r/todayilearned • u/melindarieck • May 13 '19
TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/3.0k
u/JBatjj May 13 '19
Really shows the randomness of evolution
2.6k
u/bertiebees May 13 '19
As long as it let's you live long enough to breed it's good enough!
-Evolution
249
u/C0sm1cB3ar May 13 '19
"Let me shit a few random sequences of DNA and see what happens"
Evolution
208
→ More replies (3)104
u/getbeaverootnabooteh May 13 '19
"I'm really more of a scientific concept than a sentient being who can talk, so attributing quotes to me is a bit ridiculous."
-Evolution
→ More replies (6)101
u/somewhat_pragmatic May 13 '19
Well, evolution, if you didn't want us to anthropomorphize then you shouldn't have evolved humans to the point we could do it.
→ More replies (10)566
u/EverythingSucks12 May 13 '19
How do you explain me then?
1.4k
86
u/khinzaw May 13 '19
As my paleontology professor put it, "survival of the minimally fit." It's why we have pandas.
→ More replies (5)29
u/DPlurker May 13 '19
You're alive and if you don't breed then it's just an evolutionary dead end.
40
u/cecilrt May 13 '19
its a peculiarly fascinating though.... millions of years of fking, ends with you...
→ More replies (15)26
→ More replies (24)5
30
May 13 '19
Like that moth that has no mouth so it starves to death
46
u/Tryoxin May 13 '19
Fun fact: the clothes moth is one of the moth species that has no mouth in its adult form. If you see one in your closet, it already did all its eating as a larva.
→ More replies (2)10
10
→ More replies (7)8
May 13 '19
"All animals are under stringent selection pressure to be as stupid as they can get away with."
- Pete Richardson & Robert Boyd
104
u/beorn12 May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
While there is a randomness factor in evolution, such as the emergence of mutations and the process of genetic drift, natural selection is quite the opposite of random.
In this case, natural selection favored two different random mutations in two different populations of Homo sapiens, to achieve a similar result: adaptability to low oxygen conditions due to high altitude.
17
u/Beerwithjimmbo May 13 '19
You still need the mutation to start the process. Yes of course selection pressures aren't "random" they're fixed for the same population
11
May 13 '19
Yes of course selection pressures aren't "random" they're fixed for the same population
Its important to point this out, its a very misunderstood part of the theory of evolution.
→ More replies (9)74
u/yawkat May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
Natural selection is still very random. It just balances out with large populations.
In fact, evolution is an emergent property from the randomness of natural selection. There are non-random ways to get Evolution, such as science (developing medicine is more reliable than gaining resistance through natural selection)
e: Okay, I think some people have a fundamental difference in understanding in what constitutes "randomness". In probability theory, we have a concept of random variables. These variables can be correlated or depend on other variables. "Random" does not mean "completely independent of the environment".
23
u/Hryggja May 13 '19
Natural selection is still very random. It just balances out with large populations.
In fact, evolution is an emergent property from the randomness of natural selection.
There are non-random ways to get Evolution, such as science (developing medicine is more reliable than gaining resistance through natural selection)
There is so much armchair genetics in this thread it’s making my head spin.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (45)36
u/beorn12 May 13 '19
Again, natural selection is non-random. It doesn't mean it has a purpose, goal, or direction, but it is exactly non-random. Evolutionary Biologist Richard Dawkins explains it thus:
"Darwinian natural selection can produce an uncanny illusion of design. An engineer would be hard put to decide whether a bird or a plane was the more aerodynamically elegant.
So powerful is the illusion of design, it took humanity until the mid-19th century to realize that it is an illusion. In 1859, Charles Darwin announced one of the greatest ideas ever to occur to a human mind: cumulative evolution by natural selection. Living complexity is indeed orders of magnitude too improbable to have come about by chance. But only if we assume that all the luck has to come in one fell swoop. When cascades of small chance steps accumulate, you can reach prodigious heights of adaptive complexity. That cumulative build-up is evolution. Its guiding force is natural selection.
