Please excuse this long rant - but I've heard the full album twice and I'm just so disappointed - need to vent out - might as well share it.
There's amazing moments - most notably the last 4 or so tracks you can feel the Mars Volta envelope being pushed into a new and interesting territory. Traces of the old, but full of new ideas and sounds. It's fantastic and I can see how these tracks could work very well on a live setting - especially if they jam the hell out of them.
However, I would have been much happier if these last tracks would've been developed further - a bit more space to hear the amazing instrumentality and musicianship going on. Or simply fleshing out the ideas further, and cut it as a 5 track EP -that would've been a strong comeback imo.
By far my biggest gripe is Cedric's voice and constant presence, non-stop for the full 45 minutes - I never really minded Cedric's vocals, actually loved it and always thought he did the most interesting melodies and hooks in the game - i understand how some people could never get into Mars Volta because his voice got on their nerves- from outside can be a bit grating especially during the Bedlam days - I dint' mind and actually think its brilliant and what makes me love TMV - I also didn't mind that live setting it was a completely different thing, he almost never hit the same amazing harmonies (or melodies for that matter) that are on the recorded album. But the Mars Volta live were a force to be reckoned with - Their live show and energy was undeniable - I never understood 10% of the lyrics but I could get pumped up when that 10 seconds of chorus came back after a crazy jam. and now... well --- Now there's No Light.... I can't for the life of me get excited about this music except maybe Equus 3 and two other tracks. The rest of the album just kind of felt like when someone wont stop talking to you during a concert and you just want to get lost in the music, the sounds-
The issue here is not so much with the pop format, the short songs or the "accessibility" of it all - I'd rather listen to a Mars Volta pop record these days than their 15 minute epics - So i was all for pop music, if its good, the issue is that Cedric is front and center, voice is doubled, always with same effects - NON-sTOP during the whole album - theres barely 10 seconds in the album when he's not singing - and tbh the melodies - they seem like he found this new flow for the pop format which I think is great - however he just keeps repeating the same idea in variations , all the while never even giving the music space to develop without singing on top of it. Its not till the end of the album that there is some space between his words and where the words actually feel like the melody and the emotion comes through. (again Equus 3 is a good example)
This is just my opinion, I must admit I was expecting to be slightly disappointed but listened to the 3 singles a lot in order to get myself in the groove - I'm def open to whatever they do next but I have a hard time getting pumped for the live show. I mean, if they play the first half of this record at all, I can't imagine anything other than a bored audience... the melodies and stuff are great but they aren't exactly stadium singing material - imagine 3k people trying to sing in the rap falsetto that covers this album... for 50 minutes straight. I just don't see any of these melodic ideas hitting the same without the crazy psicodelia, or the dub. It's still there - don't get me wrong, but the actual songrwiting, the vocal melodies - overwhelm the sounds --
I would've killed for a lo -fi defacto, downtempo record - but instead it feels like someone is shining a flashlight in your eyes when you are in the middle of a trip - its just in your face - its not subtle at all - Even a track like Vigil which i think is the worst they've done - they still have this atonal guitar noise just scraping your ear throug- i guess its so they show us they are still experimental, but it just doesn't work one way or another for me - its not good enough pop and its not good enough mars volta experimental dub action satisfaction for me.
All in all, still a huge fan, I will go see them live and support them - but if this would've been a 5 track EP I would've been 10x happier as that means they are still critical enough to cut out the fat - there are def 5 amazing tracks in there. but I guess they wanted to make a bolder statement. Atm it just seems they are too proud of some clever ideas they had but that dont quite work yet - I hope they keep going in this direction, but also I hope they remember what makes the Mars Volta TMV and not Omar Rodriguez Band - and I hope they understand that in trying not to be pretentious and make pop music they ended up looking and sounding a LOT more pretentious - I'd rather sing to most of their other stuff or even most punk like the Misfits have 10x better pop hooks - and you understand the feeling - here its dark lyrics with a mostly corny execution - so it doesn't hit (again, for the most part - some great tunes in here as well)
Rant over, thanks for reading.