r/TruePokemon • • Jul 23 '20 Heartwarming Bravo

While it is true that Iwata did write a new compression algorithm for Gold/Silver, it did not save any space. In fact, it actually cost space. The reason for the new compression algorithm was to increase the speed of decompression.

907 Upvotes

Bit of a longer post, but it's definitely worth the read. Hopefully, even those of you not familiar with the topic might learn something interesting. Sources and TL;DR at the bottom.

For those of you that have ever read or watched trivia regarding Pokémon Gen 2 (Gold/Silver/Crystal), or Satoro Iwata you've undoubtedly come across videos or posts such as this [1], this [2], this [3], this [4], this [5], this [6], this [7], and even this [8]. This fact has even found its way into the Wikipedia page for Gold & Silver [25]. They all basically recite the same or similar story--during the development of Gen 2, Game Freak could not fit all of the data into the cartridges. Iwata stepped in and created a compression algorithm that either allowed Game Freak to include Kanto with the leftover space or gave them enough space that they could fit in the rest of the region as planned. (For those of you unfamiliar, the first generation Pokémon--Red, Blue, and Yellow--take place in the fictional region of Kanto. The second generation--Gold, Silver, and Crystal--take place in the fictional region of Johto. The second gen also includes the Kanto region upon completion of a major event). I, too, heard this story many times and decided to look into what exactly Game Freak did differently in Gen 2 that would have saved them so much space. As far as I knew, Gen 1 was already compressed so surely there couldn't have been THAT much space to save from compression.

Well, I looked into it and I am here to tell you that not only is the aforementioned mostly made up, the compression algorithm used in Gen 2 actually took up MORE space. While Iwata did indeed write the compression for Gen 2, but it wasn't for the reason you think.

In Gen 1, Game Freak compressed the Pokémon and trainer sprites via a method called Run-Length Encoding (RLE). You can view a breakdown and see how it works in Pokémon specifically here [9]. In Gen 2, Game Freak used a different compression algorithm known as Lunar Compression Format 3 (LC_LZ3 or just LZ3) [10] [11] [12]. This was itself was based off of LC_LZ19 (LZ19) [13]. Nintendo used Lunar Compression often around that time [14], often creating their own formats and keeping little to no documentation [15].

I searched around trying to find what exactly the difference between the two are, and what would cause them to change. I eventually came across the people working on the Pokecrystal disassembly project [16] [17]. They explained the difference as "the commands are specifically chosen to work well with tile-based graphics, where some tiles tend to be horizontal or vertical mirror images of each other, which plain RLE isn't aware of." While also noting that a lot of sources get Gen 1 and 2 algorithms mixed up such as [14].

At the end, I was given a file of all Pokémon and trainer sprites from Gen 1 and 2 [18]. This includes both front and back sprites, and each sprite is split into 4 separate files: Regular image as it would show on the Gameboy, the regular image compressed with RLE, the regular image compressed with LZ3, and the regular image compressed with LZ3, but optimized to take up the least space possible. I copied the data for each file into a spreadsheet and added up the total number of bytes each format used up [19].

Gen 1:

Type --- Bytes

Plain Image 198542

Gen 1 RLE 73298

Gen 2 LZ3 110240

LZ3 Optimized 99475

Gen 2:

Type --- Bytes

Plain Image 371216

Gen 1 RLE 206790

Gen 2 LZ3 217565

LZ3 Optimized 211701

As you can see, Game Freak actually lost space by switching to LZ3. In Gen 2, the space lost is 10.7KB or about 4.95% more than the space RLE would have given. Even if Game Freak had been able to optimize the LZ3 compression (they were not), they still would have lost about 4.9KB or 2.4%. The uncompressed Pokémon and trainer sprites were also the same size--56x56 pixels (smaller Pokémon occupied 48x48 and 40x40 pixels, but sprites could be as small as 8x8; but that area is still reserved) [33].

This brings into question why exactly Game Freak switched compression algorithms. As stated earlier LZ3 would be great for tiles that are mirror images of each other, but only the Pokémon and trainer sprites were compressed; stuff like tiles were stored as-is on the rom itself. You can see a visualization of these tilesets here [34]. The answer seems to come down to speed. If we compare the Spaceworld 97 prototype to Pokémon silver, we can see that, after a wild encounter, the Pokémon loads in about half the time in Pokémon Silver vs Spaceworld 97 prototype [20] [21]. I counted 100 fames vs 42 frames, albeit these both are likely run on emulators so the true numbers could vary. Even with the extra space saved, porting the Gen 1 RLE to Gen 2 would not be worth it, as LZ3 decompression algorithm is both simpler and faster [22]. (There was some speculation that Iwata may have worked on the scripting engine for Gen 2 as "each script command in Gen 2 is one byte plus whatever arguments it takes, whereas Gen 1 just kept copy+pasting similar raw asm calls and lds for everything." [23] [24] I couldn't find any official reference to Pokémon’s scripting engine outside of the disassembly project, however).

