r/twilight • • Feb 28 '25

Character/Relationship Discussion Unpopular Take: Bella lead Jacob On, Resulting in “The Kiss”

22 Upvotes

Yes. I am ready to get downvoted to oblivion, but I’m rereading the series for the first time as an adult. I previously always HATED that Jacob kissed Bella against her will and again semi coerced her into another one, and I’m not saying he was right to do any of that….but I understand why he could feel she was hiding her true feelings for him, resulting on him “making a move”.

And honestly, I hated the fact that she could never admit it to herself where it was that plain as day that she loved the boy. Maybe she wasn’t IN LOVE with him like she was with Edward (see infatuated), but to deny she had any feelings or attraction to Jacob is silly.

I also hated the fact that Bella so easily forgave Edward for leaving (I understand why he did however) but she used Jacob to patch the hole he left and then just kicked him to the curb when he came back like they weren’t getting closer.

I feel like too many people hate Jacob for how it all played out when she even admitted she knew she crossed boundaries with him, but she knew “he understood”, like it’s his fault for catching feelings.

Then, he ends up imprinting on Ren&Stimpy for whatever godforsaken reason, like he can never be free from Bella.

I know he’s a flawed character, but he deserved better.

Rant over


r/twilight • • Aug 03 '24

Character/Relationship Discussion rosalie and emmett are not a good couple, and sapphic rosalie would've been more interesting

1 Upvotes

i have not read the books, so everything i say will be based on the movies and what i've read of the books. feel free to disagree and fill in with missing information! this will be a LONG post lol

ok so i LOVE rosalie as a character. i think she is fascinating and one of the best written characters in the series. she is a woman that was raised with the idea that she should get married and have children, and take care of her family and household (very sexist ideals) and had all of that taken away because of the man she planned on doing all that with. she was taught to put her looks (and other people) above all, so during and specially after the rape, started putting her beauty at the forefront, believing that was the most worthy thing about herself (and is seen as vapid by characters like edward, despite being anything but). she then picks up hobbies like mechanics, something perceived as masculine, to sort of break out of that mold.

and then SM goes and pairs her with... the himbo jock. i like emmett, i think he's a fine character, but he has so little depth that it feels like a at best boring pairing. and then you add the fact that rosalie refuses (and never has) to drink human blood because of how much she wishes she was still human, yet emmett has had multiple accidents where he drank it and doesn't seem to really care or feel guilty about it (nor does he miss his human life). sure, he treats her well and is in love with her, which is great and all, but them together just... makes no sense to me.

i think it would have been much more interesting to make her fall in love with a woman (honestly, even if it was a human. twilight with rosalie in edward's place would've been MUCH more interesting). imagine a woman that sees rosalie for something other than her beauty at the forefront (such as her intelligence); while of course finding her beautiful (because that's impossible to ignore), it's the other trait that trumps out and makes her interested in rosalie. imagine a woman that is okay and encourages rosalie to put effort in being pretty, but puts no pressure on her to do so, ensuring that rosalie could put no effort and she wouldn't care. also someone that UNDERSTANDS rosalie's struggles (at least to some extent), that knows what it's like to have her beauty viewed as priority and knows what it's like to be afraid of men... and then rosalie is so confused, because she was raised in a time where that wasn't allowed and with the idea that she would marry and give her life to a man, not a woman. and if it is a human, it could affect her longing of the life in a way that is much more personal than with bella, because she'd want to be with a bella, instead of seeing it from the sidelines. the angst and longing and internalised homophobia... almost writing that fic lol


r/twilight • • Oct 06 '25

Book Discussion first time reading the Twilight Saga

Post image
0 Upvotes

it’s october and i’ve just decided to finally start reading the series. tell me something interesting without spoiling xx


r/twilight • • May 18 '24

Character/Relationship Discussion Rosalie and Carlisle

Post image
0 Upvotes

OK so hear me out...

If Esme had never been in the picture...

I kinda think Rosalie & Carlisle might have ended up together and I kinda love it (no shade to Esme or Emmett, I love them both!)

Their interactions throughout the series are always respectful, sometimes kinda flirty (nice kitty) and they challenge eachother and make eachother see things from another perspective in a really healthy way.

