r/teslore • • Oct 11 '25

Is there any trans representation in TES?

44 Upvotes

I know Vivec is also intersex but I don’t know any trans representation.


r/teslore • • May 30 '22

Lavender shouldn't be in Skyrim

12 Upvotes

So, this is pretty inconsequential but here goes. Lavender and all of it's subspecies grow in dry, arid areas of our world. They thrive in hot environments with low nutrient, sandy soil and they don't like moisture at all. So, Lavender in skyrim is most commonly found in the grasslands of Midwest skyrim. The soil is likely not very sandy and is probably too rich in nutrients. The main point here though is the temperature. Even the grasslands of skyrim are likely far too cold for Lavender to thrive as it does there. So, Skyrim just isn't the right climate for Lavender to grow. And yet it does


r/teslore • • Jan 13 '24

Who else is queer?

33 Upvotes

I found out Pelinal Whitestrake was queer, and I was wondering (excluding Vivek and the gay couple in the Dragonborn dlc) who else is queer?


r/teslore • • Jul 26 '25

Why are there no fat people in Tamriel?

0 Upvotes

Since at least Oblivion and Skyrim, we have muscular or frail as physiques. But I cannot recall a single fat or obese person, not even in paintings. Ulfric’s model looks a bit stocky, and some guards have a more round shape but I assume this is the clothes more than their bodies.

I’m sure I’ve missed them, but this is a genuine question— are there any fat people in Tamriel?


r/teslore • • May 13 '25

Is siding with the Stormcloaks a spit in the face to those who died defending the Empire during the Obvlion Crisis?

1 Upvotes

With so many new audiences discovering the Oblivion Crisis for the first time, I feel this question is particularly relevant to those who only played Skyrim before. If yes, this really applies to all sacrifices for the Empire.

I have long sided with the Empire, with much of my argument based on the legacy, divine nature, and righteousness of it all. These people fought to defend all of Tamriel, and did it largely in defence of the Empire and Emperor that they cherished. Despite this valiance, the stormcloaks choose to aid in the destruction of it.

Would love to hear what you guys think!


r/teslore • • Mar 11 '25

was Numidium inspired by Evangelion?

0 Upvotes

r/teslore • • Jun 15 '25

Questions about the code of Malacath’s views on same sex relationships and other LBGTQ matters

14 Upvotes

Elder scrolls is famous it (being based) very open to LGBTQ acceptance in both games and lore, so this question is not an accusation of it not being that, but a curiosity on how exactly the code of malacath works with those things.

I have several questions concerning the code, based on the stronghold governance.

1: can a transmasc person become chief? Is there demands for someone to b AMAB to be chief?

2: can women and men have same sex relationships within the stronghold? Does the code only police relationships between a man and woman?

3: does the after life of the Ashpit make a change and exception for those who have different orientations? What would an Aroace orc get in the ashpit since he wouldn’t have much interest in 100 other partners?


r/teslore • • Dec 06 '24

The Empire is just as bad as Thalmor?

0 Upvotes

I think this could be controversial so I urge people to not fight in the comments. Now, I'm not a lore head so feel free to share your knowledge and educate me. I see the empire as a similar thing to the Macedonian empire and Tiber Septim as Alexander the great. Conquering the land left and right. The empire is this ambiguous thing in the series that is constant and is often not critiqued. Because the evil Thalmor is at war with the empire and seeks domination and control. But like... Isn't it exactly what happened before? The provinces were established nations of people with their own governments before they were forcefully taken over (some of them violently some diplomatically but still) It's kind of like a fall of the empire, non of them are eternal after all. History repeating itself and all that


r/teslore • • Dec 31 '25

Why Ulfric is (painfully) right, and the Empire just can't win.

0 Upvotes

A lot of Skyrim Civil War discourse assumes there’s going to be a “Second Great War” where the Empire finally gets its act together and beats the Aldmeri Dominion. But that idea kind of falls apart if you actually look at what the First Great War’s ending meant. The White-Gold Concordat wasn’t a temporary truce or a draw; it final, devastating loss. It was the end of the Empire of Man.

The Empire accepted foreign ideological demands, and agreed to let Thalmor agents operate inside its borders to enforce those demands. That’s not a truce, that’s a surrender. Not even a conditional one, because the Empire didn't set any conditions, it was the Dominion who imposed theirs.

The biggest red flag is the Thalmor Justiciars. A sovereign state doesn’t let foreign death squads roam around arresting, torturing, and executing its own citizens with basically no oversight. The Empire isn’t just constrained by the Dominion; it actively enforces Dominion ideology against its own people. At that point, calling the Empire “independent” is more of a legal fiction than a reality.

People also tend to assume the Thalmor are just waiting for Round Two, trying to weaken the Empire, but their behavior doesn’t support that. They’re not gearing up for another big conventional war. Religious suppression, ideological control, encouraging internal conflict, etc. all point to an occupation strategy, not a pause before renewed fighting. The Talos ban isn’t just religious; Talos is a symbol of humans successfully telling the elves to get bent. Erasing him weakens the very idea of human resistance.

The Empire can’t openly rearm, reform, or unify without violating the Concordat, and the moment it tries, the Thalmor are already inside it to shut it down. Like Vichy France, the Empire survives by collaborating, and collaboration removes any internal path back to real sovereignty.