So where does this misconception originate? Well, in one edition of Iwata Asks, Iwata sits down with one of the programmers of Pokémon Gold/Silver, as well as the CEO of The Pokémon Company [26]. In this interview, Gold/Silver programmer Shigeki Morimoto recalls the various ways in which Iwata helped out Game Freak including porting over the battle logic from Red/Green to Pokémon Stadium in just a week with no reference documents, and give suggestions on localizations for Red/Blue. They also mention the compression tools. While this may seem to indicate that Game Freak needed more space, they never actually state such. Instead, what they said was "What's more, there were the tools for compressing the Pokémon graphic code... You were kind enough to create those tools." Given how specific everything else was, if the new compression algorithm allowed them to fit in Kanto, they would have stated so. So, at the very least, this fact would be unconfirmed, and more likely a reach.

There is also the misconception that Gold & Silver were on the same cartridges that Red & Blue were shipped on. This is actually not correct. The original Pokémon Red & Green were 500kb cartridges. Western Red & Blue were on 1mb cartridges, and Gold & Silver were on 2mb cartridges [27] [28] [29]. If you download a rom of Pokémon Gen 1 vs Gen 2, you will also notice the sizes are doubled (note, this is technically illegal; do at your own risk). I should also mention that the Kanto region was included in the Spaceworld 1997 demo, albeit just one city [30]. Even in the final game, Kanto is still compressed in that it's not near as big as the original Gen 1 games [31].

Lastly, there is plenty of unused content hidden in Gen 2 that could have easily been taken out if space was an issue [32].

So, given that Gen 2 had 4 times the space of the original games, while only 1/20th or so of the extra space going towards new sprites, and the fact that RLE compresses the 2bpp Pokémon better than RLE, we can come to the conclusion that Game Freak had plenty of room for Gen 2 to add a new region.

Now, this isn't to take anything away from Satoro Iwata. His programming, management, and executive feats are nothing short of impressive. Being able to port Pokémon's complicated battle logic in just one week by only looking at source code, while also running your own company is something we may never see again. I just saw this fact repeated so often that I wanted to look into what exactly changed from Gen 1 to Gen 2. It was after learning how the compression algorithms worked, did I find out that this particular fact was nothing more than a misunderstanding taken out of context from an interview, and only picked up steam in the last 5 years.

Hopefully you've learned something reading through all of this. If you would like to view the data yourself, I have a folder with all of Gen 1 (Red) and Gen 2 (Gold) Pokémon+trainer sprites, the information sorted on a spreadsheet, and some additional notes [35].

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1lrGR7YHjUEu5CSI9rsfkdRRNywrsUMhm?usp=sharing

TL;DR: Iwata did indeed write a compression/decompression algorithm for Pokémon Gold, Silver, and Crystal, but it did not save space and was done for speed as the original decompression algorithm ran too slow.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZsErx705fM

[2] https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Trivia/PokémonGoldAndSilver

[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XGFBtVbBgnM

[4] https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/3d2xvs/til_that_when_it_was_time_to_make_Pokémon_stadium/

[5] https://www.reddit.com/r/Pokémon/comments/3d2kgf/til_that_the_reason_gs_has_kanto_is_because_iwata/

[6] https://www.techradar.com/news/gaming/10-things-you-might-not-know-about-nintendo-s-satoru-iwata-1299085

[7] https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/375087-Pokémon-crystal-version/76747652

[8] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUHi-vlACJI

[9] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aF1Yw_wu2cM

[10] https://github.com/pret/pokecrystal/blob/master/home/decompress.asm

[11] https://www.smwcentral.net/?p=viewthread&t=36913

[12] https://github.com/bonimy/MushROMs/blob/master/doc/LC_LZ3%20Compression%20Format.md

[13] https://github.com/bonimy/MushROMs/blob/master/doc/LC_LZ19%20Compression%20Format.md

[14] https://wiki.nesdev.com/w/index.php/Tile_compression#LZSS

[15] https://everything2.com/title/Nintendo+compression

[16] https://github.com/pret/pokecrystal

[17] https://discord.com/invite/d5dubZ3

[18] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/487424856913346580/733084537088901120/compression.zip

