r/tolkienfans • • Jun 12 '21

This was my favorite community, but I don't want to be a part of the same old hand-wringing over wokeness that plagues our culture.

78 Upvotes

If you all can't welcome a diversity of opinions and analysis I feel no connection to this community. I'm perfectly aware of the importance of concepts of canon and authors intention but all I see is projection of those concepts to dismiss marginalized people looking for representation in the story. It's popular here to look for the straw men, discussions with topics that seem to embody everything wrong with "wokeness" and then just pile on from there. How am I to trust that people so preoccupied with trying to dismiss other peoples representation don't manifest those feelings in their actual opinion towards minorities? LOTR is seventy years old. The writing isn't changing. There is such an unnecessary hysteria over different people trying to find different things out of the story and I find it highly distasteful. I am going to look for a community where people have the same wonderful in-depth analysis and actual empathy and sensitivity to go with it.


r/tolkienfans • • Dec 13 '25

Harsh unfair take but one reason I never enjoyed the hobbit was the lack of any female characters

3 Upvotes

It is probably unfair but one of the reasons (not the only one) I struggle to like the hobbit is the complete lack of any female character

as a child an not only characters like eowyn and even more like in the Silmarillion luthien, melian, haleth, the valier, nienor, etc... let me feel more part of Tolkien's world, in the hobbit i felt like as a girl I just wasn't part of ghe world.. it was like you are a girl so don't expect to want to be part of this world and story , only biys can enjoy that

also I know people will hate me but the dwarves are my least favorite race . ..


r/tolkienfans • • Dec 04 '23

Someone posted this over in the Ursula K. Le Guin sub

1 Upvotes

https://johnirons.com/pdfs/shadowleguin.pdf

About halfway through this essay, Le Guin talks about LOTR in a way that has me reconsidering one of my thoughts about the book's racism, i.e. that it's both possible and necessary to love LOTR as the great masterwork it is and also frankly face and criticize its racism. I'm not giving up that thought, not yet anyway, but she also suggests at least one additional thought about it.

Comments anyone?


r/tolkienfans • • Dec 24 '23

Are Harry Potter’s similarities with LOTR ever ‘admitted’ to by JK Rowling?

12 Upvotes

Not in a judgemental way, but as we all know there are a great number of similarities in the two stories:

  • Mirkwood & Forbidden Forest;

  • Said forests being the home of spiders;

  • Shelob & Aragog;

  • Gandalf & Dumbledore;

  • Wormtongue & Wormtail;

  • Dementors & Nazgul;

  • Longbottom Leaf & Neville Longbottom;

  • Etc;

Has JK Rowling ever mentioned a direct inspiration in Tolkien’s works or is it just implied?


r/tolkienfans • • Dec 29 '24

When Melkor is cast out, does it resonate with anyone else the parallel of Lucifer being cast out?

10 Upvotes

Also the name cbanges: Melkor.to Morgoth, Lucifer to Satan...lots od other stuff too....


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 13 '24

Why wasnt Frodo escorted from the Shire to Rivendell with the ring?

2 Upvotes

Gandalf knew he had the one ring, its a pretty big deal, anything could happen to Frodo on the way there, why not wait from someone to come to the shire to take him the whole way? Maybe Aragorn and some rangers if Gandalf was busy, or some elves.


r/tolkienfans • • Oct 12 '22

Tokien really hated Men

1 Upvotes

I know that the "Gift of Men" is to be able die and rest. But in light of what the elves get... that seems far too esoteric to be useful.

While elves are burdened by the passing of time, eventually Eru will remake the work and make it whole again... which means elves won't be burdened by decay any more..... that seems like it negates any "gift" from dying. Especially considering men will be called forth to help banish evil once and for all.

So... men basically are just.... dogs? Useful tools? Fun to have around, but... oh well, they die.

Or am I wrong about Tolkien's end of times?

Also, why give elves so much physical ability? I understand that the elves might be less prone to disease and quicker to heal, and light enough to run over snow.

That all makes sense with elves being born under "starlight". They are eternal, yet ephemeral. Largely unbroken and unchanged by time.

Since men were born under the "sun", shouldn't they be like the sun? At dawn, they are weak, but at their apex, they are powerful and strong, outperforming the stars. Then old age hits and they fade away, otherwise dusk.

Meanwhile the stars are still present, shining before the sun and after. They are not as strong as men at their prime, but their strength endures.

I know this question has been posed in different ways before, but I couldn't find a post discussing the sun/stare comparison.

