I have two daughters, 4 and 2, and my 4 year old doesn’t respond to any discipline. We have tried:
- getting in their level and talking to them
- explaining how their actions make others feel
- removing them from fun
- taking things away from them
- rewarding good behavior
- immediate corrections
- ignoring things that seem to be to get a reaction/attention
- time outs
- yelling
- spanking
Especially with the spanking, that has only been a handful of times in severe cases, but we don’t like/want to do it because my husband and I believe violence breeds violence. With the yelling, we tried to yell to show her we were serious, but to no avail and so we gave that up. We have tried everything else consistently to give it a fair chance to work, but she still doesn’t take us seriously when we tell her to stop and talks back.
I know that we’re in the middle of a defiant age, developmentally, since there’s so much going on, but this is now starting to rub off on the 2 year old. How do I deal with a child who openly refuses consequences? What strategies have worked for you to correct these problems and stop it before it’s regular for the younger sibling?
**UPDATE**
I apologize if this is not the correct way to do this, as I am still a novice in the Reddit world.
Firstly I want to say THANK YOU to EVERYONE who offered support, suggestions, and words of encouragement. I know I am not a perfect parent, no one is, and the advice I received here has helped tremendously.
After multiple podcasts, purchasing and reading the books mentioned, and doing a lot of self-work, we have had an amazing breakthrough! I spoke with my 4-year-old about what her likes and dislikes are to work out a reward system in order to keep the energy in my home more positive. I have been intentionally dedicating certain times and tasks as “family tasks” like brushing teeth in the morning. My daughters and I made up a silly song to sing as we brush our teeth together, and the only issue is now they have so much fun that they want to brush their teeth 3+ times a day: and let’s be honest, there’s way worse problems to have!
As far as the tempers with both of them turning physical, they have made leaps and bounds! One big contributing factor is that they are officially big cousins! Having a newborn around all the time (we are very close with our extended families) has been a great reminder to use “gentle hands”, as well as setting a good example. We have been working on age-appropriate conflict resolution with both kids. My husband and I are aware - painfully aware - as we both have multiple sisters, that siblings will bicker and it’s normal. Thankfully, we have brought the bickering about anything and everything down, and they have been working on using their words and coming to mom and dad if they can’t work through it (the 4 year old is typically the one asking for assistance of course, but if the 2 year old gets really worked up she typically just wants a hug until she is calm).
Obviously not every day is perfect, and obviously we are not perfect individuals, but I am so proud of my kiddos and myself for the changes we’ve made and stuck to. There’s been trial and error, and we still have opportunities for improvement, but we are light years from where we were. I hope anyone who is in a similar phase of life finds solace in the fact that they’re not alone. Toddlerhood is hard, but with help and encouragement it gets a little less daunting. This phase of life is full of so much stress, joy, and it is fleeting, so once again, thank you for all the helpful tips/tricks/advice that made it feel easier to enjoy the good times and work through the hard times quicker and with more positivity!