[19] https://drive.google.com/file/d/1xuGUSYIb7wCqu8MqgB3cQV2BVktlvouZ/view?usp=sharing

[20] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDELoTl1Qcw&t=4m10s

[21] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O19yQvnFomQ&t=5m53s

[22] https://discord.com/channels/442462691542695948/487424856913346580/733075709001728062

[23] https://github.com/pret/pokegold/tree/master/maps

[24] https://github.com/pret/pokered/tree/master/scripts

[25] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Gold_and_Silver#Development

[26] http://iwataasks.nintendo.com/interviews/#/ds/Pokémon/0/2

[27] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3473111

[28] https://datacrystal.romhacking.net/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Red_and_Blue

[29] https://datacrystal.romhacking.net/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Gold_and_Silver

[30] https://tcrf.net/Proto:Pok%C3%A9mon_Gold_and_Silver/Spaceworld_1997_Demo/Maps#Real-World_Correspondences

[31] https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Kanto#Differences_between_generations

[32] https://tcrf.net/Pok%C3%A9mon_Gold_and_Silver

[33] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZI50XUeN6QE&t=62s

[34] https://github.com/pret/pokecrystal/wiki/Expand-tilesets-from-192-to-255-tiles

[35] https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1lrGR7YHjUEu5CSI9rsfkdRRNywrsUMhm?usp=sharing


r/TruePokemon • • May 03 '21

The Population of Kanto in Pokemon Red and Blue [OC]

Post image
565 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Aug 26 '20

Pokémon HeartGold & SoulSilver Secret: Hidden Softlock Prevention in Cianwood City

551 Upvotes

I was trying to soft lock myself in Pokémon SoulSilver just for fun and something incredible happened... This left me speechless, because I've played this game countless times and I had no idea this was included.

https://youtu.be/H73ESn6VYvI


r/TruePokemon • • Feb 20 '24

Discussion Bulbapedia has become the fandom of Pokemon wikis

510 Upvotes

Now I know nothing will ever be as bad as fandom, but given how laggy and how many obtrusive ads there are, it's almost there. The site itself also isn't very well designed either with information being hidden within tabs that, when lag happens, usually results in the wrong thing being opened.

Things load quite slowly too, especially on mobile, whereas other sites like Pokemon Database and Serebii are so fast and easy to access compared to this. When I'm using those sites I don't feel like I'm fighting with my browser just to check where to find a specific mon.

And finally, all the missing information. So many articles on bulbapedia are straight up incomplete or missing vital information. Maps for giant caves tend to have a few chambers missing from the layout section or sometimes descriptions are just wrong.

It's honestly sad to see bulbapedia like this. I used to defend this wiki to death but now it's practically unusable. It was my preferred wiki for a long time but each year I become more and more frustrated with it.


r/TruePokemon • • Mar 04 '25

Discussion Why was Mew unobtainable in the original Red and Blue versions?

464 Upvotes

This question has bugged me for a very long time. Clearly, it was designed and had a sprite (as far as i know), and the existence of Mewtwo clearly implies its place was settled within the lore. So why wasn't it catchable? Was there any reason to it?


r/TruePokemon • • Mar 22 '24

Discussion I think a Pokémon game set only in a single city is actually exciting

455 Upvotes

easing the worries about legends ZA taking place only in lumiouse city.

I'm 100% sure what they mean, is their goal is to make a more dense city based open world, rather than the more outer fields kind Pokémon always go.

Basically aiming more closer to games like Spider-Man or Yakuza game than BOTW..... relatively speaking of course.

Which really makes me wonder, in a positive way how exactly can would they translate many elements of a Pokémon game in a only urban environment.


r/TruePokemon • • Nov 22 '20

Is anyone else bothered by Dialga's knees in 3D? I feel like he looks less cool because of this.

Post image
376 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Apr 20 '21

7 years delayed reply to "Why can't Nidorina breed?"

336 Upvotes

So, I just saw a question regarding Nidorina/Nidoqueen today, and thought that I could add my findings to the debate.

First, here is my source: the Pocket Monster Zukan (or Pokedex guidebook, an official source edited 5/4/1996, that had the creative team of the games very involved with its creation) and quoted here by a very reputable Japanese "Pokemon scholar" of sorts.

http://pkmnheight.blogspot.com/2021/01/blog-post.html?m=1

So, I translated what the guide says:

Nidoran (♀): Though it is small, its venom is very potent. The female has smaller horns. They enter breeding season every spring. At the end of summer, they lay two eggs, and two weeks later males and females hatch.

