I like Telltale games. I own all of the titles beginning from The Walking Dead to now. I like their formula, their mechanics and their accessibility. However, I'm having very mixed feelings on Game of Thrones.
I'm one of the few who didn't watch Game of Thrones on a weekly basis (sorry. Slightly bloodier and sexier Lord of the Rings isn't my cup of tea). But, I figured I could just play this game and not even have to touch the TV series since Telltale does such a good job on bringing newcomers up to speed on events. I was mistaken; after playing the first episode, I felt as though I had missed out on various references, nods, cameos and explanations to events that were not covered in the first episode and thus, I had to go and watch all the episodes to Game of Thrones before episode 2 came out.
Is it wrong to consider tying in too closely to continuity and canon events part of a game's faults?
Now, I want to be clear here, this is not the first time Telltale has adapted a licensed property. They've done adaptations of Back to the Future, Jurassic Park, The Walking Dead, Fables and even Borderlands. However, those games don't require me to be familiar with the source material to enjoy them. I didn't need to go back and experience TWD, Fables or Borderlands to know what was going on. Telltale introduced the setting and the characters enough, got the key cameos out of the way and allowed the game's story to be its own independent story, peripheral to events. (Even games like Back to the Future and Tales from the Borderlands are allowed to be an expansions of their respective universes and is given creative freedom to go past the canon events).
Maybe, this was done intentionally on Telltale's part; in order to enjoy the game, you would have to experience the TV series, thus generating additional revenue for "Game of Thrones" for curious newcomers.
What really bothers me is that now that I have seen all of episodes of Game of Thrones, I no longer feel any tension for various decisions made from the Forresters.
To be honest, playing "Game of Thrones" feels more like I'm playing (and forgive me but this is an old reference) one of The Godfather games from Electronic Arts, where I'm essentially an off-screen character who does various missions to help canon characters and I can't do too much otherwise it's going to mess up the continuity of, let's face it, a much more popular show/movie/book than the tie-in game ever will be.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uH39dSnnEo4
So, back to my original question: Is it wrong to praise works for being more 'stand-alone' and independent as well as faulting works for being tied to continuity and dependent on other source materials?
EDIT: TL;DR: Is it wrong to consider 'it follows too closely with the TV show' a flaw?