r/threekingdoms • • Feb 10 '26

Sun Quan was an actual Goat, the only one who was called "The Great " in TK era

5 Upvotes

Yes, he took over a region, helped to build it so that southern china prospered for more than thousands of years.

He was a political genius who played it well on Cao Cao, Cao pi and success to survive, he crushed Cao cao in his prime, and Cao pi after him.

A lot of people fled the north to be under his rule.

He was too generous to liu bei even when advised otherwise and crushed him too when Liu bei betrayed him and tried to take the opportunity on his men's bloods and souls.

Who hates him is someone who love cao cao and liu bei and could not stand their favs to be crushed.

And for the betrayal!

Yes Liu bei betrayed sun quan before even Sun Quan dared to do, told him to delay his attack on shu and then took it himself. And even refused to give back the lands sun quan gave him. So sun quan simply thought him the meaning of Betrayal, and again the meaning of loss.

Sun Quan was a great man of the three kingdoms era, even if he fought men of his father's generations, he stood up!

Imagine if cao pi was in his place, or Liu shan????

You may hate him, but at the end of the day, he was a winner!


r/threekingdoms • • Oct 30 '23

liu bei fails to establish moral superiority

2 Upvotes

I've been a fan of three kingdoms for a while, starting from dynasty warriors games, then total war three kingdoms, then watching red cliffs and finally I've watched the 2010 adaptation too

No matter how I look at it, as hard as the narrative tries to paint liu bei as cao cao's righteous counterpart, I can't recall a single thing cao cao was guilty of that liu bei wasn't guilty of as well. in fact, liu bei's first 15 years of career or so was just switching from one master to another, taking their troops when opportunity arose and then switching to someone else.
His idiot sworn brothers don't make his image any better, either


r/threekingdoms • • Aug 16 '26

Scholarly Before There Was He Yan, There Was...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Aug 11 '24

When somebody says ROTK 2010 is better

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Jul 10 '25

Fiction If Three Kingdoms characters lived in the modern world, what jobs would they have?

Post image
36 Upvotes

Eg: Zhang Fei - Front man of a death metal band.


r/threekingdoms • • Feb 01 '26

Scholarly Today's take: Shu never forgave Wu's betrayal and silently settled the score via Jin

2 Upvotes

When we talk about Shu after Guan Yu’s death and the Yiling disaster, it’s easy to imagine them as a grieving, betrayed kingdom. But the fascinating part is how the land of former Shu how they handled or didn’t handle their opportunity to intervene decades later when the Jin fleet that would erase Wu from the map sailed down the Yangtze years later.

By the time the Jin Dynasty consolidated power in the late 270s, Shu was long gone, politically absorbed into Wei and later Jin. And yet, the historical record makes it clear: Shu never cooperated to aid Wu, and they never attempted sabotage or warning.

During the preparation process, Wang Jun began building a massive fleet in Yi Province, the former heartland of Shu, with the express purpose of striking at Wu. However, Wu only discovered this plan through floating wood fragments downstream, not via defectors, spies, or insider warnings. If Shu had any lingering loyalty to Wu, or even a sense of “we should help them”, they had every chance to signal Wu or quietly disrupt the fleet. Nothing happened. Shu’s silence speaks volumes.

This is the crux of the Shu position: they never forgave Wu. The betrayal of Jing Province and the death of Guan Yu was too fundamental to their moral and historical code. But at the same time, they didn’t actively manipulate the course of events; they let history take its course.

When Jin ultimately conquered Wu in 280, the former Shu territories didn’t riot, resist, or attempt to intervene. There was no mass uprising, no sabotage of Jin supply lines, and no evidence of Shu officers secretly aiding Wu. The grudge was principled, not opportunistic. Shu’s moral stance was consistent: Wu deserved its reckoning, but Shu would not dirty its hands for either revenge or reconciliation.

By the 270s, less than 20 years after Shu's fall, Jin had such firm control over the region that they could run a massive, multi-year military project in absolute secrecy. The famed Shu loyalty to the Liu Bei cause was dead. The local gentry and populace had pragmatically accepted Jin rule.

Meanwhile, The Shu people and remaining elite never forgave Wu for Jing and Guan Yu. Their hatred for Wu was personal. When forced to choose, they chose the enemy they respected (and now ruled them) over the ally they despised. Furthermore, by doing nothing, they actively enabled Wu's destruction. They handed Jin the secure base, the resources, and the manpower (former Shu troops served in Wang Jun's fleet) to execute the final blow.

In the end, Shu Han achieved its vengeance and closed the Wu karma debt not through the virtue and passion of Liu Bei's oath, but through the cold, quiet Realpolitik of a conquered people. They got to watch Wu burn, but from the audience, not the stage, and to them, that was enough.


r/threekingdoms • • May 23 '23

Why Is There This Push Right Now To Suggest Everything Liu Bei and Shu Did Was Perfect And Everything Cao Cao And Wei (And Sometimes Wu) Did Was Evil And Stupid?

0 Upvotes

Because in doing so, aren't we basically suggesting that if you do everything right and be as kind and wise and brave as possible...you'll still lose because evil and stupidity triumph over everything decent in the world just...because?

Quite frankly, I'd rather see the events of the Three Kingdoms as 'All three sides were full of overall decent, well-intentioned but flawed people, showing their best and worst sides at different points dependent on circumstances, all had their different reasons for flourishing or failing when they did, some of it was their fault, some of it wasn't but there we are.' That's how I see history, that's how I see people in general. No-one goes in with the intent to sow evil, not unless they're seriously disturbed individuals which, in my experience, is pretty easy to notice based on behaviour patterns.