Nidorina : Since it is female, it has a soft personality. The ultrasound that it emits with its mouth can confuse its opponents. It is the evolution of Nidoran (♀), but it has lost the ability to lay eggs.

Nidorino : It has an irascible personality. Swinging its developed horns, it can even pierce diamond. It is the evolution of Nidoran (♂), but unlike Nidorina, it is fertile.

So, it becomes evident that contrary to popular belief, Nidorina's condition is not linked (for once) to a coding issue or bug in the original game. It is simply how the species was intended to work from a lore perspective, even before the implementation of the breeding mechanics. This information corroborates what was surmised in the menopause theory, and gives it a specific origin. Hence why it was not changed during the subsequent releases, and even when some egg groups were reworked.


r/TruePokemon • • Feb 26 '21

Anyone else already disappointed by the DP remakes? This art style is just... ugly, in my opinion.

Post image
315 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Jun 17 '20

Bulbapedia has become an unusable website due to bloat

287 Upvotes

I always loved Bulbapedia because it was such a complete and detailed source of info for Pokemon.

But using the website, especially as a quick reference, has become impossible.

The subsections of each page load extremely slowly. Clicking one of the headers of the subsections before everything is loaded consistently results in the wrong section to be opened.

I actually dislike how hidden crucial game data is. Finding a moveset for a Pokemon requires you to go to game data, which only properly loads once the whole page is loaded, and then scroll down a million tables, including stuff like Pokeathlon Stats and Side Game Pokédex Data, to ultimately find the list of moves.

To top is off, now Bulbapedia is stuffed with horribly obtrusive video ads and regular ads, all of which are terrible and slow down loading the page by a lot. It feels like browsing the Daily Mail, not Wikipedia.

I now go to the Pokémon DB instead, which in comparison is a very responsive, quick and easy to navigate website. But it's a pity, since I love the idea of Bulbapedia and I like how it has all the info together.


r/TruePokemon • • 29d ago

Discussion A message to Grant

281 Upvotes

Hello, Grant. We've probably never met in the real world and probably never will.

Today, I bought your copy of Pokémon Heart Gold from a vendor at Arkansas Retrofest 3. I opened your save and you were in the middle of the Elite 4 Rematches. Instead of deleting the save, I finished your unfinished business. Your team are all champions.

Some of them were traded in, but others traveled all the way from Hoenn. I am unsure if you had any attachment to them but it feels wrong to just let them disappear. I am currently working on a save in Pokémon White 2 to move your teammates into Pokémon Home.

I am unsure if this message will reach you nor do I believe anyone will read this. In the case that you somehow see this, I am more than willing to trade you back your old friends.

Edit: As of October 18 2026, Your Pokemon have been safely deposited into Pokemon Home. Thankfully, my White 2 file was already pretty much completed, I just had to get through victory road and beat the champion.


r/TruePokemon • • Aug 19 '21

Hisui Region Map (High Resolution)

Post image
262 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Oct 07 '25

Discussion You are still allowed to enjoy Pokemon games while remaining critical of them, and vice versa.

232 Upvotes

"You gave Game Freak your money, so you have no right to complain about the quality of Scarlet/Violet!"
"I simply don't trust criticism from people who have over 600 hours in this game..."
"Why are you even playing Sword/Shield, don't you know it's garbage?"
”If Brilliant Diamond/Shining Pearl are bad, then why did they sell so many copies?”

I've seen all these rebuttals so many times. And truth be told, I have upwards of 600 hours in Violet, and I'm closing in on 900 hours in Sword, and almost all of this time was spent shiny hunting, grinding raids and playing VGC. I've enjoyed going through this, because it's a stress relief for me, especially after a long tiring day at work, I just want to unwind and do what I like best, which is kick open my Switch and do either of those.

Now I don't mind listening to other people's opinions on the matter, but issues do unfold when people try to make others feel bad for liking an otherwise "bad" game, or disliking an otherwise "good" game. I've been guilty of this in the past, but I've done a bit of self-reflection since, and eventually learned that I'm not gaining anything from winning pointless internet arguments. I welcome healthy discussions on the matter, but quite a lot of the time it tends to still devolve into arguments, even if I phrase it in that it's my opinion: "I didn't like this because X, Y and Z" as opposed to "this is bad and you know it..."

