I felt obliged to make this post today because this subreddit was hugely valuable to me and my wife in the last year. Throwaway account.
***Some things I say here may go against the beliefs or value systems of some readers. If I say anything hurtful, please know I didn't intend to. This was my experience. And my wife's.***
TLDR; TFMR 2/14/25, Healthy Baby delivered 12/15/25 + a warning about genetic testing
On February 5 of last year we had our 20 week anatomy scan. I remember joking with the US tech, talking about what we were seeing on the screen. I remember - specifically - not wondering why the US tech would leave the room for long stretches of time. I remember not wondering why she was so persistent about getting better images of the spine. I remember joking around with my wife when they moved us into a room with a zoom call set up. There was a box of tissues in that room. We took a picture of ourselves on the zoom screen while we waited for the doctor to join the call. I came across that picture in my wife's camera roll months later and it was like I was looking at a different version of myself.
The doctor was very direct. He said that he had very serious news, that the baby had Spina Bifida, quite severe. I remember looking at my wife and (she confirmed this) simultaneously being fully sure that this guy on the screen had mistaken us for some other parents, some other miserable people. Things like this didn't happen to us. It sounds horrible to say, but that's what we thought. We sort of protested and the doctor demonstrated for us what he was seeing. The water on the skull, the banana-shape signature at the back of the skull, the open spine.
I don't really remember leaving the office. Somehow I drove us to another office where we waited in a room for a while and the doctor who we had seen on the zoom call was now in person with us. My wife signed an amnio consent, they did the draw with the big needle. I think she was crying. We hadn't called our parents yet who, respectively, had been promised their usual ultrasound pictures. We talked about the options. UCSF has some of the best neonatal surgeons, they could try to repair the spine in utero. It's not as risky as it used to be, there are success stories.
Our diagnosis was fairly grim. We talked about quality of life. No feeling or mobility below the waist, colostomy bag, multiple surgeries a year - potentially - during childhood as shunts need to be replaced to align with growth and development. We were listening closely, considering the changes we would need to make in our lives, in the infrastructure of our lives. We live in the woods, house sort of perched on a cliff, the bedrooms are down a flight of stairs. A HELOC might allow us to build a bedroom upstairs, or facilitate some way of getting a wheelchair downstairs. It was a Wednesday. We left with some pamphlets, referrals to the UC Davis and UCSF neonatal clinics.
We finally called our moms from the car. My wife's mother, a lifelong nurse - her reaction brought some clarity for me. She gasped and began to cry, and I finally understood what we were dealing with.
I don't really remember the drive home. I remember eventually ceding the wheel to my wife when we were close to home and letting myself cry in the passenger seat. My wife wouldn't stop weeping. She said she could feel him kick.
In bed at night, we could feel him kick. After that first day, my wife was confident that we would terminate. She cried and cried and did not make the decision lightly, but she was sure. I waffled. I spent time exploring what a Spina Bifida diagnosis means. At times I was pretty gung ho about making a go of it. There are resources, grant programs. We'd have to sell our house and move closer to a city with medical resources. We would spend a lot of time in hospitals, but we could do it.
It was a long weekend. Somehow (this just occurred to me the other day) we watched the Super Bowl at my in-laws's house? I can't recall even being there, but I know I saw the halftime show live. I do remember that my chest was always in my throat. People kept coming to our house, bearing food. Sometimes they would deliver it without even stopping in. I'd go outside and find a bag of tamales or homemade lasagna. It felt like things were being decided. I remember going for a long run and stopping in the woods and crying for like twenty minutes and walking home because I was too dehydrated to run back.
At night, my wife asked me to hold her belly, so she wouldn't be the only one to feel him kick. I felt him and I cried and cried.
It occurred to me, the more I read about Spina Bifida, and these gray diagnoses in general, that I didn't see a lot of representation of adults with these afflictions. There are nonprofits, conferences, events, success stories, stories of bravery, overcoming the odds, Paralympic wins, but these didn't represent the day to day experience. What did a day in the life of an adult with Spina Bifida look like. I kept exploring.
In grad school I took some classes in Disability Studies. I love the concept of ability being a spectrum that reflects the degree of care with which a society is willing to endow its most vulnerable. Or, put simply, if only 1 percent of humans needed shoes, the necessity of having shoes would be considered a disability. The solution, Disability Studies theorists propose, is immense care. Care that goes beyond the needs of the most but which extends to the needs of the few.
This was just a few months after Donald Trump was re-elected. We live in a hard world. We live in a world where the president of the United States can mock a reporter with disabilities and get re-elected. We live in a mean culture. We live in a culture of cowards, punching down.
I thought about my own childhood. I was popular as a kid. I had friends. I had girlfriends. At the same time, it felt hard. I had acne, an awkward year where my braces caused a nearly tooth-sized gap between my front two teeth. Everything is so serious when you're young. I considered my son getting his first crush on some cute person in his class. And I thought about the cumbersome infrastructure of disability. The wheelchair, colostomy bag. And that person not seeing him. Seeing just the synecdoche. The wheelchair kid. A person defined by the most painful aspect of their being.