Those who seek power often do so for reasons they believe are perfectly moral and/or necessary. In some ways, that's what makes them so dangerous, a man who truly believes he is doing good and is duty-bound to fulfil his goal, will be a far more formidable opponent than one who values his own life above whatever ideals and ambitions he may have.


r/threekingdoms • • Jan 17 '26

History "If Mao had died in 1956" Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I saw that quote the other day, and I kept thinking about how I felt that when reading RoTK (or the history).

If Sima Yi had died in 240, maybe history (and KOEI) would not remember him as a scheming traitor.

If Jiang Wei had died in 240, maybe history would not call him warmonger.

et cetera.

Do you have characters/figures in Three Kingdoms that would fit that quote?


r/threekingdoms • • Jan 27 '24

Saved this a while back: In defence of Sun Quan(and Sun Wu)

0 Upvotes

I don’t know when being anti-Sun Quan seems to have become popular in the 3K community, and there are often situations where people gather to shit on Sun Quan. However, looking at a large number of anti-Sun Quan's remarks, they are actually quite naive. This article starts from the various remarks of those that are anti-Sun Quan, and comprehensively analyzes Sun Quan. On the one hand, it is to provide some context and correct some misunderstandings about Sun Quan, and on the other hand, I hope everyone will be able to better understand the situation of Sun Wu.

First, about Sun Quan's military capabilities.

The place where Sun Quan has been shit on the most is his military ability. The so-called "Sun Shiwan" or "Sun 100k" are not called for nothing. However, after a closer look, Sun Quan's military capabilities are not that bad, probably at an average to above average level.

Regarding the shitting of Sun Quan's military capabilities, the most frequently mentions are his defeats by Chen Deng, Liu Fu, Zhang Liao, Man Chong and others - all with very few troops. Let's analyze it one by one.

First of all, Sun Quan was defeated by Chen Deng. In this battle, the name of the general was not recorded in Chen Deng's biography and the citations in "Xianxian Xingzhuang", but in Chen Jiao's biography, it was Sun Quan. However, there are discrepancies between the two records. "Xianxian Xingzhuang" records that Chen Deng defeated the enemy army ten times his own, while Chen Jiao's biography records that Cao Cao sent people to break the siege. "Xianxian Xingzhuang" is very likely to be exaggerated, and Sun Quan was only 19 years old at the time. This battle alone is unable to prove how weak Sun Quan's military ability is.

Then there was the first Hefei battle with Liu Fu and Zhang Xi, which was Sun Shiwan's famous record. First of all, it is impossible for the 100,000 people to exist. This battle took place almost at the end of the Battle of Chibi, and the participants in the Battle of Chibi were still attacking Jiangling under the command of Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu. The battle of Chibi was a matter of life and death. Zhou Yu asked Sun Quan for 50,000 elite soldiers. Sun Quan said that he was short of money and could only get 30,000. How could Sun Quan have an army of 100,000 just after fighting Chibi? Some people say that this just shows that Sun Quan is an asshole, so many soldiers are obviously not sent to Zhou Yu and insists on keeping them for himself. First of all, with Sun Quan's territory and support ability, it is impossible to get an army of 130,000. Secondly, it is recorded in "Jiankang Shilu" that Sun Quan assembled 30,000 troops at that time, 10,000 were commanded by Zhou Yu, and 10,000 were commanded by Cheng Pu. Sun Quan commanded 10,000 soldiers himself, which shows that it is really difficult for Sun Quan to come up with more troops. Therefore, Sun Quan's troops were not many in this battle. At the same time, Sun Quan did not show any military disadvantages in this battle, but when he was only one step away from breaking the city, he mistrusted the false news that Cao Cao's reinforcements were coming and withdrew his troops. It is possible that Sun Quan is too cautious, but it is unreasonable to use a hundred thousand troops to criticise Sun Quan's military ability.

Then came the iconic second battle of Hefei, where everyone loved to use Zhang Liao to criticise Sun Quan. In this battle, Sun Quan was severely beaten twice, in the outpost battle and the retreat battle. This battle was recorded in detail in the biographies of the generals of the two warring parties, and it was also the most painful defeat in Sun Quan's life. But the so-called "eight hundred destroy one hundred thousand" is more ridiculous. The most important point is that this sentence comes from Cao Pi's edict, and Cao Pi has not experienced this battle. He is a scholar-literati, and he likes to use some exaggerated rhetorical techniques... First of all, the claim of 100,000 army in Wu side is not at all reliable. At that time, Sun Quan did not have the ability to gather 100,000 troops.

Secondly, the number of 800 refers to Zhang Liao at the outpost. Specifically, the number of death soldiers led in battle. In the outpost battle, Zhang Liao fought against only part of the Wu army, not all of them, and although Zhang Liao performed superbly, the casualties caused by this battle to the Wu army were relatively limited, so the Wu army continued to attack the city afterwards, but the morale at Wei side was very high while Wu side was very low.

At the same time, it can be seen from the relevant records of this battle that Sun Quan's army's military organisation and orders were very chaotic and he was not good at fighting on land. This is not the fault of Sun Quan alone. He is not good at land combat because of the geographical conditions of Jiangdong. The confusion of military orders is not only due to the fact that Sun Quan underestimated the enemy in the first battle, but also because Sun Wu's army has implemented the private troops system since its establishment. This military system makes the effectiveness of Wu army restricted and limited, further restricting Wu army's performance. 

