r/ultimate • u/Layout88 • Apr 06 '23
Trans Rights are Human Rights: A Q&A with Penny Wu - Ultiworld
r/ultimate • u/Layout88 • Apr 06 '23
r/ultimate • u/ultitrashtalker • Nov 10 '25
Dear WFDF Leadership, WBUC 2025 Event Organizers, and the Ultimate Frisbee Community,
We, the undersigned, express deep concern about the announced inclusion of the Israel Men’s National Team at the World Beach Ultimate Championships 2025.
Ultimate’s Spirit of the Game and the Olympic movement’s values are not ornamental. They anchor our community in shared humanity, honesty, equality, dialogue, and responsibility. Inviting state representation from a country whose government faces grave, ongoing allegations before international courts and investigative bodies forces every participant into a profound moral conflict at the very moment we are asked to celebrate unity and fairness. Nobody should be forced to celebrate our sport alongside the symbols of an ongoing humanitarian catastrophe.
Sport is political. Admitting a national delegation to a world championship is a political decision: governing bodies decide who may compete under state symbols. By inviting Israel to compete under its flag and anthem, WFDF made a political choice with predictable consequences, bringing into the event a symbol many associate with an ongoing human tragedy. International sport encodes shared human-rights values and a commitment to peace and the reduction of suffering. No country is perfect, but some actions at some times plainly violate these values. In 2025, Israel’s state representation falls into that category. WFDF should accept responsibility for that impact.
This is not a judgment upon individual Israeli athletes**.** We do not hold athletes responsible for their government’s decisions. Our objection is to state representation - flag, anthem, name, emblems - during an active armed conflict marked by serious legal proceedings and findings. Neutral, criteria-based participation rules applied equally to any state in similar circumstances are governance, not discrimination. Respect for Israeli people, culture, and history does not absolve a government from accountability, nor require athletes to celebrate its symbols while grave violations are alleged and investigated. Protesting a state’s representation under these conditions is not only our right; it is our responsibility to uphold the universal values that sport claims to represent - especially when a governing body and event organizers fail to act in a manner consistent with those values. Silence would be complicity.
This decision also creates an operational burden. Asking teams in the Open division to play Israel compels athletes to perform public normalcy - spirit circles, shared fields, medal ceremonies - while suppressing a live moral objection. That should be recognized and planned for so athletes are not forced to choose between sporting aspiration and conscience.
Treating Israel’s participation as routine is not neutrality; it is a choice that disregards widely held ethical concerns. Without an open, public plan for how WFDF will address foreseeable ethical and operational conflicts, the risk of disruption grows. We ask WFDF to acknowledge the legitimacy of the concerns raised by many national programs, invite transparent dialogue, and publish clear policies in advance. Experience across international sport shows that attempts to quiet good-faith expression do not produce harmony; they push conflict onto the field.
There is a clear organizational precedent. In 2022, WFDF suspended the national federations of Russia and Belarus and barred their athletes and officials from sanctioned events following the invasion of Ukraine. WFDF justified that decision by reference to international sport governance standards and the international community welcomed it. We ask for principled consistency.
Our requests to WFDF and the WBUC organizers are as follows:
Apply precedent now Provisionally suspend Israel’s state delegation from WBUC 2025. This aligns WFDF policy with its own 2022 action and shields the event from foreseeable ethical and operational conflicts.
If suspension is not adopted, impose a neutral designation No flag, anthem, country name, or state emblems; list the team as “Neutral Athletes from [country],” with enhanced eligibility screening to ensure no delegation members are active military or security personnel. Publish the criteria and verification process in advance. This mirrors common international-sport remedies to protect competition while avoiding political state representation.
Publish a tournament-operations protocol for conscience-based non-participation If teams decline to play Israel, pre-announce bracket logic, forfeit handling, reseeding rules, and safety measures so competitive integrity is preserved and conflict is minimized. Clarify how such games are recorded, how tie-breakers are computed, how spirit scoring is handled, and how timelines are maintained (including standard captain/observer scripts).
