r/tf2au • u/Al_Rascala • Dec 20 '09
Spawn-camping.
During a time when there were many redditors on the NSW server, a vote was held on the subject of spawn-camping. The idea that it should be banned on the server came out on top, so after discussing it with Strelok, we came up with the idea that First time is a warning, second is a kick, third offense is a ban.
Edit: For anyone asking for me to define spawn-camping, see my replies to LambtheRock and Koushiro.
Edit the second: Well, it seems Reddit has spoken. Spawn-camping stays. Democracy and all that.
11
u/WatchDogx Dec 20 '09
I dont think it should be banned, in fact id like to see less moderation in general, the other day my friend got kicked from the passworded server because an admin didnt recognize him, even though he has quite a few hours on the stats.
11
Dec 20 '09
Yeah, they were inviting people in just to ban/kick them; some poeple have been pretty swift to kick/ban people. Or ban/kick them because they don't like them...
I prefer a more open community. I don't not like anybody who I've played with since the QLD server's incarnation, obviously I like some people over others but I don't hate anybody (except Mr Popo and his arrows) infact I like the majority of people.
I don't mean to stir shit up but some people need to chill the fuck out. No need to ban people because they abused you a bit, I mean I abuse:
AoW for being a ninja heavy
Monkey for reflecting every possible projectile I shoot/throw (cover me in my own piss why don't you)
Strelok for, recently, sword raping me
TJ for being bad (at least in the past, he's quite annoying as scout now)
et cetera
I'd only kick/ban people for:
Racism
Microphone spam (after a few warnings)
Abusing people (overly, like "...fucking cunt why didn't you fucking heal me. You fucking mother must have been fucked up on herion to have had you you nigger fuck..." - I heard this on another server recently; he was banned by the admin there)
Not healing specific people (I didn't mind not healing demos, or not healing soldiers during the WAR! I mean it's all part of fun)
et cetera
Long post, hmmm. I think I'm trying to say; be fun.
2
1
u/mrmarcel Dec 20 '09
I agree with laconix, and seen people being let in just to be banned.
I'd say less trying to control the server, and more playing TF2. :)
0
u/TJ_FS Dec 21 '09
TJ for being bad (at least in the past, he's quite annoying as scout now)I'll take this as a compliment?
1
1
9
Dec 20 '09
I think this is going to be a very difficult rule to administer.
You can't have a blanket ban on it. How would you even play dustbowl with that rule. It's not just dustbowl, a fair portion of tf2 maps have spawn camping as part of the map design.
So considering that there won't be a blanket ban on it. It comes down to an individual opinion on whats acceptable and what isn't. Some circumstances it's ok and in others it's not. I'm sorry but I don't see how that can work and be fair to everyone.
You guys can do what you want. But banning spawn camping is not something I can agree with.
7
Dec 20 '09 edited Dec 20 '09
I think I'd be forced to stop playing with you guys... I'd be banned within the first week.
Seriously, I think it extremely fun (for me) to get overhealed on badwater double sticky jump to the other side of the map, walk the rest of the way and then wait for RED to respawn then move in for the camp. They can easily get out with a dead ringer spy and once we cap the second point there are 2 more ways to leave spawn.
I think spawn camping is fine, it just requires the other team to stop doing the same old shit.
Counters to spawn camping:
Bonk invlun
Medic healing
Medic kritz
Medic uber
Dead ringer
I've seen BLU win on Dustbowl stage 2 because RED (my team) were spawn camping them and they decided they'd get a couple dead ringer / bonk scouts we ignored them and the capped both points before we could catch up.
tl;dr, don't ban it; adapt.
7
u/xrobau Dec 20 '09 edited Dec 20 '09
I'm not for it. Spawn camping is a valid tactic. Maps are DESIGNED for this, and they're not that hard to get around.
Edit: And looking at the comment votes, everyone else seems to think that spawncamping is fine. We we camping on the second stage of goldrush a couple of days ago, a spy snuck past us, and killed US ALL. We all congratulated the spy, it was exceptionally well played.
