r/tellphilosophy • • Sep 16 '15

René Descartes thoughts on /r/badphilosophy/

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Sep 02 '15

If it hurts when I punch myself, is it because I am strong or because I am weak?

17 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Apr 01 '16

Is it Zenophobic to be afraid of half measures?

12 Upvotes

[deleted]


r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 18 '16

Can you derive a sought from an it?

10 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Oct 29 '15

For the folks at r/badphilosophy

9 Upvotes

I know, as many people have quite hilariously pointed, this isn't the place for learns, but, well, I'm quite hopeless at this philosophy stuff and the other philosophy subreddits don't seem to be much help. I'm quite young (high school) and have gotten into philosophy a lot lately. I try and read basic stuff and work my way up, but when it comes to reading arguments on r/badphilosophy, i really can't make sense of them. I'm a theist (although I like to think I'm not in any way dogmatic), and I appreciate how this subreddit can skewer both the ratheist types and idiotic theists. The problem is, I thoroughly understand the philosophical reasons you skewer theists on, I just can't make sense of the points (although I somehow agree) Sam Harris and co. are called out on. I'll list somethings I don't understand, and if anyone could answer any of them, I'd much appreciate it.

1.Why is the ratheist claim that the burden of proof lies on the believer not true/irrelevant.

2.What is the essential debate on free will vs determinism and why is Jerry Coyne wrong in saying that determinism is widely accepted.

3.Why is it wrong that Atheists claim they don't have beliefs, since (in their words), atheism is the lack of belief?

4.What makes Sam Harris so bad at philosophy? I mean, what concepts does he struggle with?

5.Is it true that there's zero evidence for Theism? And compounding on that, is the atheist analogy of proving unicorns fair?


r/tellphilosophy • • Aug 14 '16

Isn't Consumerism the realest religion?

8 Upvotes

Should I look back on my Christian """""life""""""? Was it not a worthless waste of my time? Why did I just basically deny The truth about myself to myself and to anons?

Did I rly have a living faith for a living """"God""""? How ludicrous is that? If it really was a living faith for a living God, why did worshipping Him was such a boring drag?

Could the contrast to my real living faith and the realest living God be greater? Oh boy, do I love the religion of consumerism? Why buying stuff makes me feel comfy and warm inside? Why is spending money not a drag? Why is it the funnest, most rewarding thing to do? Why do I never dread making another big, expensive gift to myself? Does buying stuff ever lose its thrill? Do all questions finally have an answer?

Am I the only guy who could benefit from having this epiphany? Why do I think we would all benefit greatly if we just told the Truth about ourselves to ourselves? Won't The truth set us free? Is it not the Truth that we build bigger and grander temples to the practice of consumerism than we do to any other God? Aren't the "superstores" really well-named?

Christmas??? Don't even get me started on Christmas??? What is the REAL war on Christmas? Is this war anything else than an existential threat to our way of life? Is this war not to try to stop Christmas from being the high-festival day of our communal religion: cocky, cheeky, sassilicious Consumerism? When do we all come together, as a nation, nay, as a fucking Civilization, and renew our devotion to the Gods of our Fathers, and consume like we are consumed by the spirit??? (Christmas?) Will you get out of the cave bruhs?

Even at non-Christmas times of the year, when the temptation to stray gets bigger, don't we all renew our devotion?Sometimes at great personal financial sacrifice- -and are we not once again rededicated to consumerism?Take the "Christ" out of Christmas and take up your Cross and put the Cross back into X-mas??? (Bingo?)

Will you let me tell you a story about my new Brompton folding bicycle? You know how much this ungodly amount of coolness costs? $2.6k? Isn't that outrageous?

But didn't this selfless sacrifice make me feel better? Don't I love showing off my Brompton? Don't I ride it everyday? Doesn't it give me a sense of accomplishment? Don't I buy new titanium parts for it when I feel down? Isn't my newer, brighter headlight cooler? Isn't my expensive helmet snazzy?

How many people have a Brompton? Not many, right? Isn't that fapworthy? Is it not a sassy way to show individuality in a city of 10 million anons? Doesn't spending 2.6k on a bike make you a special snowflake?

Problem?

PS how many thanks to Randy?


r/tellphilosophy • • Jul 04 '16

Are Sam Harris' enemies secretly controlling /r/badphilosophy?

8 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Apr 09 '15

Metaphysics is stupid? What comes after metaphysics?

8 Upvotes

We all know metaphysics means after or beyond physics, right? Though, as a man who has read almost every single Lawrence Krauss book, I am skeptical about anything other than physics? I have heard that metaphysics is mainly trying to sneak religion back into science?

DAE the whole thing just begs the question of what comes after metaphysics? And that just isn't logically sound? Just like when fundies tell me God came before everything and I push it back in their face "what came before God!"? There is no phony god before physics so there is no more things after physics?

Also, my dad is a physician, but he never met a single meta-physician in his life? And he says he never wants to? They have nothing to do with real work done in medicine, besides trying to ruin physics with their quackery?

I never read Aristotle, but since Ayn Rand approved of him, I assume he was an atheist and libertarian theorist like her? So I don't even know what went wrong with him that he even went into philosophy? Since he proved men are smarter than women shouldn't he be smarter than her? But then why does everyone at my junior high school read her and not him? Is this even fair or does it mean most people use their feels isntead of logic and reasons?


r/tellphilosophy • • Apr 01 '15

Why should I be moral? I Shouldn't be Moral

8 Upvotes

Morality = inherently subjective


r/tellphilosophy • • Jun 28 '16

How do you get unbanned from /r/badphilosophy?

