r/tvcriticism • u/2017hayden • Nov 12 '18
Spirit Riding Free Does not Seem to be True to Its Roots.
For those of you who may or may not know Spirit Riding Free, found its base in the 2002 animated film Spirit Stallion of the Cimarron. The movie was about spirit a wild mustang, and his adventures in the plains region of North America. Specifically his quest for freedom from a group of US soldiers who were rounding up wild horses to break and tame them, while simultaneously slaughtering the Native American tribes of the surrounding area. The TV show, which is so loosely based on the same story that I hesitate to even say it’s related, is about a little girl who moved to an incredibly immaculate “Wild West” town. Once she arrives she promptly meets a captive Spirit and frees him. After which he spontaneously decided to become her glorified taxi service wherever she wants to go. Notice the contradiction, the movie is about a wild horse struggling to maintain his freedom. The TV show is about a little girl mounting up a wild horse and using him to facilitate her adventures. Now don’t get me wrong, I have nothing against the concept of the series, and I realize that any historical inaccuracy is likely due to the fact that this is meant to be a show for children. The problem I have is that they took the name of a fantastic movie, and slapped it onto a tv series that has a completely different meaning. If they wanted to make a spirit TV series they failed epically, and if they wanted to make a series about a girl and her horse why even associate it with Spirit in the first place? I know that many people argue that they are trying to play of the popularity of an already established title, but anyone old enough to remember spirit is in their 20’s by now like me. In addition I have a hard time believing that anyone who liked the movie would want to watch this series, as it’s not at all true to the movie. I guess I just want to know why this happened?