r/teenswhowrite • • Feb 12 '18

[Q] Why does English class suck?

39 Upvotes

I’m sixteen and I’ve been writing for five years now; the first three I did strictly fanfiction.

During that time, I’ve grown continually bored with English class, especially now. In my current English II class for my sophomore year, it’s the same bullshit that I’ve been learning for the last four years. Writer’s purpose, analyze the text, comprehension, and re-read, it all annoys me.

Now, as someone who creates my own stories, no one knows exactly what something is supposed to represent in a story. Sure, there are many ways something could be interpreted but the only person that knows the true interpretation is the author. I don’t want to sit and hear about the hidden meaning that Shakespeare had with how Hamlet took a bite out of a damn grapefruit.

And I apparently fail because I didn’t pick the single “correct” interpretation of Hamlet eating the grapefruit.

And don’t get me started on the restrictions and constraints for essays/poetry projects (this might be just my experiences with English teachers, but still)

My teacher will say it’s a “free thought story” project and then proceed to give us all a topic which we much research and type it up in 12pt Roman Times font, double-spaced, with 10 paragraphs, 2 page bibliography, and a “professional” title page.

That doesn’t promote creativity, that’s teaching regurgitation and rewording! (Yes, I get this is what an essay is, but that doesn’t mean I like it.)

Anyway, I’ll end it with that, thanks for listening to my rant for today.


r/teenswhowrite • • Jan 15 '18

[WSP] [WSP] Purple Prose

21 Upvotes

Purple Prose

This is a fairly common term in writing. I heard it before I knew what it meant, years ago, when I first started writing. In simple terms, it means overly descriptive writing.

Like, writing so descriptive you want to vomit because you can barely understand what the writer is even trying to say it’s so convoluted.

Purple prose is not a good thing. Descriptive writing can be a great thing! But purple prose is used to mean writing that has gone beyond just descriptive writing and into a world all its own.


The line

Let’s look at what is considered purple prose, and why.

Generally, purple prose is overdone with adjectives and adverbs. It can be a really long sentence to say something really simple, or even an entire paragraph saying something that could be said in a few words. It can also just mean writing that goes on and on with descriptions to the point of annoying the reader.

Of course, the line between descriptive prose and purple prose will have some to do with taste. I appreciate brevity. I am not a big fan of long descriptions. My taste isn’t going to be the same as someone elses, and that is okay. That being said, I have a feeling that almost all readers would agree that there is absolutely a point when prose is purple.


Why it’s easy to do

Purple prose can be an easy thing to slip into. I think it happens most when we aren’t sure yet exactly what we are saying, or we aren’t sure exactly what the setting is. It can often be used a mechanism to try to “find one’s way”. Sometimes using lots of words is a great way to try to work through our thoughts on something.

Another reason it happens: Because we want to sound pretty. Or even literary. We look at classical writers and try to emulate them, and think, oh yes, writing must sound lyrical and poetic and be descriptive to be good. While it might work sometimes, this is very, very often not true.


Examples

Yes, so some of this is going to be opinion. Below are passages I would consider to be purple prose. They are also passages that I think are often used as examples of purple prose.

It was a dark and stormy night; the rain fell in torrents—except at occasional intervals, when it was checked by a violent gust of wind which swept up the streets (for it is in London that our scene lies), rattling along the housetops, and fiercely agitating the scanty flame of the lamps that struggled against the darkness.

This is from Edward Bulwer-Lytton’s Paul Clifford

Why is this purple? I mean, isn’t it obvious? At the except at occasional internals part, I want to roll my eyes. It gets over the top, and starts to get repetitive. It has 9 descriptive phrases in one sentence. It could easily be shortened to say the same thing.

Another:

The disemboweled mercenary crumpled from his saddle and sank to the clouded sward, sprinkling the parched dust with crimson droplets of escaping life fluid.

This one is from the The Eye of Argon by Jim Theis (which yes, is supposed to be the worst fantasy novella ever, but is a great source for purple prose).

This one should be even more obvious. It’s purple prose because it's describing something simple in an extremely convoluted way. “Crimson droplets of escaping life fluid”. Obviously, just saying blood would be easier.

These examples are obviously extremes. I picked them on purpose for that reason to get across just how purple prose can get.


One of my favorite arguments against purple prose is something Ernest Hemingway said to William Faulkner when he criticized Hemingway’s writing as too simple.

Poor Faulkner. Does he really think big emotions come from big words? He thinks I don’t know the ten-dollar words. I know them all right. But there are older and simpler and better words, and those are the ones I use.

I am in agreement with Hemingway in that big emotions do not need big words. Beautiful writing doesn’t require excess or lots of description or fancy words. It can be simple too.

Obviously, if you are a more lyrical writer, there is nothing wrong with that. I am not saying descriptive writing is bad. I am simply trying to draw attention to the fact that being convoluted and over the top, is bad. Find a balance within your writing and make sure that you aren’t getting too caught up in adjectives and adverbs.

Writing should be beautiful, but don’t feel like it has to be overly descriptive to be so.


How to Avoid It

Avoiding purple prose is something you might do already. The advice to not use adverbs or to cut them is fairly common, and doing so helps to avoid purple prose. Watch your use of adjectives too. If you're finding sentences within your writing that have multiple adjectives and/or adverbs, then you might need to edit some out.

The thing is, if you are a writer of purple prose, you are likely blind to it. Just take note that if you start getting critique on your work and people are saying purple prose, then your writing might be overly descriptive, and it might be time to take an axe to some of it.

Either way, the nice thing about purple prose is -- you can edit it.


r/teenswhowrite • • Sep 05 '17

[WSP] WSP: Filter Words

19 Upvotes

Filter Words

AH. THIS. (also, sorry this is late.)

Okay, this was something I learned about writing about a year after I started and it blew my mind. Many critique partners of mine hadn’t mentioned this to me. No one had ever mentioned filter words before, and then someone brought it up, and I went, “What? What is that?”

If you haven’t heard of them, this will change your writing.

If you have, keep working to edit them out!


What are filter words

When we are writing, we often are imagining ourselves observing someone else acting out our story, sort of like a play on a stage. What we do when we write is naturally place a certain amount of space between us the reader/writer, and the character the story is about.

This is natural. But this is also something we must teach ourselves not to do.

Filter words are a layer of explanation used by the narrator to tell what the character is doing.

Here is a list of some filter words:

  • noticed

  • watched

  • felt

  • heard

  • saw

  • remembered

  • realized

  • wondered

  • thought

  • decided

There are more, of course, and these are the past tense versions, but the same applies for present tense.