Every living creature has ancestors, but only a fraction have descendants. All inherit the genes of an unbroken sequence of successful ancestors, none of whom died young and none of whom failed to reproduce. Genes that program embryos to develop into adults who can successfully reproduce automatically survive in the gene pool, at the expense of genes that fail. This is natural selection at the gene level, and we notice its consequences at the organism level. There has to be an ultimate source of new genetic variation, and it is mutation. Copies of newly mutated genes are reshuffled through the gene pool by sexual reproduction, and selection removes them from the pool in a way that is non-random.
What makes for success in the business of life varies from species to species. Some swim, some walk, some fly, some climb, some root themselves into the soil and tilt green solar panels toward the sun. All this diversity stems from successive branchings, starting from a single bacterium-like ancestor, which lived between 3 and 4 billion years ago. Each branching event is called a speciation: a breeding population splits into two, and they go their separately evolving ways. Among sexually reproducing species, speciation is said to have occurred when the two gene pools have separated so far that they can no longer interbreed. Speciation begins by accident. When separation has reached the stage where there is no interbreeding even without a geographical barrier, we have the origin of a new species.
Natural selection is quintessentially non-random, yet it is lamentably often miscalled random. This one mistake underlies much of the skeptical backlash against evolution. Chance cannot explain life. Design is as bad an explanation as chance because it raises bigger questions than it answers. Evolution by natural selection is the only workable theory ever proposed that is capable of explaining life, and it does so brilliantly."
→ More replies (14)12
2
2
u/no-mad May 13 '19
A “superathlete” gene that helps Sherpas and other Tibetans breathe easy at high altitudes was inherited from an ancient species of human. That’s the conclusion of a new study, which finds that the gene variant came from people known as Denisovans, who went extinct soon after they mated with the ancestors of Europeans and Asians about 40,000 years ago. This is the first time a version of a gene acquired from interbreeding with another type of human has been shown to help modern humans adapt to their environment.
4
u/GReggzz732 May 13 '19
But it isn't random. Evolution to adapt under certain circumstances requires centuries of build.
3
u/paracelsus23 May 13 '19
You're debating semantics.
The phrase I was taught was "random mutation with natural selection".
The point OP is making is that while the needs are the same, the mutations are completely random. Natural selection will favor any human that has increased oxygen transport ability - it doesn't care how or why.
In one population, random mutations caused a certain change in anatomy which proved advantageous. In a different population, random mutations led to a completely different change in anatomy emerging. Both solved the same problem.
But, the human body did not "decide" to evolve a certain way. It was all the result of random mutations to our genome.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (58)3
u/Kangarooskan May 13 '19
Is it evolution or adaptation?
26
u/jake123NTG May 13 '19
Evolution, it happened over many many generations of people. I understand the confusion, but think of evolution as adaptation of an entire species to any given environmental influences over generations vs the adaptation of an individual to their surroundings during that single generation.
→ More replies (1)
476
u/panzerkampfwagen 115 May 13 '19
Yeah, because evolution doesn't plan ahead, it just uses whatever arises.
171
u/Memetic1 May 13 '19
Given the abundance of Carbon on Earth, and the comparative strengths of a bone made from graphene vs. calcium it's pretty clear evolutionary valleys seem to be the rule instead of the exception.
129
u/thedugong May 13 '19
That's only one metric for graphene vs calcium though.
Maybe using graphene for a skeleton/proto-skeleton/shell is simply more energy intensive than calcium so all the graphene based organisms got out competed?
130
u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19
Carbon alone is almost impossible to work with as an organism- it's insoluble in water, very reactive around things like rubisco, and the limitations of proteomic transcription and enzymes mean you can't just "print" sheets of joined up atoms. The biochemistry of life on earth is not suited to using raw carbon, it always has to be in a larger molecule. Besides, a sheet of graphene would be immensely destructive to a cell- it'd be like an unbreakable molecular knife slicing membranes to bits!
28
May 13 '19
Graphene bone breaks would be a problem, broken bones are really sharp, I am not sure you could even fix a broken leg safely made of graphene based materials by hand.
→ More replies (2)24
u/Memetic1 May 13 '19
That's true which is why this is an example of a valley in the evolution landscape. A better solution exists, but evolution had to develop a way to find it.
