r/tos • • Nov 16 '25

Did Kirk even need to be in ST TMP?

0 Upvotes

In hindsight, I feel like this movie didn't even need Kirk. I might even say that Kirk made things worse for everyone on-board.

Kirk takes command simply because he can.

Kirk plays up McCoy's fear of transporters for laughs, despite the fact that he just witnessed a transporter accident that ended two lives.

Kirk makes the wrong decision during the wormhole sequence that could have destroyed the ship, Decker had to override his command.

Kirk's command is so inflexible that Spock ends up committing mutiny and goes after V'Ger himself.

Almost all the best answers come from Spock when it comes to dealing with V'Ger, he ends up taking several jobs throughout the ship. (Science Officer, First Officer, Communications Officer, Away Team.)

This movie could have had Decker and Spock go after V'Ger and it would have been the same outcome, if not better.

And if we were to say "But Kirk brought in Mr Spock in the first place!"

Spock had already felt V'Ger's presence, and was already in-range, and since the transporter accident happens regardless of who would be in command, the ship needs a science officer, and that's Spock.


r/tos • • Oct 30 '24

Not going to rephrase it Laddie

Post image
371 Upvotes

r/tos • • Nov 04 '25

Watching Star Trek V as a prequel to Star Trek II

0 Upvotes

I know you might be thinking "How can you use a fifth installment as a prequel when there's 4 movies behind its back?"

Quite honestly I feel that The Motion Picture doesn't fit anywhere, I still like it but it's a sterile attempt at bringing our characters together. Starting with Star Trek II you get the feeling that you're missing something, you're hearing these conversations like a bug on the wall but you don't get the proper feeling that these are friends until ST II hits us with the ending.

Star Trek V feels the most TOS out of all the movies, it's fun and we get to know the TOS characters up close, we bond with them, we begin to care for them. That could be a base for the events in Star Trek II.

Putting a few minor canon issues aside. Star Trek V just seems to work more as a prequel than a sequel.

"But what about the Enterprise A? How can there be an Enterprise A when in this scenario Enterprise OG would still exist?"

The Enterprise A may have been a prototype attempt to upgrade Starfleet vessels and give the old Constitution class a new face. It goes wrong however, the prototype is far from finished and it's why the Enterprise is in such a state of disaster when attempting to move to this new vessel, so much so that the crew might revert back to the NCC 1701 which is now doomed to life as a training vessel. Scotty thinks he knows this new ship, but it just isn't the same Enterprise. If I were to say a metaphor, the Enterprise A in this context is Windows Vista, and the Enterprise we see in Wrath of Khan is Windows 7.

Afterwards they finish up the Enterprise A and its issues by Star Trek IV, and we really see what she's got in VI.

"How does Kirk go from Captain, to Admiral, to Captain again?"

Clearly V could be set sometime after the 5 year mission. The Federation might have been impressed at how Enterprise handled a situation that brought Romulans and Klingons to drink together. This feat could have easily been grounds for promotion for Kirk.

But after a while, we see that Kirk made a mistake accepting promotion. He's not cut out for a desk job, which leads into Star Trek II.

"Men like us don't have families"

The fact that Kirk said this line always bothered me, what about David? And why is he suddenly okay with Klingons when they were the ones who killed his son? A grudge he clearly holds in VI?

So perhaps in the context of Star Trek V being a prequel, he simply says this line because he doesn't know about Carol or David. He's still the Captain with swagger we've known in TOS.

"The Excelsior."

It's strange seeing Sulu still in the bridge of the Enterprise when it's clear that he should be in command of Excelsior by this time. So if this were a prequel, he would clearly be up for promotion to command a vessel because he breached The Great Barrier. Why not give the person that performed this feat a ship, capable of Transwarp drive?

In dialogue cut from Star Trek II, you have a scene where Kirk says;

I cut your new orders personally. By the end of the month, you'll have your first command: The USS Excelsior.

"I need my pain!"

