r/themountaingoats • • Feb 15 '24

have they done anything in support of Palestine?

67 Upvotes

I know there’s literally a 90s era song called going to Palestine but I wish something material or concrete could be done bc the silence is uncomfortable


r/themountaingoats • • Nov 05 '25

Mountain Goats songs but make them about weed 🌿

0 Upvotes

Maybe Smoke Weed (maybe sprout wings)

Neal Smoked Weed (steal smoked fish)

Pale Green Weed

Smoked Out


r/themountaingoats • • Aug 06 '25

Baba fuckin vibin

Post image
9 Upvotes

this is for the person who asked me to post this at the baltimore show


r/themountaingoats • • Nov 08 '25

Disliking LMM is a Lame Flex

0 Upvotes

This has been one of those lamecool cold takes floating around the internet since the post Hamilton backlash, and I am adamantly sick of it. Hating on him is about as oversaturated a hipster opinion as "not even liking Marvel movies" or "actually preferring theaters to streaming"

LMM is a talented vocalist, genuinely likes the band, and John wanted to work with him. The amount reflexive hate I'm seeing without any justification beyond LMM sounding like LMM is perhaps expected for an indie band this indie, but a lame flex regardless


r/themountaingoats • • Feb 17 '26

What made you love The Mountain Goats?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I might make a playlist with all the songs mentioned in comments. Thanks!


r/themountaingoats • • Aug 10 '26

Some analysis on the decline in songwriting

0 Upvotes

Sorry to pile on another "I don't like Days" post. Definitely happy for you if you enjoy it, and I think there are things to like about it. Just sharing some points on how I think there's been a huge decline in the writing in the last decade. This is especially hard for a band where the main selling point for me has always been the writing.

Also I agree that the production and instrumentation are worse, but I just want to focus on the writing.

As an experiment, I used a random number picker and grabbed a section from a random song on Days.

The last day of your life, you'll be whole
The last day of your life, you'll be whole
And what was broken will then be put together again
Then you'll be totally free, and that's a guarantee

And if we go by the text
We can't really say what's next

Then I picked a random album -> song -> section from somewhere in the Tallahassee to Goths range. I landed on Outer Scorpion Squadron, not even an especially popular song.

If you really want to conjure up a ghost
Cultivate a space 
For the things that hurt you most

Rake the sands until they surface
Blind their tiny eyes

You can try this yourself, and while there are exceptions, it's clear the writing has changed. Some points:

  • There are so many throwaway words and phrases that feel like amateur poetry. "You'll be totally free, and that's a guarantee" isn't a line that would have made the final cut back in the day. Good poetry has an economy of language where every word has to be there, not just because it rhymes with the thing you wanted to say.

  • The repetitive choruses are everywhere. Not inherently a bad thing ("This Year" is structured like this), but songs like "Shallow Grave" go too far and venture on unlistenable, and the wordy verse + simple chorus thing only works if the verses carry weight. He started to do this only once or twice an album ("Foreign Object", "Unicorn Tolerance") where it was sort of a fun standout, but now it's a songwriting crutch and it's used in almost every song on this album.

  • The ambiguity everyone likes is still there, kind of, but without the emotional resonance. I have no idea what "Outer Scorpion Squadron" or "Design Your Own Garden Container" are about, but you feel a specific sadness in the imagery. "Last Day" is way less ambiguous, but even the parts that aren't spelled out don't seem mysterious. There's no feeling like "this song is an iceberg and I'm only getting the surface". All the songs on Days feel like "John had a fun idea for a line and wrote around it." Peter Balkan, JFT, etc. also feel this way to me.

    • Even if you compare more Days-like songs (upbeat / cultural references / less ambiguous) you can look at "Lovecraft in Brooklyn" or "Harlem Roulette". Pull up the lyrics side-by-side with anything from the last five years and I think there's no comparison.

There are a lot of comments on this subreddit like "the great thing about the band is if you don't like one album, you'll surely like another one" etc but I do think these issues are pervasive in everything since Goths. I don't find JFT, Peter Balkan, Days, etc. that different structurally, just slightly different narrative concept and sonic motifs.

