EDIT #2: I recant some of my issues with the controller. After playing around with it a little more today, I have a different opinion: Size & weight are no longer an issue. I don't know what the hell my first impressions were based on there, it was 2am when I wrote that. I still don't like the button action on the face, but it's not terrible. It's worth mentioning that syncing the controller is mostly idiot proof, although i tried syncing it to my shield portable today and while it ended up working, there' s no obvious way to set it to a particular controller number (say if you want to use the built in one for 'player 1' on an emu, and the wireless one as 'player 2'), and while it did sync, the sync app actually never 'finished'. the device kept flashing and the screen kept saying 'device found, connecting...' or whatever. I had to close the sync app manually, but after that, it worked, sort of. I'm saying it seems to override the main controller, which is fine i suppose in some circumstances, but not others.
REGARDING MY OVERALL OPINION: Maybe some of you would have been less butthurt if I had said what I liked about the device first, or at all. I felt the pros were obvious and we wouldn't be here if we didn't see them, but whatever.
Liked: Top of the line 8" tablet for $300. There is a lot of horsepower under the hood there, and relatively speaking it's cheap as hell. It does all the gamestream stuff obviously, and generally speaking, it works like a charm. I am not saying this is a bad tablet, people.
Did not like:: Read the article. gripes about the controller aside, i still stand by what I said. These things are factual. It has manufacturing defects in the case, and the plastic cracks. The wifi has some kind of reception problem, although it remains to be seen whether the problems are hardware or software. There is no physical reason why it uses mini usb/hdmi ports, since the device's edge is thick enough to support the larger, more common ports. The screen is 16x10, which is annoying when you're dealing with 16x9 resolutions. I can only imagine they used the 16x10 screens because they got a better deal on them. In the end, I suspect every gripe boils down to cost cutting and i doubt nvidia is making a ton of profit on these devices. I'm ok with that, they need to make money to stay in business. But they are inconveniences and you can't just gloss over this stuff when it will impact usability. Some random dude is thinking about buying a tablet. they see all these cool features and benefits on the Sheild, but then realize they need to spend over $100 more in accessories to get the full use out of it? That feels like a bait and switch. And i haven't even touched the issue that it's basically impossible to order the magnetic case, and the wireless controllers are hard to come by too.
EDIT: Ok so a lot of people seem to be saying "you drew your own conclusions before buying" or "you didn't read the specs". I feel like this is a disingenuous argument. Let me explain:
First, I bought the shield portable on a lark two weeks ago after hearing many good things about it. The thing immediately impressed me. Good build quality, great features - I was pleased to say the least. So it's fair to say that I maybe incorrectly based my predisposition of the tablet on the quality of the portable. I know, different devices, different expectations. But what I was expecting was quality, period.
Secondly, the complaints themselves, are either with legitimate failings of the quality of the product (and are objectively bad, like the plastic, cracking corners or the terrible wifi reception), or, while spelled out in the specs, not exactly advertised: (black bars on the screen becuase the screen is 16x10 instead of 16x9), the complete lack of action in the face buttons on the controller). Could I have been better served by reading a little more about the device before buying? You bet. But my argument is i shouldn't have to. Half of these issues are QA issues, and the other half are the result of cost cutting. A few (like the plastic exterior) are a little of both.
I would have gladly paid twice the cost of this thing for a metal-encased, 802.11a/c, lte device (with no wifi problems), with full-sized ports and a 16x9 screen, build in magnetic cover, and an included controller. Gladly. Would everyone? Probably not. But that's why wireless carriers subsidize purchases. The same device with a two year contract could cost...wait for it...$400!
Anyway I guess the moral is i should've waited for the 2nd gen, lte version. sure. but you know what, I didn't, because i was really impressed with the original shield, and now i'm underwhelmed. That still doesn't make any of these issues less relevant to a new buyer. - one more point - had i seen this very post, i would've steered clear like you all said.
I really wanted to like this thing. Like, a lot. This was my first experience with an android tablet (and in fact the shield portable with an android device in general), and at first glance I was blown away. As tablet the thing runs like a dream. But after the initial impression wore off, the litany of little problems started to add up until I finally gave in and will be returning mine. Here's why.
First off, Full disclosure I got this to to do game steaming. I thought i was gonna get 1080p. whoops. Despite it's awesome performance as a tablet, that was really secondary as far as I'm concerned. I have tablets. I have a kindle. A kindle Fire (g1). An ipad 3. An iphone 5S. Tablets are covered around here.
