r/trekacademy • u/noriilikesleaves • Mar 21 '26
I hate watch negative reviews of the show. Anybody else doing the same?
I did the same thing with Discovery too honestly.
r/trekacademy • u/noriilikesleaves • Mar 21 '26
I did the same thing with Discovery too honestly.
r/trekacademy • u/ety3rd • Jan 06 '26
r/trekacademy • u/lexxstrum • Mar 14 '26
Cards on the table, I did like season 1. But the minute we found out Braka set up a "wall around the Federation", and that wall could end space travel as we know it, it kinda felt old hat; once again, it's an end-of-the-world season finale.
But did it have to be?
Imagine if instead of what he did, Nus and the Venari Ral went a more diplomatic approach. They were building a "Peace Confederation" against alleged Federation oppression. So, for example, episode 2 is the Federation and the Venari Ral trying to woo Betazed to their side, with the offer to make Betazed the new Capitol the "Hail Mary" move.
Of course, this means episode 6 has to be retooled. Perhaps some diplomatic or humanitarian mission is sabotaged by the VR as proof the FED is the true enemy of freedom. And in the end, "Chairman Braka" seems to be swaying galactic opinion against Starfleet, maybe even getting member worlds to rethink their positions.
We put a VR representative as a guest to the wedding in episode 7, and Darem has to warn the new queen the VR are not to be trusted.
We need a few episodes added, and background stuff with more examples of VR turning public opinion against the Federation by duplicity and propaganda, misrepresentation of events and out and out lying.
Caleb does go to Ukeck, which is supposedly being peacefully brought into the Confederation, but is actually being forcibly taken over after it's leaders were forced to surrender, and he finds his mom. They get caught, and are declared "child soldier/terrorists of the despicable Federation Starfleet" and sentenced to death. Nahla shows up and tries to free them, but Nus decides to try her and the Federation for crimes against the Galaxy as the final step to cementing the Confederation's rightful place in the galaxy.
Finale is the trial, but instead of trying to take down the mines, it's hacking into VR databases, to show the truth of what happened on Ukeck and other worlds. The cadets manage to override Nus's control over the trials datastream, showing the potential new Confederation members the truth behind this new government. They bolt when it's pointed out yeah, the Federation made mistakes, but they weren't monsters, unlike the Venari Ral and Braka. Braka tries to save the situation, but enraged at losing everything, he decides to murder Nahla, who is saved by Anisha. The Venari ships turn their guns on the Athena and find the representatives ships defending it, as a Starfleet task force comes in to shut it all down.
Thoughts?
r/trekacademy • u/Shatterhand1701 • Dec 04 '25
r/trekacademy • u/Substantial_Ad3799 • Feb 08 '26
r/trekacademy • u/PJKetelaar3 • Dec 20 '25
Our maiden voyage of the next Paramount+ streaming offering discusses...
A generational casts with stars, returning characters and new cadets
The four-minute scene released ahead of the two-episode premiere
Listen NOW: http://www.phantasticgeek.com/2025/12/previewing-star-trek-starfleet-academy.html
r/trekacademy • u/ety3rd • Jan 05 '26
r/trekacademy • u/Flash525 • Feb 13 '26
just a theory on my part, but what with the head shaking etc, I think they're out of phase somewhat, likely the result of a failed experiment.
I wouldn’t be half surprised to learn that they're the crew of that ship when the new drive tech went wrong.
Thoughts? It seems too obvious, but then the writing team for this show don't appear to be the sharpest.
r/trekacademy • u/AnAppMadeMeDoIt • Mar 12 '26
r/trekacademy • u/NewGamePlus323 • Feb 24 '26
I'm an elder Millennial. I grew up on 90s Trek. I've only watched 5 episodes of Academy so far. I applaud this show for attempting to go in a new direction and bring younger viewers to the franchise. With that being said, I think it’s missing the mark. It wants to appeal to younger viewers and claims to relate to them, but it doesn’t seem to reflect any of the issues they’re dealing with. The Starfleet kids aren’t worried about whether they can find jobs or housing when they graduate; they’re not living in a scary, unpredictable world with questionable leadership, the big crisis (The Burn) is already over, and someone else fixed it. A show where these kids are living in the immediate aftermath of the Burn or watching the Federation fall apart, and being asked to fix a mess they inherited from past generations would’ve been more relevant. Instead, they are just doing cliched YA teen drama. They don't even have a threat like the Dominion or the Borg to deal with (that I've seen so far). But maybe that's the point? Is it all about escapism? Thats my take after watching 5 episodes (just finished the one about Sisko), but I'm not the target audience. I'm curious what Gen Z and Alpha viewers are thinking, if anyone cares to share.
r/trekacademy • u/Prize_Instance_1416 • Jan 16 '26
I don’t know if it’s the accent or the lisp, but I have some difficulty hearing what she’s saying. Anyone else have this? Think it’s maybe a recording/ post thing that they can clear up? Otherwise it seems like a well produced show so far.
r/trekacademy • u/Bostonterrierpug • Feb 21 '26
Mopping technology was all destroyed in the Burn !
r/trekacademy • u/Shatterhand1701 • Dec 07 '25
r/trekacademy • u/Prudent-Mountain-888 • Oct 22 '26
r/trekacademy • u/thelessandbestofme • Feb 22 '26
isn't it weird that they use an ACTUAL spaceship which is basically a graveyard for the training? I mean... come on. forget about how it ended up, like, the safety concerns and everything. but what about RESPECT?? a lot of people died in there. couldnt they have made a simulation on a holodeck? wouldnt that have worked just as efficiently, if, yes, better? this is concerning dumbness coming from the academy and the war college.