As for the retreat, it can be said that it was entirely Sun Quan's fault. I don't know if Sun Quan felt that he was too embarrassed at the time and decided to save a little bit of face, so he actually led the troops to protect the rear during the retreat, and the number of soldiers he brought was still very small. Zhang Liao and others charged out and almost captured Sun Quan alive. In this battle, I can't bring out any excuse to defend Sun Quan. It was a real and tragic loss, which proved that Sun Quan's military ability was far inferior to that of Zhang Liao. However, what I need to note is that in this particular charge, Zhang Liao brought out all 7,000 troops in Hefei to attack Sun Quan. So it was Zhang Liao that had the numerical superiority.

Let me emphasize that the military ability of Sun Quan is not strong, but the 'meme' of 800 crushing 100,000 is false...

In the end, in the fourth battle of Hefei, Sun Quan's 100,000 troops were repelled by dozens of Man Chong troops. But in fact, judging from the course of the battle, Man Chong only attacked a small part of Sun Quan's troops, and the casualties caused were also very little. The main reason why Sun Quan retreated was because Cao Wei's army was coming. Therefore, if you pursue the pleasure of troops numbers without looking at the specific battle situation, you can just say something like eight hundred destroying hundred thousand, or tens of troops destroying hundreds of thousands as jokes, but you can't take it seriously. 

And the same case is not just in Wu. Cao Pi was also intercepted by Sun Quan's subordinate Gao Shou with 500 troops when Cao Pi returned retreated from the south, so if Zhang Liao is Zhang 800 then Gao Shou can also be called Gao 500, correct? See the logic...

Regarding Sun Quan's military capabilities, it can be said that there are not many bright spots and many black spots, but it is definitely not weak. Cao Cao once praised Sun Quan's ability to govern the army.

[Cao Cao] Seeing the [formation] of [Sun Quan's] boats and army, the Duke(Cao Cao) sighed and said, "Once should have a son like Sun [Quan] Zhongmou, Liu [Biao] Jingsheng's sons are like pigs and dogs!"

It can be seen that although Sun Quan is not good at using soldiers, his basic skills are quite solid... as long as he does not command land battles.

The second is Sun Quan's diplomatic strategy.

Sun Quan attacked Jing province, even with the Xiangshui alliance, which led to the breakdown of the Sun-Liu alliance. In the end, the two weak parties attacking each other is often criticized. There is nothing to defend with Sun Quan's behaviour of breaking the alliance, but because of this, Sun Quan's strategic ability is underestimated, and even thinking that he is just a master of backstabbing allies and vassals.

Before Sun Quan attacked Jing province in the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, the only direction of attack to the north was Huainan. Regarding this route, from Sun Quan's view, it can basically be determined that it is a dead end. The first is the combat capability of the Wu army. It can be said that there is no way for Wu to leave the navy and fight on land. In addition to the battles of Hefei mentioned above, there are many other evidences.

For example, when Cao Rui first came to the throne, Sun Quan led troops to attack Jiangxia, and the ministers believed that they should rescue Jiangxia asap. Cao Rui said that the Wu army who went ashore was nothing to fear, and the result was as he expected.

In the eighth month, Sun Quan attacked Jiangxia Commandery, and the prefect Wen Ping stood firm and guarded strictly. The imperial court wanted to send troops to save him, but the emperor said: "Quan is accustomed to water warfare, so for those(Wu) who dare to disembark and attack on land are almost unprepared. Now they are at a stalemate with [Wen] Ping, and their offensive is half and our defensive powers are doubled. In the end, they(Wu) dare not stay long." Xun Yu, the Imperial Censor, was dispatched to the frontiers. When Yu arrived at Jiangxia, he sent the county soldiers who followed him - cavalry and foot soldiers - thousands of people altogether, to the mountains to raise torches, and Quan retreated.

When facing the Shu army in the Northern Expedition two years later, Cao Rui was not so calm.

A similar example is the third battle of Hefei. Sun Quan never dared to go ashore. As a result, he was taught a lesson by Man Chong as soon as he went ashore.

 [Sūn] Quán personally came to attack, intending to besiege the New City, but it was far from the river, so he halted twenty days and did not dare leave the boats. Chǒng said to the officers: “Quán knows we have moved the city, and must certainly be speaking boastful words within his army. Now he has come with great strength to settle things with a great achievement, and though he does not dare advance here, he will certainly come ashore to make a dazzling display of his abundant military strength.” Therefore he secretly sent six thousand infantry and cavalry to establish an ambush near [Hé]féi city to wait for them.

Quán indeed came ashore with a magnificent force, and Chǒng’s ambushing army appeared and attacked them, beheading several hundreds, while others were driven into the water and drowned.

At the same time, Sima Yi once dismissed Wu Jun's ability to fight on land, thinking that Wu Jun, who could only fight on land after the river was frozen, had no threat at all.

The Emperor(Sima Yi) said: "Water is the advantage of the bandits, and now we attack the city to observe their changes. If they use their strength, abandon the city and all retreat, this is our victory. If they dare to guard the city firmly, the lake will be shallow in winter and their boats will not be able to move. They are bound to abandon the water to save each other, and I will benefit from their weakness." In the Autumn and 9th month of the fourth year, the emperor's army attacked Zhuge Ke and drove him out of Jinyangmen and [Zhuge] Ke burned what he accumulated, abandoned the city and fled.

Sun Quan took such a weak troop to the north to fight Huainan, which was flat plains, would basically be like a sheep entering the tiger's mouth. At the same time, the economic capacity of Jiangnan at that time was simply difficult to support the long-term military occupation of Huainan. The experience of the Eastern Jin Dynasty and the Southern Dynasties all showed this point. Therefore, the difficulty of Sun Quan's northern expedition from Huainan can be compared to the difficulty of Vietnam's occupation of Guangzhou.