Protect athlete conscience and expression (non-retaliation) Acknowledge that Israel’s participation under current circumstances is exceptional, and explicitly allow non-disruptive athlete expression consistent with WFDF’s policies and international sport norms. Clarify boundaries in writing ahead of the event. Publish a written guarantee that peaceful, non-disruptive expressions of conscience will not be sanctioned or labeled as discrimination. Specify a non-retaliation policy for athletes, teams, and staff who:
decline optional ceremonies (e.g., spirit circle, anthem, photos) or adopt neutral alternatives;
wear armbands, patches, or tape; observe moments of silence; issue brief statements;
substitute a neutral acknowledgment for handshake lines;
make reasoned, respectful statements to media;
choose conscience-based non-participation in a specific match following the published protocol.
If WFDF declines action, we respectfully ask the Israeli delegation to consider the burden their state representation places on every opponent: the request to share spirit circles and podiums under a flag and anthem that, for many, symbolize an ongoing tragedy. As fellow athletes, you can help protect honesty and dignity for all participants by voluntarily minimizing national symbols (uniforms, flag, anthem, emblems), supporting neutral presentation, accepting peaceful, non-disruptive expressions of conscience from opponents, and recognizing that some teams may decline to play without hostility toward individual players. Such voluntary steps would reduce harm, allow athletes to compete without betraying their values, and help preserve the integrity of the event.
We love this sport. We mourn the human tragedy in Gaza. We reject apathy. And we ask WFDF to act with courage and consistency so that WBUC 2025 reflects the values we are all supposed to share.
Respectfully,
Irish Open Beach Team
Lebanon Mixed National Team
Polish Open National Team
Polish Women's National Team
Qatar Open National Team
Spain Masters Open National Team
We welcome other WBUC 2025 national teams who wish to co-sign this letter. Please submit your details via the co-signature form and your team will be added to the undersigned.
---
I am reposting this for visibility, as this letter has been shared with WFDF but I think it should be public too. @.ultiworld
r/ultimate • u/Matsunosuperfan • Apr 07 '25
Unless you're playing a national title contender, your opponents are not applying enough consistent pressure that offense should feel difficult.
If offense feels difficult, you or your team or most likely both are not taking the optimal approach. You don't even have to be faster than the team playing defense; the rules favor offense way too much for that to be the sole difference maker unless they're astronomically more athletic than you.
It's 2025 and the game has evolved a lot. But my thesis remains that most turnovers are the result of bad decisions, a sub-optimal offensive scheme, or both.
Playing goaltimate more as I age has really opened my eyes to all the ways there are to beat a defender and get the disc to a teammate in 7 seconds or less. I played a tournament this weekend: I think I probably threw somewhere between 60 and 70 passes with 0 turnovers. I was surprised when I looked back and realized it was my first tournament with a clean sheet.
It did not even feel difficult. I just kind of refused to do anything that would result in a turnover. It was basically that simple.
ETA: sorry y'all I did not mean to say "just be good at frisbee." I mean that a shift in mindset ("offense should be easy, how can we/I make it easy?") can be really impactful.
r/ultimate • u/richardb94 • Oct 15 '24
r/ultimate • u/Jomskylark • Sep 07 '21
r/ultimate • u/FrisbeeDuckWing • Apr 02 '24
r/ultimate • u/Excellent_Degree8241 • Nov 21 '25
Undeniably cheating. I don’t care if you did it on purpose or by accident. This is brutal and lame and France should be in the gold medal game.
USA loves to be spirit warriors til they have something to lose.
r/ultimate • u/hotlou • Apr 28 '24
I'm seeing more and more celebrations with people kissing the disc away. Stop it, you're probably infect-ing the disc. Spike it onto the ground for all I care, but don't kiss it.
r/ultimate • u/MTPoketz • Apr 30 '19
I was by no means a fan of Carleton in college but this run of memes seems to be in pretty poor taste to me. Why even have the rules about low effort posts if we are just going to blatantly ignore it?
r/ultimate • u/GEThrowawayy • Nov 25 '17
Just want to set the record straight as I hear the AUDL referred to as a men's league all to often. There are currently the exact same number of opportunities for women as men in professional ultimate. A women's league would tip the scales and grant extra opportunities for women that are not granted to men. Whether this is a good or bad can be discussed, but as a matter of fact, women and men are currently on the same playing field in professional ultimate.
Even a mixed league would favor women's participation as a women would be allowed to fill a man's spot on the line, but a man would not be allowed to fill a women's.
