r/unchartedworlds • u/SG_UnchartedWorlds • Dec 11 '23
Seeking thoughts/reactions to ideas for 2nd Edition
Hi. Yeah, it's me, the absentee writer. I feel like I've been giving the whole "things have been hella rough" speech often these days (TL:DR deaths in the family, meteoric career rise/increase in responsibility, mid-life crisis), but I've got a lot of generalized guilt about my lack of any real community interaction.
Aaaanywho. I was wondering if there were still enough UW folks around to be able to poll the community about some of the more contentious ideas I've been mulling around. Or heck, if you folks know of others who have played UW and could ask for their feedback.
Basically, I've very timidly been working on UW2 over the past year (in very short bursts), and one of the changes that I've been toying with is a shift to a d10 system rather than a d6.
(I am imagining a certain amount of raised eyebrows at this point.)
There's a lot of math involved, but the biggest advantages are the ability to re-frame the success | mixed | mishap ranges, and the possibility of having a broader stat spread (+0 to +4) for an opportunity for gradual character progression/growth.
On the other side, 2d6: 10+ | 7-9 | 6- has been the PbtA cornerstone dice resolution for nearly a decade, is present in multiple similar games, as well as being original UW's dice resolution. Breaking with that feels like a step too far, and may alienate existing players, even subconsciously/on a gut-level.
So, yeah. Thoughts on the next edition being d10-based rather than d6-based? Too much of a change?
(I've got a bunch of other things that I want to share about UW2, and I'm slowly getting back into active design. I really don't want to make any promises, because life and mental health are fickle creatures, but if this subreddit is still active and interested I'd like to start asking for feedback here, if that's ok.)