→ More replies (5)35
u/jokul May 13 '19
is there a way for the body to actually metabolize a graphene bone?
31
u/Memetic1 May 13 '19
Well it's just carbon, and we've seen nature take advantage of structures at that scale. So yeah maybe if evolution had went slightly different instead of calcium shells it might have been graphene. As for handling the stuff now. Well we don't even have a complete MSDS sheet. So even though I've been tempted I haven't ordered any graphene myself. To tell you the truth the fact that it's so potentially useful, but with unknown concequnces for the environment, and human health that combination makes me nervous. That's the sort of situation that breeds coverups.
→ More replies (14)10
u/TracyMorganFreeman May 13 '19
Most of the carbon is not in graphene form though. It's the center of hydrocarbons and proteins.
→ More replies (4)3
u/smapti May 13 '19
I don’t disagree with you but carbon is in the top 5 most abundant elements in the universe, I don’t think we can use its commonality as a variable in the evolution equation.
3
u/SparkyDogPants May 13 '19
Bones have to be soft though, not just strong. Especially children’s bones are not hard at all.
0
49
u/Titzleb May 13 '19
Evolution doesn’t “do” anything. Evolution is what we call the outcome of generations of humans with genetically advantageous traits surviving and thriving. Not knocking you or your comment, just piggybacking lol
→ More replies (7)8
u/ImadeAnAkount4This May 13 '19
Sometimes it gives you a random 6th toe, and sometimes it lets you survive a nuclear blast. If that 6th toe is a sign of fertility in a culture and the guy who has ever the ability to survive a nuclear blast has no ability to bread, then we will lose the far more useful ability and gain a useless one.
→ More replies (1)
215
u/anadem May 13 '19
Interesting find of Denisovan bones on the Tibetan plateau "suggests that these Denisovans may have evolved genetic adaptations to high altitudes, and that living Tibetans may have inherited those genes"
The Denisovan bones were 160,000 years old.
→ More replies (1)85
u/kkokk May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
Even cooler is that intersubspecies hybrids existed before humans migrated to Eurasia.
The hybrid person had a Denisovan father and a neanderthal mother, which means that in a way, they were actually less mixed than modern people today (outside of Africa anyway)
Dude was basically Genghis'ing the west before Genghis's balls dropped
→ More replies (13)12
u/lordponte May 13 '19
Huh...I might be the Denisovan and Neanderthal mix! There are a few reasons why I think this....maybe it’s this inability to finish school in four years, or my hideousness! Idk! My heart and blood are good tho, according to my doc.
14
u/PM_ME_SHIHTZU_PICS May 13 '19
Bold move cracking a joke around all the scholars in here. I liked it, but I also want to see how it plays out for you.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)18
u/kkokk May 13 '19
there is basically no Denisovan ancestry today outside of Oceania. Neanderthal ancestry is about 3% in all non-Africans.
150
u/trai_dep 1 May 13 '19
Alternate explanation: Incan gods preferred big, meaty hearts to be sacrificed for them.
22
u/Tykuo May 13 '19
Incas were not doing sacrifices this way. You are mistaking with the Aztecs
5
u/joeybaby106 May 13 '19
Yes Incas prefer to send their kids up freezing mountains to be sacrificed.
2
u/supervitis May 13 '19
Actually, by the logic of evolution this would be counterproductive. If the selected sacrifices would be the ones with a bigger heart, then the smaller heart genes would be the ones transmitted to the next generation. Meaning hearts would become smaller and smaller, on average.
4
u/kaukamieli May 13 '19
Ah, but if the said gods were real, they'd guide things to their liking. Gotta keep up with the premise.
2
66
u/rider037 May 13 '19
Yeah if a person had all of those I bet they'd be a great long distance runner
54
u/southsideson May 13 '19
I wonder what sort of adaptations the Tarahumara people have. They're a pretty poor group of mexicans that live in the hills, but they're world class long distance runners. I can't find the article, and am not sure if I am getting everything quite correct, but someone brought them to some world class ultramarathon, and they basically ran it in sandals and bathrobes and were blowing everyone away. Some claim they can run 400 miles with only taking short rest breaks for eating.