Honestly, the easiest explanation for me would be... Plot. Tolkien's world is full of men, and few elves. The men can't be too strong, or else the story would have no stakes. Following that train, in order for the elves to exhibit an otherworldly quality, that is shown by physical superiority. Is this plot contrivance the best explanation for why elves get to be immortal demigods superior to men at every turn, while men get to well.... die?


r/tolkienfans • • Nov 04 '25

Exploring Gender and Space in Middle-earth - Looking for Tolkien Readers to Share Their Insights

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m Sarah, an undergraduate student at university, and I’m currently conducting research for my dissertation titled: “Gendered Geographies of Middle-earth: Spatial Transgression and Female Agency.”

This project explores how gender and space are constructed in The Lord of the Rings, looking at how characters such as Galadriel, Arwen, and Éowyn navigate or are restricted by Middle-earth’s gendered geography.

My analysis considers both Tolkien’s texts and Peter Jackson’s film adaptations, but I want to emphasise that I’m not comparing them in terms of faithfulness or quality. Instead, I’m interested in how the representation of mobility and gendered space differs between the two mediums - for example, how Éowyn’s movement into the battlefield or Arwen’s expanded role might reflect different ideas about agency and femininity.

I completely understand this subreddit’s focus on Tolkien’s writings and preference against general adaptation debate, and I won’t be discussing or debating the films here in the comments - I’m just looking for participants who have engaged with preferably both versions and would like to share their thoughts privately. I just thought this community might include readers whose insight into Tolkien’s world would make for particularly thoughtful interviews. However, if anyone knows of another subreddit where this kind of academic project might be more appropriate, I’d be really grateful for recommendations.

About the interview:

  • Conducted online (via video, but no need for cameras to be on if you’re not comfortable)

  • Lasts around 30–45 minutes

  • Focuses on how you interpret gender, space, and power in Tolkien’s world 

  • Completely voluntary and anonymous - you can skip any question or stop at any time

  • All data will be kept confidential and used only for this dissertation project

If you’re interested (or would like more details before deciding), please comment below or message me privately, and I’ll share the information sheet and consent form.

Thank you!


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 10 '26

"Why, I feel all thin, sort of stretched, if you know what I mean: like butter that has been scraped over too much bread." What was Bilbo feeling in terms of fëa and hröa?

2 Upvotes

What would the "butter" be and what the "bread"? The scraper would be the ring I assume.

(As an aside: 'Has been scraped'. The past sense seems to be relevant. You don't feel the thinning and the stretching - you feel the result of them, and you are the result. You can't fight the scraping, nor see it coming; you just helplessly suffer its effect)


r/tolkienfans • • Feb 24 '24

verilybitchie’s new video

9 Upvotes

It’s called “The Queer History of the Lord of the Rings” and about half way through she discusses some stuff about Lang’s coloured Fairy Books and the timeline of Tolkien possibly being inspired by them whilst writing a lecture on Lang in 1939.

I didn’t know about any of it so came here to verify:

  • was Tolkien significantly inspired by Lang’s Fairy Books? And If so, was that well known?

  • if he apparently read these tales as a child then did the tale about “the dragon of the north” inspire the hobbit?

  • but mostly: could Eowyn potentially have been inspired by the specific trans-related “Prince Charming” fairy tale?

I’m no Tolkien expert so I can’t verify much they say, but they’re not claiming to be an authority either, just presenting what seem to be their own theories on some inspirations, and it’s all interesting stuff.

I’ve tried Googling my questions and found stuff about the lecture but not much else, but can’t claim to have been all that thorough.

More than that though the idea that Eowyn was inspired by one of Lang’s fairytales was presented as though it was a new idea of their own. Was it? Because it sounded very convincing.

It seemed a good video/essay. I’m not doubting the person, just the medium of video essays in general.


r/tolkienfans • • Feb 20 '23

what would you think if HarperCollins did to The Hobbit what Penguin did to Roald Dahl's books...?

1 Upvotes

I'm not saying this is going to happen... but Penguin is a big publisher and with the agreement of the Dahl Estate, they've rewritten Dahl's children books to remove all offending comments, etc.

I know there as been an outcry, but I wonder if there hadn't been, or if this becomes a trend with older children's books, do you think HarperCollins/Tolkien Estate would be willing to do the same to The Hobbit (which is a children books at the end of the day)?


r/tolkienfans • • Aug 12 '26

New gen readers

3 Upvotes

Some new gen readers seem to forget that Tolkien is the one who made fantasy what it is today, and it's impossible for anyone to replace him. I see some of them insulting Tolkien. Even if you don't like Tolkien, at least show him some respect because no one will ever reach, or even come close to, this man's level of intellect. Not George R.R. Martin, not Robert Jordan, no writer can ever reach Tolkien's genius. I personally have had a love for Tolkien since childhood. I grew up on his books, man. Even my personality has been influenced by his writing. Ultimately, fantasy is an ocean, and there's everything you might like, but Tolkien is the one who sets the waves in motion.


r/tolkienfans • • Feb 12 '24

Why do they say that The Hobbit is a children's book?

