r/TruePokemon • • Jan 01 '24

Discussion I liked Pokémon concierge, but I wish there is more to it for being a Pokémon show on netflix.

4 Upvotes

Now that is finally here, and I finally watched it, I think the show is great, and I don't really want to discredit the studio's hard work that makes the series.

But why is this the series that is only on netflix, comparative to other Pokémon animated series on YouTube, and are free by the official Pokémon channel.

Granted the YouTube show is great quality too, but is that good quality and being free, is why I wonder why couldn't TPC have a more ambitious show for being the one that you have to pay to watch(legally speaking).

Maybe like an animated retelling of the Pokémon adventures manga or something, with each arc being a 12 episode/season long.

While concierge a series on YouTube, but keeping the same budget and story of what it currently had.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 26 '25

Discussion At what point, the "hating" of pokemon is getting too far?

5 Upvotes

I swear hating modern pokemon, has become from moderate cristism of the franchise direction, to just being flat out ignorant as long as it looks cool to the internet, that it become so tiring.

It comes to the point where false info where people say whatever tf they want, had become so praised and rewarded, that it makes so much sense why nobody will even try to take pokemon fans seriously.

Saw a video review of ZA where the whole video can be summed up as "it's fine" he didn't defend the faults, he didn't get some free copy to review, he payed 70 dollars for the switch 2 version, he also address the problems, and even said is not his favorite of even the switch era pokemon games.

But top comments are basically calling him a shill/copium enjoyer/for just saying a positive thing about the game, and saying things he never even said at all.

Keep in mind these are TOP comments a.k.a people by the hundreds agreeing on shit he never even said at all, that you can easily debunk just by watching the damn video.

Or a video from a lawyer, explaining how the patents by both Nintendo and pokemon company, is not as harmful as the internet set it out to be.

But every comment is telling the LAWYER he is a pokemon shill, and for what? for not following the idea that Nintendo and pokemon isn't an an evil corp that will sue your precious indie game for violating their patent, after all?

It feels like the whole "I like cats = I hate dogs" problem on the internet, except pokemon fans just have unironically reward people replying with the latter.

There's hating this franchise for valid cristism for the brand, and then there's just flat out bullying others for enjoying the games, or spreading false info and being rewarded for this, and the more this keeps going the more it felt like is going to this direction.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 18 '25

Discussion Unless we stop buying the games , gamefreak and nintendo wont be willing to improve on them.

0 Upvotes

For context I've been playing pokemon since sun and moon almost 10 years ago im getting old yes ive seen every pokemon discourse from the alolan starters to the wild area trees and now z-a, so here's my guess on why things just dont get any better

For a sec lets all acknowledge that nintendo and gamefreak ARE triple A studios that co-own the highest grossing IP in human history and also acknowledge that they are selling these games at AAA prices.

Now let me list the things that other AAA games have that pokemon games, specifically on the switch, dont have:

-Voice acting.

-decent story(spoilers for z-a was making the loan sharks the good guys their best idea?).

-more than 5 animations per character.

-great graphics.

-actual stuff to do.

-decently optimized for the hardware they were made for.

-not so buggy releases.

And why dont pokemon games have that? It's because everyone related to this franchise thinks of it as a literal cash printer

And who can blame em for that, they have been pumping out below average games and giving them above average prices for the past 6 years and they have gained billions from them, we all know how big of a mess scarlet and violet's release was, and we shat on gamefreak for it deservingly but it still made more than a billion dollars, just for perspective pokemon as a whole gains 100x more money than they invest in games while also investing less than 1/4 of what the rest of the industry has to spend on an AAA game, so in the end they just didnt give a fuck about what we had to say about their game.

they made a very good game with pokemon legends arceus and immediatly tried to shave costs as much as possible with the next entry in that now series of spin offs.

The only way these games will improve is when they stop being as profitable as before, effectively forcing gamefreak and nintendo to actually increase the budget and game quality, this is just a fancy way of saying that to stop this from getting worse we have to stop buying the games, gamefreak made it very clear that criticism wont do shit.

So if you plan on buying or already bought the new pokemon games together with the dlc at standard price dont expect the next ones to be better.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 21 '25

Discussion Why it looks like half the complaining of ZA has nothing to do with the actual game itself.

0 Upvotes

The same thing from different people "why the wall textures, stickers" "why is this game fully rendered at once" "graphics bad" "kalos starter mega evolution lock behind wall" "gameplay is too confusing" "game is just 1 city" "no voice acting"

But never hear once about the actual game itself, believe me there is flaws in the game, once you actually start playing play the game.