There's also the very real possibility that Amaund Motierre is the final nail in the coffin for the idea of a sovereign Empire, as he very well could be the Thalmor's puppet, their very own Petain.

Consider how perfectly Motierre’s scheme aligns with Thalmor interests. Titus Mede II, for all his compromises, is at least someone who understands the Dominion is an existential threat and who might resist if the opportunity arose. Removing him creates chaos, delegitimizes the throne, and almost guarantees a succession crisis... exactly the kind of instability the Thalmor benefit from. You don’t need Motierre to be a mustache-twirling traitor; it’s enough that his actions objectively serve Aldmeri goals.

And like Vichy collaborators, Motierre can plausibly believe he’s “saving the Empire” by sacrificing its last vestiges of autonomy. Killing the Emperor could be framed as damage control: remove a liability, appease external power, preserve a managed remnant of Imperial authority. Whether or not he’s consciously a Thalmor agent, the result is the same: the Empire becomes even more hollow, more dependent, and more incapable of independent action.

Seen this way, Ulfric ends up being kind of correct, even if he’s personally awful and politically messy. I DON'T LIKE HIS ETHNO-NATIONALISTIC POLITICS. But you don’t have to like him to see the point he’s making: an Empire that enforces Thalmor law and persecutes its own citizens isn’t worth saving. His rebellion isn’t clean, smart, or inclusive, but it is a refusal to pretend the Empire is still a real, independent power.

The reason the game never seriously lays out a plan for a Second Great War is probably because, in-universe, there isn’t one. The Empire already lost anything worth keeping, and the Skyrim Civil War is essentially arguing over what comes after.


r/teslore • • Jul 04 '23

So... What's special about Altmer?

5 Upvotes

From my casual understanding of the lore there's 2 races that really stick out as being extremely boring: Bretons and Altmer.

I've been told already that Breton are pretty much as bland as it gets in terms of fantasy so I'm not even going to bother with them.

But what about Altmer?

Nords from the lore were this nation of strong barbarians who could bring down castle walls with "shouts";

Redguards came from a continent that sunk into the ocean and have weird sand magic stuff;

Imperials... Actually now that I think about it what the hell makes them special? I'm pretty sure the only thing they had going for them was that "cyrodill is a jungle" but that's out the window so...

Dunmer are weird enough that some people genuinely believe their lore was written on a single week, during a sleepless amphetamine binge;

Argonians have the whole hist, sithis thing going for them;

Khajiit were on the moon, have some 15 different variants that go from anime-catgirl and housecat to mammoth sized kitty, and I'm aware they were elves at some point but azura was scrolling through Pinterest staring at cat pictures and and so pulled a switcheroo on said group of elves and turn them to cats;

Bosmer are a complete 180 from everything people associate with wood elves... Aside from their child height.

But what about Altmer? Wtf do they have going for them? I feel like I know more about the fucking sloads than I know about these guys. I'm begging y'all, make me see anything interesting about the pissmer

Edit: forgot about orcs. Orsimer look like their god who got vored and shat out by boethiah, so they literally look like daedric shit. Had that whole ordeal with the warp in the west and Orsinium, have their own strongholds and tribal status going on and whatever else. Literal shitmer have more going on for then than metaphorical pissmer in my eyes


r/teslore • • Nov 13 '24

Isn't the Empire the perfect manifestation of Molag Bal?

7 Upvotes

Ok maybe not perfect (no continent-wide slavery, for one....) But the core facet of Bal's domain - domination.

The Empire has sought to dominate other mortals over four Eras - mostly through bloody warfare and massacres as well.

The Empire exists to dominate. Doesn't that make it - as an entity - the perfect champion of Molag Bal?


r/teslore • • Oct 21 '22

Looking for good female and LGBTQ representation

7 Upvotes

Hello! I’m looking for positive and/or good representation of women in the TES canon, and if possible even LGBTQ people. Even texts with female or lgbtq authors would be appreciated.

Good examples I know of:

  • Saint Alessia: No further explanation needed, I’m happy she exists

  • Vivec: With his dual nature and explicitly androgenous looks, he’s the closest we get to genderfluidity and trans-rep, even if it’s abstract. But I can see it.

  • Pelinal Whitestrake: Technically gay, but not really.

Background: Today out of nowhere, I realized that TES (TES5 in particular) is dominated by straight (mostly white) men. So far I’ve always rationalized that my beloved game series can’t fall into the gamergate niche, but now I’m really down because of it.

So I’m looking for some cool rep to make me feel better, at least somewhat.

--------------------

What follows is a personal vent, don’t feel obliged to read. I just need to get it out of my head. (Spoilered as to not bother you with the wall of text)

If you think about it twice, most notable women in the tes history are either evil or subservient to men. The men in history are always heroes, even if their deeds are outrageously cruel (Ysgramor, Talos, Pelinal to some extent).

Skyrim is the game I sank hundreds of hours into. Women are always underrepresented (for every woman there are two to four men, depending on where you are). Most of them fall into some negative stereotypes or are depicted negatively (the jealous bitch, the weak ruler, the self-absorbed powerhungry matriarch). In men, the narrative depicts these traits as more favorable (competitive, flawed, strong-willed). It’s an issue across all media, but it’s prevalent in skyrim’s women even more, because there are so few to paint a good counter-picture. But even if we have a good female character in a questline – she isn’t the one that’s driving it or making the decisions. Those are always men.

