r/thermodynamics • • Sep 17 '24

Question Is my professor petty for this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

My professor knocked down my grade 20% on this question bc I did not include P_0 which isn’t given and cancels out anyways. Is this petty or is this pretty standard?


r/thermodynamics • • Oct 31 '24

Question How do I solve for V4?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Jul 14 '21

Video Tokyo Station in Thermal Vision. See the Heat!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Aug 25 '26

How do I turn my Japanese Drink Warmer into a food warmer?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I had a food warmer that broke and was too expensive to replace. Got lucky with a craigslist find and got this drink warmer. It's made to heat up canned coffees and teas: black base gets warm, and those metal rods (removeable) get hot! How do I disperse this heat to best keep food inside of it warm without burning the ones on the bottom.

For presentation sake food cannot be wrapped in foil. They are rice balls stacked on top of each other.

Current idea is to encase the inside in foil and put a square of silicone baking mat on top of the foil.


r/thermodynamics • • May 04 '25

Question Does hot water stay hotter for longer, then cold water stays cold.

1 Upvotes

So basically I was wondering does hot water stay hotter longer than cold water stays cold.

This question kinda random poped into my head.


r/thermodynamics • • Sep 10 '26

Educational Thermal expansion and temp differential are involved, but who can explain my curling paper?

0 Upvotes

No wind in the room. All steam and heat. Steam side expanding would cause curl, then cooling back?


r/thermodynamics • • Oct 30 '25

Question From a thermodynamic POV , does a bladeless fan, provide a NET cooling effect? Even a nominal, barely detectable amount of sensible cooling?

0 Upvotes

Hi all!!

It’s me again, the weirdo finance guy.

I’m aware of their GENERAL operating principle of this type of appliance.

The low pressure zone is created by the pressurized gas (supplied near the base of the appliance) now exiting, as it flows across said uniquely curved inner surface.

Please correct me if I’m wrong: But to me,

The decompression process implies WORK was done, via gaseous expansion. Said work performed otherwise required SOME amount of thermal energy input from the surrounding environment to even perform said task.

Am I wrong to presume that said thermal energy input was provided by the entrained air - thus resulting in it having less kinetic energy when all said and done? A net cooling effect?

By the way , With consideration given to :

Obviously the bladeless fan’s impeller motor will surely generate heat (DUH) as a result of said compressive-related task it was designed to perform. ASSUMING That pent up heat was isolated, vented out, whatever, somehow just NOT allowed back into the surrounding room.


r/thermodynamics • • Aug 17 '21

Question Is my logic flawed?

0 Upvotes

If you had a motor that could spin at roughly 100 rotations per minute and attached a gear to it that has 200 ticks, then had the giant gear rotate a 8 tick gear, the outputted rotational energy would be 25 times the input if you attached that to a generator. Considering every possible energy loss, there would be at least 3 to 5 times the energy used by the motor being produced by the generator. Torque isn’t the thing powering the generator, rpm is. Is this a perpetual motion machine?


r/thermodynamics • • Sep 25 '24

Question Compressing gas doesn't technically require energy?

0 Upvotes

Please tell me if the following two paragraphs are correct.

Gas temperature (average molecular velocity & kinetic energy) increases during compression because the compressor's piston molecules are moving toward the gas molecules during their elastic collision.

This "compression heat" can be entirely 'lost' to the atmosphere, leaving the same temperature, mass and internal energy in the sample of pressurized gas as it had prior to pressurization.

If the above is correct, then wouldn't it be technically possible to compress a gas without using any energy and also simultaneously not violating the 1st law? For example, imagine a large container with two molecules inside. Imagine the two molecules are moving toward each other. At their closest, couldn't I place a smaller container around them? Wouldn't this have increased the "pressure" of the gas without requiring any work or (force*distance) 'compression work/energy'?


r/thermodynamics • • May 07 '22

Question hey everyone i took a dc 3v motor and connected it to an led and a turbine made of soda can sheet and made it spin using a hair dryer but the led didn't turn on. what im i doing wrong ? also should the fan turn clock wise or counter clock wise ?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Mar 12 '19

The amount of entropy

0 Upvotes

When I was discussing with my friend about the amount of entropy, he asked me why we say partial equation of Q/T and not differential when we want to find the amount of entropy. When I searched this I found mathematically differential equations for exact values and for that reason the amount of entropy is non exact amount but it is an expression for disorder or prediction for some factor so that we bring partial equation to say it is non exact and there are some other factor. We should notice that entropy is a point function .It is private with point and not the path of process. I think we should find all factors to make our equation differential and not partial? I want your opinion to lighten my way. Thanks for all


r/thermodynamics • • Jan 08 '25

Which hydro flask is better at keeping my water cold?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Thermodynamicists of reddit! Hello!

Pictured are my two hydro flasks (40 oz and 32 oz respectively). I use the same top for both of them.

When i go to the sauna (170°-180°) I fill up my bottle of choice with ice and cold water. For the past few months I’ve been using the light blue 32 oz bottle, and when in the sauna the metal exterior of the bottle gets burning hot, yet the water inside stays nice and cool.

