Since I was 12, I've identified as trans and started going by he/him pronouns because they made me more comfortable than she/her. Before then, I tried out she/they and they/them, but I never really felt right with them. So, I eased into being trans by first identifying as a demiboy, but eventually, I just didn't feel like it fit.
For a while, things were fine. Obviously, I stayed closeted to most people because being a preteen trans kid never went over well with my family, especially during the pandemic. During that time, however, I dated this boy who was also MTF. We dated on and off for about two and a half years.
I will admit that I'd always been on the more feminine side when it came to how I dressed and acted, but I brushed it off because, in my head, if a gay cis man could act the exact same way, why was it any different when I did? That shouldn't make me any less of a man, yk?
Well, toward the end of our relationship (as a whole, not just as partners), I was on a call with him, and he started asking me questions regarding my gender. He began pressing me about the way I dressed and acted, telling me that if I really was trans, I would make more of an effort with myself. Eventually, it turned into an argument, one of our last, I'll say.
Which was pointless to me because, at the time, it was something I genuinely couldn't do. I had previously been put in a position where any attempt to put myself out there as a trans boy would result in me being berated and disciplined. After trying to come out before, I knew what the consequences were. So, obviously, for him to argue that I wasn't trying hard enough, and therefore couldn't be trans, hurt. I'll admit that, especially after he knew about all of my previous struggles.
Anyways, after that, I think it got to me, and I detransitioned. I grew out my hair, started wearing more feminine clothing, and to my friends, I went back to being [deadname].
I'll also mention that I'm physically disabled and have always struggled with my identity as a trans person because of that fact. I'm pretty short for my age and don't have a particularly skinny face, so every time I attempted to look like a boy through haircuts and more masculine clothing, I felt like I just looked more like an idiot. Eventually, I stopped trying.
In my head, I already had it hard enough being disabled, and I didn't need another thing that made me feel stupid, little, or that brought upon another opportunity to be made fun of in class.
I struggle a lot with my identity now, and it's something I think about constantly. I KNOW I look at pictures of boys, cis and trans, who pass and wish I could just look like them..normal. But I know I just can't, and honestly, I don't have faith that I ever will.
It just feels like being cis is easier than making a fool of myself. But I just wish I could be a boy. Born a boy. Anything. I hate being referred to as a girl or being called by she/her pronouns, and nothing would make me happier than if I were just a cis BOY instead.
With being physically disabled comes different bodily proportions, which I've always been insecure about in general. A point my ex had made was that I never experienced gender dysphoria, so I definitely wasn't trans. And I feel like I've just never recognized my dysphoria because I've been too busy focusing on the general physical disability of my body. It overwhelms and drowns out any thoughts of whether certain insecurities might also be because I was born a girl. I don't know if that makes sense or not.
I will say I don't necessarily hate the lower part of my body, if ygm. However (yes, I'm going to put this out there because I feel it's important to how I feel), my chest has always been relatively smaller (flatter) than the average person's, so I've never really had TOO MUCH to be insecure about there. I don't even know if medically I could ever get top surgery because of how practically nonexistent they are. Don't get me wrong, they're there, and you can tell, but they're nothing crazy at all, so it's never been a huge issue for me or something I pay much mind to.
Anyways, with everything being said, I've considered coming back out to my friends and transitioning after I go to college next fall. But I just see all of these actual trans people talking about how many posers there are, and I've never, ever had anyone to validate how I've felt (not that I've ever really told anyone this).
I just fear that... AM I really being a poser just because I've identified as trans for so long, or am I valid for how I feel?
I've tried other, more generalized terms, such as demigirl and queer, but I always find myself coming back to "trans." Don't get me wrong, I know I'm too girly for a man, but I feel like I'm also too manly for a girl, and it's just so confusing. As i've stated i ever fet comfortable enough with other terms such as demiboy, queer, genderfluid, etc. I've always just been trans.
Is it because I KNOW I can't come out, so I subconsciously act more feminine because of my fear of my parents finding out? Or am I a poser?
I would really love some advice on my take because it's genuinely driving me crazy trying to figure out and validate my own feelings, especially when I don't have any trans friends to confide in either.