2 Upvotes

Spoilers ahead for those that haven't read The Hobbit yet.

So I've just started my journey through Tolkien's work by beginning to read The Hobbit - most people suggest this is the best place to start due the accessibility of the book as it is written as a 'children's' book.

However, I'm currently reading Chapter IV: Over Hill and Under Hill and I've just come across the section where the group gets taken by the goblins and the goblins have just eaten the ponies?

Combined with the bit earlier in the story where the group discovers The Troll's cave, with the clothes of their victims hanging up, this story has darkened quite quickly from the opening chapter.

The way people spoke about this book to me was that it's a classic children's story of a hero slaying the dragon and saving the day kind of thing - not one of goblins devouring ponies in dark caves.

I'm not complaining, I'm just surprised!


r/tolkienfans • • Jan 27 '23

Lack of female characters

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone ! I'm new to Tolkien's world and stuff ( i watched the movies when inwas a kid) and came again to middle earth and already finished the book trilogy. But I started to wonder the lack of female characters. We have only 3 . Love galadriel and Eowyn , but Arwen seems so distant. What do tou gyys think ? Sorry for bad english


r/tolkienfans • • Aug 11 '25

Irritated by a passage in NoME

0 Upvotes

Reading NoME, a lot of interesting things stood out, but one of the strangest was this: 

“First Elves. Awoke at ontavalië [‘puberty’] ([males] 21/[females] 18). But they did not turn to marriage until maturity of the elf-man (24), the elf-woman then being 21. These ages were ever after held the earliest suitable ages for marriage, though elf-women were sometimes married earlier. (As soon as they were 18 they were sought in betrothal – a period which, whenever entered, usually lasted 3 years.)” (NoME, p. 121) 

Two things: 

What does “puberty” mean, in this context? Clearly something before “maturity”, that is, before coming of age. But is there a more specific definition? 

I’m not a fan of the idea of women being “sought in betrothal” “[a]s soon as they were 18”. That is very early, and such relationships would probably have started before age 18 in order to develop to the point of betrothal at 18. 

Really, I don’t like this passage much. I much prefer (as usual) LACE, which feels much more egalitarian. 

Source: The Nature of Middle-earth, JRR Tolkien, ed Carl F Hostetter, HarperCollins 2021 (hardcover) [cited as: NoME]. Highlights (bold) mine.


r/tolkienfans • • Feb 28 '13

What I do as a Tolkien fan...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
18 Upvotes

r/tolkienfans • • Apr 08 '23

Are the Elves Androgynous?

10 Upvotes

Tolkien’s Elves – both male and female – tend to be depicted in a certain way: tall, slender, beautiful, beardless, and with no significant sexual dimorphism in general (sexual dimorphism refers to the physical differences between male and female members of a species, such as size).

I have already written at length about male Elves wearing their hair long in the same way as female Elves do (https://www.reddit.com/r/tolkienfans/comments/x8arb5/hairstyles_and_hair_length_of_elves_and_men_in/). But I was interested in whether Elves are in fact as androgynous as they are depicted, and particularly in the differences between male Elves and men.

Beauty

One of the first things you are taught when you learn English as a foreign language is that “beautiful” the adjective used for women, while “handsome” is used for men. I was specifically taught not to use “beautiful” to describe men.

However, this is different for Elves in the Legendarium. Both male and female Elves are generally described as “beautiful” and “fair” (apart from Nerdanel, that is, who “was not among the fairest of her people”, HoME X, p. 272). Of course Lúthien, Idril, Aredhel and Galadriel are repeatedly described as beautiful.

But male Elves are also called “beautiful” and “fair”, rather than “handsome”. (The word “handsome” doesn’t appear at all in the Silmarillion and is never used for Elves in LOTR.)

Here’s a list of some descriptions of male Elves as “beautiful” or “fair”:

  • Maedhros: “he was of beautiful bodily form” (HoME XII, p. 353).

  • Fëanor: “He was tall, and fair of face, and masterful, his eyes piercingly bright and his hair raven-dark; in the pursuit of all his purposes eager and steadfast.” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 6)

  • Finrod Felagund: “Finrod was like his father in his fair face and golden hair” (HoME XII, p. 337).

  • The epithet of Celegorm the Fair may refer to his looks (see my discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/tolkienfans/comments/y4md1w/cheatsheet_the_house_of_finwë_in_valinor/).