→ More replies (1)11
u/thegrayhairedrace May 13 '19
Pretty sure this is the TED talk version of the paper you're talking about.
It's one of my favorites.
30
→ More replies (1)2
u/pm_me_ur_big_balls May 13 '19
...assuming the adaptation even works at lower latitudes.
If it did, that gene would have propagated to everyone by now. There must be a trade-off.
90
u/black_flag_4ever May 13 '19
And me. I gain weight just looking at cake.
→ More replies (3)88
May 13 '19
Youll survive a famine for longer
→ More replies (1)138
u/getbeaverootnabooteh May 13 '19
During the great famine of 2030, u/black_flag_4ever was one of the only survivors, due to his ability to obtain sufficient nourishment to survive by simply looking at photographs of cakes. Since the famine, his offspring, carrying his efficient fat-gaining genes, have populated the earth.
39
9
u/NeinJuanJuan May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
pigments begin to bubble, evaporate, and float ghostlike into u/black_flag_4ever's nostrils as he stares into the darkening image of what was once a Frozen 'Elsa' cake, now.. fading to black
Beep! Beep! Beep! a warning alarm sounds and the screen reads three words: Replace. Drum. Cartridge.
→ More replies (1)
34
u/Memetic1 May 13 '19
So if we combined all 3 mutations we could go into space!!!🙃 I do wonder if anyone naturally has 2 of those 3 mutations?
9
u/radditor5 May 13 '19
Stop trying to make space mutants!
8
u/Memetic1 May 13 '19
But we could take the genes that the allow fungus in Chernobyl to eat radiation,https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiotrophic_fungus and maybe put them in ourselves. I want to be photosynthetic / radiotrophic damn it! Coincidentally they use the same protein to get energy from radiation that colors our skin. So if we could do that then the future of humankind is dark skin. Just imagine it how much easier it would be to do space travel if radiation could help supliment people's diets. Not to mention it could help people survive the coming food crisis that is going to be caused by climate change.
→ More replies (8)14
6
May 13 '19
I think it's funny that in a time when biologists won't shut up about convergent evolution, people get surprised to hear of cases of just plain old, regular, non-convergent adaption.
2
May 13 '19
This sounds convergent to me, right?
In evolutionary biology, convergent evolution is the process whereby organisms [...] evolve similar traits as a result of having to adapt to similar environments or ecological niches.
Two different populations evolving to attack the same environmental problem (high altitudes with little oxygen) by evolving a similar trait (improvements to their circulatory system to make better use of limited oxygen) sounds convergent to my mind
→ More replies (1)
11
u/dumbwaeguk May 13 '19
human evolution doesn't solve any problems; it just eliminates the cases where the problems weren't solved
5
u/megablast May 13 '19
If we could breed these together we would have a clear case of supermen, ready for our cloud cities of the future.
5
May 13 '19
This is called convergence, and happens with all organism. The most obvious example is how there are many different kinds of flying organisms in many different families that all evolved the same adaptation in different ways.
4
u/umnab May 13 '19
The high altitude gene is thought to come from Denizovians, a different type of humanoid from human beings. So this was not simple evolution, but breeding with another type of species.
3
3
u/supe3rnova May 13 '19
Thats what I wanted to know for a long time. Lets say we put two groups of 20 people in two different caves. Both caves are dark, minimum food but plenty of space. For the sake of it, its im possible to leave the cave.
My question is, how would those two groups evolve in such extreme conditions. We humans are adaptive so it would be interesting to see 5 and 10 generations later.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/Long-Sleeves May 13 '19
Isn’t this common sense? Evolution is a natural process of, what is essentially, mutation trial and error. Only focusing on the wins and pruning the loses from the random draw, so to speak.
Why would anyone assume it’s some magical force or switch that gets flipped like “you can breathe underwater now!” It’s like when people say it’s odd how people think fish just grew legs and such. No, no one thinks that.
Same thing as to why X group slowly evolving an advantage doesn’t mean that Y group magically happens to have the same mutations.
5
u/PU55Y_3473R May 13 '19
Also the Badjao Nomads of the Philippines whose spleens are bigger than average for longer diving and catching shit and stuff
2
4
u/Betty_77_ May 13 '19
I thought the Tibetan advantage might have something to do with Denisovan ancestry.