I’m going to say the rest of this as someone who doesn’t like SV’s quality myself. I can’t excuse the performance issues. I can’t excuse the fact the game has a memory leak. I can’t excuse the fact that people are falling through the map. I can’t excuse the questionable graphics. But I enjoy playing VGC. I can’t shiny hunt Iron Bundle in any other game. I really love the competitive QoL. I don’t mind carrying someone through a raid who desperately needs help. I also don’t mind helping people get Ceruledge, or evolve their Finizen. As I said before, the majority of my hours in Violet have come from these activities.

In fact, I liked some of the writing; Arven in particular I found to be a relatable character, especially after my cat passed away a year after SV's release. Similarly, I also find Kieran to be quite a deep, multi-faceted character who I’ve found myself relating with on occasion.

The problem is, whenever this happens and I go on record praising some aspects, at least one person is likely going to say something along the lines of the following:

"So does this mean you like SV then?"

No, it doesn't. The fact I'm starting to see this crop up more in recent times seems to suggest that the sense of nuance appears to have been lost, which is what allows good discussions to flow, and I find it quite annoying because it often tends to result in arguments. You can still enjoy playing SwSh or SV, and I'm not going to stop you from doing this. Similarly, at the same time, you can still enjoy those games while still remaining critical of its flaws, because truth be told, they're not perfect games. It's not harming anyone if you like or don't like these games, and you’re not winning anything from parading around and claiming that SV is a bad game and you should feel bad for liking it.

In fact, I've seen it the other way. I've gone on record a few times stating that I find BW quite miserable to play through, due to the poor selection of Pokemon and the railroading. And again, with the way it's formatted, it's pretty clear it's my own opinion. However, this hasn't stopped people getting irritated at me for supposedly hating what is supposed to be a "masterpiece". At some points, other users have joined in and it ends up devolving into a huge argument.

These things are why I now find it difficult to even try and hold a healthy balanced discussion where we can accept that people have differing viewpoints that can coexist peacefully. It only takes so much until bad actors show up and turn an otherwise healthy discussion into a pointless argument. I’m not a confrontational person myself, which is why I tend to now try and avoid starting arguments, or even get involved in them.

Oh, and sales are definitely not a measure of quality.


r/TruePokemon • • May 20 '20

Eviolite and Everstone should be fused into one item.

227 Upvotes

That is all.

I've been playing through White 2 with a Dewott I'm never going to evolve who I'd like to give an Everstone, but it sort of needs Eviolite to keep up or at least make XP gain easier.

Thematically, the kind of Pokémon you'd bother giving an Everstone to is one that you'd also give an Eviolite to, and giving them a permanent Everstone just sounds cooler than a permanent Eviolite, though neither of them look very interesting.


r/TruePokemon • • May 13 '20

Average Base Stat Comparison by Type - Posted this in /r/pokemon a few weeks and it didn't do so well, hopefully will encourage some discussion here

Thumbnail
imgur.com
226 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Feb 10 '24

News Pokemon Unova RPG online has been permanently shut down

211 Upvotes

Sucks for me. I haven't been a fan of the games since generation 5, and it sucks litigious Nintendo decided to silence another fan project


r/TruePokemon • • Jul 13 '19

Chinese Pokemon Bootleg Everyone Praised for its Animation Reportedly Steals User Data

Thumbnail
nintendosoup.com
209 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Mar 01 '21

The DPPt remakes totally went for the Pokemon Adventures route and I'm all for it!

Post image
197 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Aug 18 '20

(Meta) Can we just ban YouTube links entirely?

197 Upvotes

Because honesty this sub is just becoming a cesspool of YouTubers link dumping their YouTube videos and running.

I was completely for people promoting their content if (1) they actively tried to start a discussion with it and (2) the video itself genuinely promoted discussion in of itself, but in my eyes, these loose guidelines have catastrophically failed. In the last 2 days the majority of content posted to this sub has been links to YouTube videos. Not even texts posts. Just links. We're only a small sub so all it takes is for a handful of content creators to completely take over this sub.

I'm pretty sure I speak for the large majority of readers when I say we're here to discuss Pokémon. Not watch videos of people opening TCG booster packs or watch someone talk at us with no meaningful way to have a back and forth. It's time to outright ban self promotion. It doesn't have a place on this subreddit.


r/TruePokemon • • Sep 21 '20

Underwater exploration is such a cool feature of Gen 3. It should be refined and expanded upon in future generations.

Post image
192 Upvotes

r/TruePokemon • • Jan 06 '20

The G2 --> G3 Philosophy Jump is underdiscussed.

189 Upvotes

There was a huge and underappreciated shift in design philosophy from Generations 1 and 2 to Generation 3 that is ultimately responsible for a lot of the series' problems right now, imo. I want to dive into monster design (primarily) to explain why that is. Jump down to E. Summary if this is too long.