  • Celeborn: “Very tall they were, and the Lady no less tall than the Lord; and they were grave and beautiful.” (LOTR, p. 354)

(Túrin is also described as beautiful: “dark-haired and pale-skinned, with grey eyes, and his face more beautiful than any other among mortal Men, in the Elder Days”: The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 21. Túrin took after his mother Morwen, who had been the “proudest and most beautiful of mortal women in the days of old”, The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 22 – and Morwen was called “Eledhwen”, because she was so like an Elf, implying that her son, who is so much like her, is also quite Elf-like.)

No beards

Male Elves generally have no beards, just like female Elves (meanwhile, both male and female Dwarves have beards, see below).

  • In a very late text (1972–1973), Tolkien wrote: “This [lack of beards], I said, I supposed not to be due to any custom of shaving, but a racial characteristic. None of the Eldar had any beards, and this was a general racial characteristic of all Elves in my ‘world’.” (NoME, p. 187)

  • Some years earlier, Tolkien had written that “Elves did not have beards until they entered the third cycle of life. Nerdanel’s father […] was exceptional, being only early in his second.” (NoME, p. 189, fn. 2)

Whichever it is (Elves generally never grown beards, or Elves generally only ever grow beards when very old), beards aren’t generally part of the physical characteristics of male Elves.

Voices

There doesn’t seem to be a large difference between the voices of male and female Elves. Elven voices are clear, fair and musical, and the only Elf who is noted for their deep voice is Galadriel – none of the male Elves are said to have deep voices.

  • Galadriel’s voice: “Her voice was clear and musical, but deeper than woman’s wont.” (LOTR, p. 355) (As for why Galadriel’s voice is surprisingly deep for a woman, I have a not very serious theory for you: bbc.com/worklife/article/20180612-the-reasons-why-womens-voices-are-deeper-today.)

  • Glorfindel’s voice: “His speech and clear ringing voice left no doubt in their hearts: the rider was of the Elven-folk. No others that dwelt in the wide world had voices so fair to hear.” (LOTR, p. 209)

  • Fingon’s voice: “and his voice, strong and sweet, rang in the mournful hollows that had never heard before aught save cried of fear and woe” (HoME V, p. 251).

(In the earliest version of the Fall of Gondolin, the Elves have clearly never heard the voice of a Man like Tuor: “Then all who listened grew silent, and [Tuor’s] deep and rolling voice held them in amaze, for their own voices were fair as the plash of fountains.” (FoG, The Original Tale, p. 54) However, this is a very early text and the Elves were more “fairylike” at the time.)

Height

In general, the Elves, or at least the Noldor, were quite tall, both male Elves and female Elves.

  • In Appendix F we are told that the Eldar “were tall, fair of skin and grey-eyed, though their locks were dark, save in the golden house of Finarfin; and their voices had more melodies than any mortal voice that now is heard.” (LOTR, p. 1137, fn omitted) A footnote specifies that this physical description “in fact applied only to the Noldor”, referring to HoME I (LOTR, p. 1137, fn. 1). Concerning this mix-up, Christopher Tolkien states: “Thus these words describing characters of face and hair were actually written of the Noldor only, and not of all the Eldar: indeed the Vanyar had golden hair […]. But I am unable to determine how this extraordinary perversion of meaning arose.” (HoME I, p. 44). Still, the Noldor at least were tall, and we see Vanyarin and Sindarin Elves being described as tall as well.

  • “Fingolfin was his father’s son, tall, dark, and proud, as were most of the Ñoldor” (HoME XII, p. 336).

  • Fëanor: “He was tall, and fair of face, and masterful, his eyes piercingly bright and his hair raven-dark; in the pursuit of all his purposes eager and steadfast.” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 6)

  • Maedhros is known as “the tall” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 5).

  • Indis is “golden-haired and tall, and in all ways unlike Míriel” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 6).

  • Turgon: “tallest of all the Children of the World, save Thingol” (UT, p. 74).

  • Aredhel: “when she was grown to full stature and beauty she was tall and strong, and loved to ride and hunt in the forests.” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 5)

  • Galadriel and Celeborn: “Very tall they were, and the Lady no less tall than the Lord; and they were grave and beautiful.” (LOTR, The Mirror of Galadriel, p. 354). Galadriel is “the tallest of all the women of the Eldar of whom tales tell” (UT, p. 370).

However, it appears that male Elves were generally taller than female Elves, Galadriel (a Noldo who had seen the Trees) and Celeborn (a Sinda, but whose name means either “Silver-Tall” or “Silver-Tree”, https://www.elfdict.com/w/celeborn/s?include_old=1, both of which refer to his height) notwithstanding: “The Ouendi were in origin a tall people. The Eldar were those who accepted the invitation of the Valar to remove from Middle-earth and set forth on the Great March to the Western Shores of Middle-earth.

