I need to get this off my chest… I’m not anti-therapy. I’m anti-therapy that takes people’s time and money and gives them almost nothing concrete in return.
I’ve had exactly one good therapist in my life. She moved away.
Everyone else has mostly been a mix of intake paperwork, reflective listening, and “how does that make you feel?” with very little in the way of tools, structure, or strategy.
At the same time, I’m seeing more and more people say some version of: “AI (ChatGPT, etc.) has helped me more in a week than therapy did in a year.” Instead of treating that as a serious signal that something in the profession needs to change, a lot of therapists seem more focused on attacking AI than asking why so many clients feel this way.
Here’s my experience that pushed me over the edge.
I went to a highly regarded therapist I’ll call Mr. Big Deal™. This guy had a PhD in psychology, big local name, impressive office, walls of awards, photos with celebrities. On paper, this is exactly the kind of person you’re supposed to see when you’re stuck. I had been feeling stuck in life for months, so I finally went. The first session was intake. I understand the need for history, but I left with no tools, no framework, and no sense of what the plan was. By the time I was four sessions in, I had spent 4 × $185 to sit in a nice office, talk, and get reflective nods.
So after 4 sessions, I asked him directly: “What strategies do you have for me that I could start using to feel unstuck?”
His answer was:
“I don’t know. You figure it out.”
Read that again.
I was angry. If I could “figure it out” on my own, I wouldn’t be paying that much to sit there. That response felt less like a deep therapeutic stance and more like an admission that he had nothing practical to offer.
I know the defense that will be offered: “That’s non-directive therapy. We don’t tell you what to do. We believe the answer is inside you.” The problem is that, in practice, this often becomes a shield for doing almost nothing concrete, even when clients explicitly ask for it.
Let’s look at the situation logically. The client’s stated problem: “I feel stuck and don’t know what to do.” The client’s explicit request: “What strategies can I start using to feel less stuck?”
The therapist’s claimed value: advanced training, credentials, professional expertise, prestige, and a high hourly rate.
The therapist’s actual response: “I don’t know, you figure it out.” That is not “empowering the client.” It is refusing to translate expertise into anything usable. Non-directive approaches were meant to avoid controlling clients’ lives; they were not meant to justify never offering structure, frameworks, or experiments for change. When “non-directive” is used this way, it stops being a legitimate modality and becomes professional passivity.
Now compare that with what many people are experiencing when they use AI as a support tool.
When I describe feeling stuck to an AI and ask for help, I get: a breakdown of possible factors contributing to feeling stuck; simple frameworks to think through (values, skills, environment, etc.); specific actions or “experiments” I can try over the next week; and concrete language I can use in real conversations. Plus I ask it to challenge my thinking, help me with cognitive reframes, and give me CBT and ACT tools to use right now.
Yes, It is not a therapist. It is not a replacement for crisis care or complex clinical work. But it is offering more practical help, more quickly, than what I received from a highly credentialed professional who told me to “figure it out” after several paid sessions. That’s not a sign that AI is magical. It’s a sign that a lot of therapy, as actually practiced, is not meeting reasonable expectations for actionable support.
“The answer is inside you” is not sufficient as a treatment plan. People seek therapy precisely because they cannot access that “answer” on their own. Saying “the answer is inside you” without also providing structure, reflection, and concrete ways to explore and test that “inner answer” is functionally the same as telling someone, “Good luck.” Clients are not wrong for wanting more than that. It is not unreasonable to expect a therapist to say, at some point: “Here is how I understand what’s going on, and here is how we can work on it. Here are some things to try between now and next session.”
In my view, AI should not replace good therapists, but it should force the profession to pause. If a general-purpose chatbot is giving clients more usable, structured help than some licensed professionals, that should be taken as a serious warning sign. Good therapists can integrate AI as a supplement: for psychoeducation, journaling prompts, CBT-style exercises, and between-session support. But therapists who rely entirely on non-directive listening, never offer concrete tools, and hide behind “the answer is inside you” when clients are explicitly asking for practical strategies… those therapists need to step up their game. AI isn’t the main problem in those cases; it’s simply revealing how thin the value has been.
And finally, I don’t think “I had one client with AI-induced psychosis” should be used as a conversation-ender. Anecdotes cut both ways. Right now, a large number of clients are reporting that AI-based support is actually helping them move forward when traditional therapy did not. The rigorous outcome data isn’t in yet, but the signal is that many people are getting traction. That doesn’t mean ignore the risks of AI. It does mean that dismissing client experiences with one horror story while ignoring widespread reports of benefit is not intellectually honest. Instead of reacting defensively, it might be healthier for the field to treat AI as a mirror: if this tool is helping your clients more than you are, it’s time to ask why… and to raise the standard of what counts as effective therapy.