I should mention i was skeptical from the get go of the form factor for what it purports to be. The Shield Portable works because of it's clamshell design, it opens and the angle between controller and screen are perfect, and the screen is exactly where it should be relative to the controller. With a tablet, this is immediately not the case. But after falling in love with the Portable I figured it was worth checking out. That controller looked pretty sweet. The magnetic case looks like it'll do the trick standing the device upright. Here's where the trouble began...
First, I get the Shield Wednesday. I totally did not realize it didn't come with the controller packed in. Yes yes this is my fault, but seriously, there's no bundle? And controllers are even harder to come by then the damn device itself! As for the magnetic case, I can't even find one online to order! they're all backordered...
Ok, so no controller, and no OTG cable, so I spent the first few days mucking around with tablet features, I downloaded Baldur's Gate HD to run native on the android (and btw that's great although occasionally crashes when tabbing out), and generally enjoyed the device. EXCEPT WHERE THE HELL IS THE AMAZON INSTANT VIDEO APP? That's an irritation but not a dealbreaker. Whatever.
I eagerly anticipate getting the controller, which arrives today. I was immediately let down. The thing feels like a MadCatz special. It's too light IMO.The face buttons have no action to them - they don't depress! I mean, the a/b/x/y buttons do, but what passes for start/back, the hub launch button, volume...they're all strictly touch, and frankly, WAYYYY to sensitive. Brushing them gently sets them off. This is a problem, especially for a $60 controller. Even with the x/y/a/b buttons, the action is all wrong. the analog sticks are good, but that's all I like.
With the controller, the ergonomics issue rears its ugly head. Even if i could set the device up with a stand, I would be hunched over to play it. But what I really want to do is play it in bed while chilling out for the evening. No dice. What works naturally with the portable just isn't possible here.
Then there are the problems with the tablet itself.
It's plastic. ugh. all the people complaining about it coming apart - i can totally see this happening. This thing just feels too delicate.
NO 802.11a/c - I just found THIS out today, and because of that, no 1080p streaming via wifi! This is of course true for the Portable but on a 4.5" screen it's not so big a deal. Which leads me to...
**2.1: MAJOR RECEPTION PROBLEMS ** Regardless of the wifi tech built in, there is a major problem with the wifi itself. I get what appears to be half the signal on the Tablet compared to the portable in the exact same location! Imagine what that does to streaming. Speaking of streaming...
3. No 1080P streaming without a dongle for wired network! For the native-res, 1200p screen this is atrocious. Also btw did i mention black bars? Yeah we got them too.
4. No full-size USB port, no full size HDMI port. for a device that has a big enough bezel to support them in principal, this doesn't make sense.
5. There's a sim card slot that is totally useless. Because apparently there will be a LTE model coming later. Lazy.
6. The power and volume buttons are shit. This has been said a lot. they really do suck. This seems to be the case with a lot of android devices though. I don't get it.
7. This is more a personal preference thing, but lots of glossy, fingerprintable plastic surfaces. No likey.
8. lastly: battery life. I don't know what to say here. it's not that good. the thing drains quick IMO. I can get many more hours out of my portable vs. this thing.
Anyway, Overall This device feels half baked, smacks of cost-cutting to get it under the $300 price point, and has a couple of really terrible flaws built in that seem to really ruin the experience for me - the cheap plastic exterior, and the obvious problems wifi reception being the major ones.
Like I said, I really wanted to like this device. If they fix the wifi and build problems, and improve the controller (and hey, maybe make a bundle so hunting down controllers isn't such a problem), this could be a really, really cool device - a real laptop replacement for gamers who just need basic web stuff aside from their gaming. But v1 of the shield tablet, I'm gonna have to give it a reluctant DO NOT BUY
Wait for the LTE model, or V2, if it's not the same thing. In any case, wait till they fix the manufacturing process, which hopefully means metal exteriors and solid wifi reception. Or better yet, get the Shield Portable. That thing is seriously the bees knees. Functionally it is the same thing, yes, the cpu isn't quite in the same class, but my experience has been it's just as zippy and more ergonomic. And at least the portable has a good reason for the smaller ports.
Again, sorry for the wall of text. And sorry for killing everybody's puppy, but it had to be said. This thing is currently a $400 (lets be real, you need the controller & the case) waste of money in its current incarnation. If you're not super careful your device will be cracked in months if not weeks, at the very least.
Nvidia, get this thing together! I've had a taste, I really want one now, but i want it to not suck! I also wouldn't mind a slightly larger form factor for a tablet, tbh. I guess this is due to my previous ipad experience, but 8" feels too small. And while we're at it, can we just get a normal, 16x9, 1080p screen, instead of this 16x10, black bar monstrosity you're using now? kthx.