They were in general the stronger and taller members of the Elvish folk at that time. In Eldarin tradition it was said that even their women were seldom less than 6 ft. in height; their full-grown elfmen no less than 6 ft. 6, while some of the great kings and leaders were taller.” (NoME, p. 194)

Strength

Elves tend to be strong and fast, both male and female Elves:

  • “Indeed in dire straits or desperate defence, the nissi fought valiantly, and there was less difference in strength and speed between elven-men and elven-women that had not borne child than is seen among mortals.” (HoME X, p. 213) So LACE tells us that there is lower sexual dimorphism between male and female Elves (who haven’t had children yet) than between men and women.

  • Indis “was golden-haired, and tall, and exceedingly swift of foot” (HoME X, p. 237).

  • Aredhel: “when she was grown to full stature in beauty she was tall and strong, and loved much to ride and hunt in the forests.” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 5)

  • And strength was clearly prized, so much so that Elves named their children for their physical strength: Celegorm’s father-name is “Turkafinwë ‘strong, powerful (in body)’” (HoME XII, p. 352).

But it appears that even the strongest male Elves are less strong than the strongest Men:

  • Fingon would certainly be strong for an Elf, being a prince of the Noldor who had seen the Trees, the older brother of “tall and strong” Aredhel, and known for his physical feats of daring; he seems to effortlessly duel Gothmog, who had just thrust Turgon and Húrin aside, and only dies because he’s attacked from behind by another Balrog during the duel: “Gothmog, Lord of Balrogs, high-captain of Angband, was come; and he drove a dark wedge between the Elvenhosts, surrounding King Fingon, and thrusting Turgon and Húrin aside towards the Fen of Serech. Then he turned upon Fingon. That was a grim meeting. At last Fingon stood alone with his guard dead about him; and he fought with Gothmog, until another Balrog came behind and cast a thong of fire about him.” (The Silmarillion, Quenta Silmarillion, ch. 20)

  • However, when Maedhros gives Fingon the Dragon-helm, one of apparently many gifts exchanged between them, Fingon finds it too heavy to wear, while the strongest men in Hithlum are able to use it: “But in all Hithlum no head and shoulders were found stout enough to bear the dwarf-helm with ease, save those of Hador and his son Galdor.” (UT, p. 98) “Húrin did not wear the Dragon-helm with ease” either (UT, p. 98), but Túrin would of course later wear it and become famous for it. Túrin, grandson of Galdor, is of course one of the strongest Men in the Legendarium: “The blade scored it with a dreadful gash, but those hideous folds could not be pierced by any strength of men, not though Elf or Dwarf should forge the steel or the hand of Beren or of Túrin wield it.” (LOTR, p. 728) (Since this statement refers to “strength of men”, we cannot say that this quote proves that the strongest Men are stronger than the strongest Elves and Dwarves.)

The implication is that the strongest Men are stronger than the strongest male Elves.

What does this mean?

We know that both male and female Elves are tall and strong, although male Elves are taller, and that the strength difference between male and female Elves is less than that between men and women. How would this work? Simple: male Elves have less muscle mass than (male) Men, so that male and female Elves of the same height would have similar amounts of muscle mass.

This is also supported by a comment Tolkien made concerning depictions of Legolas. Christopher Tolkien writes that, “Ultimately, of course, the Elves shed all associations and qualities that would be now commonly considered ‘fairylike’, and those who remained in the Great Lands in Ages of the world at this time unconceived were to grow greatly in stature and in power: there was nothing filmy or transparent about the heroic or majestic Eldar of the Third Age of Middle-earth. Long afterwards my father would write, in a wrathtul comment on a ‘pretty’ or ‘ladylike’ pictorial rendering of Legolas: He was tall as a young tree, lithe, immensely strong, able swiftly to draw a great war-bow and shoot down a Nazgûl, endowed with the tremendous vitality of Elvish bodies, so hard and resistant to hurt that he went only in light shoes over rock or through snow, the most tireless of all the Fellowship.” (HoME II, p. 327)

So Legolas was tall and strong, as Elves generally are (see above) – but he was still lithe.

This is also confirmed by Niënor, a young human woman of the House of Hador, easily passing for a male Sindarin soldier: the Elven soldiers of Doriath accompanying Morwen to Nargothrond are “tall”, but Niënor is as tall or taller than most of them: “Tall and strong she seemed; for of great stature were those of Hador’s house, and thus clad in Elvish raiment she matched well with the guards, being smaller only than the greatest among them.” (CoH, p. 202)

A look at the Dwarves

Dwarves also have low (or practically non-existent) sexual dimorphism, but very differently than the Elves.

