r/theology • • Aug 03 '20

Or anything, really

Post image
393 Upvotes

r/theology • • Dec 24 '20

Christology We all have a part to play.

Post image
340 Upvotes

r/theology • • Feb 14 '21

I'm sure the 3rd century Saint Valentine, “being known only to God,” would be delighted by how we remember him.

Post image
306 Upvotes

r/theology • • Apr 04 '20

Some light relief from the all the shenanigans

Post image
265 Upvotes

r/theology • • Jul 05 '25

I often feel this way about theology

Post image
250 Upvotes

r/theology • • Jul 21 '20

Discussion A painful truth...

Post image
235 Upvotes

r/theology • • Jan 12 '25

Discussion A fundamentalist cartoon portraying modernism as the descent from Christianity to atheism, published in 1922.

Post image
205 Upvotes

r/theology • • Mar 08 '21

Question Wonder if anyone is interested in this. This is my great grandfather's original published book from 1884. On the harmony between Christian faith and physical science

Thumbnail
gallery
179 Upvotes

r/theology • • Feb 18 '25

Biblical Theology Found in an old magazine

Post image
173 Upvotes

r/theology • • Mar 10 '21

What do you guys think about this graphic?

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/theology • • Oct 25 '19

Goodbye

137 Upvotes

This sub is broken. I hope someday it gets fixed. I am just frustrated with the overwhelming number of vague, indecipherable, profound-sounding jargon with personalized definitions for words rather than the objective definitions commonly used. I am tired of all the insane ramblings of scriptures with no logical argument or supporting statements.

This is not a theology subreddit. This is a pseudo theology subreddit. I know theologians. I've spoken with them on matters of spirituality and morality. This sub would make them cry.

Goodbye.


r/theology • • Jun 03 '20

Interpreting Genesis

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/theology • • May 15 '19

My new book stamp.

Post image
132 Upvotes

r/theology • • Jan 10 '22

Eschatology Rapture not biblical

129 Upvotes

I'm of the view the rapture is not biblically true or theologically coherent. There's the verse in Thessalonians about being caught up to meet him, and you would have to frame your whole theology of this issue around this verse (which is always a dangerous thing to do). I also don't believe it's theologically coherent with the new testament approach to suffering - we are called to persevere in faith and persecutions as God's glory is more revealed through this. It strikes me as an escapist theology of God removing his followers and destroying creation rather than renewing and restoring it. Its a pretty new doctrine developed in the last couple of centuries after fictional writings associated with it. However its a pretty widely held belief in some churches. What do you think? And how would you articulate your position on it to people whose theology has the rapture as central?


r/theology • • Aug 03 '24

Discussion Did the Bible ever state that these folks turned to Christ and gave up their ways or just that he hung out with them?

Post image
124 Upvotes

r/theology • • Apr 08 '20 Heart of Silver

Why you can’t find god/faith

123 Upvotes

After studying theology for nearly a decade (all religions but mainly Abrahamic)ive realized that if you ask god (or a higher power) for a sign he’ll give you one. Problem is that it’ll be so obscure and coincidental (scientifically explainable) that you won’t be able to justify it to your unfaithful peers. By doing this he demands that one reach out and search for him. One must overcome nihilism to find god. Search hard enough and you’ll find him.

  • a former atheist


r/theology • • Mar 08 '24

Question Can anyone help me source this Bonhoeffer quote?

Post image
106 Upvotes

I came across this, this evening and have never came across it in any of his writings. Does anyone know its source?


r/theology • • Feb 11 '20

Prayer Bear

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/theology • • Dec 02 '20

God Is there anything God cannot do? Yes! Titus 1:2 "God, who cannot lie" 2 Timothy 2:13 "He cannot deny Himself" Hebrews 6:18 "it is impossible for God to lie"

Post image
94 Upvotes

r/theology • • Mar 29 '20

O.K. I think it's time for me to start a typical Teenager Bible study. Hehehe.

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/theology • • Mar 18 '25

Paul hijacked Christianity and turned Jesus into a Greco-Roman god.

85 Upvotes

Most Christians assume their beliefs come from Jesus. They don’t.