7 Upvotes

I've tried everything. Telling them that it is morally just to unban me. Logically proving that my unbanning is inevitable. Logically proving that it is morally just to unban me. I even used fallacies (they seem to dislike people complaining about fallacies, so using them must be a good thing).

What do I do?


r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 23 '16

Why does my philosophy department hold a weekly seminar on polite beer drinking noises?

7 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Jul 21 '15

How can free will possibly exist?

7 Upvotes

And if it does, how can it possibly apply to human beings?

Is there anyone who could explain? At the very least, is there someone who could recommend some good books on the subject? Or a link to an existing discussion online, for instance?

Also, why is everything here phrased like a question? Does this rule have humorous intent? Am I missing something here?


r/tellphilosophy • • Apr 30 '15

Why was I banned from /r/BadPhilosophy?

7 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 20 '16

What's the easiest way to memorize all the logical fallacies so I can use them during road rage?

6 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Oct 25 '15

Some people here say that this writing on Marx was bad. Why do you think so?

Thumbnail
slatestarcodex.com
6 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 12 '15

What ought we do to the crow?

6 Upvotes

Fight the wildebeest?

(Why am I not mod? :( )


r/tellphilosophy • • Jul 06 '17

If Morality is only a matter of opinion, why does my Mom keep telling me to clean my room?

5 Upvotes

I was in my history class (three years before I got kicked out of University) going over the atrocities of the past few centuries, and my first thought was "why does my bitch teacher cry when look at videos of the Holocaust?" Speaking objectively, Morlity is subjective, and is only a matter of opinion; why should I care? Why are there vegans? Why does my Mom keep asking me to clean my room (she's such a bitch!)? Why does my Dad get angry when he sees how much Dorito dust is all over the furniture? From an objective point of view, why should the furniture be clear and not covered with Dorito dust? Why is everyone so afraid of Facts and Science?


r/tellphilosophy • • Nov 26 '16

Is Charles Sanders Peirce the Greatest Philosopher of All Time???

5 Upvotes

Here's an argument to get us started:

P1. If there exists an epistemological paradigm that serves as a sound replacement to standard analytic epistemology (SAE), then SAE is false and untenable. (Because SAE continually generates shaky concepts that are highly susceptible to being defeated by lowly counter-examples, and if there is a method that soundly replaces it, then this means we have acknowledged these shortcomings as fatal to it)

P2. Rational persuasion epistemology (RPE) serves as a sound replacement to SAE.

P3. SAE is false and untenable.

P4. SAE is one of three codified methods for performing epistemology (the other two being rational persuasion, and Quine's naturalized epistemology, and we can reject Quine's method on a circularity charge).

P5. If P3 and P4, then the method that replaces SAE is the most impressive epistemological method/theory. (On account of uprooting the most highly practiced form of epistemology)

P6. Rational persuasion epistemology is the method that soundly replaces SAE.

P7. Rational persuasion epistemology is the most impressive epistemological method/theory.

P8. Epistemology is the most important philosophical endeavor. (cuz science)

P9. If P7 and P8, then whoever formulated RPE must be considered the greatest philosopher of all time on account of his/her advancing of the most impressive methodology/theory within the most important philosophical endeavor.

P10. Charles Sanders Peirce formulated RPE.

C. Charles Sanders Peirce is the greatest philosopher of all time on account of his advancing the most impressive methodology/theory within the most important philosophical endaeavor.

QED?


r/tellphilosophy • • Jul 01 '16

what is the meaning of nihilism?

5 Upvotes

I just wanted to understand the reason behind Nihilism and wondered if whoever reads this could answer it please?


r/tellphilosophy • • Jun 12 '16

It has been shown that most professional ethicists are rather unethical, since this holds true, what kind of fucked up shit is Christine Korsgaard into?

5 Upvotes

Does anyone else believe that she is a masochist and usually partners with a sadist named Will?


r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 23 '16

How do cultural marxists deal with the ethical implications of being born white?

5 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Dec 21 '15

How to study Philosophy being drunk?

5 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 12 '15

How would you ask a genie to grant you infinite wishes without it being a logical fallacy?

5 Upvotes

r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 11 '15

Why can't I be a Calculator? And why is it my Mother's Fault?

5 Upvotes

I am two weeks into a STEM program, and I already know about most of the Universe from watching Cosmos and getting a real cosmospectivist perspective by getting high, donchaknow? I was wondering lately while reading Sam Harris' Blog about how I'm literally a meatpuppet controlled by MRI's why can't I be a calculator? Heidegger says that machines have an agenda of their own, but I obviously don't have one because Brain Chemistry and that's why I slept through three exams, so why can't I just be a machine? Also, why is it my Mother's fault that I'm not just a machine? And why do all the funDIES like my RA's, parents, police and academic counselors try to tell me that I have these mythical theological things like "responsibility" and "an obligation not to leave Dorrito Dust Everywhere in the Dorm"? Why doesn't everybody Science yet, like I want to?


r/tellphilosophy • • Mar 09 '15

Most Philosophical Problems are caused by people being Immoral.

5 Upvotes

I am a Moral Person and I have never had Philosophical Problems.

I have never had to deal with the Cretan Liar because I don't go to Dirty Countries like Crete, and I never lie. I have never had to deal with the Barbershop Paradox because Beards are great. Most Philosophical Problems must result from people not being Moral Enough, and I know, because I am a Moral Person.