Here’s an example of filter words in action:

She heard a loud bang. She didn’t know where it was coming from, and crept toward the basement. She realized it might just be a raccoon, but she thought it could be burglar. Finally, she decided it would be best if she didn’t go downstairs. She felt it was just too scary, and instead, decided to call her friend Joe.

You might be reading this and saying, I don’t see the problem. It’s sort of a subtle thing until you figure it out, but the idea is that the writing can be more vivid, more exciting, and more present without the use of filter words.

Let me rewrite it without filter words:

A loud bang echoed through the room. She didn’t know where it was coming from, and crept toward the basement. Maybe it was just a raccoon, but it could be a burglar for all she knew. It was probably best if she didn’t go downstairs. A shiver of fear crept up her spine and she grabbed her phone, dialing Joe’s number.

You create a more sense of immediacy. Without the use of filter words, you gain the opportunity to show more of what’s happening rather than telling it. Learning to write without the use of filter words is a great way to enhance your writing overall, but it can take a lot of time to learn this skill―and can take just as long if not longer to edit filter words your of your writing.


Try this

Post a passage from your own writing that you noticed used filter words. Try to edit them out, or rewrite the passage without them. Which passage do you like better? If you aren’t sure how to edit them out, post a passage, and I will take a look and give you suggestions.


r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 10 '17

[Q] [Q] what are some of your least favorite cliches in YA?

17 Upvotes

r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 06 '17

What is Teens Who Write?

17 Upvotes

WELCOME TO TEENS WHO WRITE!

This subreddit is meant for teens who write. If you’re a teen and want to improve your writing skills, share your writing, and hopefully receive some critique, this is the place for you.


About me:

I’m Moon, and my goal is to be here to share knowledge with you and hopefully, help you improve your writing.

While I’m not a teen, I am a teen librarian, and I am also a writer. I’ve been writing seriously for roughly five years, and have completed four manuscripts. My love is young adult fantasy, and that’s mainly what I write. I am working toward traditional publication, and have signed with agent!

My knowledge is limited. I make mistakes, and I’m still learning new things myself. I’ll try to help as best as I can, and if I can’t find an answer, I’ll do everything within my power to find someone who can answer. So please keep in mind that I am only one person, with one set of experiences and knowledge!

I’m also available by email when you need me at nimoon.writes at gmail dot com.


HOW THIS SUBREDDIT WILL WORK:

Every Monday, I will post a Writing Skills Post (WSP). These will be a series of posts, each covering a basic topic of writing that can help you improve your prose. If there is a specific topic you want me to discuss, or anything you’re interested in learning more about, please feel free to email me at nimoon.writes at gmail dot com.

Every Wednesday, I will post a Flash Prompt (FP). These will be writing prompts to get you thinking, that you can post to and share your work. They will be 1000 words or less, and are meant to help you exercise your abilities!

Every other Friday, we will have a Critique Post Thread (C). Critique posts are available so you can post a chapter of your work, and get some feedback from your peers. If you post on a critique post thread, I ask that you critique at least one other piece. If you want to critique more, or didn’t post but want to critique, all the better! If we each critique at least one other piece, then hopefully everyone will get some feedback. You can post on the critique post any time during the week, but a new one will go up each Friday to keep things uncluttered!

Sharing work is best done through Google Docs. If you aren’t familiar with Google Docs, it’s fairly easy to use, but you will need a Gmail account. The nice thing about using Google Docs is you can set the permission to comments only, and a link can be opened and edited by multiple people at one time.

Of course, Other Posts are welcomed! Feel free to create posts to ask questions or share information. But if you are looking for critique, I ask that you wait to post on a critique post. If you are seeking a beta reader or critique partner though, feel free to post asking for those.


OTHER THINGS TO LOOK FORWARD TO:

Contests. I plan to host two contests a year. Maybe one short story contest and one first chapter contest. There will be small prizes for these contests. The first will be in October, so keep an eye out for that post.

Critique Partner Match-ups. If people are interested, I can also host a CP matchup. Everyone looking for a partner can post information about their work, and answer some questions about their critique style. I will then do my best to match each of you up in groups of two or three. I’m not sure when the first one of these will be. Maybe December.

If you aren’t comfortable critiquing, I also hope to teach this skill. Learning to give good critique is hard. There’s a balance between being mean and unhelpful, to being support yet critical. I’ll do my best to answer questions about this, or help you learn this balance if you wish. Look for posts on critiquing in the Writing Skills Posts, as it’s a topic I will talk about at least once.


r/teenswhowrite • • Oct 16 '17

CONTEST ANNOUNCEMENT

16 Upvotes

CONTEST ANNOUNCEMENT

So, instead of having a writing skills post this week, I am posting this: our first contest announcement.


Put on your short story pants!

Your will have to write a short story with the theme:

The Unknown

What I mean is, tell me a story about a character discovering something unknown. Maybe its a horror story with an unknown killer or creature your character must find. Or maybe its a unknown place they are discovering, or an unknown love they are learning about. A secret.

It's up to you. It just has to be something unknown being understood, discovered, or learned.

That’s right, flex your writing fingers and get typing, because come November 13th.

The submission window will run from November 13th, to November 20th.

On the 13th I will create a post that explains how to submit your entries. I have created a subreddit, just for this purpose, and you will make a post there, and follow the directions.


Rules

Here are the things to think about:

  • Do not go over 5,000 words.

  • No NSFW content. No sex scenes, nothing overly graphic. I don't like reading about rape, and I would prefer not to read about a dog being killed (it breaks my heart).

  • You will have to write this in reddit format, so be aware that when you go to post it, tab indents do not work. You will need an enter break between each paragraph.

  • You have to relate to theme at least some, but don't stress out about this too much!

Have questions! Just ask!


The Winners and Prizes

The winners will be decided by a panel of judges from a variety of writing subs. We have Mods from /r/fantasywriters, /r/pubtips, /r/writing, and /r/writingprompts (and me!). We will gather, read submissions, and vote. The person with the most votes will win first, etc.

We will choose a first place, second place, and third place winner.

The first place winner will get a $40 amazon gift card, second place will get $20, and third place will get $10. (If for some reason an amazon gift card is an issue, I will discuss it with the winner then and see if we cant find another happy prize solution!)

You will have to have an amazon account and be willing to share that email with me to recieve your prize! And of course you will get bragging rights! (and some special flair that states you are a contest winner!).


Have questions? Ask away!


r/teenswhowrite • • Jan 08 '18

[WSP] [WSP] Action Scenes

14 Upvotes

Hey everyone. Sorry for not keeping things on the schedule over the holidays. Things have been crazy. But start this week, I am hoping to get things back on track!