  • “The Naugrim were ever, as they still remain, short and squat in stature; they were deep-breasted, strong in the arm, and stout in the leg, and their beards were long. Indeed this strangeness they have that no Man nor Elf has ever seen a beardless Dwarf – unless he were shaven in mockery, and would then be more like to die of shame than of many other hurts that to us would seem more deadly.” (HoME XI, p. 205)

  • “It was said by Gimli that there are few dwarf-women, probably no more than a third of the whole people. They seldom walk abroad except at great need. They are in voice and appearance, and in garb if they must go on a journey, so like to the dwarf-men that the eyes and ears of other peoples cannot tell them apart. This has given rise to the foolish opinion among Men that there are no dwarf-women, and that the Dwarves ‘grow out of stone’.” (LOTR, App. A, p. 1080)

  • If that wasn’t clear enough, Tolkien says explicitly that Dwarf-women have beards: “For the Naugrim have beards from the beginning of their lives, male and female alike; not indeed can their womenkind be discerned by those of other race, be it in feature or in gait to in voice, not in any wise save this: that they go not to war and seldom save at direst need issue from their deep bowers and halls.” (HoME XI, p. 205)

Further thoughts

I find it interesting that Tolkien has two races, the Elves and the Dwarves, that are each associated with the sexual characteristics of one sex: the Elves have more feminine or neutral physical characteristics (beardless, beautiful, lithe and with clear voices) and the Dwarves have more masculine physical characteristics (bearded, stout, with deep chests).

Interestingly, both races are strictly monogamous and marry only once in their lives:

  • Elves: “The Eldar wedded once only in life, and for love or at the least by free will upon either part.” (HoME X, p. 210) When Finwë wanted to remarry, the Valar debated this and eventually allowed him to marry Indis, on the condition that Finwë, Indis and Míriel would never be alive at the same time again. Divorce isn’t an option.

  • Dwarves: “For Dwarves take only one wife or husband each in their lives, and are jealous, as in all matters of their rights.” (LOTR, App. A, p. 1080)

Which of course reminded me of this quote: “According to Daly and Wilson, ‘The sexes differ more in human beings than in monogamous mammals, but much less than in extremely polygamous mammals.’” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_dimorphism, fn. 92, referring to the following source: Daly M, Wilson M (1996). “Evolutionary psychology and marital conflict”. In Buss DM, Malamuth NM (eds.), Sex, Power, Conflict: Evolutionary and Feminist Perspectives, Oxford University Press, p. 13.)

There seems to be a connection between strict monogamy and low sexual dimorphism. Is this what Tolkien had in mind? Very unlikely, but I still find it interesting.

So yes, Elves are androgynous, and there is less of a physical difference (in size, strength, voice etc.) between male and female Elves than between men and women. In general, and I know that this might be a bit too scientific, it sounds like male Elves don’t produce as much testosterone as men do, which would explain why they are generally lithe and beardless, why their voices are clear, and why there isn’t much of a strength difference between male and female Elves.

Sources:

  • The Lord of the Rings, JRR Tolkien, HarperCollins 2007 (softcover) [cited as: LOTR].

  • The Silmarillion, JRR Tolkien, ed Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins, ebook edition February 2011, version 2019-01-09 [cited as: The Silmarillion].

  • Unfinished Tales of Númenor & Middle-earth, JRR Tolkien, ed Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2014 (softcover) [cited as: UT].

  • The Children of Húrin, JRR Tolkien, ed Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2014 (softcover) [cited as: CoH].

  • The Fall of Gondolin, JRR Tolkien, ed Christopher Tolkien, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt 2018 (hardcover) [cited as: FoG].

  • The Book of Lost Tales Part One, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME I].

  • The Book of Lost Tales Part Two, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME II].

  • The Lost Road and Other Writings, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME V].

  • Morgoth’s Ring, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME X].

  • The War of the Jewels, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME XI].

  • The Peoples of Middle-earth, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME XII].

  • The Nature of Middle-earth, JRR Tolkien, ed Carl F Hostetter, HarperCollins 2021 (hardcover) [cited as: NoME].


r/tolkienfans • • Jan 15 '25

Questions about the Valars’ gender

0 Upvotes

I’m currently re-reading The Silmarillion and I have some questions regarding to the origins of the Valars’ gender after reading this excerpt:

”When they desire to clothe themselves the Valar take upon them forms some as of male and some as of female; for that difference of temper they had even from their beginning, and it is but bodied forth in the choice of each, not made by the choice”

If this excerpt means that the result of the Valar being male or female is based on their natural temper and personality traits, does that mean they have no gender/biological sex before they enter Arda? So plenty of gender studies believe that biological sex has been heavily affecting one’s gender identity/roles. So does it happen in the other way for the Valar, that their gender traits (the features that make them more masculine or feminine) affects their ultimate sex?