Like how the day and night time Segway can be annoying, platforming and gathering can get kinda bland, some segment of the story really take their time, traversal options take way too long to fully unlock, how some spaces do not compliment the new battle system at all, like the corridors in those night battles, and the switch 1 version of the game could have run better.

But I never hear these complains atleast not as loud as the things that barely has anything to do with the overall game, feels like the very problem with those "hyper realistic" details on AAA games, but the very polar end of it, like "wow the building is basically a cube with stickers...okay now tell me, what is the actual game like."

I ain't here to defend a game you hate, and I kinda like, but I feel like it's getting obvious , where some are just here for the brownies and is cool to hate pokemon, as if you are a teenager in the 2000s, then actually legit hate the game you played.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 07 '22

Discussion Why are people actually excited for the new games?

0 Upvotes

Sorry, this will read like a disorganized rant but I'm really trying to remain reasonable with my nitpicks here.

We are a month to release and the game looks like an Unreal demo set to low on all settings, and you would be delusional to think the game will be completely overhauled in a month. Delusional.

Besides the endless complaints about graphics that we have heard ad nauseum, which STILL remain unaddressed or unfixed, the open world looks like a classic case of "slap open world on something just to make it artificially larger than it actually is" -- I mean we got a whole 14 minutes of footage and the open world looks not only ugly, but extremely barren.

That bit when they come across the Tera Jigglypuff and its just... standing there. The whole "Let's go" thing has you throw out your Pokemon and just afk to beat the entire evil team? Is this really what we wanted? And now we have a crafting system slapped on? Is this a Ubisoft game?

Now, I'm sure the game will be fun, I mean its Pokemon, and now you get to take selfies with your team! Awesome. But man. We should be striving for something more than just "fun". Pokemon deserves better in every aspect and its a shame that this is what passes.

I don't know man. The game looks ugly, runs worse than a 2017 game (how does a single Sunflora lag the game), has a barren open world, and its a shame because we all know it could be infinitely better than it is now. We all know the potential Pokemon has and its a massive shame that not only does Gamefreak cut all these corners, but the overwhelming majority of comments on these trailers praise the game like its a revolution in gaming. Have we set the bar so low that this is what we praise?


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 21 '22

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: B2W2 weren't good games

4 Upvotes

Just about ten years ago these sequels came out for the Nintendo DS, following up on the originals. I didn't buy either game at the time but overpaid for the games last summer and played through them for the first time. These games are seen by many for the high-water mark of the franchise. However, after beating the story and doing post-game quests, I found it wasn't really as good as people say.

Old Pokémon Return

Black and White made the bold choice to only have new Pokémon in the wild. I thought this was cool at the time, a way to signal that this region was far away and to bring in a lot of fresh designs. Even though I didn't like every Pokémon, it was a bold choice.

Fans did not like this and so GameFreak pivoted sharply to usher in plenty of old Pokémon without any real explanation. Why have wild Pokémon changed so much in just a few years?

While an expanded dex usually comes with the second games of a generation, GF really goes overboard in this regard. They quickly cast the new Unovan Pokémon to the side to rush after nostalgia. You start in Aspertia City, then go to Route 19 and 20 until you get to Floccesy Ranch. While there are largely just Unovan Pokémon at the start, here is where the game starts to engage in revisionism. At the ranch you wind up finding Pokémon like Azurill, Mareep, and Riolu who evolve into fairly strong Pokémon. For trainers, this is a good place to build your final team using non-Unova Pokémon.

It sucks that they don't do justice to these Pokémon when they had just previously put such a spotlight on these new ones. Then there are some places like the Castelia Sewers which don't have Unovan Pokémon at all.

Legendaries

Legendary Pokémon in particular seem rather haphazardly placed in the game as well. I was surprised to encounter Cobalion just in the middle of a route even before I had all my badges. I caught it, but it was really weird to just see it there so early in the game. I had expected to get much farther along in my journey before considering that. I didn't, but could've placed it on my team and had a much better advantage against the in-game trainers.

Virizion and Terrakion are also just there in the overworld. For Unovan legendaries, I'm disappointed they don't even have a semblance of a story. There's not even something like a side-quest. The Lati twins also just appear in the post-game without any real rationale.

What's worse is that the other Unovan legendaries, the forces of nature, can't be caught at all. Of course this was in order to promote the Dream Radar AR game that they required you to purchase separately. It seems bad in retrospect, particularly how once again the Unovan Pokémon don't get much care or attention for players of B2W2.

Graphics

We should admit that the graphics in these games aren't great. The pixelated style does not work well with the pseudo-3D camera movements and it just higlights the flaws of using pixels. Particularly in some places, like the Skyarrow Bridge, this style does not work. In battles, the Pokémon have large blocks that grow and shrink as the camera moves around, but it rarely looks alright.