Again, feel free to disagree and it's good to like things!


r/themountaingoats • • Apr 25 '24

State of Grace by Taylor Swift is very Goats-esque

0 Upvotes

I'll preface by saying I'm not at all a swiftie and very much a Goatsie. That being said, my wife is on a Tswift kick so it's been playing in our house. I had to re-listen after I heard State of Grace. Specifically the acoustic, specifically Taylor's version. The rhythm, the cadence, heck even the lyrics could be a John song. Especially in the Get Lonely era, if you will.

Share your thoughts on what you think is a very tMG Taylor song. Better yet, what's a song by them that sounds like it could be on a Taylor Swift album?


r/themountaingoats • • Nov 19 '24

Oh we’re doing tier lists?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/themountaingoats • • Nov 10 '25

Things are bad now and they are only going to get worse.

0 Upvotes

Maybe the reason some people aren't feeling the new album is because the overall theme is such a downer. And then the nature of the album as a single solid mass causes it to really drive that point home. Overall I liked the album and thankfully I lived under a rock when Hamilton blew up so I have no feelings about LMM, but jeeze, this guy is suffering and also he will be dead soon , again and again. I guess it's a reflection of the state of things, but some optimism wouldn't kill ya John.


r/themountaingoats • • Mar 25 '24

Why does TMG tour such random small cities?

0 Upvotes

I feel like they have not come to my urban metropolis in years. Is it a preference for small crowds? An attempt at equality (giving small communities their own shows?) A general distrust of large venues and liberal intelligentsia types?


r/themountaingoats • • Jul 28 '26

John Darnielle's middle name

2 Upvotes

Hi! I'm writing a novel and I'd like to include an allusion to JD without being too on the nose. Does anyone know his middle name? I can't seem to find it anywhere. EDIT: Not trying to be stalkyish. I posted this here bc I thought my research skills were failing me. Several of some minor characters in my novel are musicians; I'm considering named one of them JD or Sean (like the protagonist of Wolf in a White Van). Thanks to those of you who've responded with suggestions.


r/themountaingoats • • Apr 04 '24

Harm reduction at TMG shows?

0 Upvotes

I went and saw Laura Jane Grace a few weeks ago and noticed that at her merch table there was a free harm reduction box with things like condoms, emergency contraceptives, drug testing strips, suicide hotline info, and even practical things like ear plugs and mints. I’ve been to seven-ish TMG shows and never seen anything like this that I can remember, and with John’s history and politics I find that kinda surprising! Honestly, I’d really like to see them implement something like that in the future. Thoughts?

ETA: I think people are misconstruing what I meant by this post a bit, I’m certainly not faulting John or the band for NOT doing this by any means!! All I meant was “this seems like the kind of thing that aligns with the band’s philosophy, it would be cool if they did it and I wonder why they don’t.” No ill will meant at all!!


r/themountaingoats • • Oct 19 '26

Another question, do they take song requests?

0 Upvotes

What is the etiquette around requesting songs too, don't want to annoying anyone by yelling autoclave too loudly or too many times?

Edit: glad I asked and obviously now I will not do this, I haven't been to this type of concert before so my only experience to go off was youtube videos where people do this loads. Does make sense that thats both annoying and not honoured by the band.


r/themountaingoats • • Aug 15 '24

The Diaz Brothers in my ass

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/themountaingoats • • Oct 29 '23

Is Cleaning Crew the greatest song ever released by the Mountain Goats?