Writing Strong Action Scenes

Maybe you have a character that gets into a bar fight, or you have a whole group of characters that end up having to fight some giant beast to survive. Whatever it is, you’ve got a fight scene, and for some reason, it’s falling a little flat. Here are some tips that might help:


The Emotions Should Still Be Here

Yes, fights are about actions and having one character kick another characters butt, but one of the most important things about the impact a fight scene has in a books is about the emotional struggles the characters are going through that either inspires the fight, or might happen during a fight.


Imagining it Like a Movie Scene

This can at least help you with imaging which parts of the scene are the most important to write. If you have multiple characters fighting, then considering which character the camera would focus on during certain parts of the fight. Consider whether it is best to focus upon the actions of the fight, meaning the punches and kicks, or gunshots, or is it better to focus on the thoughts going through one of your characters head.


Don’t Break Tension

Be careful. Going inside a character's head is great, and it is important to have some of that balance in a fight scene so your reader feels emotionally connected to it. But if you spend too much time thinking of thoughts a character might be having, then you can slow down the blow by blow of the fight and that will slow things down and can break the scenes tension. I would say that one of the number one things you don’t want to do with an action scene is break tension. Keep the flow of tension as high as you can.


The Words on the Page

Blow by blows can work. But sometimes you don’t need every detail. Pay careful attention to your prose patterns. Don’t repeat words too often, which in a fight scene can be easy to do. Make sure your characters are using different techniques, or at least techniques reasonable for them to accomplish. Your completely untrained character isn’t going to be able to overcome three other fighters without some type of magic or something. But your well trained characters could. Like with movies, there is a little bit of unbelievability you can wiggle around with, but you still need to do your best to keep your reader grounded in reality. They need to believe the fight scene could happen how you have it happening.

My last little bit, is avoid words like: Suddenly, Then, and Now. These can be words that would be of interest to use in a fight scene, but often, if you can find a way to write a scene without them, the prose will be stronger.


What tips of tricks have you learned while writing action scenes?


r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 17 '17

[Q] [Q] Does anyone else feel horribly useless when they're not writing?

14 Upvotes

I feel like I always have to be writing as much as I can or else I'm just wasting my time. I know that's ridiculous but the feeling is still there.


r/teenswhowrite • • Dec 21 '17

[Q] Anyone hate how pretentious a lot of writing seems to be?

12 Upvotes

I see this a lot nowadays. It seems a lot of people, in trying to make some sort of huge, fancy theme and some message about mankind and shit, forget how to make a good story. If you look at a lot of fiction, the dialogue is often really stiff and uncomfortable, and a lot of the characters always seem to be direct subversions of common tropes. Now I’m not saying subversions of tropes are a bad thing, really. In fact, in most cases, they add to the story. But when the characterization of the person suffers, it becomes a little too much to bear. For example, there is nothing wrong with making an antihero. But a lot of people get so carried away that their hero turns into a pile of edginess that broods so much it makes the audience hate him.

Same with villains, too. You obviously want to have the reader understand the villain’s mindset, but I see a lot of writers get obsessed with the whole “no villain is truly evil! They only do bad things because they’re a broken person who needs a little TLC to be all better!” Mindset (side note: some people are like this irl, but, c’mon, there are people who are just plain assholes/sadists, regardless of their pasts).

And with a theme, especially. Having a story with a theme can make it better, but it’s not the main purpose you should have in mind when writing (expect, maybe, if you’re writing a purely allegorical story, like Lord Of The Flies). When you shove something like “at their extremes, good and evil are really the same” (i’m just pulling that out of my butt here) into every single page Of the story, not only will it become tedious and boring, you’ll lose the reader’s interest. A writer’s main focus should be writing a good story that people will enjoy. Not every piece has to be a social-political statement on modern capitalism and the greed it comes with disguised as a story. That just comes off as full of itself, IMO.

Tl;Dr: stories don’t have to be screaming a message to the viewer to be good


r/teenswhowrite • • Dec 06 '17

[YAY!] LET'S TRY A SHORT FLASH FICTION CONTEST!!

12 Upvotes

CONTEST TIME!

I'M READY TO TRY AGAIN.

The prizes will be smaller, but so will the words. There is no wait between now and the submission window, BECAUSE ITS OPEN. It will be open for two weeks.

You will post your submission on /r/teenswhowritecontest NOT HERE.

You will be sure to read the rules about how to post! Please! available here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/teenswhowritecontest/comments/7hyfhz/flash_fiction_contest_rules/


THE RULES

  • Your word count can not be over 250 words. But you can only write 50 words, if you want, or 100. That's up to you.

  • Your story must mention something wintery. Snow, ice, white, cold, its up to you. The story can be about one of these things too, internal cold, external cold, a magic with ice, a world with only snow. That's up to you!

  • The submission window will start now and go until the 20th (this way I can give you your prizes for christmas! I will leave it up for a long time, and give you guys an update when there is a week left, three days left, and one day left!

Your post will go live immediately so others will be able to see it. Since this is more a lighthearted and fun contest, this way we can also just enjoy reading each others posts. That being said, nasty comments or anything rude will not be tolerated!

See the official rules for formatting concerns!


The Winners and Prizes

The winners will be decided by ME. MUHAHAHAHAHHAHA. I might also ask for MNBrian's help, if you are familiar with him, but otherwise I will be choosing three winners. There is no first, second or third. There is just top three.

What do you get?

Well, I WANT to do little redditsanta like gifts -- IT WILL BE A MYSTERY UNTIL YOU OPEN IT! But that means you'd have to be willing to give me an address where I can ship a small packaged of gifts worth roughly 5-10$. If this isn't possible, you will just get a $5.00 gift card through amazon.


Have questions? Ask away!


r/teenswhowrite • • Sep 11 '17

[WSP] [WSP] Dialogue Punctuation: How to do it Properly

12 Upvotes

I’m going to do the next few posts on dialogue, because writing strong dialogue is key to having a good story.

I’m going to to break it down as follows:

  • The grammar of dialogue―because oh, my, lord, do people get this wrong all the time.

  • Dialogue tags―dos and don’ts.

  • Stilted dialogue, what it is and how to fix it.

So, let’s get right to it.


The Grammar of Dialogue

This isn’t a big deal. You write, and sometimes you get a little comma there, a little comma here, some period in there, and god forbid a semi-colon. But for some reason, when it comes to dialogue, people seem to get these things wrong.

But that’s cool, because like I said, it’s really not a big deal. Fixing this stuff is easy-peasy, and has no real impact on your prose or the story you are trying to tell.