She would have struggled I initially with resenting him for turning her, but once she saw and understood the purity and compassion of his intentions, she wouldn't hold it against him.

They both also have the same core values - compassion, family values, etc. They're really well matched for a healthy relationship.

I also think Carlisle would have found a way for Rose to have a child/children to look after. Either by adopting or maybe an orphan baby from the hospital or something. He'd do whatever he can to make her happy.

Can anyone else see it?


r/twilight • • Feb 14 '24

Book Discussion Bella cooking for Charlie is disturbing

0 Upvotes

It's absolutely bizarre in the books that Bella is somehow tasked with cooking dinner for Charlie? She apologizes for not having cooked for him those few times she came home late, excuses herself out of meeting others because she has to "cook him dinner" and other weird mentions like this. On top of this she actually has a job in New Moon, which I didn't even remember, while also being 18, while also finishing her education?

It's absolutely disturbing and ridiculous. If Bella was doing this before age 18, then it's weird and off as she was the teenager and therefore it was the parent's job to cook for her, or at least even if she was participating in making dinner, it would be a /participation/, with a clear sign that the burden fell on Charlie for the most part. After turning 18, then it's even more bizarre because she is a grown ass adult likely waiting to move out of the house to go to college or get married or whatever adult things she wants to do, and therefore her living at Charlie's is just a temporary arrangement. With Charlie being a grown ass adult, while she's also legally an adult, so the splitting of chores and whatnot should have been even more equal then, with her cooking for herself, him for himself, etc. But his being the parent, and given that it's technically his house, the bigger chunk of the job should fall to him, and that's really normal, with Bella doing her own share of ensuring she cleans up after herself.

Instead, he really just had a teenage girl cook him his dinners and cleaning the whole house, and then a recently barely legal adult do the same.

Not to mention the parts where Charlie somehow supports Jacob kissing Bella without her permission, something the movie luckily glossed over. And yet Bella is terrified to announce she's gonna get married, like somehow that's more shocking than Charlie making her feed him like he's handicapped or a toddler. Billy Black is one thing considering he's actually disabled, and even then it seems Jacob does so willingly (taking care of him), in some ways. whereas Bella, it's like it's thrust upon her and she doesn't have a choice. It's like she's a live in maid used by both parents and it's sincerely disgusting.

There's honestly so many unhealthy elements in the story, and yet Meyers never writes them as unhealthy, she just somehow acts like it's Tuesday. I dont know what kind of upbringing she got but it's sincerely disturbing.

edit: yes I know Charlie isn't forcing Bella to cook. there is still an imbalance in the fact that he's the parent, and yet she is the one who has to step up in lieu of her parent(s) doing it. not to mention that the snippets from the book that I recall, specifically mention her having to make Charlie dinner or fix him dinner, not like she's cooking for herself, but like she's cooking for him specifically, and that makes her sound like she's his wife. that, coupled with everything else, especially that in New Moon she's depressed over Edward leaving, makes her sound seriously overworked in a way that makes no sense for her age. The problem again is the context and undertone. because when she talks about it it's always framed as "cooking dinner for Charlie", not as her cooking for them both. because of it she doesn't sound like a responsible young adult. it would be ok IF it was in the context of Charlie and her both doing that, but it isn't. she really doesn't sound like she's a well brought up young adult, but like she's his wife. that's the disturbing part, and yes, there's obviously worse in the book.


r/twilight • • Jun 11 '26 This

Meta Discussion Unpopular opinion

348 Upvotes

It annoys me when people in this fandom refer to Renesmee as something other than her name, like "Rasputin," "Renegade," "Zimbabwe," "Rapscallion," "Receptacle," etc.

Her name is not THAT strange, it's literally just Rene and Esme. I always thought it was pretty 😅 Somehow, every time someone uses a weird different name, it trips me up and I'm confused for half a second on wtf they're talking about. And they won't even use the SAME fake name throughout; it'll be all of those names I listed being used interchangeably through the post/video! 😭


r/twilight • • Jul 30 '26

Character/Relationship Discussion Edward is such an awful character, and I'm honestly surprised he still has so many fans.