I thought about the rhythm of the surgeries, as they had been outlined by our doctor. It occurred to me that surgeries are hugely painful, recovery complex. On forums online for adults with Spina Bifida, I read stories about sepsis, about infected ports, kafkaesque insurance debacles, humbling negotiations with government assistance programs, with housing, the physical infrastructure of housing, getting an apartment, a job.
I thought about being a teenager and getting your first crush and knowing that your penis will never work. Not even knowing everything about sex but understanding that something fundamental is missing, something that, culturally, we perceive as integral to Love and to our capacity to be loved.
I have to put a big parenthesis here: I believe that full lives are being lived today by people with Spina Bifida, and with other so-called (because we don't have a better metric!) disabilities. I also believe that my wife and I were better equipped than most to support someone with Spina Bifida. We have a good income, stable lives, a loving marriage with excellent communication skills. I don't want to propose that a life with Spina Bifida cannot be a full life. The metrics need to shift. The word Brave has been washed of any meaning by the easy way we apply to to any affliction that we ourselves can't imagine enduring. Is it Brave if you don't have a choice? Well, yes. What else can it be? The people who make a full life without some critical aspect of what our culture expects of a full life requires the ability to create a brand new, personal metric for what a full life even means. If someone is reading this who has a disability, or who has a loved one who has a disability, certainly that person is brave, and certainly they are a full person, with a full life.
I will spare you all the details of the termination, because either they are familiar to you, or you will have learned about them elsewhere on this subreddit. I will only say that the care we received was top notch. We also have a community of people who love us and who took care of us and were quick to set aside any doubt about making the "right choice."
We came home, we cried and cried and didn't sleep and they gave us his footprints. My father in law had been building a crib. A few weeks later, he delivered to us a small box. Made from pieces of what would have been the crib. I cried because it reminded me of a coffin.
I read the Robert Hass poem On Squaw Peak
On Squaw Peak
I don't even know which sadness
it was came up
in me when we were walking down the road to Shirley Lake,
the sun gleaming in snowpatches,
the sky so blue it seemed the light's dove
of some pentecost of blue,
the mimulus, yellow, delicate of petal,
and the pale yellow cinquefoil trembling in the damp
air above the creek,--
and fields of lupine,
the blue blaze of lupine, a swath of paintbrush
sheening it, and so much of it, long meadows
of it gathered out of the mountain air and spilling
down ridge toward the lake it almost looked like
in the wind. I think I must have thought
the usual things: that the flowering season
in these high mountain meadows is so brief, that
the feeling, something like hilarity, of sudden
pleasure when you first come across some tough little plant
you knew you'd see comes because it seems -- I mean
by "it" the larkspur of penstemon curling
arching the reach of its sexual being
up out of a little crack in granite -- to say
that human hunger has a niche up here in the light-cathedral
of the dazzled air. I wanted to tell you
that when the ghost-child died, the three-month dreamer
she and I would never know, I kept feeling that
the heaven it went to was like the inside of a store window
on a rainy day from which you watch the blurred forms
passing in the street. Or to tell you, more terrible,
that when she and I walked off the restlessness
of our misery afterward in the Coast Range hills,
we saw come out of the thicket shyly
a pure white doe. I wanted to tell you I knew
it was a freak of beauty like the law of averages
that killed our child and made us know, as you had said,
that things between lovers, even of longest standing,
can be botched in their bodies, though their wills don't fail.
Still later, on the beach, we watched the waves.
No two the same size. No two in the same arch
of rising up and pouring. But it is the same law.
You shell a pea, there are three plump seeds and one
that's shriveled. You shell a bushelful and you begin
to feel the rhythm of the waves at Limantour,
glittering, jagged, that last bright October afternoon.
It killed something in me, I thought, or froze it,
to have to see where beauty comes from. I imagined
for a long time that the baby, since
it would have liked to smell our clothes to know
what a mother and father would have been,
hovered sometime in our closet and I half expected
to see it there, half-fish spirit, form of tenderness,
a little dead dreamer with open eyes. That was
private sorrow. I tried not to hate my life,
to fear the frame of things. I knew what two people
couldn't say
on a cold November morning in the fog --
you remember the feel of Berkeley winter mornings --
what they couldn't say to each other
was the white deer not seen. It meant to me
that beauty and terror were intertwined so powerfully
and went so deep that any kind of love
can fail. I didn't say it. I think the mountain startled
my small grief. Maybe there wasn't time.
We may have been sprinting to catch the tram
because we had to teach poetry
in that valley two thousand feet below us.
You were running -- Steven's mother, Michael's lover,
mother and lover, grieving, of a girl
about to leave for school and die to you a little
(or die into you, or simply turn away)--
and you ran like a gazelle,
in purple underpants, royal purple,
and I laughed out loud. It was the abundance
the world gives, the more-than-you-bargained-for
surprise of it, waves breaking,
the sudden fragrance of the mimulus at creekside
sharpened by the summer dust.
Things bloom up there. They are
for their season alive in the bright vanishings
of air we ran through.