r/trekacademy • u/ety3rd • Dec 21 '25
r/trekacademy • u/MoonchanterLauma2025 • Feb 14 '26
Earlier this week, season 1 episode 6 "Come, Let's Away" introduced the old derelict U.S.S. Miyazaki, whose backstory notably includes being the focus of a renowned and debatably propagandic comic book Tales from the Frontier, which kept spirits up among ex-Federation citizens during the galactic dark age following the Burn. Unfortunately, several viewers have observed oddities in the comic book pages which suggest an A.I. algorithm was used as a budget-saving measure. Firstly, that's not a 31st century uniform style! And then observe Captain Chi's hands in some frames. Or the very limited facial expressions. Also, the abysmal lettering of the speech bubbles and caption boxes. Did these images come as output from using the Kelvin movies as input?
Here are hi-res screencaps from cygnus-x1.net. Please go support that site! They have almost 800 images for just this episode. Unlike A.I. "artists", they are great!
r/trekacademy • u/NAStrahl • Jan 26 '26
ST:SA presents a fantastic opportunity to expand upon Traveler lore further in the franchise. And I'm willing to play the role of a cadet Watcher, with it implied that a certain 'Wes' is my teacher and mentor. (Wait, can a 41-year-old pass as being the average age of the other cadets?)
r/trekacademy • u/Burning_sun_prog • Mar 13 '26
r/trekacademy • u/ZedPrimus84 • Jul 27 '25
So the new uniforms aren't bad. I like the delta on the left side. Based on the change, I'm guessing this is set a few years after DISCO S5, otherwise Starfleet is just as flippant with changing uniform design in the 3190s as it was in the 2380s. The new combadge is....a choice. But...letterman jackets? Seriously? I remember folks used to refer to an Academy themed show as Star Trek:90210 derisively and the costume designers thought process was "Let's give the cadets letterman jackets...that won't nail the whole 90210 thing home at all."
But I'm probably in the wrong here. I'm probably going to get crapped on for this.

r/trekacademy • u/jefhaugh • Feb 21 '26
Has anything been said as to why the Academy training ship is naned Athena and not Enterprise? The Wrath of Khan established Enterprise as a training vessel, why not continue the famous name?
r/trekacademy • u/giftopherz • Feb 05 '26
Let me preface my rant by saying that I'm out of my depth here. I'm familiar with Star Trek and besides the most recent movies, SNW and now Academy, I know nothing about the franchise. Having said that....
I feel like the latest episode just ran over Sam's own growth and overall potential for the show. She's coming from a species that has been isolated and is very wary of the "organics" like they mentioned, and yet she's too bubbly (at this stage) towards everybody. When it comes to Vulcans, for example, they share the same traits and still manage to convey both feelings relatively well.
While I like the premise of the episode, I would've prefer if the stretched it the full season... it would've made more sense to see her come to terms with her own autonomy and sense of self while also growing to understand humans and shedding the robotic side of her.
Anyways, talking lot of nonsense but actually enjoying the journey.
How are you liking Holly Hunter's antics as captain?
r/trekacademy • u/azssf • Jan 17 '26
Could someone explain to me the dialog between Caleb and Tarima when things go badly during the dinner?
I’m too old to recall being a teen/very young adult.
r/trekacademy • u/lexxstrum • Jan 23 '26
From everything we've seen, the Venari Ral are a crime syndicate. And the Emerald Chain was a "capitalist syndicate" that did its business in a shady way, so it was kinda also a crime syndicate. So, we've got a kleptocracy and a pirate clan as our major adversarial powers in the 32nd century. Kinda variations on a theme; I get the idea that fringe elements would rise to power, like Raider gangs in post apocalyptic settings.
But I had this weird idea watching the latest episode: what if some minor species/power became a major player in galactic affairs? It's something that happens in nature, and in societies actually: a power vacuum leads to a previously out of power group amassing tremendous amounts of power. And yeah, I get that's what they've done with the Chain and the Venari Ral, but they can be dismissed as criminals.
What if the 120 years post Burn led to some minor species becoming a major player? They quickly become a superpower while the Federation and the Empire both crumble. In my little thought experiment, I used the Pakleds (although if i was writing this, I'd want to use some other species).
I imagined that somehow, Pakled Clump ships were spared the Burn. This left them one of the few species able to maintain starflight. Rather than quickly trying to conquer known space, they soon realize that the species around them will give them almost everything for food, information, protection and continued commerce. Soon, the Pakled navy is patrolling neighboring systems, with more and more alien groups begging to join the Pakled coalition. And for 120+ years, this Coalition was keeping it's region of space safe, and its people strong, while Federation and Klingon systems were fighting for scraps. They quickly become a major player in the quadrant, and love their new position.
And then DISCO brings warp drive back to the galaxy, and the Federation starts to rebuild. Now the Pakled Coalition isn't looking as great, and they fear losing their status. Or maybe they are able to keep their little group together in spite of the return of the FED, and become an upstart rival to them.
I know, it's all kinda academic, and maybe the story works better with pirate empires scavenging the world, but it would be interesting to give the 32nd Century a less black and white choice as an antagonist.