Under such a premise, Sun Quan can only consider more development directions. In addition to attacking Jing province, it also launched a large-scale development in the south. It took decades to calm down Shanyue and develop Jiao province at the same time. At the time of Sun Quan's death, Shanyue had been basically pacified, and the development of Jiao province was also fruitful, all of which reflected Sun Quan's strategic vision.

Regarding the attack on Jing province, Sun Quan himself had a gambler's mentality deep in his heart, because it was useless to continue to smash Huainan, so he bet that Cao and Liu would not be able to defeat him after he took Jing province. As a result, the follow-up situation was as he expected. Although Cao Pi is frequently mocked for not listening to proper advice, unexpected factors were also an element of the success of the matter. Relying on his keen diplomatic sense, Sun Quan knew that Shu could only rely on himself in the end, eapecially if Jing province was permanently lost. You can say that Sun Quan is shameless, but things developed exactly as he expected.

As for the conflict between the weak and the weak, in fact, the strategic planning of the Shu Han did not consider Sun Wu's situation at all, and it can be said that the development of a military confrontation is a common strategic mistake of both sides. But because Sun Wu was the one who betrayed the alliance, Sun Quan must take the blame. After all, there is no reason for the victim(Shu) to take the blame.

At the same time, some people shit on Sun Quan's ineffectiveness with regards to his Northern Expeditions.

In fact, Sun Wu's military pressure was far greater than that of Shu Han. After the Battle of Chibi, Cao Wei launched a total of four attacks on Shu, including Zhang He once, Cao Zhen once, Cao Shuang once, and Zhong Hui once, if you count the battle where Zhang He went to fight Caogu and was beaten violently by Zhang Fei. There were much more attacks on Wu, namely Cao Cao four times, Cao Pi three times, Cao Xiu once, Sima Yi once, Wang Chang once, and Sima Shi once. After the death of Wei, the Western Jin Dynasty fought a tug-of-war with Wu around Jing province and Jiao province for many years.

It can be seen that Sun Wu has always been Cao Wei's main attack direction, and at the same time Sun Wu will also complete the task of containing Cao Wei's main force very well. For the Northern Expeditions, the total number of Wu State was more than that of Shu Han. Even in the confrontation between Jin and Wu after the fall of Shu Han, Wu State attacked Jin State far more times than Jin State attacked Wu State.

Third, the only thing that can be legitimately blamed is Sun Quan's lack of determination and results in the Northern Expedition.

There is no way. One is that Wu army's infantry combat ability is worrying, and it is difficult to obtain great results. The second is that the private troops system implemented by the State of Wu not only weakened the combat effectiveness of the Wu army, but also made the generals of the State of Wu strongly resist going abroad to fight. The third is that the imperial court of the state of Wu is too deeply bound to the gentry families of the state of Wu, so the enthusiasm for the Northern Expedition is very low.

A typical example is Lu Xun. After Shiting's victory, Lu Xun was not interested in Zhu Huan's proposal to take advantage of the victory and annex Huainan, so Sun Quan also gave up this plan. Later, when Sun Quan sent Lu Xun to lead troops to attack Lujiang, Man Chong learned of the Wu army's movements in advance, so Lu Xun simply withdrew his troops and didn't even bother to fight. This group of Eastern Wu gentry supported the Northern Expedition based on the premise that they could not make the Eastern Wu gentry pay the price.

Taking the four governor-generals of Eastern Wu as an example, the strategic deployment of the four was reduced step by step. Zhou Yu advocated that the whole Yangtze River should be controlled and united with Ma and Han to attack Cao Cao. Lu Su advocated dividing Jing province and unite with Liu to annex Cao Cao's territory. Lu Meng advocated occupying Jing province and defending against Cao and Liu. After Lu Meng's death, no one in Wu put forward military strategies (except Zhu Huan and Zhuge Ke), and they all wanted to live in their own territory.

For example, the city of Wan, which Sun Quan captured in the 19th year of Jian'an, was abandoned after 30 years of governance. Apart from the widening gap in power between Wei and Wu, the reason was that the city went deep into the north bank of the Yangtze River, which was not the core interests of the Jiangdong gentry.

After Sun Quan's death, Zhuge Ke, who became regent and assisted the government, advocated the Northern Expedition, which aroused opposition from the both the government and the public. After the defeat, he was even killed in a coup. Can you imagine that the Imperial court of Shu staged a coup and killed Jiang Wei because he lost the battle? For such a court that was not interested in the Northern Expedition at all, it was not easy for Sun Quan to organize multiple Northern Expeditions in the first place, and it was inevitable that the Wu army had little success and thus low enthusiasm.

Fourth, Sun Quan killed too many in his later years and the state affairs of Wu were chaotic.

Back in the day, in the 3k community, there was a debate on who was most likely to kill their meritious officials and officers after unification.

Let me be fair here, but among Cao Cao, Liu Bei and Sun Quan, only Sun Quan has never killed a meritorious officials(note meritorious). Cao Cao killed Xu You and Lou Gui, Liu Bei killed Liu Feng (of course the reasons are more complicated), and Sun Quan really never used execution on any meritorious officials. I admit that Sun Quan is a hot-tempered and hard-to-serve monarch, but there is no need to demonize him, at least his tolerance is much stronger than Yuan Shao and his ilk. Sun Quan tolerated Yu Fan many times, but Yuan Shao killed Tian Feng. Sun Quan hated Gan Ning, who had a rough personality and enjoyed murdering and refused to obey orders, but still tolerated him. When Yuan Shao met Qu Yi, who had a similar personality, he killed him directly after using him.