6
u/alphabeat Dec 20 '09
I'm of the "tactic" camp. Ubers, dead ringers etc. Just change your strategy.
2
u/LambtheRock Dec 21 '09
So everyone seems to be ok with spawncamping, saying it's easy to break out of. If it wasn't such a big problem, why is their a topic on it?
I think it's important for people to realise that getting spawncamped is not fun. The Reddit servers are not pugs or clan servers, where spawn camping is sometimes essential to winning a game. We're not here to be forced inside spawn, waiting for an uber that might not even work, while people ragequit left and right.
Spawn camping is a matter of being polite. It's like going 'oh gee, I really need to fart and I could totally just do it now but I'll be polite and do it somewhere away from people'.
Think about it the next time you go to camp - is it essential for your team to win? Is you enemy organised enough to break out of it without wasting ten minutes? Will they all rage quit, not bothering to break out of it?
Ah well. I don't heal spawn campers either way, and you'll cop an earful from me if you do it. I don't care who you are - spawn camping is not a nice thing to do, and is just not fun for the other team.
1
u/Al_Rascala Dec 22 '09
This. This is exactly what I was going for. Thank you, for articulating it much better than I could have.
5
u/Managore Dec 20 '09
Hmm, I don't think spawncamping should have a penalty, unless the spawncamping team is ignoring the objective (e.g. BLU team spawncamping on a attack/defense map without attempting to cap or push the cart).
Most maps are well designed enough so that if one team is spawn camping the teams are already vastly, vastly unbalanced. Sticking with attack/defense maps, the BLU spawn area usually has enough entrances so that it's almost impossible to spawncamp them, and the RED spawn is usually located behind the objective, so if BLU is spawncamping RED they've practically already won. When BLU is being spawncamped in maps such as Goldrush stage 2, working as a team should be enough to break the spawncamping (some bonk scouts, some heavies being healed by medics and some pyro/demo/soldier spam can break through almost anything). If the whole team runs out one at a time and doesn't try to work together at all they almost deserve to lose.
2
u/LambtheRock Dec 20 '09
Define spawncamping first of all - if we go with the statement that spawncamping means staying right in front of spawn and attacking constantly then RED team will always be banned on maps such as Badwater.
Does spawncamping also count for the Spy that manages to get to spawn and pick off the lone person who just spawned? The Scout that runs to get the teles and kill the Snipers camping on top of Goldrush spawn?
What about the good old Ninjaneer that manages to ninja past everyone on the final of Goldrush. You know, like Frugle and I always do? Cause god knows if an Engie can get past you and set up you deserve that :3
I'm not saying I approve of spawn campers (looking at you Demo sticky spamming scum), just trying to get this as detailed as possible to prevent any arguments or loopholes (Gravelpit anyone?).
2
u/koushiro Dec 20 '09
Yeah, that's a good point. I can't define it, but I know it when I see it, to coin a phrase. Unless someone can come up with a good set of standards -- and with all the variables involved I can't think of a rule much better than "Are people spawning being given a fair chance to engage with the people attacking them?" -- I think it'll just come down to a case-by-case basis.
0
u/Al_Rascala Dec 20 '09
That's a pretty good rule, I think. Something like sticky-camping would be right out, something like defending the first part of the cart pretty much wouldn't. There's usually at least one or two admins on the server whenever there's a game on, so it most likely wouldn't come down to one individuals choice anyway.
Have an upvote, good sir.2
Dec 21 '09
Bonk. Dead Ringer. Uber. Sacrificial Heavy. Any team can break out of a stickied spawn, if they have any kind of communication.
2
0
u/Al_Rascala Dec 20 '09
Something like the demo sticky-camping, or a medic and two heavies just waiting outside the door. Things like badwater, where there're multiple exits and a wide-open space wouldn't be camping, IMO, or someone running around, getting a kill, and running off to kill others. But getting yourself nice and comfy outside the spawn door, when there's only one exit, is spawn-camping. And for the record, I think ninjaneering (Like you and frugle always do) should count as well, but if I'm out-voted on that then I will admit defeat on the matter.