A. Generation 1

Generation 1 is remarkable for a large number of well-rounded monsters that often stand out only in Speed as a basic stat, especially early in the game. Critical Hits bypass stat modifier moves and effects, and deal anywhere from +50% to +95% damage, based on your level; your chance of a critical is based on your species' Speed value. The way this math works out, all species grow increasingly deadly towards the end of the single-player game, and notably high speed is worth about 8% more damage on average for most fully evolved monsters, with more variance for exceptionally slow final forms. Overall, it's not the biggest difference in the world, but it is a difference that exists.

Also of note was the fact that tight move availability was built into the system and accommodated for; all TMs were supposed to be attainable only the once, which meant the expectation was that most monsters would use Normal moves as their bread-and-butter if their type moves weren't effective on the situation.

It was therefore reasonable to carry multiple of the same type of move on monsters during the story mode; you used Flamethrower, Surf, Ice Beam, Fly, and Strength for ordinary scenarios due to their high PP, accuracy, and availability. Fire Blast, Hydro Pump, Blizzard, Sky Attack, and Hyper Beam were the original 'Z-moves', notable in their especially dramatic visuals for the Game Boy; the ultimate attack of the Fire-type being in the literal shape of a Chinese character for a sacred Japanese festival is about as shonen as it gets, and 5 PP is just not enough to go through a dungeon with that as your key attack.

(You may have noticed I skipped Electric; the reason Thunder has 10 PP but an unusually low accuracy, I am sure, is tied to the decision to make Thunder a common level-up move but Thunderbolt was a rare gym treasure in Gen 1. Even if you were going to abuse one of the many glitches for free Thunderbolts, that meant abstaining from putting Thunderbolt on your electric type for a third of the game.)

The single Special stat was an interesting system. For those who don't know, all types designated as special (Fire, Water, Grass, Electric, Psychic, Ice, Dragon, Dark and almost certainly Fairy if it existed then) had their offensive moves powered and defended against by the sole special stat.

In theory, splitting special has allowed for more variation in monster designs; in practice, it's rare for a strong special attacker to be usable and have a poor special defense (though it does happen, and is basically the entirety of Deoxys' schtick). The reverse scenario, where a monster needs high special defense and poor special attack, can be handled almost as well by simply not giving that monster special attacks on a high special stat. It's a positive development, but not an earthshaking one.

Finally, the stat calculation system used in Generation I was significantly different from the effort value and base stat system used in Generation III and forward. Simply put, there were 16 different 'gene values' for each of the five stats, and you could potentially max out every stat every single monster had, but it was a slow system, well-hidden from the player, but had the benefit that there was no such thing as 'bad' stat experience; you couldn't ever train against the 'wrong' kind of monster and ruin your work.

B. Generation 2

Critical hits were divorced from level and speed in this generation, making them swingy and potentially decisive from a low level, but almost entirely a product of RNG rather than something that could be meaningfully built for; critical-hit focused builds have almost never featured seriously in either storyline play or competitive play until the most recent generations.

Generation 2 began the process of splitting the special stat into two different stats -- as of Gen 2 they were separate in every way but genetics, a move with mixed results; it was one of the many countermeasures inserted to bring down the Psychic type in Generation 2, a move that was arguably too successful.

The incredibly high Special stat typical of Psychic types, along with high speed, a lack of resistances against it, and a lack of useful attacks super-effective against it, all contributed to its blistering powering in Generation 1.

Generation 2 moderately expanded the movepools of a number of monsters; perhaps one of the most notable adjustments was the creation and distribution of the Fire, Ice, and Thunder Punch TMs, replacing Ice Beam and Thunderbolt. Simultaneously, Flamethrower, Thunderbolt, and Ice Beam frequently found themselves placed very high and late in level-up learnlists. There was a design statement in Gold and Silver, only moderately interrupted by Crystal, saying: mainstay moves belong to pokémon of that type and they shouldn't be easy to earn.

C. Generation 3+

Generation 3 completely divorced the genetics for the Special Attack and Special Defense stats, adding another complicating factor in getting maximum stats. More drastically, it added Natures, which push a stat to +10% or -10% of its value after stat experience, doubled the number of genetics values from 16 to 32, and changed the stat experience system.

Stat experience was revamped completely with Effort Values; Effort Values cap a species' maximum stat experience across all stats to roughly a third of what was possible before Generation 3, which allows for pokémon to get 'bad EVs' -- stat XP in a stat that's not maximally useful to that monster at endgame.