If you strip away Paul’s writings and look only at what Jesus actually taught, you’ll find no original sin, no salvation through blood sacrifice, no faith-alone doctrine, no pre-existent Christ, no vicarious atonement, and no dying-and-rising savior theology. Every one of those concepts came from Paul—and none of them exist in Jewish thought.

Where did Paul get them? From Greco-Roman mythology and Hellenistic philosophy.

Paul didn’t expand Jesus’ message—he completely replaced it with a theology that had nothing to do with Judaism and everything to do with mystery cults, Platonic dualism, and Roman salvation myths. Paul’s version of Christianity is a direct copy of Greco-Roman religious concepts, rebranded to look Jewish.

The Christianity you follow is Paul’s invention—not Jesus’.

Original Sin – Paul’s Doctrine, Not Jewish Theology

Jesus never taught that Adam’s sin doomed humanity. That idea does not exist in Jewish scripture. Judaism teaches personal responsibility for sin. Ezekiel 18:20 says, “The son will not bear the iniquity of the father… the righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him.” Deuteronomy 24:16 states, “A person shall be put to death for his own sin.”

Yet Paul completely contradicts this and introduces a foreign doctrine in Romans 5:12: “Sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, and in this way death came to all people, because all sinned.” 1 Corinthians 15:22 expands on this idea: “For as in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive.”

This concept is alien to Jewish thought but identical to Greco-Roman fatalism. The Greek term for inherited human corruption, ἀναγκαία μοῖρα (anangkaia moira), means “inescapable fate.” This concept pervaded Stoic and Platonic philosophy, where the physical world was inherently flawed, and humanity was trapped in imperfection. Paul Christianized this worldview, teaching that humans are born in sin (Romans 3:23), incapable of righteousness, and must be redeemed by Christ’s sacrifice. Judaism, in contrast, taught yetzer hara (inclination toward evil) and yetzer hatov (inclination toward good)—meaning humans have free will and are not born condemned.

Paul’s inherited sin doctrine parallels Greek myths like Pandora’s Box, where a single ancient mistake (Pandora opening the jar, Adam eating the fruit) unleashes sin and suffering upon the entire world, condemning humanity to a broken existence that only divine intervention can fix. This is not Jewish theology—this is Hellenistic determinism repackaged as Christian dogma.

The Dying-and-Rising God – A Pagan Archetype, Not a Jewish Messianic Expectation

Paul rebrands Jesus into a Greco-Roman-style salvific deity, which has nothing to do with Jewish messianism. The Jewish Messiah was expected to restore Israel, enforce Torah, and bring justice to the world. Nowhere in Jewish eschatology was the Messiah supposed to die as an atoning sacrifice for sin. Paul invents this concept wholesale.

Here’s where Paul’s version of Jesus perfectly matches pagan savior figures that existed centuries before him:

Osiris (Egyptian) – Osiris was killed, dismembered, and resurrected, becoming ruler of the afterlife. His death brought renewal to his followers. Paul claims Jesus’ death and resurrection offer eternal life (1 Corinthians 15:20-22).

Dionysus (Greek) – Dionysus was torn apart and reborn, and his blood was believed to grant eternal life. His worshippers drank wine in his honor, believing they were partaking in his divine essence. Paul institutes the Eucharist, where followers drink Jesus’ blood for salvation (1 Corinthians 11:25).

Mithras (Persian/Roman) – Mithras sacrificed a bull, and its blood brought purification and salvation. Early Mithraic initiates underwent a baptism ritual, just like Paul’s followers (Romans 6:3-4).

Attis (Phrygian) – Attis died under a sacred tree and was resurrected, bringing salvation to his worshippers. Jesus was crucified on a tree, and Paul claims His death grants justification (Romans 5:9).

Paul perfectly maps Jesus onto these pre-existing Greco-Roman archetypes. The concept of a divine being who dies and resurrects to save humanity was already present in pagan religions—Paul simply grafted Jesus onto this template.

