I know at this point a lot of people have given up on the reddit, myself included at times. But just hear me out:
I think we can all agree that many of the rules regarding reddit posts have been, and are, unnecessarily strict. I know there are many different things to blame regarding the reddits failure (please comment yours), but I believe it's because of these rules. What I'm going to do is pick apart some of /r/ultrahardcore's current rules and then compare them to other thriving gaming reddits.
The problem with the reddit’s rules lies in the “You should not start a thread for:” and “No-Nos” sections.
Drama (Host X is a bad host, Player X hacks etc.)
No, I don’t want posts made specifically to instigate drama; what I want is more leniency. At times, posts would be removed simply because “it was an opinion” or “it MAY have caused drama” or people would start debating on topics they were passionate about (remember the cutclean drama?). In order for people to want to use the reddit with/over twitter, people need to be able to post what they want. We should be able to talk about UHC config issues, scenario issues, and hosting issues freely.
Resource packs.
Why we ever disallowed community created content from being posted to reddit is completely beyond me. I understand that there’s a wiki used to list many player’s texture packs, but I’ve been apart of the community for >5 years and just learned about it 2 minutes ago. It hasn’t been updated in two years and is basically hidden.
Hosting questions or issues (Post to /r/UHCHosts or read the hosting tutorials instead)
In the past year, there have been 10 posts to /r/UHCHosts. It would be much more efficient for questions (not answered by the hosting tutorials) to be posted to /r/ultrahardcore to get quicker answers or to maybe even inspire players to start hosting.
Many of these rules seemed to be created to make the reddit less “spamy” but that's ridiculous.. People will upvote what they want to see and downvote what they don’t want to see, post removal should not be common.
Successful gaming reddits.
Let’s take a look at a successful gaming reddit, /r/osugame. I’m not going to talk about the actual content, but the rules in place and how they’re being used. I also encourage you to list some of the reddits that you visit that /r/ultrahardcore can learn a thing or two from.
They literally have 9 rules, all of which are completely reasonable. Basically anything relevant to the game is allowed to be posted; the community then decides what’s worthy of attention using upvotes/downvotes. There’s probably around 800,000 active players, 80k are subscribed to the reddit, definitely a ratio /r/ultrahardcore should aim towards.
Why am I trying to fix reddit?
After many months of the UHC player base declining, it seems to finally be on the rise again. I want to continue to see this growth; I miss 120+ players games so much. As a community, we should be taking advantage of this situation by fixing up our old home. When the community was most active, people found UHCs through the reddit. We are missing out on an opportunity to attract more community members.
Other notes
-We need new moderators that are still apart of the community and can relate with new players.
-We need more content; videos, clips, anything that will introduce this community to more people
-We need new flairs. “Fun” flair for jokes. “Videos” should be more specific, maybe split it between “clips” and “highlights”. "Resource Pack" flair.
I understand that these thoughts are just my opinion; please comment what you think of them.