I have no issue with the depiction of a patriarchal society. But the game never once questions or criticizes it. It just assumes that is the perfect state of being. Witcher3 is a lot more progressive on this end (though I have my gripes with it, too). It’s still a patriarchal society, but it has female characters who are fully fleshed out, have their own agency etc… The game doesn’t fix any social issues, but it at least makes it clear that these injustices are not okay.

There is a thing such as gender-neutral or -blind (same goes for sexuality) writing. TES tries to do it, but it does so badly. Because their world is not gender-neutral. Their world is favouring men by a large margin. To claim that gender doesn’t matter is just insincere. The world just makes an exception for the protagonist. Which is super sad, because on the cover, Skyrim looks very diverse. You have diverse races, you have social issues like immigration and poverty and good female armor.

I’m mostly disappointed with myself that it took ten years for me to realize it. It tells a lot of how ingrained this sexism is within me. I have an extensive headcanon for my dragonborn, I love daydreaming myself to skyrim. Of course I never made my personal stories sexist, at least not knowingly. I have my female dragonborn, her girl- and boyfriends, her strong mother-figure. But looking back, that fantasy doesn’t converge with the universe’s canon.

Let’s see what we have in Skyrim alone:

Good rep:

  • Aela, Uthgard the Unbroken, Mjoll the Lioness: Women who are strong-willed and just do their thing. This is a thing considered normal in the men they deal with, which makes their small number really sad.

  • Lami, Arcadia, Carlotta Valentina, Ysolda: Not warriors, but they are no less cool! They are out there running their own businesses. Carlotta is a single mom, which is extra badass!

  • Ria, Tonilia, Gabriella, Brelyna: Every faction seems to have this one female character who is just chill. She has her own goals, can be romanced, but her life isn’t solely based around the dragonborn’s existence. Which, if you’re playing a female dragonborn is even better, because then you finally have some female friends! We rarely have female friendships depicted.

  • Everyone is bi: Every eligible marriage candidate does not care whatsoever what’s in your pants. Which is really cool – if it wouldn’t feel like a cheap copout. If everyone is bi, where are all my queer couples in Skyrim?

Bad rep:

  • Queen Potema, who is evil to the bone! Yikes!

  • The Night Mother is another evil female figure.

  • Saadia: Single woman of color struggling to make ends meet. She is of course evil. (The quest was good, but damn… can you give your minorities a break for once?)

  • No LGBTQ people. At all.

  • Pelinal Whitestrake: Oh, the grudge. I could take the homophobic excuses in the 90s and 00s, because that was not a good time to come out. But it’s 2022 now. Come on! By now it’s as laughable as the things we see in so many tv-shows, where the producer proclaims “they gay” but never show it on screen, because they want to shill the show in china and in the conservative parts of the US, too. So all their rep is only virtue-signaling. Shout out to the brave guys who came up with his concept though. But I can imagine management swooped in and said “remember the straights who pay you”. It’s just sad.

  • Housecarls: Women who live to carry your burdens. Oh gripes. The men do this too, I don’t envy them either. Fun fact: Remember how Aerin gets berated by the fans for his simping for Mjoll? Subservient behaviour in men is free to laugh at, but in women it’s accepted if not expected.

Rep within the factions:

  • Jarls: The female jarls are depicted overwhelmingly bad: Laila Law-Giver is corrupt, Elisif is weak and unexperienced. Idgrod Ravenclaw is actually good, but we can’t leave good alone, can we? So she’s a bad mother now. Maven is a bitch. Some of the civil-war replacements are actually good (Brina and Sorli), but they barely exist.

  • Civil War: Rikke for the win. But aside from her, the civil war is a dickfeast and in the end, it’s all about the men.

  • Companions: Of the twelve people residing in Jorrvaskr, four are women. One of them is the motherly stereotype who has no life outside of caring for her boys and one of them is permanently bitchy. But overall, a lot less toxic masculinity in the old halls than expected.

  • Thieves Guild: They have the same overrepresentation of men, but have the best female cast in all the factions. Tonilia, Vex, Sapphire, Niranye and especially Karliah are all distinct characters with their own goals and don’t really fall into negative tropes. The men might be a bit more macho-esque than the companions, but the women know how to handle them and it’s a fairly relaxed atmosphere between the genders

  • Dark Brotherhood: Astrid is the evil woman who puts her pride over the greater good. She is a good and rounded character though. Babette is… yikes.

  • College of Winterhold: Again, with four female members among the fifteen, women are underrepresented. We again have the stereotype of the bitchy begrudger in Faralda. Also, female rivalry over a man with Faralda and Nirya. Mirabella is cool, but gets sacrificed because ew… woman in power.

  • Dawnguard: Actually, a lot of good female characters here. All of them are diverse and can kick ass. There are no unnecessary rivalries or bitching between them. There are still no women in power, but at least they aren’t depicted with negative stereotypes.


r/teslore • • Jun 06 '25

Are the Divines... real?