Salvation by Faith Alone – A Mystery Cult Doctrine, Not Jewish Teaching

Jesus taught that salvation comes through righteousness and obedience to God: “If you want to enter life, keep the commandments” (Matthew 19:17). Paul overrides this completely, declaring in Ephesians 2:8-9: “For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works.”

This doctrine mirrors Greco-Roman mystery religions, where initiates were “saved” through belief in a divine figure rather than by living righteously. Paul nullifies Torah observance, which Jesus explicitly upheld (Matthew 5:17-19). His teaching directly mirrors the Hellenistic soteriology (σωτηρία, sōtēria) of the Eleusinian Mysteries, where salvation came through initiation into secret knowledge, not moral action.

Blood Atonement – Taken from Pagan Sacrificial Systems, Not Judaism

Jesus freely forgave sins (Luke 7:48) and emphasized God’s mercy. But Paul rejects this and declares in Hebrews 9:22, “Without the shedding of blood, there is no forgiveness.”

This is not Jewish theology—this is pagan sacrificial religion. In Judaism, animal sacrifices were symbolic and secondary to repentance. God repeatedly states that He desires mercy over sacrifice (Hosea 6:6, Micah 6:6-8). Paul instead adopts the sacrificial soteriology of Greco-Roman cults, where divine blood offerings were necessary for salvation.

Paul’s Cosmic Christ – Borrowed from Greek Logos Theology, Not Jewish Messianism

Paul elevates Jesus to a pre-existent divine being (Colossians 1:15-20), which does not exist in Jewish Messianic expectation but aligns perfectly with Platonic Logos theology (Λόγος, “divine reason”) developed by Philo of Alexandria. In Greek thought, the Logos was a divine mediator between God and the world. Paul takes this Greek philosophical concept and applies it to Jesus.

Conclusion: Paul Created a Greco-Roman Religion Disguised as Christianity

Strip away Paul’s pagan imports—original sin, faith-alone salvation, blood atonement, a dying-and-rising god, and cosmic pre-existence—and Christianity collapses back into a Jewish movement focused on righteousness, justice, and preparing for God’s Kingdom. Paul took a Jewish teacher and forced him into a Greco-Roman framework, creating an entirely new religion.

The Christianity you know is Paul’s Christianity, not Jesus’.


r/theology • • May 15 '22

Ecclesiology Got a classic in the mail today

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/theology • • Aug 06 '23

Can Gods omniscience and our free will co-exist?

83 Upvotes

Religious of Reddit, I have recently come across an interesting argument I have never explored before. The argument says that the omniscience of God and the free will of humans cannot co-exist. If God is fully omniscient and knows what will happen in my future and God is never wrong, the means God cannot be wrong about my future and therefore the future he sees for me will happen and I cannot choose otherwise. On the other hand… is it possible in Gods omnipotence can he prohibit himself from knowing the future and thus allowing us to maintain free will? Up until now I have always held that we have free will and God is omniscient, however, I have not yet been able to debunk this argument. Considering all this, I am looking for arguments that maintain Gods omniscience and our free will at the same time. Is it even possible that both co-exist?


r/theology • • Jul 25 '26

Biblical Theology saw this in a different sub. could someone please explain?

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/theology • • May 07 '26 Mindblown

I Studied Early Church History… and Now I Don’t Understand How People Reject Catholicism or Orthodoxy

81 Upvotes

I’m new to the faith and recently started attending the Catholic Church. One thing that keeps pulling me toward Catholicism and Eastern Orthodox Church is the historical continuity. When you start reading the early Church Fathers and studying history seriously, it becomes hard to ignore that Christianity was deeply sacramental, liturgical, bishop-led, and connected to apostolic succession from very early on.

What I’m wrestling with now is this:
For those of you who appreciate theology and history, what are your strongest objections to Catholicism or Orthodoxy?

I’m not asking for shallow “religion bad” answers or modern cultural criticisms. I mean genuine historical or theological reasons why you would not become Catholic or Orthodox despite their connection to the early Church and apostolic lineage.

Some of the questions I’ve been thinking about are:

At what point does doctrinal development become corruption or innovation?

Did Jesus promise indefectibility to a visible apostolic Church institutionally, or primarily preservation of the gospel through believers?