The changes to stat XP have overall made it quicker to finish training a monster compared to Generation 1, but the process has become much less organic. Later developments like Super Training offered a more immersive take, but were tedious in time constraints and Super Training itself was abandoned after only one generation.

It's hard to say if these changes were principally made with the goal of deeper customization and breeding, more interesting endgame, or both. Whatever their purpose, they have had dramatic effects on the monsters that preceded them.

Significant narrowing of stats ultimately required the physical/special split in Generation 4, as many monsters simply found themselves unable to function with both of their types at once. This leads to mechanically effective but immersively puzzling decisions like physically frail monsters withstanding direct shots from hurricanes.

In addition, Generation 3 dramatically expanded movepool access to the 80-100 Pow moves, restoring Thunderbolt and Ice Beam back to TMs and finally adding Flamethrower to the list. It did this as well as making many more TMs and tutors reobtainable, while many monsters found themselves able to use TMs or obtain moves via breeding they had never been able to before. The most instructive of these examples are the Hitmons; as Fighting-type monsters primarily known for their skill rather than their raw strength, they were limited as far as moves that relied on inhuman strength like Earthquake and rock-attacks... until Generation 3, when the Fighting-type became a blank check to learn powerful Rock and Ground moves. This has been a major step in the trivialization of the Rock and Ghost types as defensive types.

As a minor note, monsters from Generation 4+ have had increasingly diverse learnsets within the game, relying less on TMs for standard story mode coverage, allowing TMs to occupy a space focused on more esoteric or endgame moves (generally).

Finally, Generation 3 introduced abilities, which were overwhelmingly conservative and uninteresting compared to those introduced by later games; Generation 5 proved to be necessary for many monsters to have a second chance with the "Hidden Ability" pass introduced by the Dream World, although it was not a universal salve.

D. Miscellany

I'm not gonna waste a lot of characters talking about the overworld and hidden machine design; I think it's a well-worn (but accurate) saw that there was just better merging of world design and self-teaching and exploratory gameplay in Generations 1 and 2, though the element didn't really evacuate the series entirely until Gen 7 or so. The Ride Pager sucks because it's basically reducing exploration to an Uber app, but where did this problem start?

Generation 3. Zigzagoon.

Zigzagoon and Linoone can learn up to five HMs, compared with Rattata's debut of zero (eventually three in later generations). Two of them are even the pesky (and all-too-common) Water HMs; one of them is, for some reason, Whirlpool. They have more significant Water-type mechanics than the partially muskrat/capybara based Raticate, who was famous among Gen 1 players back in the day for picking up an odd amount of Water TMs, significantly helping it last through mountainous areas.

Generation 3 represents the beginning of a position that boils down to, roughly, HMs are a pain; accept that they're a pain and get used to it, this is the tradeoff you make to get to explore other areas.

I'd also like to highlight that Generation 3 is where Sunny Day (JPN: Clear Skies) and Rain Dance began to get this weird usage as proto-terrains. Groudon, associated with volcanos -- famous for darkening the skies -- makes the sun come out? Rain Dance makes fish pokemon in the water swim faster? Sandstorms make underground rock monsters more waterproof?

These are design changes that only make sense taken from the angle that they're meant to be be proto-terrains more than meteorological conditions, something that's become increasingly important due to reduced bulk rendering the meteorological healing moves (Morning Sun, Synthesis, and Moonlight) largely extraneous on most monsters that get them. It's just not important what they do to recovery anymore, for the most part.

E. Summary

The number of complicating factors that can make a pokemon less than perfect have gone up dramatically over the years. In Generation 1-2, every single species of pokémon has just over 1 million potential genetic variants, but every single one can be trained to its maximum stat XP in every stat.

There are over 5.1 billion possible variations of every single pokemon that has three abilities and one gender, at minimum, under the current philosophy. Since Rattata have two genders and three abilities, there are more possible mechanical variations of Rattata than there are people alive in the world right now, and most of these variations are some version of 'it's kinda sucky for a Rattata.' This necessitated Hyper Training and increasing randomness reduction in breeding and legendary capture to reduce the worst of it.

Changing stat experience made competitive battles quicker and more decisive, which is generally hailed as an improvement by those heavily into those battles, but required the Gen 4 Physical/Special split that further blurred the lines on what the difference between special and physical are. The stat spreads of monsters in the first two generations, as well as their learnsets, types, and abilities have rarely been revisited in a significant way after Generation 3, causing the great majority of these pokémon to simply not stand up to snuff with their newer counterparts.