Gān Níng was coarse and brutal and enjoyed killing, and once disappointed Mèng and also at a time violated [Sūn] Quán’s order, [Sūn] Quán was furious at this, and Méng at once explained request: “The realm Under Heaven is not yet settled, battle officers like [Gān] Níng are difficult to obtain, it is appropriate to tolerate him.” [Sūn] Quán therefore generously treated [Gān] Níng, and in the end obtained his use.

Qu Yi was conceited due to his accomplishments, became arrogant and errant, Yuan Shao summoned and [then] killed him, and then annexed his troops.

I need to introduce Yu Fan. He has outstanding talent and made a lot of achievements, but his personality is extremely disgusting. In today's words, he is a straight up asshole. After Sun Quan captured Yu Jin, he treated Yu Jin very kindly in order to put on a political show. As a result, Yu Fan repeatedly humiliated Yu Jin in public and beat him with a whip. Yu Fan also humiliated Mi Fang, who was also a general like Yu Jin, and deliberately pretended to be drunk at banquets to refuse Sun Quan to pour wine (then sat up as soon as Sun Quan walked away), and when Sun Quan was discussing immortals with his ministers (the superstitious atmosphere in the Eastern Wu court was relatively strong), he stood up and said that these are all dead people, what else is there to discuss. In all fairness, if you have such a subordinate in your workplace can you tolerate him? 

Needless to say, Sun Quan's tolerance for a monarch in feudal China is definitely far larger than ordinary people like us.

But the state of Wu was in chaos. To be honest, it was not Sun Quan who should be most responsible, but these 'loyal ministers'. At the beginning of the establishment of the Wu regime, the main members of the team were Sun Jian and Sun Ce's former troops and scholars who had fled to the south, that is, the so-called Huaisi generals and refugee northern scholars. Therefore, although the Sun family is from Jiangdong, Sun Wu is a completely 'foreign regime'. In order to gain a firm foothold in Jiangdong, Sun Quan chose to cooperate with local gentry who were willing to cooperate, and gave them a lot of power in exchange for support.

Among the four families of Gu, Lu, Zhu, and Zhang in Wu Commandery, Sun Quan married Sun Ce's daughter to the Gu family and the Lu family, his own daughter to the Zhu family, and the four families themselves married each other. Gu Yong became the prime minister, Lu Xun when in expedition, became a general and when entering court, became a minister and finally became a Grand general and then a Prime minister, and Zhu Ju, who became Sun Quan's son-in-law was also a person who when in expedition, was a leading general, and when entering court, was a leading minister.

When Lu Kai was still alive, he was known for being outspoken and critical of Sun Hao, and for defying the emperor's will on a number of occasions. As a result, Sun Hao secretly bore a grudge against him. At the same time, He Ding (何定), who also hated Lu Kai, constantly spoke ill of Lu Kai in front of the emperor. Sun Hao had long considered getting rid of Lu Kai, but he could not do so because of two reasons. First, Lu Kai held an important office as Left Imperial Chancellor so Sun Hao needed his help to keep the government functioning. Second, Lu Kai's relative Lu Kang was a senior general guarding the border between Eastern Wu and the Jin dynasty, so Sun Hao did not want to antagonise Lu Kang by harming Lu Kai. Therefore, even though Sun Hao deeply resented Lu Kai, he tolerated Lu Kai.

From this record, we can see how powerful the Lu clan is. It can be said that it is not a big problem for Lu Kai to depose Sun Hao directly.

Look at what these Wu gentry have done.

The Taifu He, was in charge of Wu Commandery and didn't reach at first. The powerful families within Wu disparage him, so they inscribed on the door of the government office that "the chicken in Kuaiji cannot crow". He heard of this, reached the government office and glanced back, demand for his brush, and wrote back "Cannot cry, [but can] kill Wu children". Therefore, [He] used various soldiers to verify the mansions of the Gu and Lu clans and [further] search among their officers and men for those that hid amd fled for committing crime, then had every case reported above, [and] those who committed crimes were numerous. Lu Kang was the governor-general of Jiangling at that time, so he requested Sun Hao [to release the guilty], and [the guilty] were released.

Wu gentry harbored fugitives, concealed hidden population, and in the end, even Sun Hao didn't dare to pursue them because of Lu Kang's intervention. It can be seen who is the vampire and parasitic power group in Wu State. With these gentry families in power, how can Wu government be clear and bright?

Would Sun Quan not understand these things? Sun Quan understood it clearly. So in his later years, he frantically punished the gang of Jiangdong clans. First, he sent Lu Yi to monitor and expose these gentry clans, and then after that, he beat them hard with the help of the 'dispute between the two palaces'. The purpose was to prevent the Wu regime from completely falling into their hands , At the same time, it also left the image of a tyrant in his later years. The reason why Sun Quan let Zhuge Ke take power as regent to assist his descendants was not necessarily because of Zhuge Ke's great talent, but he couldn't let the power directly fall into the hands of Jiangdong gentry.

Sun Hao is also similar. After he came to power, he continued to attack the aristocratic family. In the end, the attack was too much, shaking the foundation of the state of Wu, and finally being unable to organize effective resistance to the Jin army.

To be more specific, the dispute of the two palaces was not a succession debacle but a well-crafted ploy that got out of hand.

Sun Deng died young, which meant that all Sun Quan's efforts were in vain. Sun Quan's other sons were not as strong as Sun Deng at all, and Sun Quan was already over sixty and had no more energy to train a successor from scratch. At this time, the powerful Jiangdong clans has become a threat to the successor. Just like Zhu Yuanzhang began to kill heroes indiscriminately after Zhu Biao's death, Sun Quan also began to use extreme methods to pave the way for his successor, so he supported the King of Lu Party.