0 Upvotes

One thing that I have learned, in my deepest delving into TES lore, is this: absolutely nothing you hear from another character can be trusted.

The lore is 99% conjecture. Things written in-universe. Statements of a broad, vague manner, sometimes from Kirkbride (who makes it clear not even he can really be trusted), and sometimes directly from certain figures who may or may not have reason to tell you the truth, if they tell you anything. Every single culture possesses its own pantheon, its own ideology, its own interpretation of events that range from "identical with different names" to "this deity may as well be a different myth entirely."

There's one exception. You can probably, usually, trust one thing: your eyes. Your direct observations as the protagonist(s). If something happens, it does happen and can happen and is based on a true fact.

And there is an exception to the rule that every deity has its own culture.

And that's Daedra.

Daedric Princes all have their own names, and every single culture knows that true name and the Princes themselves introduce themselves by those names. They may come up with nicknames like Skooma Cat or Hyrma-Mora or Boethra, but everyone agrees on their names.

And all of these Princes appear. You can see them with your own eyes on numerous occasions. They have dedicated days of summoning. Nobody, anywhere, has ever denied the Daedra exist. Their blessings cannot be attributed to anything else.

But the Aedra?

Despite their very bodies literally orbiting us, they cannot be contacted. They never appear or speak to you or anyone else in any way we can confirm or prove in any manner.

You get blessings from them, maybe. They intervene, supposedly. Sometimes they hand out prophecies... if you believe that.

But you'll never, ever hear their voice in-game. You'll never see them in-game. You cannot summon them, you cannot visit their realms (except Sovngarde, and Shor/Lorkhan may not even be there and is not a Divine), they have no minions, no servants, nobody except the faithful, hopeful mortals of Nirn. You cannot prove that any of their blessings are, indeed, them.

For every instance of an Aedric blessing, there are ten instances of prayers by their most devout followers - Arch-Curate Vyrthur comes to mind - going completely ignored.

There are exactly two manifestations of the Divines that we can witness, that I recall; Martin's sacrifice (for which there exist plausible explanations besides mantling Akatosh himself), and Alduin's death (and calling himself Firstborn of Akatosh).

Do more manifestations like this exist?

Is there any, truly undeniable proof of the existence of the Nine Divines? And if there are, which ones? Akatosh is the only one whose existence seems near-impossible (but still possible) to deny.

EDIT: Oh, I'm also aware of certain other manifestations like Wulf, and a few interventions within Knights of the Nine - I've played all the games.

But these things can be explained; Wulf could easily... well, not be Tiber Septim. He could simply be some other strange, wandering spirit or even just a regular, cooky dude. The Knights interventions are very indirect and, again, plausibly explained as other things.

The proof I am seeking should be as hard to deny as the existence of Molag Bal or Mehrunes Dagon. We have seen those guys a whole bunch.


r/teslore • • Aug 13 '18

Stormcloak Victory is the Only Moral One

0 Upvotes

I’ll keep this short. In vanilla Skyrim, squads of thalmor and imperials escort Nord/Stormcloak prisoners to be probably tortured when you are in an Imperial-controlled Hold. When you liberate Skyrim, there are no longer Thalmor. They don’t come to take over, and Skyrim is at peace.

That being said, there is no reason to side with Imperials. Imagine thinking you did Skyrim a service by erasing the “blight” of your brothers (and sisters) of Skyrim and reinstalling a foreign state that cannot protect your freedom of speech.


r/teslore • • Feb 12 '25

stormcloak victory seems the only hope to rouse Skyrim from its 4th-age torpor and decrepitude

0 Upvotes

This may be a long post (as I feel the need to vent, but what else is reddit for?).

So I've recently begun playing Skyrim again after an 8 year hiatus (so far on my second attempt at a no-death, survival mode run, damn Malkoran and his glitchy ice storm that one shot me on 600 health and 50% magic resistance!)

I've noticed a lot of things I previously ignored. These seem to show that Skyrim is in every sense a really decrepit and shabby place as of TES5.

These include but aren't limited to things like:

  • the walls of Whiterun are completely crumbling (surely Baalgruuf is capable of and should be repairing them);

  • how Skyrim's home grown soldiery and military prowess is so crap that one or two of Cyrodil's crack legions could anihilate half of Skyrim's forces (i.e. the Stormcloaks);

  • how Skyrim is completely infested with bandits;

  • how utterly corrupt and/or incompetent the Jarls are (and on the whole, despite all the Imperial simps on this sub, I see no way in which the pro-imperial jarls are any better on the whole).

Given how prior to the Civil War, Skyrim had had no war for centuries, and one can presume that the Civil War itself is not very destructive (e.g. neither the Stormcloaks nor Imperials are going around destroying farms or massacring enemy villages due to a strong desire to win hearts and minds), this is strange.

The only explanation I can come up with is that five hundred years of imperial rule have completely infantilised Skyrim's leadership by depriving it of effective power, removing their skin from the game, and encouraged many Nords to try and become a form of inferior imperial and exploiting Skyrim's economy for the benefit of Cyrodil with the collusion of a native class of Nord compradors (like the current Jarl of Falkreath).