Also, nice to see you reddit :)1
u/Corasian Dec 20 '09
I was actually wondering how to define what spawn camping was since yesterday someone accused me of spawn camping on cp_gorge when I was on red which went against my definition of spawn camping since they did have adequate chance to kill me but I was moving around outside their spawn killing them as they left.
1
u/takatori Dec 20 '09
What's "ninjaneering"?
1
u/Corasian Dec 20 '09 edited Dec 20 '09
its when you do stealth stuff with the engie like get behind the other team without them noticing
3
u/takatori Dec 20 '09
To me this sounds like playing the game better than the other team and being penalized for it.
1
u/koushiro Dec 20 '09
Ninjaneering in general refers to playing offensive engineer, and setting up in surprising places. In this case, we're talking about specifically the third stage of Goldrush -- if an BLU engineer can sneak past the front lines (or blatantly run through with an uber) then he can set up camp outside RED's unused secondary spawn doors, which RED is forced to deal with once BLU caps the first point.
3
u/takatori Dec 20 '09
So how is a problem? If he manages to sneak in there doesn't he deserve to reap the rewards of success?
As with spawncamping, the spawning players can uber up or go over to spy and take him out.
2
u/koushiro Dec 20 '09
Personally, I don't have a problem with it; it's annoying, but it's risky to do and it's not usually a huge problem unless they build a tele and three or more engineers set up there -- and that's less of a spawncamping problem than it is a mass-engineer problem.
Like I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, the only real problem I have with spawncamping is when you're not able to fairly engage with the person who's killing you -- e.g. one or more demos stickycarpeting the spawn exit and detonating from a safe distance, or snipers scoping the doors. Heavy-medic combos (and their ilk) standing in front of the doors are annoying, but you can at least deal with them head-on.
2
u/takatori Dec 20 '09
I understand the frustration, but take the challenge as part of the game and change my strategy to counter it.
Anyway thanks for the info & opinion!
4
u/PortConflict Dec 20 '09
But define 'Spawn Camping'. In the payload maps, thats what the defensive team does at the first part, is spawn camp to prevent the blues from advancing to the cart. In a CP map, I can understand how its annoying though.
So, one rule for one set of maps, another for the rest? Nah.
1
u/_chendo Dec 20 '09
Don't do it, change your strat. As said by most of the other comments in this thread
1
1
u/koushiro Dec 20 '09
"It's a legitimate tactic!"
But seriously, I think this is a good call and a good system for punishing it. Most maps are pretty good and have a reasonably-sized safe area outside spawn, but on those that don't -- BLU spawn on Goldrush stage 2 and RED spawn on Cranetop stage 1 (sorry, Al!) come to mind -- it's incredibly frustrating if even one or two people are doing it.
1
-3
Dec 20 '09
That's fair. The same could apply to other rules too, i.e 3 warnings for mic spam etc.
-3
u/Al_Rascala Dec 20 '09
I think we should institute it. And use both text and sound for the warnings, just to be safe.
-1
u/rmccue Dec 20 '09
Good idea.
5
Dec 20 '09
Bad idea.
1
u/rmccue Dec 20 '09
I meant the second part. Just sound warnings can be misheard. Or not heard at all.
Eh Strelok? :P
11
u/takatori Dec 20 '09 edited Dec 20 '09
I've never heard a decent explanation of what's wrong with executing this tactic.
If you're lucky and skilled enough to get past the other team's defenses and manage to get to their spawn, it's up to them to fight back and dislodge you.
This isn't like some other games where spawncamping consists of killing players the instant they appear. TF2 has protected spawn rooms just in order to prevent spawncamping from becoming griefing--the spawning players always have options to fight back and time to plan their approach.
I've never seen an incident of "spawncamping" that couldn't be countered by decent teamplay on the part of those respawning.
Easy counters: wait for spawning medic to uber up, then rush the camper; a spy can slip out cloaked after someone else triggers the camper's stickies; dead ringer; scouts can escape using Bonk then circle around to take out the camper; everyone wait and rush together.