Judging from Sun Quan's final act of sending Sun Ba to death, he may not have loved his son very much. King Lu's party and King Lu himself are just tools he uses, just like Lu Yi before. Sun Quan's purpose was to use the Lu King party and the Crown prince party to engage in internal fighting to weaken the ministers, so as to minimize the probability that the heir would be controlled by powerful ministers.

But Sun Quan's thoughts are difficult to understand. As the saying goes, accompanying a king is like accompanying a tiger , let alone a moody tiger like Sun Quan. Sun Quan was a man who had very deep thoughts and was difficult to guess. When he was the county magistrate, he asked Lu Fan, who was in charge of finance, for help but was refused. Sun Quan was angry. Zhou Gu used his power to help Sun Quan. Sun Quan was very happy. As a result, After Sun Quan came to power, he never used Zhou Gu again. Sun Quan once resented Yin Mo, and everyone came to him to plead for mercy. As a result, the more they begged for mercy, the angrier Sun Quan became. In the end, it was Zhuge Jin who helped Yin Mo confess to Sun Quan that he was forgiven. Lu Yi thought he had figured out Sun Quan's temperament and helped him frame the ministers, but in the end he went too far and was executed by Sun Quan. Sun Quan would never tell his subordinates directly what he wanted to do, but required them to guess, and Sun Quan was also a person who often changed his mind, but Lu Xun failed to guess Sun Quan's thoughts in the end.

Judging from Sun Quan's behavior before and after Lu Xun's death, he did not want Lu Xun to die. After Gu Yong's death, Sun Quan appointed Lu Xun as prime minister and asked him to continue to be in charge of Wuchang, which showed that Sun Quan still valued Lu Xun at this time. After Lu Xun died, Sun Quan was furious and continued to question Lu Kang, which showed that Sun Quan was very angry about Lu Xun's death. If Sun Quan's purpose was to force Lu Xun to death, he should be relieved at this time.

I personally think that Sun Quan wanted Lu Xun to sing a play with him. As Lu Xun's predecessor, Gu Yong was a prime minister that made Sun Quan very satisfied. He held a high position and was a representative of the Jiangdong clan, but he rarely expressed his own opinions on things. This was exactly what Sun Quan wanted, and he needed Such a person came to help him silence the Jiangdong clan. After Gu Yong's death, no one in the Jiangdong family was more suitable to take this position than Lu Xun. Lu Xun's ability and prestige were unmatched by others. Such a person was the best tool, and Sun Quan still needed him to help him. Sun Quan hoped to intimidate the entire Jiangdong family by suppressing Lu Xun, so Lu Xun's performance was very important. Sun Quan wanted to use Lu Xun's embarrassment and unbearability to reflect his own Imperial authority, so that others would be less able to resist his decision. If Lu Xun by following Gu Yong's example and shutting up and acting like a mascot, Sun Quan can gradually realize his plan. This is exactly what he wants to see.

Sun Wu had 3 major factions - Huaisi faction(refugees and gentry from the north), Jiangdong faction(Wu and Kuaiji gentry clan), and Sun Wu clan members.

Sun Quan's greatest worry was the Jiangdong faction. This is because the Huaisi faction was slowly dying out and was also intermarrying with the Jiangdong faction. Meanwhile, the Sun Wu clan members were either being suppressed or defected during Cao Cao's time. After Gu Yong's death, the leadership of Jiangdong faction fell to Lu Xun.

Sun Quan initial decision to start the Crown Prince struggle was to suppress the Jiangdong faction. Specifically the Wu commandery faction. Previously, he already suppressed the Zhang clan of Wu commandery after Zhang Wen praised Shu Han. The rest of the Jiangdong gentry(particularly the Lu, Gu and Zhu clans) did not resist at that time because Sun Quan was on a winning streak and was going to declare Emperor soon.

After deposing the Zhang clan, he used Ji Yan, Yin Fan, and Lu Yi to suppress all of his officials. But because these 3 'cruel officials' offended everyone, they did not have a good end and so Sun Quan's method failed.

With no choice, Sun Quan started the Crown Prince struggle. He supported Sun Ba through the Sun Wu imperial clan + Huaisi faction + Kuaiji gentry clan to balance out Sun He who was supported by the Wu commandery gentry clan and Huaisi faction who intermarried with Wu commandery gentry clan and had stronger inheritance rights.

In the first move when Sun He was the stronger party, he used false accusations to exile the Gu clan, Zhang Zhao's son, and tried to suppress Lu Xun. Zhu Ju and Wu Can were given death, and Zhang Chun and Qu Huang were demoted.

Lu Xun died of anger after being reprimanded by Sun Quan. Originally, Sun Quan wanted to make Lu Xun look embarrassed, but Lu Xun would rather die than bow his head. Everyone felt sorry for Lu Xun and hated the King of Lu's party even more , and the situation began to get out of control. Sun Quan wanted Lu Xun to take the blame. Lu Xun's responsibility was to live and let Sun Quan scold him, but he threw the blame back to Sun Quan himself by dying. Sun Quan was very shocked and angry at the result: "Okay, you are just. You are smart, you are a loyal minister , and you want to be famous for eternity, but I am a fool and an old fool. I have brought disaster to the country and the people, and will be infamous for thousands of years. Your clan can continue to prosper, but who will protect my inheritance? At this final step, you will not you are willing to help me, you only care about fulfilling your own reputation, you bastard!"