As an aside, there are already more opportunities for women than men in club ultimate as women are allowed to play in 3/3 divisions and men are only allowed to play in 2/3 divisions. Again, I am not taking on stance on whether this is fair, unfair, good or bad - I am just stating a fact.
Edit: Changed my mind and didn't edit anything.
r/ultimate • u/unchuckable • Sep 20 '24
Preface: this is coming from a USA-centric perspective and is not a robust, well-researched opinion. It's a hypothesis I've discussed with a few people and wanted to see further discussion. This is not a strongly held belief, just an idea I wanted to share for conversation.
My hypothesis is that the proliferation of youth ultimate may be limiting the potential of the top levels of the game. My theory is that increasingly robust (and in Vermont varsity-status) programs could motivate young players to drop other sports and focus on frisbee.
Some anecdotal ideas to support the theory: a quick look at Division I college championship rosters shows that there aren't many rookies on top teams coming in with little to no ultimate experience. Programs are getting freshman who have years of high school and youth club experience, but who likely got that experience by focusing on frisbee to the exlusion of other sports. Because top programs are getting these ready-to-go players with disc skills and tactics, there's much less motivation to recruit or develop non-experienced multi-sport athletes from around the campus. Back in my day, teams would try to recruit the former high school soccer/basketball/football/track star and turn them into frisbee players. Now we have frisbee nerds who need to develop into track stars. I'm not sure which way is better.
Another data point I'm less sure of: at the Wolrd Juniors championships, France defeated USA in the girl's final. From my limited knowledge of the USA team and watching the game, it looked like team USA was super skilled overall, but were athletically outmatched by France, at least at the top of the roster. Maybe USA could have or should have won with some different strategies, but it looked to me like France ran us out of the gym.
These conditions lead to the current state of the game in the USA where small-ball offensive strategies are ubiquitous. Is it actually the best way to play, or is it the best way to play with the current pool of players as they were developed? Anyway, I'm certainly not committed to this idea but I'm interested to see what everyone thinks here.
r/ultimate • u/CULTimate • Feb 11 '24
I’ve seen a lot of you people wearing pit vipers,, I know some of you went…
r/ultimate • u/rjmcleod • Apr 20 '25
r/ultimate
•
u/layoutorleave
•
Dec 14 '24
This is an email I sent to the USAU Board, CEO, and staff after declining a spot on Team USA as a selector for the masters open team for World Beach Ultimate Championships.
______________________
Dear USAU CEO, board members, and staff,
I have declined a spot on Team USA (WBUC Masters Open, team selector) and I wanted to write to you about that decision.
With the failure to pass the ceasefire statement motion at the WFDF congress earlier this year, where USAU voted “no” on the motion, I feel that USAU does not represent my values and values I hold dear about the Ultimate community. USAU had the opportunity to take even just a symbolic stance and didn't meet the bare minimum bar of supporting an end to the violence. While I recognize that any organization won’t be 100% aligned with my personal values, standing up against an ongoing genocide when given the opportunity is one I cannot abandon. As such, I cannot in good conscience represent USA Ultimate as a member of Team USA.
I remain grateful to the staff for their work and am still honored to be selected for the position. Having spoken to various folks involved with the Team USA process, I also appreciate that under USAU there is room for personal expression of beliefs and I support athletes willing to participate and share their views. However, I am most interested in changing the organizational stance. It is not clear to me that as a Team USA player, I would have any greater access to foster such change. That’s why I’m writing to you all.
I urge you to consider what the “no” vote conveys to our community and to those who would join. I would argue that it most deeply affects our most marginalized players and signals that ultimate is a space where human rights will take a back seat to some unknown force. The lack of transparency about the decision only further alienates those who care deeply about this issue. As a practical point, if there is concern about the diversity of the talent pool at the highest level, decisions like this will only worsen the imbalance. Personally, it feels extremely difficult to invest in an organization with this position.
Ultimate is a space where I have found great joy and belonging and also learned a great deal about who I am and who I want to be. I know that to be true for many others. In that spirit, I sincerely hope there is continued discussion and momentum towards action within USAU on this matter. If there are other avenues to engage in the organizational position on this and other issues, I would like to know and participate.
Thanks for your time,
Byron Liu
______________________
As for why I'm posting publicly about it, I guess I just wanted to let others who may still have this on their mind that there are others that do as well. And with the hope that we all think about what relative power we have in the communities and organizations we participate in and how we can leverage that.