This of course is quite credible given historical analogies (one that springs to mind is how several centuries of Roman rule meant that by the third century AD the still-self governing cities of Greece and elsewhere were completely at the mercy of tiny handfuls of poorly led and equipped barbarians, a pattern repeated in the fifth and seventh centuries, or how the removal of Roman legions from Britain in the C4 made the native British incapable of defending themselves from the Saxons). A more contemporary example of how difficult some say the EU minus American aid would find it to repel a serious Russian attack despite the EU dwarfing Russia in population and GDP.

This seems to also be noticeable in terms of Skyrim's magical traditions. Nords used to produce quite effective and competent mages and some Nords train at Winterhold, but apart from Baalgruuf and Ulfirc, almost all the Jarls (and would-be Jarls like Erikur) seem to prefer Elf or Breton house wizards. There seems no interest in raising and training local mages, despite how advantageous that would be in the long-run for skyrim.

The East Empire Trading Company completely dominates Solitude's docks (whereas in Windhelm it is merely one of several players) suggesting that the Empire has used a variety of fair and unfair tactics to completely dominate Skyrim's economy for the benefit of the Cyrodilics who control the EETC like the Emperor's relatives and only an independent Skyrim would give local traders a fair chance.

The complete weakness of Skyrim's native forces in the face of crack units from Cyrodil also seems striking. This is especially the case since the Stormcloaks are filled with veterans of the legions (including Ulfric himself), but Tullius is certain that if he didn't have to rely on local levies, he could crush the Stormcloaks very quickly. I imagine this has something to do with centuries of imperial rule having encouraged Nords to try to raise armies and fight like imperials to the neglect of their own traditions (one analogy would be the repeated failure of the US in post-WW2 Asia such as Afghanistan or Vietnam to create effective armies by insisting on using American methods and complex combined arms operations). Since unlike the real world, Tamriel is a fantasy world with god-like heroes, magic racial powers etc. it is more credible than our world that Nords might perform better militarily if they tried to return to their old ways rather than the more technically proficient but foreign imperial way of war.

I could go on and on.

But the crux of the issue seems to me that Ulfric and his supporters in charge of an independent Skyrim seem to be the only hope of enabling Skyrim to return to its old ways. This is shown by how Ulfric, unlike the stupid Greybeards afraid of their own shadows, is willing to use the thu'um as a weapon, and ignore the silly limits placed on it ages ago. I suspect Ulfric's willingess to overturn centuries of traditions in an appeal to an older past is Skyrim's only hope of returning to its old glories and once again becoming a real power like in the FIrst Age.

The general response of course is that if Skyrim gains independence the whole Empire will fall and with it men.

I know that this view is very popular on this sub, but I've never really understood why it seems so persuasive.

For most of Tamriellic history, the Empire of Cyrodiil consisted just of Cyrodiil, but was able to defend itself against all comers. Cyrodiil's massive size and the fertility of its land mean that a well-run Cyrodiil should be as strong as three other provinces put together. Also generally, attacking armies need a 3-1 superiority to break prepared defences. I see no reason to believe the Aldmeri Dominion has this level of superiority over the Empire's armies on their borders as of Skyrim especially now the empire is motivated and prepared.

Skyrim's clear present weakness where a handful of Cyrodillic legions can conquer it seems to suggest that possessing Skyrim is not actually that great a force-multiplier for the Empire, the only real benefit it has to the Empire is as a location for the already fabulously wealthy Cyrodillic elites to get even wealthier and recruit grunts.

However, there's no reason Nords who wanted to fight in the legions after a Stormcloak victory couldn't simply go south and enrol, serve for a few decades and then return.

This of course brings us to an even more unclear issue - why was the Mede Empire so unprepared for the Great War in terms of numbers of soldiers?

We know from the Elder Scrolls novels (Lord of Souls etc.) that Titus Mede I politically was unable to touch members of the Elder Council like Hierem.

Members of the Elder Council under Titus Mede II like Amaund Motierre also seem fantastically wealthy beyond the level any Jarl in Skyrim could hope to be.

The inability of Titus Mede II's armies to resist the Aldmeri Dominion army and the warnings allegedly received by Titus Mede II from his generals about the Empire's military weakness (according to the "Great War" by Legate Quintius) seem to suggest a Cyrodillic economy in which the economy was being run for the benefit of a small number of members of the Elder Council and the Emperors avoided e.g. taxing the wealthy to avoid antagonising the Elder Council meaning the Empire simply had no money to pay for a reasonable amount of troops (historically this is a common explanation for how the Western Roman Empire collapsed, or rather was unable to defend itself from rather unimpressive groups of barbarians).

If this is the case, the loss of Skyrim might actually be better for the Empire if it forces the imperial government to begin extracting more resources from the wealthiest members of its own society rather than just taking the politically easy option and exploit the peripheries.

Edit: the only issue I'd be really concerned over is whether Ulfric would have time to train other Nords in using the thu'um. He'd have to do something like recreate the Imperial College of the Voice and use Tiber Septim's precedent, though it might be difficult to rediscover other shouts without the Greybeards helping.


r/teslore • • Sep 23 '23

Why is it taboo to criticize the thalmor on this subreddit?