11
u/TheB1ackPrince May 13 '19
be careful about anything you read about neanderthal and denisovians contributing to sapien sapien DNA. not saying it did not happen, it most certainly did but the lasting effects are still really not known. as recently is 10-15 years ago they were saying no neanderthal DNA. now they say all out of africa have other homonids.
we certainly interbred with other human like species, in africa and most likely outside of africa. our knowledge of the human genome is so limited atm it is hard to truly compare to these ancient species where it is even harder to attain full dna samples. the science is progressing but articles love clickbait headlines.
4
May 13 '19
Thats because evolution doesn't think. It doesn't solve anything. Random things happen. Those with beneficial random things survive and breed. People tend to anthropomorphize the body and evolution, but its not thinking or making decisions. You constantly hear "You body does X because it helps with Y" as if the body decided to do something because of its benefit, but really the benefit is why it spread, not the need. Evolution is just happy accidents that people breed around. I wish more people understood how it actually works.
2
u/ImadeAnAkount4This May 13 '19
This is one of the coolest thing I learned about evolution from my anthropology class. Apparently eyes were evolved around 1,500 different times.
2
2
u/Beerwithjimmbo May 13 '19
Of course it does, evolution isn't guided, it needs a mutation to work with first. If there is no beneficial mutations then they die... There may well be innumerable X people didn't evolve to deal with high altitudes and dies and we'll never know about them
2
u/GReggzz732 May 13 '19
So many other evolutionary traits in different ingenious people too!
Evolution at its essential requires this!
Such a beautiful and graceful way of propagating life!
2
2
u/xxNightingale May 13 '19
It's like a talent/skill tree in a game. You get to choose skill to learn on level up.
2
u/up48 May 13 '19
Combine them to make a fucking super human, maybe add some Scandinavian or Dutch genes to make them tall as fuck too.
2
u/Fluffy_Con May 13 '19
Surely through globalization this could have significant impacts on humans through the ease of access we have to migrating. Otherwise why would we have evolved such traits and other factors we’ve adapted to.
So practical example being, parents are from an island with a generally low altitude throughout and were both born in coastal city’s - assuming my heritage follows suite and my ancestors were generally low altitude dwelling humans (from Ireland) surely I would be affected to some degree as I was born and lived my whole life at 1600m above sea level and in a country with very different weather conditions etc.?
2
2
u/y2k2r2d2 May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
There was also a Bird that went extinct but another branch of the bird evolved to be that same extinct bird. Hence it was reinvented bird.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Yogymbro May 13 '19
This is so cool.
I was literally told that saying different human populations have genetic differences is racism the other day. :(
2
u/juusukun May 13 '19
Why are evolution and early capitalized? What are native early peoples? Are they early native peoples?
/R/titlegore
2
2
2
2
u/TippsAttack May 13 '19
Wouldn't that be adaption, not evolution?
If it's not, what's the line between the two. I've always been taught that evolution is a giant leap of a change with a species that's generally pretty drastic.
2
u/laughterwithans May 13 '19
The model of evolutionary biology mostly refers to slight compounding changes over large lengths of time, not significant mutations or changes in a single generation, as these tend to not affect population change.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/boogertaster May 13 '19
This is a little misleading. Often evolution solves the same problem the same way. For example, the 4 chamber heart evolves separately in birds and mammals.
https://blogs.unimelb.edu.au/sciencecommunication/2012/09/07/the-evolution-of-the-heart/
2
2
u/_TzzzK May 13 '19
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it also explains the skin colours of people. Darker skinned people lived nearer to the equator where the concentration of sunlight is higher as the increased melanin decreases the chance of getting skin cancer and related symptoms, while lighter skinned people lived nearer to the poles where the sunlight was less concentrated and they needed to absorb all they can get. (I'm like 90% sure about this so please add on or correct any misleading/wrong parts)
3
3
May 13 '19
And maybe it isnt so farfetched to consider the illness rates of whites and blacks in North America. None of them were from there
2
3
3
9
u/Mister_Teapot May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
Remember, evolution affects the entire body!