As I mentioned in the email, I am all for athletes sharing their positions at these worlds events, but I am most interested in what we can collectively do to drive change on USAU's official position here. If anyone has thoughts or actions on that front, please reach out!
r/ultimate • u/No_Look_turfedflick • May 16 '23
Weird question I know, but I figured I might as well post here. I’m a pretty aggressive player who tends to lay out a lot. I am considering getting a tail sewn on (I am a furry) but I’m worried a tail will increase drag while i am in mid-air. I’m also wondering if anyone else has done this, in the case of using your tail as a propellor (like a helicopter) for better flight. Has anyone experienced this or had any thoughts? Thanks for humoring me, lol
r/ultimate • u/Mooney2021 • Apr 08 '22
The instruction from our provincial organization is that a player needs to declare as male or female at the start of the year and stay with that for the year. I am not saying that it is easy but this seems to deny the way some people understand and experience gender fluidity or being non-binary. Are there other ways this is being handled that might be an improvement?
r/ultimate • u/ATX_Torch • Jun 12 '24
r/ultimate • u/FrisbeeDuckWing • May 03 '22
r/ultimate • u/D_Edge42 • May 28 '18
Between not going for skyball D’s & that final Pitt score? He’s better than that, whatsup?
r/ultimate • u/BBQchickenBackhand • Oct 05 '18
With recent talk about the AUDL boycott, I'm curious to see everyone's opinion on this topic...
Talking from a strictly financial perspective, women's ultimate is not worth the investment. I'm not saying women's ultimate should not be a thing, I fully support all genders playing ultimate; however, historically women's sports do not have a favorable financial return in comparison to male sports. There are sports that complement women's strengths, sports such as gymnastics, tennis, and ice skating, and those sports do receive favorable returns. However, in the case of women playing sports that are identical to men's sports, NBA vs the WNBA for example, the male version will always receive a higher return.
That being said, I am concerned for the future of ultimate because of the extreme focus on gender equity. In my opinion, the only way to grow the popularity of ultimate, in the hopes of it becoming as popular as other professional sports, is to focus on male ultimate because of the higher viewing rate and higher financial return.
I would like to hear everyone's input on this! :)
r/ultimate • u/PrairieSurge • May 23 '24
For the last several years one of the greatest mysteries of college ultimate has remained unsolved.
How did Oklahoma Christian, a school without an Ultimate team, acquire funding to give scholarships to players to play ultimate?
Ultiworld and other news organizations have been largely silent on this fascinating subject, and it seems that they would like us to believe that there isn't a big story here; however, I believe that there is a deep-seated conspiracy at work.
MKBHD did OKCU.
Let me take a step back and lay out all of the facts. First off, MKBHD is a outspoken advocate for Ultimate Frisbee. He uses his platform to share his love for the sport and has had a major hand in increasing the number of young players entering the scene. However, one man, even one with over 82 million subscribers on YouTube, can only do so much for the sport. If I had his resources I would want to use them to change the landscape of Ultimate forever, and I believe that he has.
For years, I've heard that the next evolution of College Ultimate would come when schools begin fielding scholarship teams, but with few financial incentives (you aren't going to fill a stadium where the die hard fans) it seemed unlikely that this would ever happen. However, Oklahoma Christian bucked this trend.
Fact: Oklahoma Christian was the perfect school to attempt this experiment. No existing team. No major youth scene from which to draw. A school that can compete at the D3 level (and therefore most likely to make an immediate impact.) Most importantly, a school that has no connection to MKBHD, and therefore could not be traced back to him.
Fact: it is important that it appears this scholarship came from outside the frisbee community. If it became obvious that this experiment was the pet project of a major ultimate celebrity, other schools looking to emulate their success may be turned off.
Fact: The experiment worked. Oklahoma Christian was almost defeated by a second men's D3 scholarship team, one in its first year, out of Davenport. The first scholarship D3 women's team, also from Davenport, made a surprising run in the bracket as well.
With the formula now proving successful for two separate teams, I expect to see an increase in scholarship teams over the next few years. It remains to be seen if a D1 size school will take the plunge.
And if MKBHD didn't start this trend, he should join it by sponsoring a team, potentially his Alma Mater, Stevens Tech, a D3 team out of the Metro East.