They do try a number of visual flourishes like adding lens flares when you walk outside or other particle effects in the overworld. Yet they don't really make the game look better as much as it looks busier.

Gameplay

Busy rather than better seems to leak into the gameplay too. Pacing in the game feels off, and multiple times I'd have to go into the tall grass to grind my team several levels since I couldn't beat the local gym leader. I couldn't travel too far due to the large number of arbitrary barriers that were put in place to progress.

While I appreciated loosening the need for HMs, these obstacles would be replaced by clowns blocking gates just because they could. It's arbitrary and broke some of the immersion. I need to beat the gym leader? Fine, but at least give me a good reason. I think GF has continued to be weak in this area and I don't like it.

The worldbuilding in general feels strange. Drayden is now the 7th gym leader, still a Dragon-type user. Yet Iris becomes champion and is also a Dragon-type trainer? One of those two should've been replaced to add a little more variety.

Worldbuilding

This game introduces a number of new locations to the region, such as Aspertia City, but without a lot of justification. Why was this place inaccessible before? Why was Virbank City inaccessible before? I get the urge to add new places to make the region exciting to explore again, but as a sequel it's hard to say this place always existed but you can't visit it. Lentimas Town seems the strangest addition of all, adding nothing useful as far as I can tell to the story or the world.

Other new places, like the Marine Tube, are neat additions but don't have any relation to the region's inspiration of New York City. I live there and I've never gone through a marine tube. If there is one, please let me know! The park in Castelia City also pales in comparison to Central Park. PokéStar Studios is far more Hollywood than Manhattan.

It just seems like there were a bunch of disconnected ideas thrown in for the sake of adding more to the game rather than a coherent approach to expanding the world.

Is this all there is?

As I got to the endgame, travelling all the way back to Route 1 and 2, I battled a handful of trainers. By Gen 5 it was clear that there were certain themes in each generation. We'd have a regional rodent, bird, bug, etc. Youngster Jimmy has all five rodents. Lass Mali has all five birds. As I grinded through each fight, it gave me a bad feeling. It made me think that the future was just going to be formulaic forever.

B2W2 are sequels, admittedly different from the "third version" we'd expected. Still, the game comes across as lacking boldness and inventiveness. Similar to previous generations, it focuses on the third legendary. We got another 100 base stat mythical, and it seems like this could just continue on indefinitely.

The games are still 2D. They are still on a grid system. They add more things like hidden grottos and triple battles, but nothing feels fundamentally better to play.

Of course that's not what happens. Gen 6 brings a new 3D world with freer movement and mega evolutions. There is no Pokémon Z, though there could've been, and X & Y do feel like a fresh game in a few ways. Of course, they have their own flaws that can be discussed, but it does feels more inventive than B2W2.

People will defend the fifth generation as having the best story, and perhaps that's true. However, in terms of creating a fun and enjoyable game B2W2 feel like a step down compared to their predecessors.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 06 '15

The level cap is way too high

2 Upvotes

TL;DR: The level cap should be lowered to 80, because it's significantly easier to reach than Lv. 100, and almost nothing in-game reaches 80 anyway.

In many RPGs, the highest level you can possibly reach is only slightly higher than the final boss's level. In some games you could reach max level before the final battle with a little effort. So why is the level cap in Pokemon set to 100, when the final bosses are around 50-70?

In competitive battle, your Pokemon are lowered to level 50 anyway, making maxing out your team's levels pretty much pointless. The only reasons to level your 'mons past 70 or so are for bragging rights, or if they learn moves ridiculously late (though recent games seem to be making an effort for everyone to learn everything by level 50, or as level 1 moves, further reducing the need for a level cap of 100). Grinding the last 30 levels or so takes forever, as most wild Pokemon only go up to 50-60, and trainers to 60-75, giving out far too little exp.

Personally, I think the level cap should be lowered to 80. It's achievable with reasonable effort, cutting the experience needed to max out in half. It's the highest level of wild legendaries, as well as most post-game final bosses' signature Pokemon. Very few 'mons surpass level 80 (Red's Pikachu, Alder's grandson's team in challenge mode, ...Magikarp). It's reasonable for these master trainers to have trained their Pokemon to their full potential, right? So if GF can't make battles against Lv. 100 trainers a thing, the level cap is too high.

Do you think Lv. 100 is a reasonable max?


r/TruePokemon • • Nov 19 '20

Am I the only one that doesnt like the idea of being able to Control the camera in the next pokemon games? If they end up doing it.

