanks to devs for keeping the game updated! Kudos to you guys.

I know alot of people complaining and ranting the game but you have to realize that this game is NEVER meant to be easy. You cant expect all people to get hook up on this game, same as: not all people are hooked to the good ol' classic chess. This kind of game requires above average intelligence and not a lot of people have that.

So yeah, if you dont find this game enjoyable for you, I think you have to re-assess yourself of what kind of games you should be playing instead of ranting and whinning; resulting to losing of potential players. Ok boomer.


r/underlords • • Oct 21 '19

Suggestion Concern with Jail and time zones: Jail should be on a 28- or 32-hour cycle

55 Upvotes

I love the concept of jail and I think it's necessary. However, I have a major concern that jail might cause a pattern that favours people in certain time zones.

I mean this as follows:

Assume Player A at GMT-6 and Player B at GMT+6. Also assume that Jail resets at 00h00, GMT 0 (i.e. 18h00 GMT-6 and 06h00 GMT+6).

What this means is that, in a normal waking period of 7am - 11pm, Player A will have 11 hours of one jail roster and 3 hours of another, while Player B will have a full day on the same roster. This favours Player B: they will be able to play longer on the same roster and understand/pilot each game better.

This gets worse if we consider Player A and B might only be able to play in the afternoon/evenings, giving Player A a few hours on two rosters while Player B still has a full evening on one roster.

How to fix this?

The simplest approach is to have jail update on a 28-hour rolling window, rather than every 24 hours. This will cause it to update 6 times over one week, with the update time changing by 4 hours each day. If we want to put it even further out of sync to avoid weekends still favouring certain regions (since 28 fits into a 7 day week perfectly) we could change this to a 30 or 32 hour cycle.

The other alternative is to timezone-lock regions, which will negatively affect matchmaking times.

Actual numbers and examples showing the problem

As nimogoham points out, it might even be better to have a prime number window (29, 31, 37 come to mind) so as to avoid some time zones having regular interruptions between the 18h00-22h00 "sweet spot" while others will never experience that.


r/underlords • • Nov 11 '19

Valve needs to write a dev blog addressing all the concerns and feedback since the big update

0 Upvotes

Right now, the balance tweaks are cool, but there's been a lot of valid concerns surrounding the game regarding game length, underlords and how they're incorporated into the game, alliances, etc...

I personally would appreciate it if valve comes out with a statement and address what they are planning instead of keeping their heads down with their ears open. It's hard to support a game when we don't know the direction it's going to be in a week. Big streamers leaving, player numbers dropping, it's a sign something is wrong somewhere and even me after 200+ hours is starting to lose interest in the game.

We're working on it isn't a good enough response anymore. I want you to give us a solution on how you're going to push underlords in the direction that makes everyone happy. To grow the game, etc...


r/underlords • • Oct 31 '19

Play to unlock is obnoxious

48 Upvotes

Finish X games in sixth place or better to open an option is annoying. Save the unlocks for cosmetics. The unlocking gameplay mechanism makes me wonder if I made a mistake switching to Underlords and should go back to the original auto-chess.

Anyone else really put off by the recent update?


r/underlords • • Dec 19 '19

List of Removed Things that encouraged patience and long-term planning.

0 Upvotes

Underlord picking before the game and planning for talents that you will choose based on your build? Gone.

Building up interest over time instead of blowing it all up early for short-term gain? Gone. (This is actually the biggest change of all. Passive gold gain has been increased by whooping 40%)

Planning for creep rounds with unit positioning? Gone.

And overall going for the long-term build has been made non-viable.

Valve is clearly trying to push Underlords into the mobile market crowd with those pro-ADHD changes.

Honestly Underlords has been my favorite online game after the big patch but now i see it going the way of Artifact.

Edit: Forgot to mention the Jail which encouraged planning a new build every day (which i did and it was a lot of fun).


r/underlords • • Aug 22 '19

Guides & Tips Just found out a small useful feature: Click hero on TAB menu to highlight only this hero type

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/underlords • • Aug 23 '19

Discussion New blacklist change has to go

19 Upvotes

For those who are not aware, blacklisting is where the units that you leave in the shop will not appear in your next shop roll. This used to only apply to re rolls, and not when the shop auto rolls at the start of each round. This was a nice little buff to re rolls, because it would give you a slightly higher chance of getting the units that you want. Recently, they made this effect also apply to next round shops.

This seems like a minor change but it actually hugely affects gameplay, primarily in the first 10 rounds. The first 10 rounds used to be essentially draft rounds. You didn't know what you wanted and you put together a bench based off what the game offers you. Generally by round 10 you pick what build you want to go for based off of your opponents boards and what you have so far. There wasn't any way to influence what you units you got in your shops so everyones options were equally as open.

Now, you can actually influence what units you get in your next shop. By buying units then selling them (when you cant afford to bench it), you can increase the chance that that unit will be in your next round shop. Or by leaving units in the shop that you would normally buy, you guarantee they will not appear in your next shop. In the first few rounds the amount of heros you can get is very small, so this effect is quiet noticeable. This means if you want to take advantage of this mechanic, you must decide which units you want and which units you don't want in just the first couple rounds. This heavily discourages players to stay fluid and adapt their builds in the first 10 rounds, and encourages forcing builds. In the first few rounds I found myself leaving units in the shop that I could buy solely because its better for me to blacklist them, which just narrows my options to whatever build I have already decided to blacklist around.

TL;DR: In the previous patches, it was pointless to leave units in the shop if you have bench space and gold because all it did was give you more options. Now doing this can be a disadvantage because it will decreases your chances of getting specific units you already decided you wanted. Remove blacklisting on next round shops so the game plays more like draft and less like constructed

EDIT: I am only suggesting that they remove blacklisting from the next round shop refreshes. It should stay on re-rolls