I thought about the pea in its pod, the tiny fish-spirit. We would open the box and kiss his footprints, which are perfect. To me they looked huge, but really they are tiny. They told us that his body would be used in research, I can't remember, stem cells. You shell a pea, there are three plump seeds and one / that's shriveled.
But here I have to say something else that might be controversial: A friend, who endured something nearly identical, was admonished by a mutual bridesmaid in a wedding. The other bridesmaid had brought along her 18 month-old daughter, who was on oxygen, bloated and mottled, wasn't expected to live to three years. This mother told my friend that she had made a selfish decision as a mother. (My friend replied, "good thing I don't respect your opinion because that might have hurt my feelings.") In the past year, I've come to believe that parents who choose to terminate do so out of love and compassion, in an endeavor (a very parental endeavor) to take all of their child's pain on as their own. The parents who choose not to terminate, sometimes (SOMETIMES!) do so selfishly. And their child endures pain because the parent could not endure it.
At some point, the amnio results came back. Not genetic. It was a fluke. My wife got a prescription for lots of folic acid and took it diligently.
She wanted to try again right away, so we did, right after I got back from a conference, the first time we had been apart since the termination, late March. The next cycle we were pregnant again. We found out exactly two months after the termination. April 14, also our wedding anniversary. We told our immediate families right away, but decided not to tell anyone else until we got through the 20 week scan.
Here is where things got complicated. I went on a bachelor trip with a friend. When I got back, I went on a long run. I got a text from my wife: COME HOME NOW.
I called her and she was crying. "It's happening again," she said.
I told her to meet me at the nearest road and I got in the car and she filled me in.
During the initial stages of this second pregnancy, we had opted in to a vast spread of NIPT genetic screens. I think this is standard these days. For some reason I (mistakenly?) assumed that the vast array of screenings we got were a consequence of our previous pregnancy. Since, I've learned that this is standard these days.
What had happened was this: the NIPT had indicated for trisomies 14 and 22.
That night, we found ourselves back in that helpless cycle of googling and worrying and crying, and we were back on this subreddit.
This was a Thursday. I'm fairly certain because some time that evening I found this incredible piece in the nytimes.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/01/upshot/pregnancy-birth-genetic-testing.html
To summarize, these tests are new, and expansive, and are often wrong. They have high rates of accuracy for common chromosomal abnormalities like T21. But for rarer trisomies, they are wrong as often as 90% of the time. I wish someone had told us this.
I remember this was a Thursday because these two trisomies are incompatible with life, generally. The idea that both could occur simultaneously, and that the fetus would still have a heartbeat, would significantly boost the likelihood that we are among the many who have found themselves in the prevalence of false positives. I do understand, scientifically, the difference between an indication and a diagnosis, but god, how fucking mean. Anyway we called our OB over and over and they made a last-minute appointment for us and sure enough, a heartbeat!
So we waited and waited. We couldn't let ourselves relax. Not in our natures. The amnio would resolve the question of whether there was a trisomy, or two of them, but they couldn't do the draw until 14 weeks. So we waited. During this time is the most busy period of my work life. It's a crazy, fun time, with a lot of people who we love coming around and my wife had to hide her bump the whole time, demure at the offered glass of wine, and, in mid summer in Northern California, wear baggy clothes. It was a hard time.
Mercifully, the amnio came back and all was well. Our 20 week scan came and we made the early morning drive full of dread and grief and anticipation and it went just fine. Like everyone else's. We went to in-n-out, and home goods and costco and had a nice day. We settled.
Back in February of last year, my wife's boss, a wonderful goof, girl dad, came and brought us food. He and his wife had gone through something similar. More like a miscarriage I suspect, but we never landed on it. He said, crying, "It's like, people who haven't been here aren't complete people."
I know that sounds mean, but I keep coming back to that.
Absence - I propose, amateur philosopher that I am - is not a lack, but an addition to yourself. When you lose somebody, you don't lose a part of yourself, as the saying goes, you actually gain an absence, while the rest of you stays the same. In other words, you grow. You gain empathy reserves you didn't know you had. You start to pay more attention to the pain of others, to not gloss over painful experience, but to live in them for a minute.
I know that nobody can understand. Even on this subreddit, there is a diversity of stories, many more painful than ours. I want to say that because of this, I am slightly better equipped to feel your pain. I'm sorry I wasn't able to before.
So now the good part. Our daughter was born two months ago, healthy, beautiful. Our first kid. She is beautiful and engaging. Sometimes she wears these pants that were gifted to us last Christmas. They were a gift for someone else. It makes me sad. But it is not her fault or her problem. I don't know when we will tell her. It isn't her problem. She looks cute in those pants.
Today, we went on a walk with our dog in the woods behind our house, a two mile loop. We cried and talked, and agreed that I should make a post, because a year ago, we read every post on this subreddit, multiple times. THANK YOU, by the way, to everyone who has posted here, and to the mods. You are wonderful people. We had this walk, with our dog and with our daughter on my chest. We remembered the drive home a year ago, how anxious we were, how the decision felt too grand and cosmic for our humble equipment. We made a decision, we took his pain and made it our own. He still sits in his box on our shelf. We called him Spud and we love him. We opened his box and kissed his footprints today.
I hope this helps somebody.