0 Upvotes

I just dont really like being able to move the camera because I end up missing things or getting Lost. I hope they keep the fixed camera for most of the game.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 27 '24

Discussion What happened to Game Freak after B2W2, during the development of XY, and why gen 5 deserved a better treatment

0 Upvotes

As I anticipated earlier here is a post about what happened to GF in about 2012, during the development of XY.

There is a video. It is in Italian, however I will explain what it tells briefly. I can not post it here.

It is about the reviews some GF employees wrote on the Internet about GF. It tells the way it is run is authoritarian, archaic and not meritocratic at all, except for high ranking employees who get it easy all the time.

But what is most important is what you can find out if you place all the bits together. In about 2012 there was a mass firing event. The obvious reason is BW selling less than any other new gen main title. The video explains how in GF new employees do not get high quality skill transfer, and how GF does not have many people capable to use new tech and, as such, should have stayed away from 3D, or should have learned to use new tech better.

New people did no longer have the ideas, but they were not good with new tech knowledge either.

Note : XY was mostly already developed but at the end a lot of storyline and postgame contents were cut off. This is why it feels like a originally pretty good but also mutilated game. I know this from another Italian Video I watched, however I can not post URLs.

But what I really want to talk about is not WHAT happened, but WHY and why it should not have at all.

BW tried to reboot Pokémon as a more mature franchising. It did not make a new timeline but it made Unova thousands of miles apart from the first 4 regions, in what is known in real life as the North American continent. All Pokémon living there were new, even though many resembled some of the gen 1 Pokémon. The storyline was very different than usual. It featured villains who did not appear as evil on the outside, and it required the player, unlike any other game, to catch the box art Legendary of his or her version, and fight the other.

Compared to all other new gen titles, BW sold less. It sold 15 - 16 million copies. However the market changes in size and the 26 million of SWSH is for example MUCH less than the 23 million of GS. People became more, videogames became more well accepted and no longer a virgin/incel/geek thing only, older boys started to keep playing longer. So we need to compare BW with gen 3 or 4 at the earliest and with gen 6 or 7 at the latest, especially because gen 1 and 2 benefited from the Pokémania era, and gen 8 and 9 from the post Covid Videogame/Anime/Manga popularity growth.

What we find out is BW did not sell much less than what it should. First, if 2 generations are released on the same console, the second sales less. Gen 4 DP (17 m) sold more than gen 3 RS (16 m) because the market grew a bit and it was already a different console. SM indeed sold less than XY. So BW was set to sell between 16 and 17 millions, and it sold 1 million less. Why did it ? Possibly because of the old fans backslash. Many fans born between 1988 and 1992, starting with gen 1 and about 19 - 23 back then in 2011, started to give low ratings to gen 5 Pokémon designs. And indeed the only flaw of gen 5 is Pokémon designs. By gen 6 they were gone, married with kids.

The "low" sales made GF take a wrong turn, and what I described in the first part of this post happened. Now Game Freak learned they only needed to make barely passable games and wait for the market to grow. Afterall is not like Pokémon lives on videogames, most of the money are from toys and other merchandising.

BW were ironically the most divisive games, with people either loving or hating them, either black or white. But nowadays gen 5 is one of the most loved overall. What happened ? People change their minds, and the people who started with gen 5 are now about 20 years old.

But what if BW sold better and B2W2 did too ? GF would not have took a wrong turn and would have made better games. They worked hard for BW, and hard work being rewarded is a much better moral lesson than do the bare necessities and let the name of the Brand and the market do the rest. This is my main point here : gen 5 was meant to be the new gen 1, the backbone of a new Pokémon Universe with more mature themes. It rather became one of a kind, something relevant for no longer than 3 years. Gen 1 is still ever present and always relevant, and it deserves to be so, but no one outside of actual Pokéfans who are either younger than 25, either have been Pokéfans for a VERY long time, would recognize any gen 5 Pokémon. And yet gen 5 deserved more. Its weakness is the ugliness of all fully evolved starters and the lack of truly marketable Pokémon. Maybe, even if that way it would not have stayed fully true to itself, a few more marketable Pokémon should have been added, and BW just like B2W2 should have featured older Pokémon from the start.

But gen 5 had the best storyline of the franchising and it deserved to be the new gold standard.

Let us see what GF can do now to get back on track and to remit its debts to gen 5.

In 2027 it will be time for gen 5 Remakes, the Unova games of the mega/3D timeline. What they should do is stop making new generations after 2026 (by then there will be a tenth generation which will be released well before gen 5 Remakes), afterall 10 is the perfect number, and get all the time they need to make the Remakes. Even if they get released in 2028.

They should fix the flaws of BW and add new features, while finding a way to make a better 3D. Or maybe just go back to 2D so they will have time and energy to make much more content. I know they will not go back to 2D, but they should.