Sun Quan originally thought that the Wu court was his plaything, and all ministers on either side were under his control, just like the previous Lu Yi incident. However, Lu Xun died in front of him unexpectedly. As the dispute between the two palaces spiraled out of control, the situation developed far beyond Sun Quan's expectations. This incident had such a severe impact on Wu that even the enemy countries knew about it. Sun Quan also tried his best to treat Zhu Ran, the only remaining veteran among the veterans, but it was too late. When Sun Quan was critically ill, he admitted his mistakes to Lu Xun's son Lu Kang and burned all the documents that had been used to accuse Lu Xun.

But Sun Quan did not restore Lu Xun's reputation, and Lu Xun's posthumous title was also completed during Sun Xiu's period. Sun Quan's act of burning the documents not only because he felt a little guilty for Lu Xun, but also hoped that Lu Kang could ignore the past grudges and continue to serve Sun Wu, just like his father did back then. Sun Quan himself may still have resented Lu Xun until his death.

For the second move, when Sun He faction lost power, Sun Quan attacked the King Lu supportes to 'compensate' the Wu commandery clan. This means killing Yang Zhu, Quan Ji, Sun Qi and others. He also forced Zhuge Ke to kill his son.

The third move, was to finish the play. Depose Sun He, making Sun Liang crown prince and kill Sun Ba.

At this time, all of Sun Quan's objective had been completed: specifically weakening all of Sun Wu's gentry clans, particularly the Wu commandery gentries and deepen the blood feud between the Wu gentry clans and Kuaiji gentry clans while tearing a rift between the 3 major factions: Jiangdong gentry faction, Huaisi faction and Imperial clan faction so that neither faction is too powerful to threaten the Imperial center.

The only thing Sun Quan could not foresee was Lu Xun suicide and the factionalism going out of Sun Quan's control.

All in all, Sun Quan did not hesitate to kill Sun Ba in order to weaken the gentry clans. After weakening the factions, Sun Quan left 5 people to support Sun Liang: Zhuge Ke(leader), Sun Hong, Teng Yin, Lu Zhi and Sun Jun. The two Suns are blood-related and part of the Sun Wu clan members. The rest were from the Huaisi faction. Not a single one was from the Jiangdong faction(be it Wu commandery or Kuaiji commandery).

After reading this article, I believe that all kinds of people probably have their own answers to what kind of person Sun Quan is. Personally, I think Sun Quan is undoubtedly an outstanding individual. He has many black spots, but more shining points. I am not opposed to everyone shitting on him, but shitting on a person must first be based on understanding this person. I hope this article can be helpful to everyone.


r/threekingdoms • • May 24 '25

How destructive would 3K be if we gave each warlord faction the United States military?

1 Upvotes

Really dumb and obvious question but how would it change China in the meantime


r/threekingdoms • • Feb 06 '23

Sun Ce and Zhou Yu

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Jan 31 '23

Sun Shangxiang and Sun Quan

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Oct 04 '26

Games What do you guys think?

Post image
3 Upvotes

So theres a game called Heroes Vow Three Kingdoms and I just want to make a simple character mod. Would this suit the Three Kingdoms universe a little bit? Yes the image on the left has quite some pixels still indeed, I like the AI generated image but it still needs some hand tweaking for sure. Normally I am using paint.net to finetune images but since switching to Linux I instead try to use Gimp. Defintely need to get more comfortable with that tool aswell because I do not think the image scaled very well haha


r/threekingdoms • • Feb 28 '22

Intermezzo: Musing on long-shafted axe & Xu Huang

0 Upvotes

We’ve covered almost each of Xu Huang’s notable moments during his life.. and just in case asking, short summaries of him, Xu Huang as he was one of the best warrior and general in Chinese history, particularly 3 kingdoms era. In more specific term, he is one of the top three best officers we found with particular high streak of military records alongside Zhang Liao and Zang Ba….

While his personal characteristic are also no less prominent… I mean, if we comparing the command style of the best officers under Wei, such as Yu Jin for his rigorous disciplines & high standard, Zang Ba for his dominant & independent nature, while Deng Ai for his long-term military intelligence & *“sixth sense”(*this one is scary aspect of Ai, we will cover next time)

….Thus Xu Huang’s soldiers characterized by its shrewdness & “high risk-high-demand” type.

==================================================================================

==================================================================================

for this intermezzo served also as addendum note for Xu Huang analysis on the usage of axe as practical military weapon before we enter Deng Ai, we must know that most of it information came from cultural basis which came not from the primary source, which means the informations came from later era, such as paintings of Xu Huang from Qing dynasty era or some Peking opera

Thus we found the cultural consistency of the axe in regards of Xu Huang as his alleged preferred weapon, which of course, shaping the modern depiction of him as “axe wielder”…. Not unlike Zhang Fei with his trademark “snake-tongue” shaped cavalry spear”

Now the question is how much accurate such depiction with real life Xu Huang? Then the answer is we cannot measure the cultural depiction alone were reliable one, while up to this day there’s no official biography records or archaeological proof for Xu Huang’s weaponries. However, if we measure the consistent cultural depiction which at best unchallenged, with the factual usage of axe in battle during Xu Huang’s era, then we can ruled the possibility of it.

First we take a look on the Chinese axes themselves.

==================================================================================

Xu Huang as campbreaking specialist

While not as common as sword, spear, bow or gun, axe remained an important weapon in Ming arsenal. a person I believing much regarding Chinese military history, culture, & technologies also stated no doubt that this weapon has been used by Chinese warriors across Han dynasty era. For the most part, Chinese axes are quite consistent in form, different types of axes are simply minor variations of each other. According to Handan Excavation of the Zhaodu City Site in the Warring States Period in a record from 1954 It is not quite evident to what age they belong, but they may possibly be traced back to the Contending States Period. An iron axe of the type which was thought to belong to Han was unearthed from Cha-chien Ling,

Da Fu (大斧, big axe)

Da Fu is the umbrella term all long shafted axes. Proper names for war axe include Yue Fu (月斧, lit. 'Moon axe'), Kai Shan Fu (開山斧, lit. 'Mountain-openning axe'), Jing Yan Fu (靜燕斧, lit. 'Silent swallow axe'), Ri Hua Fu (日華斧, lit. 'Sun ray axe'), Wu Di Fu (無敵斧, lit. 'Invincible axe') and Chang Ke Fu (長柯斧, lit. 'Long shafted axe').