Secondly, if it is true that they have no genders in the very beginning, would this setting become paradoxical with the origins of Melkor and Manwe, because Melkor and Manwe have been long before referred as a “he”, and it is stated already they are twin brothers before Arda is even created. Ulmo and Aule are too already referred as males before they enter Arda.

Maybe I miss something when I was reading this part. For the involvement of gender studies, I’m currently studying a course related to gender and that’s why this question comes to me when I read The Silmarillion. I known it’s fiction and gender issues is never the point of the story, but it makes me wonder more about the relations of gender and sex in real life. I hope someone could give me some answers regarding to this questions.


r/tolkienfans • • Aug 07 '24

There is so little description in the Hobbit

5 Upvotes

Just got halfway through reading the book, and I am enjoying the read. However, one issue I do have is that there is hardly any description of anything that is told to you, such as the creatures. This became a specific issue with the trolls and the introduction to the elves which hardly had anything to describe about them to the point where you couldnt really imagine any form of a silhouette. I think that at least basic three sentence description of what you are looking at would have gone a long way.


r/tolkienfans • • Sep 13 '24 Helpful

The Valar are incompetent

4 Upvotes

A very basic idea, but one which has been brewing in my mind for a while. I know Tolkien said somewhere that we should be careful not to blaspheme the Valar and question their decisions, but I can't help it. They had one job. They were sent to the world to make sure things run smoothly, to guide and protect the children of Eru, and to govern the world in Eru's stead until the Children were ready to govern the world themselves. And they failed to accomplish almost all of that. First of all, they did the best they could to separate the Children, requiring the Elves to come to Aman whilst the Men remained in Middle-Earth. The only reason elves ended up in Middle-Earth at all was because they disobeyed the Valar and actually decided to do something about Morgoth (a Vala) taking over the entire world which Eru created whilst the Valar walled themselves off in a separate continent. The Valar consistently failed to stop Morgoth from conquering and destroying the world for thousands of years, until finally Earendil begged them to do their job and help the elves out. They did (and only for the Elves' sake, by the way, as they never cared at all about men). But after that, they once again completely checked out of protecting Arda and walled themselves off again in Valinor. Whilst several dragons, at least one Balrog, and a very powerful evil Maia (Sauron) wreaked havoc on the Children throughout the second age, they did nothing. Thanks to a miracle (not from them, but from Eru) the Children against all odds managed to defeat Sauron, though only after he caused the destruction of the greatest civilization men ever wrought, Numenor, whilst the Valar did, as always, nothing to stop him. And throughout the Third Age, as Sauron grew in strength and almost conquered the whole world again, the Valar were kind enough to send a few old men who had severe limitations placed on what they could do to help. One of those Maia actually ended up turning against the Free Peoples and allying with the Dark Lord. Only one of the Five Wizards, the only help the Valar ever sent, ended up actually helping the Children. So, effectually, the total help the Valar ever provided in the whole of the Second and Third Ages was a single not particularly powerful Maia, plus a Maia who ended up actually making things worse, and a few Maia who didn't do anything, kind of like the Valar themselves. And even in the First Age, when they were a little more present, it still took them a couple thousand years to do anything, plus they actively worked against unity between Men and Elves. Not to mention the fact that they never did anything whatsoever for men, as they didn't seem to like them particularly well. I'm almost convinced that them fading further from Middle-Earth in the Fourth Age is actually a good thing for Middle-Earth and its inhabitants. Of course, there are a few minor exceptions, such as Frodo's invocation of Elbereth Gilthoniel against Shelob, but those are few and far between. Rant over. Correct me if I got any of the facts wrong.


r/tolkienfans • • Jan 10 '24

Yes, Morgoth is literally Satan - proof from Tolkien's own words

14 Upvotes

When I speak about the Legendarium with someone, I take a certain liberty to refer to Morgoth as "Satan" in order to simplify for a person I'm talking to. A few times, including a presentation I made for the class, I also call him "Devil" or "Satan of Tolkien's mythology" a lot, again, in order to simplify for others.

However, there are a lot of people who'd say that is incorrect.

"Tolkien's works aren't Christian allegory!"

"Morgoth is inspired by Satan, but he also has traits of X."

"This is oversimplifying!"

And so on. And on the Internet, a lot of the times in the discussions about Morgoth someone will make a comparison with Satan, and people will start speaking about how Tolkien hated allegory, therefore Morgoth can't be Satan.

And, honestly, that's just so incorrect. But let's put aside the painfully obvious similarity in their stories and the fact that they, linguistically, have the same name (Satan - "Enemy, Adversary", Morgoth - "Black Enemy"), let's look at Tolkien's own words on the matter.