Post image
2 Upvotes

Throughout their entire relationship, he treated Bella terribly. He constantly talked down to her, literally called her a child to her face, invaded her privacy, controlled who she spent time with, and made decisions for her instead of with her. He'd already decided to leave her months before New Moon, yet he kept dating her and let her fall even more in love with him instead of ending things sooner. If he was so sure he was leaving, he could've done it after the hospital incident instead of waiting until September and making it even more painful.

He's also disrespectful to Rosalie, has a really strange dynamic with Alice, and isn't a great father to Renesmee. Bella never really got to be herself around him because she put him on a pedestal. Their relationship never felt like love to me. It felt like obsession. Edward was fascinated because he couldn't read Bella's mind, and Bella was obsessed with the fact that he was a vampire and could eventually turn her into one. If Edward had just been a normal guy living in modern times, I don't think either of them would've looked twice at the other.

I honestly think Bella would've been happier with Jacob. She was more relaxed around him and didn't constantly idolize him. He wasn't perfect, and what he did in Eclipse was absolutely assault and completely unacceptable. But a lot of his behavior in that book felt wildly out of character. It honestly seemed like Stephenie Meyer realized she'd made Jacob too appealing as a love interest, so she wrote him in a much worse light to make Edward the obvious choice. Then she had Jacob imprint on Bella's daughter, which completely shut the door on any chance of Bella and Jacob ever being together.

At the end of the day, I think Edward and Bella were drawn together more by fantasy than genuine compatibility, and that's why I've never been able to see them as a truly healthy or convincing couple.


r/twilight • • Sep 09 '23

Movie Discussion This is probably a stupid question but how does Edward know that someone is coming without looking at them?

1 Upvotes

In the first movie, Edward was at Bella’s house and he left when he knew Billy and Jacob were coming before he looked them. In the second movie, Edward tells Bella that Jacob wants to see her without looking at him coming towards them. So how did he know?


r/twilight • • Dec 10 '23

Book Discussion Does Bella completely cut off Charlie in the books?

5 Upvotes

Have never read the books, just started Twilight book 1, but I just read an article that said Bella completely cut contact with Charlie when she became a Vampire. Is this true? If so did the movies change that to keep him in Bella’s life? It seems so harsh and not like something book Bella would do, at least so far as what I’ve read about her in the first book. This is the article I read https://screenrant.com/twilight-bella-charlie-ending-choice-not-justified/#:~:text=Bella%20cuts%20her%20father%20Charlie,amount%20of%20flack%20from%20critics.


r/twilight • • Sep 28 '22

Fan Content/Showcase Jokes about renesmee’s name are so obnoxious 😭

144 Upvotes

I can’t be the only one who just haaates the whole renaissance/regurgitation/rasputin/etc bit. I’ve been in the fandom since pre-twilight renaissance, and you’d think a joke going since 2018 would eventually get stale… but if anything, the tiktok fandom has just made it even more prevalent. Like we get it, it’s a stupid name. But the jokes, to me, are even more stupid. 💀


r/twilight • • Jan 02 '26

Character/Relationship Discussion Disorder in women Cullen

0 Upvotes

If the women in the Cullen family had any disorders (depression, generalized anxiety, borderline personality disorder, bipolar disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, social phobia, autism, schizophrenia, eating disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, etc.), which ones would make the most sense for the characters? (Just a random and genuine curiosity)

In my opinion, Esme could have mild depression, due to her history and how she almost died, and anxiety from worrying too much about her family. Rose would have post-traumatic stress disorder (we know the reason) and depression because of the vampire life she hates. Alice would have bipolar disorder, I see some very extreme mood swings in her, attention deficit, perhaps because of the visions and the fact that she is very hyperactive, dissociation, also because of the visions. Bella would have depression, and this is quite noticeable in New Moon, anxious attachment disorder (the fear of Edward's abandonment), and mild social anxiety.

And you?


r/twilight • • Mar 21 '26

Character/Relationship Discussion WTF is this pice of shit.

0 Upvotes

To explain, I’m reading the books for the first time. I’m currently on Book 3, chapter “Fire and Ice” plus about 50 more pages.

