I'm hoping someone here might have an idea before I conclude I've received a defective hard drive.
I'm adding a brand-new 8TB WD Red Plus NAS drive to my Unraid server. The plan was to preclear it and add it to my existing array, but I cannot get the drive to be recognized at all.
System specs:
- Unraid: 7.3.3
- Motherboard: MSI PRO Z790-P WIFI (MS-7E06)
- CPU: Intel Core i5-13600K
- RAM: 64GB DDR5
- PSU: Gigabyte UD1000GM, 1000W
- Storage controller: LSI SAS controller with SATA breakout cables
- BIOS: MSI Click BIOS 5, E7E06IMS.AC0 (April 16, 2024)
Existing storage:
- Parity: 10TB WD Red
- Disk 1: 8TB WD
- Disk 2: 6TB Seagate
- Disk 3: 4TB WD
- Disk 4: 4TB WD
- Cache: 1TB Crucial P3 Plus NVMe and 1TB SATA SSD
All existing drives are detected and functioning normally.
The problem:
I installed the new 8TB WD Red Plus in an available drive bay and connected it to the LSI controller using an available SATA breakout connection.
The drive does not appear under Unraid's Unassigned Devices or Tools → System Devices.
I can feel a continuous, gentle vibration from the drive, suggesting that it is spinning.
What I've tried:
Reseated the SATA connections.
Tried two different breakout connectors (P2 and P4) on the LSI controller cable. Other drives connected through that breakout cable are working.
Connected the new drive directly to an available motherboard SATA port using a standard SATA data cable, bypassing the LSI controller entirely.
Checked the MSI BIOS under Settings → System Status. The BIOS detects an existing WD drive on SATA Port 5 and the NVMe SSD, but the new drive is not detected on any SATA port.
Checked BIOS settings. Intel VMD is disabled, and nothing obvious appears incorrectly configured.
Tried a different SATA power connector on the same PSU cable chain. That cable also powers a functioning cache SSD.
Rebooted multiple times with no change.
The new drive has never appeared in either Unraid or the motherboard BIOS.
Current thinking:
I'm leaning toward a defective drive, but I find that surprising given that it's brand new.
I've also considered the SATA 3.3V Power Disable issue, although the drive appears to spin continuously, which makes that seem less likely.
My next planned test is to temporarily connect the new drive to the known-working SATA data and power connections from an existing drive, then boot directly into BIOS to see whether it's detected. I'll restore the original drive before starting the Unraid array.
My questions:
- Has anyone encountered a similar issue with a WD Red Plus?
- Is there anything specific to this MSI motherboard, LSI controller, or SATA power configuration that I might be overlooking?
- Is there another diagnostic step worth trying before I return the drive?
I'd appreciate any suggestions. I'm trying to rule out everything reasonable before declaring a brand-new drive DOA.
Thanks!