I ran the numbers for switching a family of 4 (all lines porting in) with 2 iPhone 18 Pros, 2 Galaxy S26 Ultras, and an iPhone 16 + Galaxy S22 to trade in. Totals are over 36 months (the length of the device credits), pre-tax, activation fees included.
- Verizon Unlimited Ultimate ($220/mo): ~$8,500. Both iPhones free with trade-in, S26 Ultras ~$200 each with no trade-in.
- T-Mix Loaded ($240/mo, 11 Picks): ~$9,250
- AT&T Premium 2.0 ($220/mo): ~$10,750. Big discounts need one trade-in per phone, so two of the four phones are close to full price.
Why T-Mix Loaded loses: on T-Mix, phone deals cost Picks. A flagship deal is 3 Picks, so 4 phones need 12, but 4 lines on Loaded only get 11. You pay the top-tier price and still can't get all four phones on the best deal.
The only way T-Mix beats Verizon is dropping to T-Mix More ($180/mo, 7 Picks) and splitting the Picks into smaller deals:
- iPhone 18 Pro x2: $930 off each w/ port-in (2 Picks each)
- S26 Ultra #1: $1,000 off w/ trade-in (2 Picks)
- S26 Ultra #2: ~$830 off w/ trade-in (1 Pick)
That gets you to ~$7,950, but every Pick goes to phones for 3 years. No Netflix, no Hulu, no perks at all. You also drop from 250GB to 60GB of hotspot.
Bottom line: T-Mix only wins if you treat it as a bare plan and burn every Pick on phones. At the same tier as Verizon Ultimate, T-Mobile is about $750 more over 3 years.
Prices checked Nov 16. Holiday promos change weekly, so verify in store.