What the hell is wrong with Bella? She’s with Edward. She loves Edward. She only wants Edward. And every single time Jacob shows up, she rejects him. Every time she regrets it and wants him back, only to push him away again.

And now they’re sitting together in that tent. Edward is sitting there like a cuck, watching the love of his life lying in a sleeping bag next to Jacob, and she acts like this is completely normal and fine.

After Jacob leaves, they swear eternal loyalty to each other. Jacob is completely broken, Edward brings him back, and then Bella says “kiss me” to Jacob while her fiancé is literally waiting in the woods????????? What the hell is wrong with Bella.


r/twilight • • May 09 '26

Character/Relationship Discussion people are constantly like " team edeward, team jacob" i'm team alice.

0 Upvotes

HEAR ME OUT!!!

ok IMO edward is a little creepy and i know hes like suppoused be but hes like 105 and bella is 17 likeee creep much and jacob will be jacob he disrespects her boundaries like in eclipse he kisses her and she BREAKS HER HAND WHILE TRYING TO PUNCH HIM AWAY, i think that bella should get with alice, alice likes her and is freinds with her and was so welcoming to her in the first book and bella is way to hot for edward, edward looks like hes constapated and jacob looks like he keeps smelling a fart but bella is like a fucking angel she is soooo pretty and like i can't discribe it, i might just be really gay for her.


r/twilight • • Mar 13 '23

Character/Relationship Discussion A horrible daughter

0 Upvotes

Doing my weekly rewatch of twilight, and like Bella was a horrible daughter. Like I know, she probably has trauma from her parents breaking up, but like the codependency and just lack of empathy for her father truly is just hard to watch because had that been my daughter you would be locked into a tower like Rapunzel like I’m sorry because yes granted you’re 18 but you just runoff to a whole nother country all in the name of your suicidal boyfriend yeah you’re going into a mental hospital.


r/twilight • • Jul 13 '24

Character/Relationship Discussion This is lame (the caption, not the couple!)

Post image
11 Upvotes

Look, it's 2024. I'm not gonna start a huge "Team Edward vs Team Jacob" discussion. Neither do I want to. But am I the only one who feels rubbed the wrong way by these super biased and dismissive meme captions on the official Twilight social media accounts?

Like, I totally get that many people have issues with the character of Jacob Black. He's a tragic antihero, with borderline villainous tendencies, who did some pretty bad things. But Bella still loved him. A lot. Almost enough to break her out of the supernatural bond she had with Edward. That's canon.

They're kind of a huge deal. The true star-crossed lovers of Twilight. At least half of the main books focus on their relationship, if not three quarters of them. Most of the series, really.

Now, I don't know which books everyone was reading, or if they read the books at all (which l'm sometimes unsure of) but if they did, then they should be aware of the fact that we spent a massive chunk of the series in Bella's head, agonizing over her doomed love for Jacob, and vice versa.

Bella and Jacob are Twilight, at least just as much as Bella and Edward are.

And while many readers, and watchers, might hate them together, just as many, if not more, got invested in their heartbreaking tragedy of a love story, including me.

Because of that, I can't help but hate it when a, presumably rather young, social media manager can regularly take to the official Twilight account and publically mock and diminish their relationship, be it out of a personal vendetta or simply for the lolz.

Given the facts above, it almost feels like false advertising, since they're promoting a series where said relationship and kiss, that they publically trash in the same breath, are very much a massive deal.

I know that the series is mostly old news at this point, and thus possibly just inevitably doomed to post-ironic meta-commentary, but imagine a new reader, brought in by Midnight Sun and the renaissance, constantly being exposed to this stuff online, hence expecting nothing but pure, unadulterated Team Edward from it, and then most of it ends up actualy being "Bella struggles because she secretly loves Jacob: The series" lol.

It just doesn't line up with what Twilight actually is, and what most actual fans connect with it, and it reminds me of the days where everyone publicly ridiculed and hated it, only that it now happens under the official banner, and the convenient mantle of irony.

Now, again, I'm not trying to start a fight, or get anyone fired or anything. Don't think could, even if I wanted to lol.

What am l gonna do, talk to the manager?! ;D

I just wish that, at the very least, the official Twilight accounts could be genuine about this series. We've kind of earned that.


r/twilight • • May 11 '25

Character/Relationship Discussion LGBT in twilight?