0 Upvotes

For my 3 or so years on this subreddit I noticed that whenever I mention the tower theory, make the thalmor seem like the bad guys or even just mention and entertain the idea of something that criticizes the thalmor like them causing the void night even though the means to change the moon cycles have existed for thousands of years and a group willing of fanatics willing to play dirty as with lord narafin using daedric artifacts when altmer society hates anything daedra or padomay related. But no let’s play devils advocate for a group that’s mysterious and dangerous cause no official lore exist ms cause MK isn’t in Bethesda. Well first of all MK was part of Bethesda during the latter half of morrowind’s development as he left in 2000 but still contributed a bunch to the lore and during the production of oblivion we wrote most of the mythic dawn commentaries and mankar’s final speech and his work still influences Bethesda to this day. But he doesn’t work there anymore so his word is invalid. And like I said on my questioning on criticizing the tower theory, we like to write and speculate about lore that could be either be loosely related or not even true at all but it seems a good chunk of this subreddit discourages theorizing or slandering the thalmor in some way gets you downvoted to oblivion while give that similar slander to almost any other race and most of this subreddit is fine with it. So I just want a straight answer, why is it bad to speculate or even criticize the thalmor on this subreddit without pissing off a good chunk of it? And dot. Give me those same “not cannon” arguments because like I said we speculate about non cannon stuff it’s just that many seem adamant about downvoteing those that criticize the thalmor in some way. So I want a straight answer as to why.


r/teslore • • Feb 20 '23

Where did Vivec using neopronouns come from?

0 Upvotes

I'm very fond of Vivec using neopronouns, it's a really cool idea and is nice representation for folks who use them. But I'm confused as to where it came from. I've heard conflicting reports over the years - that it's just a thing fans came up with, that it's something Michael Kirkbride decided in the last few years (the one I hear the most is Vivec being xe/xir), etc. etc. Is there a source for Vivec using neopronouns or is it just pure fanon?

EDIT: Thanks to /u/Niranox, we have the origin point for Vivec using a neopronoun; http://www.pearltrees.com/nigh_thawks/teachings-of-the-elk/id8917797/item93821166

<RottenDeadite> Can you talk about Vivec's Children for me?

<MK> They are all of the metaphors made real for hir to deal with before the Hortator.


r/teslore • • 18d ago

Are Orcs the remnants of Dwemer

1 Upvotes

I got to thinking about the chronology and it got me wondering about this. One of those books cite the transformation of Trinimac's followers into orcs as happening at roughly the same time as the transformation of Chimer into Dunmer and we know the Dwemer disappeared during their war with the Chimer. So...are the Orcs what happened to the Dwemer?


r/teslore • • Feb 24 '26

Theory: the Thalmor defeated Mehrunes Dagon, ending the Oblivion crisis

10 Upvotes

Someone surely has had this theory before because it's pretty obvious. If so, please direct me to any discussions concerning it.

The title may be clickbait, but hear me out. At the end of TES 4 we see Martin turn into an avatar of Akatosh and fight Mehrunes Dagon. Akatosh is the god of time. There could have been a dragon break in this moment and in TES 5 we learn about the effects. Multiple timelines took place simultaneously. The Thalmor defeated Mehrunes Dagon, as did the Argonians, as did Martin Septim. The narrative of TES 5 dictates that the Thalmor are the bad guys and the player has to hate them. But the series is known for unreliable narrator. We shouldn't assume that the Thalmor lied about their role in the Oblivion crisis.


r/teslore • • Mar 17 '26

God head is not as interesting as you make it

0 Upvotes

Starting off , I wanna say that my position is not one of satding completely against this group of people , arguing for the sake of arguing. However having recently replayed Skyrim and coming upon lore stuff again , I have decided to search the internet to see what people say about the games cosmology. I have seen discussions that seem to think the whole godhead perspective as really deep and amazing etc . I personally think that the Anu and padomay beginning to be more interesting than a lot of people actually think . Firstly I think it is a great framework that can explain things on a grander scale and a smaller scale. Villains and events can be better understood . It is also a framework that can have more potential for development for future games. On the other hand I find godhead to be very obscure, instead of explanatory and clear as people think ( and no people are not stupid idiots that don't get "esoteric" stuff). A lot of the appeal I see comes from a need to give every mechanic a meta purpose in the game , which I find gimmicky and flashy mostly. It actually says nothing about the world itself. The godhead feels like a concept of utter flatness and blandness due to it's homogenous nature. Yes , the first time I came upon chim in morrowind and vivec was having the whole I know I cant defeat you because chim moment,I was very excited . It's interesting and fun , but now it's feels more like a spark that has spread to far and is burning everything. Again , I am making this post in good faith , and I wish to get actual engagement and discussion. By the way I read stuff , I am capable just like everyone else so don't throw me any "it's esoteric " or. " It's complex ".


r/teslore • • Jun 06 '25

Skyrims probability of defending itself against the dominion

1 Upvotes

I believe its probable that Skyrim after winning the civil war could defend itself from the dominion and empire, if there's even an empire at that point.

  1. When the Alessian Empire tried to take Skyrim by force they only managed to hold power over west Skyrim, They never to my knowledge held any power over the kingdoms of the west. Noted this is before Skyrim was completely united.

  2. The only real reason Skyrim is so heavily imperial by the time of the Great War was because Tiber Septim started the current empire, (yes at the time of the war it was the mead impire but all mead did was takeover an already basically put together impire and start improving) they could worship Talos and weren't being forced around. After fighting and being disregarded after the war they lost most of their care for the impire.