The other day I switched to my bigger 40 oz bottle, and noticed that when in the sauna after 30+ minutes the exterior metal of the bottle wasn’t hot, in fact I could hold it in my hands with no discomfort. I didn’t notice if the water had gotten warmer, though the ice chunks may have been smaller than usual.

I’m wondering which bottle is better at keeping my water cold? Does the 40 oz have an issue with its double wall insulation, therefore the inside coolness is cooling down the exterior metal instead of keeping the water cold? Or is the 32 oz bottle that gets burning hot to the touch the faulty one?

tldr: i have two double wall insulated metal water bottles. the exterior of the 32 oz gets burning hot in the sauna, the 40 oz does not. Which one is actually better at keeping my water cold?

I’m thinking the 40 oz one is worse, but want to confirm before I decide which one to keep! Thank you! :)


r/thermodynamics • • Feb 26 '24

Question should i convert inches to feets on thermal resistance?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Aug 03 '26

Question Could you create a pocket sized fan that intakes the warm outside air and outputs cold air?

0 Upvotes

I've seen people using the shark instacool fan thing with a fan, cooling plate, and mister attachments. But for 150 dollars I would think that you'd be able to find a way to actually cool down the air from the fan.

Is there a reason why there are no pocket sized fans that dont just move air around? why hasnt someone made a cooling air handheld fan? Would this be a project that's achievable for me to attempt without understanding thermodynamics? why cant you just have a peltier plate or cooling plate inside a fan to cool down the air as it blows?

I'd love to hear anyone's insight about this since I want to learn about this issue.


r/thermodynamics • • Jan 27 '26

Question Why doesn't the sun heat the space between earth?

7 Upvotes

However It heats the earth? If it's not heating the space between Earth and the Sun. How does it heat Earth?


r/thermodynamics • • Jul 22 '26

Question How do counterflow heatexchangers not break the spirit of thermodynamics?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Assume a heatexchanger with minimal losses, the heat being transferred over thermoelectric generators. Eventually near 100% of the heat in the system should be recovered as electricity since losses just get shoved either into the next cycle or recovered further downstream. Put in a heat pump producing the temperature gradient and place all its waste heat producing parts somewhere ideally into the input stream.

I've been laughing about this quite a bit now, but honestly can't see the fault. Except for the movement of the air all losses should be about contained within the system (e.g. just wrapping the heat exchanger around itself multiple times) and eventually recovered by the TEGs. But the heat pump is shoving in more heat from the environment than it consumes in electricity, dropping the temperature in the room until it gives up on you, all while the TEGs are turning the excess heat into electricity.


r/thermodynamics • • Jan 24 '20

Why can heat go higher in temperature than cold?

4 Upvotes

The Sun, for instance, can reach up to 27 million degrees Celsius, if I'm not mistaken, whereas the lowest temperature (absolute zero) only reaches -273.15° Celsius.

For your record, I'm a total novice and this has been going through my head for quite a long time.


r/thermodynamics • • May 08 '20

One kg (m1A) of a liquid at T1A = 300 K is mixed with 1 kg (m1B) of the same liquid at T1B = 400 K in an adiabatic calorimeter. Assume that there is no change of phase and that the density and specific heat of the liquid remains constant at ρ = 1200 kg/m3 and cp = 5 kJ/kg K. Calculate the change

0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Sep 13 '18

How Continuous Combustion Gas Turbine Works?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Jul 14 '24

How to solve this "Gibbs free energy of ideal gas to relate the entropy of the gas with the temperature changes"?

0 Upvotes

Determine an equation to show the changes of Gibbs free energy of ideal gas to relate the entropy of the gas with the temperature changes.

I really stuck on it and I didn't get it, I found it in past years exams and there was no tables for Maxwell relation. So I don't know how to solve it


r/thermodynamics • • Aug 24 '22

Question How does condensation of water vapor not violate the second law of thermodynamics?

0 Upvotes

When water vapor is cooled below 373.15K it condenses into a liquid. Why does that happen when water vapor has a higher molar entropy than liquid water?


r/thermodynamics • • Jul 31 '21

Question Why makes a air conditioner more heat than cold?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • Apr 28 '23

Question Can someone explain why heat pumps can’t be used for an “infinite energy glitch”

1 Upvotes

I’ve just started the topic of heat pumps so please be forgiving about my lack of understanding.

Basically from what I’ve learnt, you can essentially take energy from an environment and transfer it to a “hotter” environment using some work input.

Let’s say I used a heat engine to transfer 20kj of energy to a well insulated basin of water. And to do this I used 5kj of input work.

Then say I used some relatively efficient turbine to transfer the 25kj of work inputted into my basin into 8kj of electrical energy.

Surely I could then take that 8kj of energy and use it to transfer another 22kj of heat energy to my hot water basin. This would then result in an even greater electrical energy gain.

My question is why can’t I just repeat these steps to turn my 5kj into essentially unlimited energy (so long as there is still energy in my cold source environment).


r/thermodynamics • • Jun 28 '26

Question why are people putting thermal paste performance in W/mK

0 Upvotes

why a watt divided by a meter times kelvin, it makes no sense, ahouldnt it be W/m^2K a single meter is not saying anything, is this a simplification? or did someone mishear it?