Also, let me just say that this will be with regards to American English. Some of these rules are different for British English, but I’m not going to go into those differences, so if someone else wants to post about them, please feel free.


Let’s start with some examples. First, let’s look at what I often see.

INCORRECT examples:

“Welcome home,” She stood up and gave me a hug, “I missed you so much.”

“When they come to pick you up, make sure you have your bags ready to go.” she said.

“What time was that movie at?” She asked, “I need to leave early so we can go get Danny.”

These are all wrong. Here’s what they should look like:

CORRECT examples:

“Welcome home.” She stood up and gave me a hug. “I missed you so much.”

“When they come to pick you up make sure you have your bags ready to go,” she said.

“What time was that movie at?” she asked. “I need to leave early so we can go get Danny.”

Before we get complicated, know the basics. Dialogue is always surrounded with double “ “ marks. The ending punctuation marks goes inside the second ” mark, whether its a comma, a period, a question mark, or an exclamation point. It will always be .” ,” ?” and never ”. ”, ”? .

The first word inside of the first “ mark is capitalized. There is one instance when this rule isn’t true, but when in doubt, go ahead and caps that first letter. Read below for the instance when it isn’t true.

Also remember―any time someone new is speaking, start a new paragraph. If you are going back and forth between characters, each time the other speaks, start a new paragraph. If you introduce a new speaker, start a new paragraph. Basically, when in doubt with dialogue, start a new paragraph.


Dialogue Tags

Let’s start with the second example:

“When they come to pick you up, make sure you have your bags ready to go,” she said.

She said is a dialogue tag (or if one was in present tense: she says). It’s the most basic and most used tag. We all know it, right?.

Dialogue tags are any action that involves speaking. Understanding this distinction first will help you get your punctuation around dialogue right.

Here are some examples. I am sticking with past tense, but the present tense version also applies:

  • hissed

  • growled

  • whispered

  • called

  • shouted

  • asked

  • repeated

  • continued

  • added

  • agreed

  • admitted

  • muttered

  • mumbled

  • lied

  • interrupted

  • begged

  • argued

You get the idea. Each of these actions involves words passing through one’s mouth to accomplish. Some words can be used as dialogue tags, but they are also words that are actions―and can stand as actions without dialogue. You will have to be a judge of that yourself, but some of these are:

  • laughed

  • giggled

  • sighed

In my opinion, I don’t generally agree with using the above three tags unless the words being said by sighing, laughing or giggling are short.

CORRECT examples:

”What?” she laughed. ”No,” he sighed.

I really don’t think someone can sigh a long sentence. But they can totally sigh after saying a long sentence. Just be aware of this distinction if you choose to use those types of dialogue tags.

Understanding what a dialogue tag is is key to understanding punctuation, because it is the tag that informs whether or not to use a period or a comma.

Commas & Dialogue

If a character speaks, and you then attach a dialogue tag to that dialogue, it is attached through the use of a comma.

CORRECT examples:

“That last Game of Thrones episode was so good,” she said. “He ate all my chocolate,” he accused. “I didn’t want to break up with him,” she whispered, “but it was the only option I had.” “The police arrested him,” she said. “They took him right in front of me.” He picked up his sword, saying, “I didn’t meant to kill her.” He shouted, “Help! Help!” He looked at her and asked, “What did you mean by that?”

Whether the dialogue tag comes first, last, or inside a sentence, it is attached to at least one piece of the dialogue with a comma.

If the dialogue tag comes after the dialogue, you DO NOT capitalize it. Why? Because you didn’t put a period between them, so you don’t caps it.

Periods & Dialogue

So, when do you use a period then? There are two instances. First, and most common, is when you don’t use a dialogue tag.

CORRECT examples:

He picked up his sword. “I didn’t mean to kill her.” But the smile on his lips didn’t lie. She wringed her hands together in her lap. “What do you mean he didn’t want to go?” A tear fell from her eye. “He ate all my chocolate.” The boy threw the empty box on the ground and pointed a finger at his dog. “He ate all of it!”

None of the sentences here have dialogue tags. They have characters doing actions while speaking, yes, but since we are not specifically using a dialogue tag, we do not use a comma. We use a period.

Just like with other sentences and periods, if you finished a piece of dialogue with a period, the next sentence needs to be capitalized. Just because a “ mark is between the period and the next sentence doesn’t mean you ignore the rules of a period.


The second instance is when you are using a dialogue tag, but the dialogue continues.

CORRECT examples:

“The police arrested him,” she said. “They took him right in front of me.” “That last Game of Thrones episode was so good,” she said. “I didn’t know what to expect.” “They took my chocolate,” he cried. “I just wanted to eat my chocolate.”

If the first section of dialogue is a complete sentence (everything within the “ “ makes a sentence), then after the dialogue tag, you use a period. Do not attempt to connect the two pieces of dialogue unless the first piece of dialogue is not a complete sentence. Also, do not attempt to connect the two pieces of dialogue with an action that is not a dialogue tag.

If the first piece of dialogue is NOT a complete sentence, feel free to use commas on both sides of the dialogue tag to connect it. This is also the only time it is acceptable to NOT capitalize the first letter inside of the “ tag.

CORRECT examples:

“When the man came to pick up my son,” the father said, “I expected him to come alone.” “If you don’t stop yelling,” the soldier threatened, “you’ll lose your head.” “What kind of a girl,” he asked, “doesn’t like a bouquet of flowers?”

INCORRECT examples:

“The police arrested him,” she wrung her hands together in her lap, “they took him right in front of me.” “They took my chocolate,” he cried, “I just wanted to eat my chocolate.”

And the most common:

INCORRECT example:

“That last Game of Thrones episode was so good,” she paused, “I didn’t know what to expect.”

Paused is not a dialogue tag. You are not speaking when you pause―you are pausing. It is a separate action and thus would get periods around it.

CORRECT example:

“That last Game of Thrones episode was so good.” She paused. “I didn’t know what to expect.”

Question Marks or Exclamation Points and Dialogue

Generally, this is one of those weird things because a ? and ! will act as both a comma and a period. If you need a question mark or an exclamation point, then you simply put the question mark/exclamation point instead of a comma, and use your tag. Or you put your question mark/exclamation point down instead of your period, and write your action.

The weird part: if it is in place of a comma, meaning you are connecting the dialogue to a dialogue tag, you DO NOT capitalize the first letter after your “ mark. If it acts as a period, connecting dialogue to an action, you DO capitalize it. See below for examples.

CORRECT examples:

“What did she look like?” he asked. She asked, “What are you looking at?” “I don’t understand!” He lifted his papers and scanned them. “What do you mean?” “Why didn’t she want to go with me?” He scratched at his chin and thought, waiting for her to answer.” “What are you doing here?” she screamed. “I don’t want you here. Go!” “Don’t look at me!” he cried. “I don’t want you to look at me.”