E Mei Qu has a three chi long shaft and nine cun long edge. It is mainly by sappers unit, u know sappers? Those who engaged in siege, counter-engineering combats, and fortification warfares..

Feng Tou Fu has a two chi five cun long shaft and an axehead with Chinese phoenix motif. It is also used by sappers or engineer teams

Now we get the idea that the usage of axe are not just for fancy personal preference thingy, but also has practical usage.

Now as we mention above, the long shafted axe are usually used by those who engaged in dismantling enemy defenses, so the abates or makeover barricade like this:

Now I want to focus on some notable operations of Xu Huang.. as we mention before, Xu Huang no less has engaged in three anti Guan Yu operations during his life And by the excerpt in the events where Guan Yu always losing, which in Jiangling against Xu Huang & Li Tong, and also in his late career against Xu Huang (again) & Cao Ren in Fan, we noticed the similarity of Guan Yu’s military strategy motives that usually using abatises, trenched earthwork defenses or fortified camps for impeding his adversaries. (yes, biographical record suggested Guan Yu seems favored much such usage of defensive works)

Now Guan Yu aside, during the northern campaign, Xu Huang also manage to Zhang Shun, one of Cao Cao's officers, and defeated the rebel leader Chen Fu and destroyed some 30 rebel camps

For the opposing side who wants to break those defensive works or enemy camps. Usually need the Da Fu axe which allegedly used by Xu Huang, which we surmised that the weight of such huge axe swing are that needed for crushing those wooden works or arranged beams which impeded their advances, or even the frames of military tents

Conclusion:

Based on those historiographical analysis which supported by Xu Huang’s reputation as the breaker of camps & defensive structure specialist, yeah… it is highly possible that Xu Huang also preferred defense-breaking long-shafted Da Fu axe as his weapon.

Of course this not ruled out that Xu Huang are probably using the standard weapons such as short-shafted Dao (sabre), longswords, or the Chinese infamous multi-headed halberd… but during his operations breaking the enemy camps or fortress, he most likely swapping on the axe.


r/threekingdoms • • Dec 04 '24

Scholarly More Of Cao Cao's Wives And Lovers

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Jan 07 '22

I think Liu Bei is overrated cuz Cao Cao is good at cunning while Sun Quan is smart and also virtue is almost useless in a battlefield

0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Feb 25 '25

Fiction I draw Liu Bei, the way I imagine him. I draw his face based on tigers. This is because tigers are considered a symbol for power. At first, I planned to give him some scars, but I felt like scars would kinda ruin the "strongest warrior in the history" vibe .)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Apr 25 '20

Were Liu Bei, Zhang Fei, and Guan Yu in a relationship?

3 Upvotes

I haven't read the original novel because I'm lowkey illiterate in Chinese, but in the animated adaptation (it comes up when you search 三国演义动画片) it really seems like they were? They are so so close to each other, and I know social customs etc were different back then but like,, it just Doesn't Seem Very Straight. Is anyone familiar with the original novel or the actual historical records who knows anything about this?


r/threekingdoms • • Feb 10 '26

The theme of every kingdom

0 Upvotes

As i read The three kingdoms history for the first time i always noticed that each kingdom has a theme

Wei: ambetion

Wu: family

Shu: Somehow in history is about Opportunism

What do you think?


r/threekingdoms • • Sep 27 '23

Why ROTK 1994 is better pt 2

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Oct 11 '23

Liu Bei was one of the most treacherous leaders in the 3k period and was more treacherous than Cao Cao

19 Upvotes

He served Gongsun Zan, abandoned him.
He served Cao Cao, betrayed him.
He served Yuan Shao, abandoned him.
Went back on his word to Sun Quan
Betrayed Liu Zhang

I love Liu Bei, and I think his rise to power is the most interesting out of the Three Kingdoms because he was starting with the biggest handicap, but he was far more ruthless than he is given credit for, imo. Fact he managed to survive like he did and eventually thrive is a small miracle unto itself.


r/threekingdoms • • Feb 10 '26

Sun Renxian ( Sun Shangxiang) was never in love with Liu Bei

11 Upvotes

Like i feel that Sun Renxian is a way underrrated, that woman was never in love with Liu Bei who was older than her with 20 years at least and a threat to her family and their intersts!

She was an intilligent woman with a strong carachter that worked out as a spy and was a danger to liu alongside Cao Cao and her brother that zhuge liang said liu bei feard she would cause a rebellion inside liu bei camp and fa zhang advised him to send her back.

I think liu bei didn't send her bc he would use her as a hostage ( a precious one too)

She was a fighter and have trained many woman to fight and she had her own power in her husband camp wich is unusal for women in her time.

Lady sun is a great carachter in history and turning her into a tomboy who is so " in love " with an older man ( 20 years) who was her family enemy.

That marriage was never happy, they both didn't bother themselves even to act the dutiful husband and wife...

Like, do you really believe they were in love?


r/threekingdoms • • Jun 24 '26

Scholarly TToCA Cao Cao X Xun Yu Pride Month!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/threekingdoms • • Feb 04 '22

Xun Yu, Sima Yi and Xun You Character Design

Post image
0 Upvotes