I want to preface this post with the fact that I do not own The Sprawl's rulebook, so apologies if I'm not using terminology as stated in the rulebook.
A discussion around The Sprawl sprung up in a Discord channel that I'm following, one related to the way the "starting meet" and "end meet" rolls happen. I couldn't really get any clear answers to my overarching question there, and the person I was talking to said I would probably find people better at explaining things on this subreddit, so here I am.
From the way I understand it, the mechanics behind the "starting meet" and "end meet" are very similar to one another: the player(s) roll dice, they check their results (in the case of the "starting meet" this is adjusted by a player character skill), and based on those results, they must choose one or three beneficial options out of five to happen at the meet and suffer repercussions for any options not chosen.
My question/problem is with those options themselves. Specifically, every single one of those options is both immutable (i.e. the GM cannot change them) and must always create a consequence/penalty if they are not taken (any that do not always have a consequence erode player agency over how the meet goes, and that player agency is the whole point to the roll in the first place). In my eyes, this creates a situation where the GM is forced to design every job in a way that those options always have consequences. This can get their hands tied should the players stumble into a situation where this restriction cannot be maintained. The jobs themselves also become more predictable because the players will always expect to have the same options to choose from and with the same types of consequences tied to not picking any given option. For example, the GM cannot allow the players to accept jobs from a J with whom they're intimately familiar because that would make the consequences of not choosing "get info on the J" inconsequential, the GM cannot allow jobs that would attract a ton of unwanted attention from all sorts of different actors because that would make the consequences of not choosing "does not attract unwanted attention" to be too consequential compared to not choosing any of the other options, etc.
Why not allow those options to be changed/defined by the GM for each meet? This would free up the GM to design jobs that would otherwise not be able to accommodate the pre-defined options. It also still retains the system itself to give players agency over what consequences their characters suffer from inaction, versus the alternative of following rule 0 and throwing out the entire system the instant any one of the five options becomes "polluted" (for lack of a better word). For example, if the players would get offered a job from a J with whom they're intimately familiar, the GM can swap out that option/consequence for one where the job might attract unwanted attention from two different sources, and the players would need to take separate precautions against each one. Or maybe the players could get offered a job from a J who is flatout unwilling to negotiate pay (but offers way more than usual for the job), but there is a lot more behind that J than behind most Js, so the GM could swap out the "get more pay" option for a second, separate "get info on the J" option. Or if we're talking about "end meets", the GM could maintain the profile of an honest-to-a-fault J that always pays in full, but working for that J always risks extra heat, so they could swap out the "get paid in full" option for a second, separate option to avoid extra heat.