Odd Ball Things

Ellipses, and interruptions. I … hate this stuff. So I will do my best to explain this part, but if someone has a better way to explain it, by all means!

Ellipses are similar to ? and !. They go inside ” marks, and the capitalization rules are the same.

“I don’t want to go…” she whispered. “But I have to.” “I lost it and, well…” He shrugged. “It’s gone.”

Interruptions are more complicated. You first have to decide which type of interruption you have. If the person is being cut off, then you simply need an em dash inside the dialogue tag.

“What do you wa―” “That’s not what I mean―”

But if the speaker is interrupting themselves while in the process of speaking, then the em dash goes outside the dialogue tag, and next to the action of interruption, with no spaces. This is not commonly done, and I wouldn’t advise using it unless absolutely necessary.

“We first saw the monsters here”―he slid his fingers over the map and tapped to a mountain range―“then we saw them to the souther, here.” “They took my dog”―her voice cracked―“I couldn’t stop them.”

In this case, do not capitalize the action of the pause, as there is no period separating them.


Let’s Review

  • A dialogue tag is an action that involves the act of speaking.

  • If you connect a piece of dialogue to a dialogue tag, you use a comma and do not capitalize the dialogue tag.

  • If you connect a piece of dialogue to an action that does not involve speaking, you use a period and do capitalize the next sentence.


There are sometimes really weird occasions where you are writing a sentence with an action involving speaking, and could be a dialogue tag, or couldn’t. Then its really up to you.

“You should have seen them. There were hundreds. All running toward us. All dead.” He spoke in a rush, only pausing long enough to breathe.

“You should have seen them. There were hundreds. All running toward us. All dead,” he spoke in a rush, only pausing long enough to breathe.

Just keep the basic rules in mind and you should do okay.

That’s it. I hope. This is easy to edit out, so remember, you don’t have to memorize these rules right away, you can just remind yourself when it’s time to edit if you aren’t sure you have it right.


r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 25 '17

[YAY!] Just finished my first draft!!

12 Upvotes

Hi, everyone!! I just finished the first draft of my novel that I have been writing since January, and I just wanted to share all of this excitement with you!! I'm so excited to start the editing phase and for a long time I didn't think I would get this far. I didn't know if I would ever finish it and for a while things were moving so slowly, but now it fees like everything is happening so fast and it's so exciting ahhh!


r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 28 '17

[WSP] [WSP] Active versus Passive: How to Edit it Out

11 Upvotes

Active versus Passive Voice: How to Edited it Out

Last week we discussed what active versus passive voice was. This week I am going to focus a little more on why it’s something writers should edit it out when they can, how to catch it in your own writing, but also how it's a huge issue with active versus passive in critiques.

I brought up a few cases last week where passive language served a purpose.

I was guided down the passageway and shoved into the cell. Food was added to the table for the feast.

It’s important to realize that passive language has its place, and its purpose. There is no rule that says never to use passive language, and if someone tells you that, ignore them. They don’t know what they’re talking about.

With that said, very often, editing passive language out of your writing is important.


Why?

You can pull older books off the shelf and you’ll find them riddled with passive language. This isn’t wrong, necessarily, but books have changed a lot even in the past twenty years. Some of these changes (if not all of them) come from readers changing how they read, and what they like to read. A lot of readers these days want things to move faster. They want more direction writing, and faster paced stories. Especially in young adult fiction, and genre fiction.

Passive sentences tends to slow things down, and puts more distance between the reader and what is happening. With active sentences, there is no breath of space between the noun and the verb, the action is happening now.

She was walking.

Versus

She walked.

Active sentences are stronger. The hold more pop, and more punch.


How to edit it out

I gave some examples last week, and I’m not going to even try to run through every example of a passive sentence and how to edit it, but here are some things you can look for:

  • Was verb -ing. (as seen above with was walking). Nine times out of ten, if you have was or is in front a verb with -ing, you have a passive sentence and should delete the was or is, and change the verb to its simple form or its past tense form.

  • Had been / has been / have been. This generally sounds very clunky when used in a sentence to begin with. You can usually swap around the nouns in this sentence to a more active version.

The feast had been eaten by the king.

Edit it to:

The king had eaten the feast.

  • Watch the use of the word being. Generally, if something is being, or was being done, you can transform the sentence from passive to active by rotation the nouns, and making sure you delete the was being or is being.

The dog was being petted by Sam.

Edit it to:

Sam petted the dog.

  • Was action by noun. These sentences happen less often, but these too can be edited from passive to active. Generally, you follow the same rule for the others, and attempt to delete the was and by, and move the nouns until the sentence works.

The sword was held by the thief.

Edit it to:

The thief held the sword.


Remember passive voice is important too. It has its place and purpose. Usually, it serves its purpose best when some part of the sentence is unknown, as mentioned last week. Maybe we don’t know who is doing the action―in which case, passive is appropriate.

She could have sworn she was being watched.

Sometimes, a passive sentence might just be nice and necessary to mix things up.

The man was interrogated for over sixteen hours by the police.


When people overuse active versus passive language in critique

Some people might disagree with me, and I’m sorry if you do. But I feel that very often, people will simply say, “This is passive” in a critique, and often that isn’t exactly what they mean.

I am pretty sure, even I have done this. Its a natural go to when we read a passage, and something about it feels off, and we can’t quite put our finger on it, but we know that its not as active as it could be.

The thing is, active and passive often get caught up with other important things we must learn while writing:

  • Show don’t tell. (It’s so easy to mark telling as passive, because in a way it is passive. But it is not passive in the sense of grammar.)

  • Filter words. (I will go over filter words next week. I see this a lot. It makes what is happening to the character passive, but again, it is not passive grammatically speaking.)

  • Character passiveness. (This is when the character isn’t doing anything and being passive. Again, an important thing, but it isn’t the same as ‘active versus passive’ in regards to grammar.)

Make sure that you make these distinctions in your own work, and when you are critiquing someone else’s work. Being told that the issue is simply the grammatical passive versus active will take a writer a different way to enhancing their writing, then say if a character is being passive in a certain scene.

“This is passive,” just usually isn’t enough.