5 Upvotes

Yes, maybe


r/themountaingoats • • Jun 17 '23

I saw this recently and thought it was very fitting for tMG

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/themountaingoats • • Dec 05 '25

Number 109, what's up

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/themountaingoats • • Apr 26 '19

CONTROVERSIAL MOUNTAIN GOATS OPINION

0 Upvotes

I like them....what does controversial mean?


r/themountaingoats • • Apr 14 '20

Unpopular Opinion: Songs for Pierre Chuvin didn't have to be recorded on the Panasonic and it doesn't really add anything

1 Upvotes

Excellent album, but it should've been recorded on a proper microphone and doesn't really gain anything from being recorded on the Panasonic like earlier albums did. These are beautiful, well made songs and they don't need the fake lo-fi purity anymore.


r/themountaingoats • • Dec 11 '22

I found John and Peter hiding in my homework

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/themountaingoats • • Jan 28 '23

How to fix 'Hostages' (God, I'm gonna get murdered for this haha)

1 Upvotes

Okay, hear me out!... please😭

When talking about the album Bleed Out one of the phrases I always say is "there's 2 seven minute songs, one is amazing and the other is Hostages". The problem is that, because TMG songs are usually nowhere near that long, a song that takes on that length HAS to have a distinct purpose and reason to do so, and I just don't think Hostages does. If you haven't yet burned me at the stake, please read below each problem I have and how I'd fix them.

The chorus is AMAZING (from a writing perspective), it's such a violent punch, especially when considered as a stark contrast to the first chorus... however, it's sung 3 times, and for the first TWO TIMES John just kinda does his 'whisper singing' for it...... like.... why!?!? I seriously can't understand why he wrote the line "We may run out of bullets but we're never gonna run out of hostages" and even CONSIDERED singing it normally. It needs to be SHOUTED, YELLED. So, the first fix I'd make is to make the transition from first verse to chorus much more like "Training Montage", in that the very light, delicate singing on "may not reflect our stations views" goes into a BELLOWING "We may run our of bullets"

Next... this one is gonna be controversial... but... ummmm... it doesn't need so much instrumental solo. Look, don't get me wrong, I ADORE the Jordan Lake Sessions version of See America Right BECAUSE I love the extra instrumental on the end... but hostages doesn't need it, or at the very least, it doesn't need THAT much. You know what? I'll say it! My fix is to make it the same length as Wage Wars Gret Rich Die Handsome... that's it... that's the fix! You can have 15-20 seconds at the start and the end (and maybe in-between verses), but every time it goes beyond that it just feels un-needed. (Seriously tho, even if you disagree with me, you have to admit, the placement of a 30 second instrumental break RIGHT AFTER the "one thing I love" line is the most peculiar thing!)

That's it... I expect I will get a black spot put on my back by posting this, but... ummm... oh well, I guess😅😅


r/themountaingoats • • Sep 04 '22

On behalf of my home city of Baltimore, I apologize for the absolutely obnoxious traffic before tonight's show.

2 Upvotes

It's the bicycles. Blame the bicycles. Does John have any songs about smashing up bicycles? Cause I need to listen to it now.


r/themountaingoats • • Aug 08 '26

Days is sort of a miss for me Spoiler

8 Upvotes

I'd give it a solid 6/10, whereas most others are in the 8-10 range. My opinion of it might improve with time, which often happens with TMG albums, but I'm not holding my breath. Should've known how I would feel the minute John said it was a sequel to Goths, AKA my least favorite album in their discography. 

My main issue with both Days and Goths is that they lean heavily on time-and-place references that don't make much sense to people outside of a particular demographic. Most TMG songs are set in very specific moments in time, of course, but there's a metaphoric quality to those songs that makes them more accessible. Days doesn't really have that, in my opinion.

That would be fine, but the lyricism is also kind of underwhelming in this one. There are exceptions ("full mouth of teeth to grind" is incredible, as is "a creature you could be kind to...") but most of the tracks are just less interesting versions of other TMG songs. The Last Day of Jimi Hendrix's Life was one that came to mind; just like Days and Best Hard Rock Albums, it explores sensations that you take for granted when you don't realize that death is drawing near. I think it does so much more elegantly than the former two.

I loved Shallow Grave and Eddie Nash's Grave, but the rest just didn't hit for me. I suppose with a band as prolific as TMG, there are bound to be some albums that you like more than others. Jenny and Peter Balkan were each a slam-dunk, so I can't complain too much.