Kirk has yet to face a no win scenario by this time. Sybok couldn't get to him because he's yet to feel a scenario where he can truly express fear. This can perfectly lead into Star Trek II.

First it's his Captain's chair, then it's Spock, then the Enterprise. He faces a volley of events that would break someone, you need pain? You got it.

It's baggage that he carries from II all the way into VI. It's why V seems out of place when viewed as a sequel.

"Life is a dream."

None of this is proper set up as canon, there's still mentions of Spock's comeback in Star Trek V. But putting that aside, Star Trek V seems very self contained, and written in a way where we can get closer to these characters than ever before.

If we were to dream that this pointless sequel could be a proper prequel instead to set up the stakes for Star Trek II, then life can be a dream.


r/tos • • May 04 '26

Somewhere I’m confident someone is driving around in the Enterpise. This is Pennsylvania new license plate numbers. Obscured to protect driver.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/tos • • Oct 29 '25

“Wolf in the fold,” shouldn’t have been an episode

2 Upvotes

I know I shouldn’t give so much progress to a 60s sci-fi but it was still disappointing seeing so many interesting and unique characters who were woman only to be swept away and killed, only used as vessels to further the emotional impact of the men. I mean the whole episode was basically about killing women as a plot device. Why can’t we further learn about them and their personalities? Also one of Spock’s comments in this episode, “women are more prone to fear and horror,” that was surprising, idk it really felt like women were dehumanized in this. This episode is the least of what star trek should be, it doesn’t fit in with an idealized advanced society. I also know this trope is commonly used, I suppose I wish Star Trek was able to get away from it but not everything is perfect

Idk, am i missing the whole point here? I feel like it could’ve at least been done differently


r/tos • • Nov 01 '25

Shatner Jesus

Post image
0 Upvotes

Happy Halloween!


r/tos • • Oct 22 '20

Trying to like TOS

0 Upvotes

I started with TNG, which I love, so I'm trying to watch TOS finally. I'm three episodes in and frankly I'm finding it extremely difficult to watch. Every 5 minutes they objectify women in some way, and in these three episodes the main plot has revolved around it. Does it get better? Do women stop becoming foreign species compared to the men?


r/tos • • Nov 24 '25

Massive Mistake in Star Trek TOS: The Doomsday Machine Remaster

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/tos • • Dec 25 '25

Star Trek's Christmas Party We Never Saw--Until Now! | Star Trek: TOS

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/tos • • Apr 23 '23

Brunch anyone?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/tos • • May 29 '22

The SCARY women of ST:TOS ...

0 Upvotes

As I look back at the original series, it's amazing how many female antagonists there were.

Gene Roddenberry (creator of STAR TREK) had a serious fear of women - - -

Roddenberry was freaking TERRIFIED by women !!!

Many of the episodes of ST:TOS represent this !!!


r/tos • • Nov 03 '25

Hate for Pavel Chekov

22 Upvotes

When I watched TOS the first time, as a teenager, I loved all the characters unequivocally and without critique. It's a beautiful thing to be young and enthusiastic and uncritical and unskeptical! I wish I could get it back sometimes (and sometimes I can!).

Upon adult rewatching, the single character among the entire cast that I can't get behind, like, at all, is Pavel Chekov. His entire existence is predicated upon a need for a young, Monkees-like character to draw a youthful audience (which ended up being completely unnecessary), and so he gets as much or more screen time than other, more interesting characters (e.g., Uhura, Chapel, M'Benga, perhaps even Sulu). So what we wind up with is a wig-wearing/mop-headed Monkee-kid on the Enterprise mean to serve a demographic rather than being a character with a character's purpose.

Chekov is often problematic in episodes. In "Day of the Dove" he attempts to rape Klingon Science officer Mara, prompting Kirk to (thank God) punch him in his stupid mouth and knock him out. In "Spectre of the Gun" he is more interested in maybe getting to have sex with an imaginary character created to help destroy him than he is in helping the crew to survive, getting himself deservedly killed in the process.