Except the brain tho, most definitely not the brain.
Everything else though!
→ More replies (19)
2
2
2
2
2
1
u/malk500 May 13 '19
Careful OP, it's safest to pretend that there are 0 physical differences between ethnicities.
13
May 13 '19
There's a lot of middle points between "ignoring biological differences" and "boneheaded crackpot eugenics" that you seem to be glossing over
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Allokit May 13 '19
So the best mountain climber in the world should be a Chilean Tibetian or a Tibetian Chilean.
2
u/recitt20 May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
Chilean here, our natives don't really live at high altitudes not comparable to Tibetans at least, I think OP means those from the Peru/Bolivia part of the Andes, those people really live at high altitudes, I think the highest city in the world is somewhere in Peru or something like that.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
May 13 '19
Only because the ones who couldn't died and weren't able to reproduce.
Of course, I don't mean literally everyone, I mean statistically, over time.
1
u/KPokey May 13 '19
We let them have babies together, now we're ready for altitudes so high, we're ready for space.
What next, SCIENCE??
1
u/Lunaticfringe365 May 13 '19
Sounds like they could have some children that would be wicked mountaineers.
1
1
1
u/Nottakenorisiwtf May 13 '19
I solved the problem of altitude by living in the Netherlands. Adapt, survive, windmills.
1
1
u/ThrowawayNerrd May 13 '19
The Tibetan mutation is actually inherited from an ancient race precursors to humans called Devosonian. They were another species of humans like Neanderthals.
1
u/LawlessCoffeh May 13 '19
Now cross breed people from those locations and get the best of both worlds!
1
u/thoushaltnotpiss May 13 '19
The Bajau people have bigger spleens I think? Supposedly it works like an extra oxygen tanks for when they're underwater for minutes on end
1
1
1
u/AnnualThrowaway May 13 '19
Except at certain altitudes where the adults could live, they couldn't keep pregnancies to term, so pregnant women had to go to a lower altitude.
1
May 13 '19
I learned about this in an evolutionary biology class, and another example is lactose tolerance. It seems that there are two different places where it evolved using different mechanisms to do the same thing. It was Europe and Africa where they can trace these evolutionary traits to.
1
1
1
u/dingo_deano May 13 '19
“There’s only one race, that’s the human race , don’t even diss yourself ‘cause that’s a disgrace”
1
1
u/typhoid-fever May 13 '19
honestly ethnic Andean's hearts getting stronger instead of the blood adaption makes more sense instead of it being pure chance they are differnece, simply because of all the cocaine
1
u/RandomEskimo May 13 '19
It's called convergent evolution and it's not just limited to humans, for instance birds and bats both developed wings in different ways independent of each other. If you find this as fascinating as me have a look at all the different eyes that have developed independently in nature.
1
1
1
u/CouchAlchemist May 13 '19
One of the things I learnt from QI a long time back was survival of the fittest(fit in broad generic term) is not the magic mantra for evolution. It's just all permutation and combination until there is a survival rate. In all these permutations, in most cases, there is more than 1 variation that promotors survivability.
1
u/buttmunchr69 May 13 '19
When China took over Tibet they moved Han Chinese there to outbreed Tibetans. But the Han Chinese had high infertility rates and their offspring were underweight.
1
u/Somethingwithplants May 13 '19
It is called convergent evolution. There are some really good examples around, like evolution to develop flight aka bats and birds, evolution of an eye that can do 3d imaging aka octopus eyes vs mammals eyes.
1
1
May 13 '19
I think evolution is not a conscious effort of beings body but just a random outcome that worked!
3
1
1
u/griersy92 May 13 '19
I also a function of the activities required in that environment, which might account for the variation in affected organ.
1
u/furtivepigmyso May 13 '19
Kiinda want to say no shit, it's not like there's only ever one possible solution to every challenge the environment presents.
1
u/Cellari May 13 '19
The One who inherits both never gets out of breath in stairs. Also probably wonders why no one else find stairs exhilarating.
1
8.3k
u/AdvancedAdvance May 13 '19
So basically the child of one of the Natives and a Tibetan would win every Tour de France.