After BW Remakes they should work more with gen 5, making games with the first 649 Pokémon. Indeed there is no need to make every 3 years 100 - 150 new Pokémon, there are 1000+ now and there will be 1100 - 1200 then. And they can not even put more than 700 or so Pokémon in one game anyway. They could make a 11th generation in the distant future, but by then it will be pointless, and should never get called 11th because after you pass the 10 threshold it starts to get ridicolous.

They should also change the Anime. Ash is gone, Liko will not last after gen 9. Why not making a gen 5 Anime instead of a gen 10 one ? Afterall, they can not use the Best Wishes characters, but they do not have to. Neither Hilda nor Rosa were ever used, even though both May and Dawn were. I found out there is the chance Hilda was not used because her game backsprite had a...sexy backside. Is it true ? If so, it was the most ridicolous and petty reason ever. So many videogame protagonists are way sexier afterall.

With Pikachu gone they must find a way to have a marketable mascot for such Anime however. I am not sure what they should do, but fully evolved gen 5 starters are not a good idea. The regional Pikachu clones do not hold up well either. So maybe they should find a different formula than having a single mascot.


r/TruePokemon • • Mar 06 '25

The pokemon fandom refuses to be happy.

2 Upvotes

I swear, 90% of the post I've seen on legends Z-A are just annoying. People complaining that the game is a sequel instead of a prequel, people complaining about the graphics, and so much more. I swear this fandom is SO ANNOYING!


r/TruePokemon • • Aug 01 '14

My opinion on hacked Pokemon, a more polite explanation.

3 Upvotes

Here's the deal, after the unneeded hate fest towards me that happened earlier today, I think I need to truly explain what I think about hacked Pokemon. (Without me sounding like an arrogant dick.)

I personally don't care, I really don't care if someone tampers with their game to get Volcanion, Hoopa, etc. or even Mega Formes without stones. I feel as when it comes to hacking, I think it's fun to do and interesting to see what Pokemon have been hiding in the game's code and see how good they are or something.

I get really annoyed how the fandom freaks out when they find out a tournament player had an Aegislash in a cool looking ball (GF really needs to bring back seals.), or has a perfectly legal team that is fully shiny. Why do people do this? Because not everyone wants to train and breed a team for 5-6 hours. I know I sure as hell don't, because I don't take Pokemon as serious as some other people.

/rant

Edit: I apologize for acting like a dick back in that one thread.

Edit 2: Except for you /u/coldpleasure, you suck.


r/TruePokemon • • Jul 30 '25

Gamefreak should be striving for a game design similar to CrystalClear

0 Upvotes

This is a topic I think about everytime I hop back on Pokémon.

While the new games are often criticized, I enjoy them and think there's a lot of potential in them and one thing I notice is that some features and details show that the developers have intentions to move the series forward.

However I think in terms of direction, they are going the wrong way, specifically in open world design. They should take a page of how Crystalclear plays.

The Map

I think the huge open space idea that Scarlett and Violet try is not the best approach because you end up with mostly a bit of a bland space and towns look like out of place with so much open space around them. Sometimes looking more like a boomtown in the middle of nowhere from a western movie.

Where they should be going is scaling down back to the straighter paths that the old games had, those maps were smaller but they took advantage of trees and diversity in the things you encounter in towns, plus the vibe was much cozier, make little towns look like little towns and not tiny cities, give more detail inside each small town, enterable buildings npcs that enrich the world with Dialogue, points of interest, etc. Also bring back the maze-like forests and caves.

tldr.: my point is open world doesn't always mean huge open space, a denser, diverse and smaller world will feel bigger

The Story

The second problem I have is with the story. Mordern Pokémon is unnecessarily way too linear. One of the reasons players fell in love with the games was that they put exploration first, story second. The stories used to be pretty simple in a way modular. SV kind of gets it but they go a little too simple and repetitive, for example with team star you always encounter them in the same copy paste bases and do the same challenge with different pokémon. Older teams stories were always some different scenario, with team rocket you encounter them in caves, they rob a house, have a secret base, kidnap an old man in a ghost tower, take a whole city hostage.

I get that CrystalClear does away with the story but the old story structure has a potential for being pretty modular, instead of having a story that drags you to the finish line by hand, they should have a more puzzle like story where you explore at your leisure and find out what's happening piece by piece.