In other cases, he's not dangerous but simply embarrassing: he gets stupidly involved with Yeoman Landon in "The Apple" and Irina in "the Way to Eden" (mostly forgiven as Scotty and even Kirk get stupidly involved with women during the series too), and as a Starfleet officer, he screams at the sight of a dead body (dead of old age, not even a gruesome death) in "The Deadly Years."

Finally his one "endearing" characteristic is his complete acceptance of 23rd century Russian propaganda: that everything important ever was made or discovered or invented in Russia. Ha ha. He's so charming and funny.

Somehow or another as an adult, I've discovered that I could do without Chekov in every episode he's in -- or that I wish his screentime had been given to Uhura, Sulu, or Chapel.

Perhaps another hot take: if I had to replace any of the original TOS crew with their Kelvinverse counterparts, I would instantly and gladly sub in Anton Yelchin's Chekov. He played him with such earnestness and intelligence that I really liked his character (much more than Koenig's). By the way, I don't blame poor Walter Koenig: he didn't ask for the wig, the hairstyle, the annoying lines, or the bad behavior -- he did the best he could with what he was given. He just coulnd't win me over. At least, not until the feature films, in which he seems a bit more competent and likeable.

Does anyone else here feel the same way, or are you all Chekov-lovers? I want to know if I'm crazy or if others have had the same experience rewatching these as adults and finding Chekov to be largely useless?


r/tos • • Jan 14 '24

it's sad that SNW has more outlandish adventures than TOS

2 Upvotes

like kirk is supposed to be the legendary captain of the enterprise and the crew have outlandish adventures... but have you guys seen SNW. they got adventures under pike that make kirks look tame by comparison already.


r/tos • • Feb 25 '23

No fighting, boys!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/tos • • Apr 27 '26

Who was better ?

1 Upvotes

Who was better with space alien women, Commander Riker or Captain Kirk?


r/tos • • Feb 04 '23

Works for me!😉

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/tos • • Jun 20 '26

Sulu excelled in all things... and then some.

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/tos • • Aug 15 '25

Mirror, mirror and season 2

0 Upvotes

Man has ten minutes left and he's telling a woman shes perfect and she can do anything

they telling uherua to distract sulu and they already know they are messing with the ship lol Spock clearly hates it Weird episode but good the episode before the ending is the first time iv even noticed the humour with nomad and Kurt joking about having a son 😂😂 it's much better than season 1


r/tos • • Jul 31 '24

James t kirkel

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/tos • • Sep 16 '26

Hottest female guest star?

22 Upvotes

I go with Mira from Lights of Zatar but the Lieutenant from Shore Leave was nice as well. What about the android from What Little girls are Made of? Damn! Most were hot!


r/tos • • Nov 15 '25

Khan's race?

11 Upvotes

What is Khan's race, and is there info about it? Not sure if I should ask this here but doing a ttrpg with some friends who chose star trek and the dm said if I can find a good enough info file I can make a character of this race...


r/tos • • May 16 '23

Hide your daughters! 😬

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/tos • • Sep 26 '23

Flying "Trans Kirk"...🤣

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/tos • • Oct 01 '25

Cage/Menagerie - Real Vina Not That Bad?

13 Upvotes

It’s always bothered me how Vina is left behind because she’s “fugly”. Not a very enlightened future ie women judged like “meat” at Mar-a-Lago. I mean look at Shrek - where a human woman turning into a female ogre was the “happy ending“. Is this just mid-1960s beauty standards, misogyny, or part of Roddenberry’s sec obsession? And it’s 2366 - surely surgery could repair a lot of damage for Vina and Capt Pike. And people with even worse disabilities lead happy lives (and Vina’s is basically cosmetic).

Anyway, I’m rewatching all of TOS and finished Menagerie tonight (and Cage a week ago to start) - so this is fresh in my mind. Also having watched 2.5 seasons of SNW I find these episodes more poignant than in previous viewings over the years. I guess from the past bonding of Pike and Spock obviously. I wonder if SNW will go up to the time of the cadet ship accident (I know there’s been foreshadowing of that and Pike knows it’s coming).