r/umpiringfails • • Feb 27 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness Clear nick but not out? one of the biggest let-offs for mr 360 👀

1.4k Upvotes

One of those classic “how was that not given? moments when AB de Villiers edged Zaheer Khan, the Indian fielders went up confidently, and even Zak had that knowing smile. The ball clearly seemed to kiss the bat, but the umpire’s finger stayed firmly down. No DRS drama here just pure tension.

AB stood his ground, calm as ever, while Zaheer charged in again with even more intensity. The duel became even more gripping after that decision. Cricket is a game of fine margins, and sometimes those margins come down to umpiring calls that change momentum entirely.

Was it a genuine miss by the umpire, or one of those edges that look worse in slow motion?

SC - https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNlcpCPPBmV/


r/umpiringfails • • Mar 02 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness Aleem dar was one of the most underrated umpires ❤️🔥

790 Upvotes

Aleem Dar quietly built one of the most respected umpiring careers in modern cricket. Known for his calm body language, consistency in tough calls, and ability to handle high-pressure matches without drama, he was a familiar and reassuring presence on the field for years.

Since his retirement, many fans feel that the game has missed that steady authority he brought to big moments. While no umpire is perfect, Dar was widely appreciated for maintaining control without becoming the centre of attention.

SC - https://www.instagram.com/reel/DMkeId_BGnK/


r/umpiringfails • • Mar 30 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness Harbhajan Singh speaks on the 2007-08 Border Gavaskar Trophy umpiring, and he does not hold back. 😂

724 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Mar 16 '26

DRS Would Like to Unsubscribe Ranking the rarest umpire decisions in cricket. Which one surprised you the most?

673 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Mar 26 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness Moments like this show how poor umpiring used to be and why DRS became necessary 💀

630 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Feb 12 '26

Not Out But Somehow Out Poor umpiring by Simon Taufel

370 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Apr 02 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness One of the worst umpiring decisions ever, even Wasim Akram could not believe it. What do you think about this?

333 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Nov 21 '25

Umpire Forgot Physics Such a bad umpiring

254 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Nov 17 '25

Vintage Umpire Madness 39 Incorrect umpiring decisions against Sachin tendulkar

196 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Feb 25 '26

Not Out But Somehow Out Some words by Irfan Pathan on Steve Bucknor bad umpiring

173 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Dec 21 '25

Not Out But Somehow Out When Umpire is so confused to take decision.

170 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Feb 18 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness Umpire forgot he was the umpire! 😅

168 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Dec 05 '25

Vintage Umpire Madness Sachin tendulkar face says it all.

130 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Jan 15 '26

DRS Would Like to Unsubscribe DRS decision that left cricket fans stunned..

125 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Feb 24 '26

Not Out But Somehow Out Decision that steve bucknor still regrets about sachin tendulkar

119 Upvotes

Former elite umpire Steve Bucknor once revealed that the LBW decision he gave against Sachin Tendulkar remains one of the calls he regrets the most in his career. In interviews and public interactions, Bucknor has spoken about how pressure, angle of vision, and the pace of the game can influence split-second decisions, and how that particular moment became a lifelong lesson in humility and accountability. The clip and his comments have resurfaced among fans, sparking fresh discussions about umpiring pressure, human error, and how even legends of officiating have moments they wish they could take back.

Source: Original Post


r/umpiringfails • • Mar 12 '26

DRS Would Like to Unsubscribe Umpire Indians getting stronger every IPL season. What do you think about this decision? 🏏

118 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Nov 18 '25

Umpire Forgot Physics Sachin Tendulkar Vs Steve Bucknor on wrong umpire decision

108 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Jan 08 '26

Umpire Forgot Physics Which Umpiring decision in cricket is the worst among these five?

106 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Feb 23 '26

Vintage Umpire Madness TV Umpire to Director, can we check the height on this one for a No Ball? 👀

103 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Feb 20 '26

Not Out But Somehow Out Umpire Vineet Kulkarni break down this interesting runout! Decision was Not Out

101 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Dec 08 '25

DRS Would Like to Unsubscribe Irfan Pathan’s funny moment with umpire Billy Bowden

101 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Nov 29 '25

Vintage Umpire Madness Sunil Gavaskar’s walkout in Melbourne in 1981 is one of the most controversial moments in cricket history and highlights his intense competitiveness and frustration with umpiring decisions.

100 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Nov 19 '25

Vintage Umpire Madness Poor umpiring by Simon Taufel No bad mouth, no argument. Nods down, goes back to pavilion.

93 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Apr 06 '26

Not Out But Somehow Out Abhishek Sharma catch controversy explained by umpire Anil Chaudhary. Right call or not?

88 Upvotes

r/umpiringfails • • Dec 30 '25

Umpire Forgot Physics Throwback, parveen kumar angry on wrong umpiring

64 Upvotes