Level scaling

Finally level scaling is a divisive topic but I personally think it really works in a non linear rpg, these games are fairly easy anyway to the point that you don't have to grind and SV shows that no level scaling doesn't work very well because you have to follow a set path of gyms or else you might be overleveled. But a simple option for static levels could solve this.


r/TruePokemon • • Apr 27 '17

so, i'm playing yellow

1 Upvotes

and it's surprisingly still very solid. get past the one 8-bit music track that hurts your ears, and it's pretty much the same as any pokemon game, and the sprites are actually quite good. definitely worth 8.99


r/TruePokemon • • Mar 09 '23

New Gens Need WAY More New Pokémon

0 Upvotes

Hear me out. Let me break it down (also I'm discounting mythicals in these breakdowns because they're unavailable in-game).

Kanto:
-150 Pokémon all neatly distributed.
Johto:
-99 new Pokémon, horrid over-reliance on Gen 1, badly distributed.
Hoenn:
-133 new Pokémon mostly fill the region, the Hoenn Dex also has nearly 70 mons from gens 1-2 and old Pokémon are nice familiar faces instead of clogging up the spawn pools.
Sinnoh:
-Bit trickier, due to the cross gen evos, but the roughly 80 entirely new Pokémon fill Sinnoh nicely, and even better in Platinum. Despite having quite a few less new mons than Hoenn, they're distributed pretty much just as well.
Unova:
-Enough new Pokémon to fill the region, with every route pretty much introducing new Pokémon. The first half of Unova managed to feel huge even though it was fairly small, and granted having every new area have new Pokémon is a lot easier when you have 153 to fill only half the map. AND this was accomplished without making the region feel small, due to how explorable everything is.
Kalos:
-450-ish regional dex, only 69 new Pokémon, barely anything new shows up during the game. Over-reliance on old mons (the champion's ace is literally a fully evolved early route mon from 10 years prior, ew) and loss of regional identity due to old games' early birds, bugs and rodents showing up immediately. It's impossible to evenly distribute such a small number of Pokémon throughout such a massive region. Even with 150-ish new mons like Unova would've only made up a third of the dex.
Alola & Galar:
-Slightly better distribution than Kalos, but largely the same problems, both having 80-90 new mons in a regional dex of 400+
Paldea:
-Somehow, same problems as Gens 6-8, but that's probably because about 15 of the new Pokémon are either "old Pokémon but a dinosaur" or "old Pokémon but a robot".

So, here's my point.
A regional dex as big as 400, in a region as big as we currently have, needs probably around 200 new Pokémon.
Proportionally, Hoenn and Sinnoh had good new Pokémon distribution due to the new mons taking up about 2/3 of the PokéDex. Both regions also didn't have the previous games' early birds/bugs/rodents except Wurmple in Sinnoh. Those tropes contribute to regional identity, which is lost. There's no room for any rare huntable Pokémon like Bagon, Snorunt, Chimecho, Axew, Gible, Dratini, Larvitar, Misdreavus etc.
New Pokémon now just feel like an obligation so they do the absolute bare minimum. They massively reduced the number of new Pokémon AFTER tripling the region size, as well as just throwing in old Pokémon to fill up space. Is it a lack of new ideas? Or are they trying to move away from the idea of new Pokémon being important?

Genuinely, I can see a future where Gen 12 comes out and It's literally regional forms of the Kanto starters, then like 30 regional forms of various old Pokémon and that's it as far as new Pokémon go.


r/TruePokemon • • Aug 01 '24

Discussion Fakemon actively limit the potential of actual Pokemon designs.

8 Upvotes

We know it. A lot of the time, fans make designs leagues better than most designs Gamefreak come up with. From things like Mega Flygon to normal evolutions of older Pokemon, you name it, a fan has made it. Recent designs are cool and all, but a lot of fanmade designs are cool as well.

And herein lies the problem. Gamefreak as a company wouldn't be able to use those designs, or reference those designs, for fear of public outcry and backlash. Of course, they have a crazy powerful legal team and backing of Nintendo to probably sue the artists, but again, way too much effort for little reward.

Fakemon are awesome and I agree we should keep making them. Always cool to see new designs. But GF as a company probably finds trouble skirting around designs that border on stealing from artists etc. Wonder if anyone else feels the same.


r/TruePokemon • • Aug 03 '25

Discussion Do you think power creep will ever reach the point that we'll get an ability capsule style item to make pokemon shiny?