Try This

Post a passage that you feel has passive sentences. Try to edit them out yourself, but if you aren’t sure, post and I will take a look and note where the passive verbs are.


r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 06 '17

Introductions

11 Upvotes

Introduce yourselves! What do you write? What is one of your favorite books? What do you want to get out of this subreddit?


r/teenswhowrite • • Jun 14 '18

Finding it difficult to write

10 Upvotes

I love writing but I'm finding it more difficult to sit down and make it happen. I'm afraid of how it will turn out and how bad the quality will be. Does anyone have any advice to get over this?


r/teenswhowrite • • Jan 10 '18

[Q] 2 gay soldiers in world war 2 NSFW

10 Upvotes

I saw an article the other day about two soldiers in world war 2 who were secret partners and they found old letters between the two I did my research and found out how brutal it would be to be caught during world war 2 from black mailing and even being threatened to be killed or other soldier refusing to fucking help when the person was in trouble. I figured it might be a good book idea about two soldiers who were secretly together like the article I read and the troubles of it. It would also be a good book of the social revolution going down in our time. It’s a pretty good damn idea tbh but I WANAN hear thoughts


r/teenswhowrite • • Dec 04 '17

[WSP] WSP: Cliches and Tips to Avoid Them

10 Upvotes

Cliches and How to Avoid Them

/u/Audri_Sage asked me to talk about this. I will do my best, but I’m not sure I have loads of information that isn’t already sort of common sense. But, that’s okay, let’s talk about cliches, and some ways to avoid them.


Know Your Cliches!

This is obvious, right? Part of avoiding cliches, is simply knowing them. If something feels overdone to you, then you should attempt to avoid it in your writing.

Ones that I hate and come to mind for me:

  • Princesses who run away

  • Someone who doesn’t want to be king or queen who is forced into it

  • Love triangles

  • Mary Sues

  • Female characters who need a man to feel validated

  • Male characters who are almost completely detached from their emotions and women helps him learn how he feels.

These are just some I am not a big fan of. What are some you guys know and attempt to avoid?


Ask Yourself Questions?

Part of what makes a cliche a cliche, is that it falls flat. What I mean is, often these themes or story ideas, lack a layer of depth. It is often this layer of depth that can drag a cliched idea out from being cliche, and into being something different. Like with anything overdone, if you do it right, it can work.

Things to think about:

  • Is some part of it true to us? What I mean by this is, no matter if you are writing fantasy or sci-fi, or realistic fiction, is there an element to your theme or story that ties back into something true of humans and human nature. You can have a princess who wants to run away, but what about her running from her throne will connect to readers? The average person won’t connect to the idea of a prissy princess who doesn’t want to be pampered and wants to just be on an adventure and find love. But they will relate to an idea that might be about a princess trying to run from her abusive father king. Make it real, make it true for your readers, and it will become less cliche.

  • Is it an idea that is already overdone? So, sort of like above, know your cliches. The thing is, you couldn’t write a dystopian after The Hunger Games went big, and you couldn’t write vampire novels after Twilight went big (and both are still very very hard to do). You do have to try to listen to the industry and see what might be oversaturated in the market―simply because there are a few of those bigger cliched themes, that will always stay cliched until more time has passed. And if you have a manuscript that is cliched, that you love, maybe set it aside and come back to it when the cliche has passed (or at least become less saturated).

  • Can you twist it on its head? If you notice that something about your story is a cliche, can you twist it around so it isn’t? It can be a great way to come up with unique story ideas, and that can be really inspiring to write a story. What if the princess wasn’t a princess at all, but maybe there is some twisted story in her past about how the real princess was kidnapped at a young age and someone replaced the real princess with your MC. Then you can see where the story idea leads you. It can be a lot of fun to play with cliches by flipping them around, and seeing if you can keep the cliche―a princess who wants to run away from the throne―and make it into a story that no one has ever heard before.


One Note Characters

This is a big cliche I wanted to take a second to talk about separately because I think it deserves its own little space. Writing cliche characters can be easy to slip into, because of how our brains often think about characters when we are creating them. The thing is, we do have a tendency (at least I know I do) to think about characters in a few words. Sometimes, I think, writers are even told to think about characters in a few words. Oh, my MC? He’s a barbarian who trusts no one because his family died when he was young. We fall into these cliches because stereotypes are easy to think about, and can help us paint a picture in our head―but the second you put them into a story, they fall flat and feel cliche.

So, here’s some things to think about:

  • Don’t stereotype. I’m sure most of you realize this and avoid it anyway. Don’t assign a few descriptive words to your character, or if you do, be careful about it. It can be an easy way to set your brain thinking the wrong way. This is sort of why I hate those character sheets. I know some people really enjoy them, but I don’t. They often put me in a mindset where I am trying to fill in boxes about my characters rather than letting them live and breathe on the page. It just doesn’t work for me.

  • Make sure their want or goal, is tied to something deep. It will add a layer to your character right away, and make them feel less cliche. It’s easy to say something simple, like my barbarian wants revenge, and there isn’t anything wrong with that, but make sure the emotional layers are there that not only tie your character to the revenge, but to show why that is their goal, and their emotional growth as they either fail at their goal or achieve it. This is obviously just good character writing, but sometimes the lack of a deep emotional tie to a character's motivation can make a character feel flat and cliche almost immediately.


There are a lot of other ways to avoid cliches, I’m sure. This is one of those things that just happens as you become more familiar with your genre’s specific ones. Ask yourself questions as you write, and make sure your characters have layers of thoughts and emotions.

What are things you’ve learned, or cliches you hate? How do you avoid cliches?


r/teenswhowrite • • Sep 26 '17

[News] Contest in November!

10 Upvotes

So, after giving things some thought, and talking to some peers, the submission window for our contest will open the first week of November, and run for a week. It will be a first chapter contest, (there will be a rough word cap because I don't want to see any 5K chapters!). I am going to leave it completely open theme wise for this round, unless a whole load of you comment back protesting.

I am currently speaking to some friends and peers about helping with critique and judging. But the contest will be judged by me and a few other mods of other writing subs.

Prizes currently are open. I can offer small cash prizes, like gift cards ranging from 50-25-10. BUT I would much rather offer critiques and find a few published authors and or agents who would be willing to read and offer a lucky chosen person a three chapters and query critique, or something else of that nature.

The details of the submission process aren't decided yet, but I wanted to share the information, as I hope to soon be gearing to advertising the contest elsewhere too!

If you have any comments or feedback, feel free to share!


r/teenswhowrite • • Sep 18 '17

[WSP] WSP: Protagonist Creation Part 1: Major Flaw & Capability

10 Upvotes

Hello everyone! This is the first installment of a series about creating memorable protagonists to help steer your story along. This week will be focused on flaws and capability.


Your Protagonist and Their Major Flaw

All characters, whether support or main, need at least one flaw they need to overcome. Ideally, this will be something that is relatable to your target audience.