  3. Skyrim completely united under one military cause could defend itself from the dominion, the few passes into Skyrim could be more heavily fortified and reinforced (similarly to the Bangkorai garrison), the whole sea of ghosts is its own unique defense, the Providence is basically self sustaining and is its own fortress especially with a Dragonborn able to bend the will of dragons, think of the power that the Skyrim army lead by the Dragonborn and parthanax militarizing an alliance of dragon and mortal with possible help from Hammerfell defending the 4-5 some odd mountain passes after the passes have been fortified in stone and anger.

TL-DR I think Skyrim could easily defend itself and prosper if the Stormcloaks won the war. All historical facts are to my knowledge and could be wrong.


r/teslore • • Nov 14 '23

Do all Altmer share in the Thalmor's goals?

1 Upvotes

My knowledge of this of bit of the lore is very rusty but from what i've been told the Aldmeri Dominon or Thalmor or High Elves (whichever is right) believe in and are pushing for Elven Supremacy. Like with their outlaw of Talos worship just because the thought of a human ascending to Godhood is offensive to them.

I've also heard of this plot behind the scenes of these Elves wanting to "ascend" the mortal plane themselves. Again, I don't know alot about this and am still currently learning about it.

Anyway what I want to ask is this something all High Elves (even those that just seem like regular folk) believe in? Do all of the Altmer race think themselves something of higher beings? Or is this just something the Elite in Altmer society buy into with the rest just going on with their regular lives.


r/teslore • • Mar 24 '22

You give Lore a Bad Name (FKA Worst of the Lore), part. 2: Ebonheart Pact

7 Upvotes

Second issue of my feared, dreaded series about the questionable lore we are witness of!

The first one saw a lot of replies contradicting me, and I took note of every argument advanced, my opinion is more nuanced now. Feel free to add your own stone to the edifice if you hadn't yet!

The Ebonheart Pact was hated since the (humble, maybe too) beginnings of the game, because it was an alliance of races who hated each other and had a complicated history of war and enslavement interacting between them. As years went by, the hate attenuated but we can still get some, thanks mostly to Fudgemuppet, who never skip an occasion to hate on ESO.

So what's the problem? Some of the Dunmer people made an alliance with some Nord and some Argonian to repell a Kamal invasion and then chose to stay side by side to face the nascent Three Banners War.

But in my opinion this was quite poorly written. I do not hate on the alliance itself, but more on how it benefits its people. High-King Jorunn is obviously the winner here, and the other races are just figurants. During the quest where the Pact is (again?) sealed, Jorunn represents the Nord, while minor representatives are present for the ceremony, namely General Noramil (whose background is absolutely unknown, we don't know which House he's part of for example) and some Argonian warrior named Eyes-of-Steel, without background either. Moreso, they ceded incredibly important artifacts in the name of the Pact, nothing less than Saint Veloth's weapon and what I think is kind of a mobile phone to the Hist.

Where are the big players? We meet Almalexia in Mournhold, but she doesn't seem interested in the Pact, I wonder why (neither are Vivec nor Sotha Sil, but they are met in later chapters of the game). We even meet some high-ranking members of House Indoril, Dres and Redoran during our journey (but yeah most of them ended up dead after we encounter them).

Argonian don't have a centralized leader (at that time mind you, I remember reading from Oblivion or Skyrim that Shadowscales were pledged to the King of Argonia or something like that), but it was Heita-Meen who convinced and lead her people to help. But now, she has to share her power over Stormhold with a Nord and a Dunmer. I think we can call that a backdraw.

My issue is that the whole lacks coherence, which did nothing to calm down angry players at the time. For instance, in the Dominion you get the proper leaders of their province, Queen Ayrenn, King Aeradan Camoran/The Silvenar/The Wilderqueen, and the Mane. The Daggerfall Covenant is also led by three king (Emeric, Fahara'jad and Kurog or Bazrag).

What are your takes on this? As a Dunmer lover, I demand reparations!


r/teslore • • Oct 24 '23

Vivec, Genders and Toxic Masculinity. NSFW

29 Upvotes

I appreciate everyone who chimed in on my first real analysis about Vivec themselves being the actual simulacrum of the Nethiman's Wife. So as a follow up, I wanted to go over an observation that I have not seen many other make.

So Vivec, important and controversial figure in universe and in our own. One of the most important parts of discussing Vivec is their gender. Vivec is intersex. Duality is a big part of Vivec, being they are literally split down the middle, and the represent Mastery, and is positied in the 36 lessons as being simultaneously the meeting ground of Sotha Sil's masculinity, and Almalexias femininity. Not that Vivec is half and half, they are simultaneously both, and the opposite, and everything. What this does not answer however, is what Vivec's gender is.

So in the games, Vivec uses he/him pronouns. In the annotated analysis of of the 36 lessons, the first note is one about the use of pronouns. Rottendeadite prefers to use neopronouns for Vivec, and personally I use they/them. The reason at least on my end, is to underline that Vivec is not a "man" but something that includes masculinity. Vivec is all genders and gender expressions. However, then why does Vivec use masculine pronouns? is it real world bias getting in the way? Publisher meddling? The year the games came out? I don't think so. The lessons make Vivecs gender explicit in a number of places, and the fact the game still had a T rating while still including everything with Molag Bal, I think shows people worried about ratings or whatnot had not reviewed them. So I think the use of He/Him must have a meaning to it as well.