In this rare (https://youtu.be/NTz2-im7s9k?si=rjvSWuhJjxsYwyzK) interview he calls him the Devil:

There are in existence a very large collection of legends about the world of the past, particularly after the exiled Elves came back and conducted their war against the Devil in the north-western part of this world we live in.

In a sketch of The Earliest Silmarillion in The Shaping of Middle-earth:

After the despatch of the Nine Valar for the governance of the world Morgoth (Demon of Dark) rebels against the overlordship of Manwe, overthrows the lamps set up to illumine the world, and floods the isle where the Valar (or Gods) dwelt.

Christopher Tolkien in his Commentary on Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth:

Melkor was not just a Local Evil on Earth, or a Guardian Angel of the Earth who had gone wrong: he was the Spirit of Evil, arising even before the making of Eä.

Yes, Morgoth is Satan. He is not an allegory, he is the same character interperted differently through Tolkien's own writings. Saying he is not would be like saying Lucifer in Milton's Paradise Lost is not Satan.

The Sun and Moon in his mythology aren't allegories for our sun and moon, they are the same thing mythologized interperted differently. In the same way, Eru and Morgoth are different interpertations of God and Satan that he made a crucial part of his mythology. They are not new characters, they are the same religious figures looked through a different lens.


r/tolkienfans • • Jul 12 '23

Enjoying Tolkien's works as an atheist

64 Upvotes

I am sorry I can't write a more in-depth post, but I want to go to sleep, as it's 2 a.m.

I have been a Tolkien fan for a very long time. I am actually reading LotR for the fourth time in half a decade. His works have impacted me like no others. I have always wished I could become an individual as impressive as him.

However, I am also an atheist. I don't see religion as something bad, I just think reality is, unfortunately, much more mundane. We are born, we grow up, and we die - and that's it.

Despite that, I still love Tolkien and his works, and I think he was a superb author.

I wonder, what do you think about this? Can you enjoy the piece of literature even if you fundamentally disagree with the author's beliefs to the point he would probably outright reject you? Are there any other atheists here?

I am curious about your opinions.


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 25 '25

Tonal dissonance in the portrayal of Rohan

2 Upvotes

So, I feel that Tolkien's desire to include Anglo-Saxon themes in the portrayal of Rohan got the better of his judgment.

The Lament for the Rohirrim is well-known for drawing influence from the Old English poem The Wanderer:

Where have the horses gone? where are the riders? where is the giver of gold?
Where are the seats of the feast? where are the joys of the hall?

vs.

Where now the horse and the rider? Where is the horn that was blowing?
Where is the helm and the hauberk, and the bright hair flowing?
Where is the hand on the harpstring, and the red fire glowing?
Where is the spring and the harvest and the tall corn growing?

Linguistic and architectural elements are also based on Old English or the Anglo-Saxons. Similar themes of nostalgia and resignation are overrepresented in Old English poetry (The Seafarer, The Ruin) - in very clear contrast to Norse poetry, for example, which leans more towards the heroic and the optimistic (Gothic is too poorly attested but it feels more Norse to me). Given that and the content of the poems, it's reasonable to conclude that the Anglo-Saxons developed this outlook as a consequence of their migration, the conflicts during the 5th to 8th century, and the general feeling of inadequacy when faced with the remnants of Roman architecture.

Both in the Lament for the Rohirrim and in some other exchanges, the people of Rohan show flashes of that Anglo-Saxon morosity, but in the LOTR universe, there isn't much reason for them to be like that. The primary source of feelings of inadequacy and decline would be Numenor, but they're not direct descendents of Numenor (their only relation to Numenor is distant and indirect), don't live close to large and ancient human sites, and don't have much reason to relate strongly to Gondor's decline or the decline of Elves or Dwarves. Their involvement only kicks off deep into the Third Age, too.

Anyway, that's my shower thoughts. Let me know what you think ;-)


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 28 '24

What The Hobbit is about

3 Upvotes

I see behind Bilbo's adventure, a tale for children resting in the comfort of their home. Children who will eventually be thrown into adventure without warning, and will long for the quiet of the parental home.

But along the way they will be accompanied by the divine presence of the father, who will then leave them, only to return again... just as God played hide-and-seek intimately with the author, so with every man; and so with Bilbo did Gandalf, the paternal emissary of the Heights. Though all may seem lost, certain victory awaits in the end, for the father's presence is beyond the clouds of patent hardship, fatherhood has no end. He will always return.

And the frowning hobbit has become a man along the way: he has fought evil, he has served and been served by his companions. With dwarves as with any company. He has acquired for himself a piece of the resolution and wisdom from the Heights.

Indeed, The Hobbit is a story for children: whether they are old or young, it is the kind of story that every father would like to give to his children, to awaken their dormant greatness.