This is a repeated problem in Generation 3+ design; choices were made for a new direction without due consideration to either past monsters or design philosophy. While I enjoy many of the designs that resulted from Mega Evolution and Regional Forms, and the reintroduction of 'important attacks' with Z-Moves, all of these are related to the problem of dealing with old monsters and mechanics that got left behind due to hasty mechanical changes in the G2->G3 jump.

This is not to say that the Generation 1-2 paradigm was flawless in the monster taming fantasy; while it was more organic, it was repetitive and mindless, which brings its own set of problems.


r/TruePokemon • • Aug 16 '25

Discussion I miss going into houses

185 Upvotes

This is trivial but I really miss seeing what a family of 4 living with their Pokemon looked like. Felt inviting and comfortable to just wander in a persons home. It’s something I love about all RPGs. SwSh and PLA were the last game that felt like townspeople were actual people living.

So it seems like we won’t be doing that anymore and honestly I’m greatly distressed by this reality. Lemme in! LET ME IN!!!!!


r/TruePokemon • • Aug 12 '19

If Masuda wants Pokemon to feel like real creatures, then the pokemon games should have pokemon act more based on natures and characteristics

185 Upvotes

I think somewhere(dont have source) Junichi Masuda said he didnt call IVs IVs because he wanted Pokemon to feel like real, individual creatures. Well, to me pokemon often feel the same because they all have the same personality in game, despite having natures and characteristics.

When Pokemon Sun and Moon came out, they added little messages with what the Pokemon are doing. This made them feel a bit more alive, yet they all did the same things. What I thought is, depending on the nature, characteristic, or even ability or status, could determine these little messages.

For example, say we have a Drednaw. This Drednaw has a Brave nature and a "Hates to lose" characteristic. When its in battle, it will say things like "Drednaw roars at the opponent". If Drednaw is on low HP, it could say something like " Drednaw roars in anger". If this Drednaw also had Strong Jaw, it could also say "Drednaw is snapping at the opponent".

Whereas another Drednaw may have a Naughty nature and the "Likes to eat" characteristic. The text box could say stuff like "Drednaw is giggling at something", or "Drednaw is taunting the opponent" or " Drednaw is looking hungry".

If it is in a Double Battle,this Drednaw could make fun of its ally. If said ally was Timid and much smaller then Drednaw, it could be frightened by its ally.

Think of Undertale. In battle, the characters do simalar stuff like this, stuff like "Undyne suplexes a boulder to show off her strength" or "Sans is looking tired". These little messages give the character more personality.

If Pokemon were constantly interacting with each other like that, it would make individual pokemon more memorable. I have played with a Trevenant four times, and I cant remember any one in paticular for anything, other then one has a brave nature and the other helped beat Totem Mimikyu. Now, I would've remembered the Brave one better if it, like, gave encouragement to allies in double battles or if it "showed no fear" of a larger Pokemon or something. It also wouldnt be too difficult to code. We dont need one for every single ability, situation, or even every characteristic. Just having one for each nature and then a bunch of others scattered around would be fine.

What do you think? Would this make your Pokemon more memorable and make the game more immersive? Or is it pointless and not worth the dev's time?


r/TruePokemon • • Jul 07 '25

Discussion I feel like is really exhausting to be a Pokémon fan.

183 Upvotes

I don't mean in that genwunner mentality of "Oh man old games were better, what happun gamefreak" I'm talking as someone who always likes interacting with Pokémon fans, it's getting tired of what 90% of the discussion is just this constant loop of complains and rant about "modern Pokémon bad"

I don't mean just Reddit or twitter, even real life friends I know are just like this.

I ain't here to invalidate your frustration, but we have been hearing this discussion for more than 5 years now, and is getting more exhausting even outside of Pokémon, can I literally just enjoy a donkey Kong game without a pokemon fan telling me that Pokémon has no voice acting yet.

How many times I tried, to just wanna have a fun conversation about future Pokémon game like "dream game" of sort and like 90% of comments are nothing but "Oh a fIx gAmE wOulD be nIce!?! Lolololol" like good job, you stated the obvious, now do you have something else to add?

I'm all for validating that current state of Pokémon is far from their prime, but that's really not something I wanna keep talking, about for 5 years, nor I wanna continue this for the next 5 years.

Scarlet violet open world not the best...okay, can we actually see what could we hypothetically make it fun beyond just asking for the bare minimum requirement, zelda ain't widely known for being the one of the best openworld game of all time eniterely because it was playable, especially on the switch 1, because the Devs actually do add things when it is in a playable state..