0 Upvotes

Are there any indirect or direct mentions of anything LGBT in twilight whether that be the movies or the books? I haven't reread/re-watched in a while, and I have an obscure faint memory of something non-heterosexual being mentioned in the books.


r/twilight • • Jan 09 '25

Character/Relationship Discussion Am I becoming Team Jacob?

0 Upvotes

After years of being a fan of the saga, for the first time I find myself wanting Bella to end up with Jacob. I'm reading New Moon and I'm really enjoying this Jake before the transformation and I kept imagining Edward coming back one day to see how Bella is doing and see her having fun with Jacob in the Swan's living room, doing their homework together, then Billy and Charlie arriving and eating a lasagna that Bella made together, and all of them together and happy. I can imagine him thinking that something good has finally happened with his departure, and that Bella can be human and happy with Jacob, and because of that he decides to go back to his family and tells them that Bella is fine and happy. I wonder if maybe this made Alice not see any of Bella's decisions and doesn't see her jumping off the cliff, or even sees it but doesn't see it as if she killed herself so she doesn't talk to anyone and ends up seeing that Bella is fine but doesn't talk to her. And somehow the wolves manage to defeat Victoria, and Bella and Jacob live happily ever after (or would Bella at some point become a Leah after Jake imprints on someone different?)

The only way I could become Team Jacob was if Edward never came back, because I hate the person Jacob becomes after Edward comes back, I only like him again when he imprints on Nessie.


r/twilight • • Aug 16 '24

Character/Relationship Discussion Leah isn't that innocent.

1 Upvotes

Yes, her situation really sucks, and yes, she has every right to be upset about the situation with Sam and Emily.

But she loses some of my empathy when she uses Embry's paternity just to cause deliberate pain.

Embry and her mother have nothing to do with Leah's situation and her use of this particular touchy subject makes her a bit of a jerk in my eyes.


r/twilight • • Jun 13 '25

Plot Discussion The certificates Spoiler

1 Upvotes

In twilight breaking dawn 2 bella goes alone to meet this guy at a restaurant and is given some sort of certificate for both Jake and renesmee, what are they? Why did she pack a bag for them? And why did they want renesmee and jacob to leave somewhere together? I'm just hoping for some information on what happened here since I'm a little confused


r/twilight • • Nov 24 '25

Movie Discussion Bella says the most Washington state thing ever

1 Upvotes

Watching the last movie and Bella says "the snow is sticking" which is like the most Washington state thing I have ever heard in my whole life. If you know you know and I'm sure that other places say that too but like seriously it kinda killed me XD


r/twilight • • Oct 08 '25

Meta Discussion The joke of calling Renesmee every other R word is getting old

6 Upvotes

It’s getting hard to read comments when you call her everything else. The joke is done.


r/twilight • • Jun 06 '24

Twilight-ish They are not vampires opinion

0 Upvotes

Okay so I had this conversation with a few people back in college. How Stephanie had a dream about the meadow scene, how they are strong and sparkle and I was reading a book series called wicked lovely at that time with fairies in it and came to the conclusion that twilight vampires are actually fairies instead, just based on the meadow scene itself and steph took liberties to make sparkling vampires. Fairies glamour themselves, have powers, and are stronger then humans.


r/twilight • • Aug 27 '25

Twilight-ish If Twilight got a remake, who would be the perfect casting to you?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I saw Florence Hunt in bridgerton and I immediately thought she looked like Bella from the illustrated guide. What's your perfect casting?


r/twilight • • Aug 13 '25

Movie Discussion Haven’t seen Twilight

0 Upvotes

I’ve never seen the Twilight movies, but I’m actually pretty curious about them. I know they’re not exactly high art, but I feel like they’re such a big part of pop culture that I should at least watch them once. The problem is my boyfriend flat-out refuses. He keeps saying they’re really bad and not worth his time, so he doesn’t see the point.

I get that they’re not everyone’s cup of tea, but I think it could be fun to watch them together ; even if it’s just to laugh at the cheesy parts. Any tips on how I could convince him to give them a try with me? Or should I just watch them on my own?