Some examples:

  • Self doubt

  • Shyness

  • Lack of bravery

  • Addiction

  • Arrogance

  • Ignorant

  • Selfish

Throughout your story your character must overcome their main flaw.

A good way to devise a satisfying flaw is to ask yourself what your character’s goal is. This is usually something the character either needs, or something the character wants. Their goal will be to do or get whatever that thing is.

For example, if you’re writing a story about a farmer boy, a likely goal may be to escape his peasant life. A corresponding flaw for him would be a fear that he can’t survive on his own.

Alternatively, if you’re writing a contemporary story about a musician, her goal may be to release an album. But her flaw is the strong need to work alone even though her goal requires teamwork.

By having a character flaw directly contradict the main goal of the story, their flaw will naturally become a major focal point. This creates an important layer of conflict that every story requires.


Your Protagonist and Their Capability

As mentioned before, protagonists need at least one major flaw. But having at least one major capability to help them achieve their goal is also important. A capability is something your character will be above average at.

Some examples:

  • Analytical mind

  • Leadership skills

  • Skilled fighter

  • Determination

  • Empathy

  • Stealth

  • Creativity

For this, we’ll be going back to the farmer boy whose goal is to search for a better life. In this case, his capability could be that he is very observant. Throughout the novel, he watches hunters setting snare traps and learns how to make one himself so he can hunt. He also watches a hunter smoke meat over a fire and learns to do this himself.

The things he observes helps him learn how to survive on his own--and work toward him overcoming his flaw.

For a second example, let’s look at the musician again, whose flaw is that she only wants to work alone.

In this case, her capability could be that she is very personable. Since she is personable, drummers, music producers, and even booking agents like our protagonist. This allows her to build friendships and eventually, she learns to work with others.


Your characters should each have these three things:

  • a goal

  • a flaw

  • a capability

The goal will inform what your character’s flaw is. The flaw will inform what your characters capability is. Your character’s capability is the tool that your character uses to overcome their flaw, and ultimately, achieve their goal. Together these three things can help you build a strong character arc.


This post is a part of the Writing Skills Posts presented by /u/nimoon21 and /u/tempesthedragon, mods of /r/teenswhowrite. If you’re a teen writer, and are looking for somewhere to find support, please join our sub! If you aren’t a teen writer, feel free to also join but be respectful and understanding that Teens Who Write is a subreddit created for young writers.

Previous Writing Skills Posts can be viewed on our Wiki.


r/teenswhowrite • • Aug 21 '17

[WSP] [WSP] Active versus Passive Voice: What It Is

10 Upvotes

Active versus Passive Voice: What it is

I’m sure many of you have heard at some point in time, someone say, “This is passive.” And, if you have heard that, then you’ve also probably heard that passive is bad.

Learning to identify active voice and passive voice in your own writing is a great way to improve your prose.

But first, you have to understand what it is.

―

Active versus passive is a specific grammatical thing that is used to describe types of sentences.

Active sentences generally follow the format of:

Who is doing what.

Or

The subject/noun is acting/doing.

Passive sentences tend to be more like:

What is being done to subject/noun.

―

What This Looks Like

Active sentences can look simpler. This isn’t necessary a rule of thumb always, but it’s at least something to keep in mind.

She walks the dog. He ate the peach.

Passive sentences can often look more complicated, as they usually add extra unnecessary words, or sometimes twist a sentence around.

The dog was walked by Jane. The peach was eaten by him.

These are crazy simple examples obviously, but I just wanted to give you an idea of what these sentences look like.

―

Let’s get a little more complicated

So, above was a simple version of active versus passive. But, obviously, this can get more complicated. The larger idea of a passive sentence is that the thing doing the action is unknown, not important, or not relevant.

I was guided down the passageway and shoved into the cell.

We don’t know who is doing the guiding or shoving, so this sentence is passive, but rightfully so.

Food was added to the table for the feast.

Again, we don’t necessarily know who is adding the food, and it probably doesn’t really matter. But if you were interested in making this active try: Someone added food to the table for the feast.

It was decided schools would be closed the day before thanksgiving.

One last example to show a passive sentence. Again, the who doesn’t really matter. If you wanted this active, try: The school board decided to close the schools the day before thanksgiving.

Sentences like the ones above don’t necessarily have to be active, but activating them can be a good exercise. With more practice you will learn when active sentences are better, and when a passive sentence is necessary.


The most common version of this I see:

She was standing on the cliff and was looking at the sea. He was watching her as she danced.

This is something I see all the time. These are versions of passive sentences that should be edited out!

Make them active.

She stood on the cliff and looked at the sea. He watched her as she danced.


Next week I will discuss why active versus passive can be so important to your prose, and go through some more examples of passive sentence that are better edited out, than left in.


r/teenswhowrite • • Dec 22 '17

Winners of Flash Fiction Contest!

9 Upvotes

We had some great participation in the contest, with over fifteen submissions. The writing was very impressive. You guys made this hard for me, and I read each submission as it came in.

Great job everyone!


Here are my three winners:

/u/Astronomiicals

You got in just in time. Your submission Winter was very well written. The use of sensory details was great. You really brought winter alive.

/u/primealx

Your submission Her was very emotional. You did a great job of packing quite the blow in only 250 words, something that is not easy to do!

/u/pepperman94

Your submission Nuclear Winter was a very cool twist on the prompt idea. Packing all that action into so many words left more to be desired, but you did a good job using contrast to show regular life to this horrible event.


Everyone did great! I had a hard time picking my top three. It seems like this type of contest might be the way to go for the future. Any feedback would be great. It sounds like firmer deadlines with exact times for things might be something someone wanted. I went with a much more laid back feel for this contest.

If you are a winner, please private message me about your prize!


r/teenswhowrite • • Nov 22 '17

Critique template, how to speak your mind and help others.

9 Upvotes

How to give proper critique? Everyone does it differently, and as long as it is helpful there is no right or wrong. To help people get started, I decided to share the feedback template I use for my critiques, which is based on the templates shared on other writing subreddits.

Here are some things that this template is not:

  • It is not a tool to give objective critique, after all our feedback is only an opinion, so don’t see your feedback as a fact and don’t see feedback you receive as a fact.

  • It is not THE template for critique. There are many, so feel free to use this one as inspiration for your own. Better even, do use this as inspiration for your own.

  • It is not a full list. Feel free to add or remove elements if you feel like it for a certain story. I myself always add a score of 1 to 10 on each of the elements. In fantasy stories I tend to add a category for magic or the creatures in it, in sci-fi I also look at how sci the fi actually is. Play with it!