0 Upvotes

Hear me out. As a kid, the only way to method hunt was masuda method. Over the years, they've introduced more and more effective ways of method hunting, culminating in the sandwiches from Scarlett and Violet, which often feel like cheating. Pokemon go has also made many shinies trivial to obtain if you participate in community Day or certain other events. Raids now even make legendaries in go quite easy to get if you're willing to shell out for passes. They got so easy to get that game freak even introduced square shinies just to make them feel more special, and marks feel like their attempt to further make hunting worthwhile for more than just the new color pallet. But as they do things like hyper training, mints, ability patches, etc. they make things that were once impossible to control now easily changed as long as you have sufficient BP or whatever. Could there be a hypothetical future where we get the shiny patch? I wonder how they'd try to balance it around organically found shinies if they did.


r/TruePokemon • • Dec 24 '22

Discussion Unpopular opinon: dex cut was the right thing to do

2 Upvotes

The Pokémon fanbase just seems to be blind, since it doesn't understand why things are done. There are now more than 1000 Pokémon, so it would be impossible to have all of them, undersand! Do you know why Kalos's alien plotline was scrapped? Because they had to make models for 700+ Pokémon, so be careful of what you wish for. Quality > quantity


r/TruePokemon • • Nov 13 '25

Discussion Johto’s level curve isn’t bad

0 Upvotes

I keep on hearing that the Gen II games having a bad level curve but I don’t see it.

Johto in general has a much lower level for its major trainers than other regions. If you only do the mandatory fights then you would still be at an appropriate level.

I didn’t grind but I didn’t have any issues becoming Champion.

Are people referring to Red? I don’t include Mt. Silver content since it’s postgame optional content to me.


r/TruePokemon • • Jan 25 '24

Idea Pokemon franchise is sorely missing a proper sandbox

0 Upvotes

I am sorry for mentioning this, but Palworld got me thinking

Pokemon currently does not have a sandbox of any sort whatsoever. The only one we ever had was the first Pokemon Stadium in the 90s, technically Go too if we count AR mobile games that require movement.

With the massive success of Palworld, regardless of moral implications tells me that a proper sandbox simulator for Pokemon would be giganticly popular.

Every Pokemon game atm, regardless of genre or whether its a mainline/spinoff has a forced unskippable storyline that spans dozens of hours, is massively linear and handholdy until 30+ hours in.

We know how popular sandbox games can be that allow players to engage in whatever they like. We saw this with Palworld and the likes of Fortnite. Theres some real untapped potential for Game Freak and TPC.


r/TruePokemon • • Feb 27 '26

The ages in Pokémon don’t make sense to me

0 Upvotes

I recently discovered that Brock is 15 in gen 1 and the anime but then turns somewhere between 17 or 19 in heart gold and soul silver and that brought some questions to mind.

First of all, don’t each character age by 1 year each gen, and isn’t heart gold and soul silver just a remake of gold and silver? If so how did Brock age somewhere between 2 to 4 years in just 1 year.

And lastly why does Lucy have a crush on him if she’s in her 20s and Brock is 15?


r/TruePokemon • • Feb 04 '22

Discussion I prefer Random Encounters in grass to Overworld Pokémon

19 Upvotes

I feel like I’m on a sinking ship for thinking that random encounters promotes more interesting playthroughs/experiences overall and that if people want to see Pokémon in the overworld, they should just play Pokémon Snap or hopefully continue Legends as a side series.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 10 '22

Discussion you were held at gun point to make "the pokemon killer" what would you make.

1 Upvotes

Lets say, EA or Ubisoft wants to have that pokemon dough like what they probably always wanted, and they pick the pokemon fan at gun point to direct it

you at least have an the "good" realistic AAA budget,time and staff to produce it, so nevermind the logistic.


r/TruePokemon • • Apr 25 '26

Discussion The Physical Special split + larger movepools have made Pokemon more homogenized

23 Upvotes

There is something that has bothered me about the physical special split, and I have felt that it makes Pokemon somewhat more homogenized. Now, I'm not saying it's entirely a bad thing, it was a QOL and mechanical upgrade in many ways, that changed the direction of the series and is a clock we just can't turn back at this point, but there is something I miss about the old ways.

In Gens I-III, attack types were always linked to either Attack or Special Attack, and the respective Defense stats. Fire was always Special, Fighting was always Physical. This made certain Pokemon effectively nerfed based on their stats. Famously, Flareon had a better physical Attack stat, but had basically only access to Normal-type and Fire type moves, the latter of which it couldn't use effectively. Then in Gen IV, it didn't get Flare Blitz until Gen V, so it was left behind by not having a strong physical Fire move.

But here's the thing; I actually find that more interesting that certain Pokemon aren't necessarily good at their respective Type as attackers. I think it's interesting that some Pokemon have Type not as offence, but only in terms of a liability in terms of what they're weak to. Should Flareon mainly have a role as a fire-breather? Or is it a pet, a Normal-type Eevee that can take on some aspects of various elements, but is still mainly doing dog/fox things? Some more points;

- I think it was interesting for Beedrill to learn the Bug-type moves Twinneedle and Pin Missile because it actually stings people, but no Poison-type moves because bees usually aren't severely poisonous (unless you're allergic). And in contrast, Butterfree didn't learn any Bug attacks at all, it was a bug and can be crushed by a Rock or burned by Fire, but it's role should be focused on wind, powder, and the mild psychic abiltiy that was assigned to it as a flavourful addition originally. That's what makes them different. Now they can both learn Bug Buzz, and Beedrill can learn X-Scissor. What's the fundamental difference?