Lucky for me, Rottendeadite had asked Kirkbride about it, and was given this insight:

It has also been indicated to me, by Michael Kirkbride, that Vivec is a "He" because of, as Kirkbride put it, "the BEST thing."

So this does confirm it is for a reason, and my interpretation of "the best" would be deeply tied to toxic masculinity and gendered expectations in both our and the fictional world. What I mean, is that while Vivec is all genders, I do not think Vivec's experience as each gender is equal, or consistant. In a patriarchal society, Masculinity is seen as a moral good, and all deviations as lesser. So if we think of Vivec's gender as represented by a percentage, really only 100% male would be valid as a representation of masculinity. This is desirable for Vivec to present this way, however I think it is clear that Vivec struggles with the aspects of themselves that do not fit this very narrow band of expression.

For instance, in Sermon 18, Vivec is told by Almalexia that one of the children Vivec must defeat, is already within themselves. Almalexia is the clearest example of a Mother figure, and is a representation of womanhood in general in teh 36 lessons. What she does here is point out that Vivec has definition, and boundaries. That they have a name and a duty, and therefor Vivec can likely not become all things. To me that sounds like what is expected of women as caretakers of children. You have to give up a lot of freedom, and that is what is expected as women in a patriarchal society.

I guess I should say that, personally, I do not see rape as being something inherently done to women by men. However I think within the 36 lessons. Vivecs experiences as a woman and about women tend to hide hidden details of trauma, rape, disappointment, ect. That was kinda central to my previous post. If the Simulacrum of the Netchiman's Wife is not literally that, but a metaphor for Vivec acting within the gender expression of their mother, as they are a child and not actualized in their gender/not living in a society that would allow them to, then Vivec is presenting acting in femininity as demeaning, robotic, just an act. This would not fit the propaganda level of interpretation of Vivec as god king of Morrowind.

This is then also underlined with Vivecs interactions with Molag Bal. People have interpreted the 36 lessons as Vivec admitting/hinting towards past traumas in their life up before becoming a God and getting to rewrite their history. So the meeting with Molag Bal could be literal, or it could be metaphorical, but either way they are meant to represent rape and sexual trauma. Vivec's removal of their head to deal with Nerevar has been pointed out to sound like Dissociation. The Children Vivec has with Molag Bal are representations of Vivecs inner demons, which Vivec has to then kill and absorb in order to process. One of which, Moon-Axle, is a manifestation of Vivecs desire to be all things and perfect. Vivec's spear Muatra is an anagram of Trauma, and although represents Vivec's intersex genitals, its undeniable that its used in a very Phallic mode the majority of times.

So, while its clear the killing of Vivecs children with Muatra is symbolic for processing trauma. People have also interpreted it very literally as Vivec raping and killing their kids with their penis. I don't think thats what is going on, however what I do think is that imagery is important. Vivec is processing these traumatic experiences, and they are not a "pretty" process. Working out Trauma can sometimes be very difficult. I would argue that Vivecs methods while understandable, may not exactly be the healthiest.

"Reach Heaven by Violence" is a major theme in the 36 Lessons as well. It is a description that reminds me of the Ubermensch. Becoming a being which defines ideology through the undeniable force of will you put out into the world. There have been a lot of writing about the interpretations and misinterpretations of the Ubermensch and I think its hard to deny that it has the shape of Toxic Masculinity. There are 6 walking ways to reach CHIM in the 36 lessons, but the one that is always come back to is this method. Violence as justification for itself. Vivec also describes in sermon 23 their city as a place to "cut" its people into "better" shapes, which brings to mind the Morag Tong. That sermon also has this line:

'Girls burn their dresses on my arrival if I am armored. They crawl to me as bled pilgrims.

Which is unmistakably a male power fantasy of having naked women crawl all over you. Even the fact its described as being a "Ruling King" evokes ideas of masculinity and power.

This is also where I put my feelings on the Trail of Vivec, which I am not a big fan of personally, however if we see Vivec as viewing masculinity as power, then his treatment of Azura, and the uncomfortable implications of them shoving their spear down her throat, are relevant. Its meant to make us uncomfortable. I read an interpretation that Vivec hates Azura, because as a Daedra who acts as a loving mother, Vivec sees her as a gross pretender. That Vivec is comparing Azura's femininity to their own, and Vivec's experience of womanhood has been one of trauma, disappointment and rape.

I should also clarify, I am talking about Vivec's experience of being a woman. I am not saying thats what is inherit to being a woman, and in fact I think underlines an internalized Misogyny as a part of Vivec's character.

In conclusion, Vivec is all genders, however Vivecs experience of gender has been effected by the society they grew up in, and they seem to view masculinity as power and actualization, and femininity as rife with trauma and disappointment. I think its telling that in order to reach Amaranth at the end of Coda, Vivec takes on a more motherly role, showing that Vivec needed to grow and learn to accept all parts of themselves in order to actually achieve what they desired.