- On the above note, the split has meant that we have to double up on attacks so that most Pokemon have STAB coverage in their preferred stat, but a lot of moves, IMO have little identity. Bug Buzz is described as "The user vibrates its wings to generate a damaging sound wave. It may also lower the foe's Sp. Def stat." Bugs can do that, but I'm not sure what's "Bug" about the damage that causes. Why is this especially effective against Grass types? A sting makes sense. It's not too bad though, as this move is exclusive to Bug-type Pokemon. But what about X-Scissor? What's "Bug-like" about cutting something in an X-shape? They justify this move on anything with claws, and some Physical Pokemon get very wide coverage. Why can Weavile, Sceptile, Gallade and Zangoose do this?

- The amount of vague "energy ball" style attacks kinda drive me nuts, most Types have one of these to fill the Special attack lane. Did you know EVERY Eeveelution can learn Shadow Ball? Why? What's dark and ghostly about most of them? And of those, do Eeveelutions even need to be able to do a spirit bomb? Alakazam is a Special Attack specialist and can be thought of as using energy attacks with Psychic powers, but why Energy Ball? Does Alakazam seem like the type to be especially good at drawing energy from nature? Celebi, sure, but why Reuniclus? And for that matter, why physical Grass types like Rillaboom? Focus Blast is another one, and it was designed for Lucario, now every Special Attacker has 6 kinds of chi balls.

- There are Pokemon like Basculegion that have moves like Wave Crash with descriptions like "The user shrouds itself in water and slams into the target with its whole body to inflict damage. This also damages the user quite a lot." But isn't it the water part that does damage to Fire types? Why does your ability to crash into them hard make it super effective against Fire? Shouldn't your Special Attack affect how good you are at "shrouding yourself in water", and how much water is used in the attack? A lot of aggressive fish/aquatic Pokemon have this going on with Waterfall and Wave Crash.

- More restricted movesets, especially when Pokemon used to just have two/three attacking types max naturally made it really special when they would randomly learn an off-Type attack, like Pin Missile with Jolteon or Confusion with Butterfree. It was cool. Now I can't remember all the types Pokemon have access to.

I dunno, I just feel like I would like to see what would have happened if more Pokemon were allowed to exist that aren't that good at their own element were buffed in other ways. And also if move weren't invented to have universal coverage, other sweepers weren't as able to eat their lunch.

I have a proposal which could be worth trying in a ROM hack or something, which would be to keep the physical/special split, deal base damage on that alignment with the correct stat, but make the super-effective damage linked to the Type's lane. For example, with Wave Crash, Basculegion could deal high base damage by using a physical Water-type attack, but the super-effective damage is calculated against it's Sp. Atk and the target's Sp. Defense, meaning Basculegions's ability to use the properties of Water specifically, is somewhat limited compared to a Blastoise with Water cannons.

I would like to try making a ROM hack trying out this change, with somewhat stripped back movepools, to get a bit of old-school feel to it. I feel like Gen II-III was the sweet spot for that specific vibe. A lot of rebalancing would need to be done to give Pokemon their own niche and role. I feel like they've succeeded in doing this for a lot of new Pokemon by having more mechanically complex Abilities and mechanics, it's not that there's a small number that have a niche these days, I just think it's odd when they just slap Dazzling Gleam on whatever for coverage and every Pokemon shoots energy and magic.


r/TruePokemon • • Oct 30 '24

Discussion Main series Pokemon has the most complex turn based combat system of all time.

0 Upvotes

Every single time I say this, I always get a lifeless response of them mentioning the lack of difficulty in the main campaign.

  1. The difficulty of the game has nothing to do with anything of what I'm talking about. It's like saying Tekken isn't a complex fighting game because enemies in survival mode and arcade don't use optimal combos.

  2. As far as the campaign goes, you can find difficulty in the battle facilities.

In gen 7, which is the biggest Pokemon game out there, there's 728 moves and I believe a little over 100 passive abilities. I've heard people say "oh quality over quantity." There's only so many times you can make a move similar to another move with a slight change in power. If a director says, put 728 moves in the game, there's bound to be bat crazy strategy ideas in the game and obviously there are, but even from gen 1 they went above and beyond with moves like transform and reflect type. There's more moves in this game after that break the laws of the game entirely like trick room, power swap, foul play, there are even field traps and field weather and field terrain. The games are wildly innovative and expansive.