  • It is not a list you have to follow to the letter. The questions added to the elements are there only to give you some inspiration on what to look for. Feel free to add more details or remove some of the questions if they don't apply to the story you are giving feedback.

While you can follow the template, feel free to also give it your own voice. When giving critique on characters, there are a few questions here on the list that may help you think, though you are free to just tell about the characters what you like to tell. Let the template help you, but give feedback like you would give feedback.

Secondly, how to give feedback. I’d advice to read the story you are about to critique first, just read it. Don’t take notes or mark parts, just read and only read. Then after that, read it again, now while making notes and line-edits like words spelled wrong or big grammar mistakes.

Then it is time for critique. I read the story a third time, all while I give critiques on all the things I come across. During this I sometimes read the same paragraph five more times, let it really ring in my head. Sometimes I go back when I feel something is odd. Finally I read it a fourth time, aiming to just read. Usually I find one or two more points to give some feedback on during this final read.

When giving feedback, focus on the story, not the writer. Try to also add things the story does good, though you might not be able to due to the limited amount of characters on Reddit or if you are pressed on time. But do try to mention it.


General Critique

  • What did you think of the story? This is something I usually write after my first read, to really capture my thoughts as someone who picked up the story and sat down to read it. I also use this for some general critique that accounts for the story as a whole, which I usually do add later.

Mechanics

  • Do things work or do they not? Think about titles, hooks, etc. Things might not be wrong, but still don’t work regardless. If something works or doesn’t work for you, also say why it did/didn’t. It might help the writer.

  • Does the title fit the story / chapter?

  • Is the title interesting to you?

  • Does the genre fit the plot?

  • Did you notice the hook and get hooked by it?

  • Is there a repetition of specific words or structures?

  • Is there too much passive voice or does it actually serve a purpose?

Setting

  • Where does the story happen? Note that this doesn’t focus on how it is described, but on what is described. If the story is set in Mexico, do things happen the way they happen in Mexico or do people pay with Euros for example? Stories can go without specifying an exact location, but things still need to match.

  • Do you realize where you are when it is important for the plot?

  • Are things in line with how they logically should be, or is it explained why they are not?

  • Does the setting contribute to the story?

Characters

  • Describe the characters briefly. If you tell what you think about the (main) characters, you might help the writer show what they want to show. Also, comment on the character interactions outside of dialog.

  • Who are the main characters? What are their strengths and flaws?

  • Are the characters behaving naturally?

  • Do you see the character, or do you only see the role they play in the story?

  • Also very important, mainly when giving critique on longer fragments / stories, do you see characters changing?

  • Do the characters have realistic motivations for their actions? Note that in some genres, motivations may exist that are not realistic in the real world, like becoming head wizard, which are realistic there.

Staging

  • Do the characters interact with the setting in a realistic way? A protagonist opening all windows of his house would make sense in summer, but not during a winter storm.

  • Do the characters react to changes in the setting?

Plot

  • Is the story working towards something?

  • Are there any plot holes? Or are there fillers in the plot that can be removed from the story?

  • If a certain goal is achieved in the story, is it satisfying for you as a reader?

  • Do you feel like some things happen just because they have to happen for the story?

  • Is the plot believable? Note that rules for believability may vary with the genres.

  • What questions are you left with?

Description

  • Are descriptions shown or told?

  • Are the descriptions too short / too long? Does it miss some important things?

  • Do things repeat in the descriptions?

  • If a metaphor is used, do the metaphors add to the description?

  • Is the story consistent in the tense it uses for it's descriptions? (The house is green vs. The house was green)

Dialog

  • Is the dialog natural?

  • Does the dialog help the story forward?

  • Is there enough / too much dialog?

Engagement

  • Do you feel emotionally engaged in the story?

  • Do you feel intellectually engaged in the story?

  • Do you feel a part of the story or more like an onlooker?

Pacing

  • Does the story feel fast or slow?

  • Is the pace fitting for the story?

  • Does the pacing change at the right moments?

POV

  • What is the POV? (First person, second person, third person - Omniscient or Limited)

  • Is the POV consistent?

  • Is the chosen POV justified by the story?

Language

  • Most mistakes in spelling and grammar can be fixed as line edits, if this is not possible due to Google Docs being set to Read-Only or if the same mistake happens a lot, put it down here in the critique. You can also use it to go more in-depth on grammar rules.

Other

  • If you find something and it doesn’t fit under any other category, put it here.

Overall Impression

  • After reading the text a few times, what do you think about it? Where should the writer start his improvement and what is best to be saved for later?


r/teenswhowrite • • Nov 20 '17

[WSP] WSP - Oxford Comma

9 Upvotes

The Oxford Comma

Commas in general, are weird things within writing. You put them everywhere. You put them where you think they should go, and you hope you got it right. Even those of us who have been writing for awhile will put commas where they shouldn’t go, and miss them where they should. It seems like something that should be easier, but honestly, it’s not.

Let’s just talk about the oxford comma for now.


Why it’s Important

This is also named the Harvard comma, and the serial comma. In general, the idea of the oxford comma is that it comes before the conjunction in a list.

The catch with the oxford comma is that it isn’t really required. It’s more common in the US, and less common in the UK. You can, technically (as far as I know) not use it. (I fully admit not to being a grammar expert. I am just trying to share my writing knowledge in a way that is useful for writers, not teachers!).

The thing is, it’s important because there are times when if you do ignore it, the entire meaning of a sentence can be changed.

John sat down to dinner with his girlfriend, a doctor and a microbiologist.

John sat down to dinner with his girlfriend, a doctor, and a microbiologist.

This one comma changes things from saying that his girlfriend is a doctor and a microbiologist (which would be insane, she’d be a real genius), versus saying that John sat down to dinner with three people, one his girlfriend, one a doctor, and one a microbiologist.


Obviously, sometimes as a reader we can infer what the writer meant because the other option is just absurd, but it’s good practice to get into the habit of using the oxford comma to make things clear.

Let’s look at some more examples:

(A favorite I saw on a website once)

I love my parents, Lady Gaga and Humpty Dumpty.

I love my parents, Lady Gaga, and Humpty Dumpty.

Sometimes you can rewrite the sentences so that it doesn’t matter if there is an oxford comma or not. If you rearranged the above sentence, it would make it clear that you aren’t saying your parents are Lady Gaga and Humpty Dumpty.

More examples, with pictures, because why not.

I had eggs, toast, and orange juice.

I had eggs, toast and orange juice.

Picture

And the last one (I thought about the stripper one, but felt it might be too inappropriate!):

We invited the rhinoceri, Washington, and Lincoln.

We invited the rhinoceri, Washington and Lincoln.

Picture!


r/teenswhowrite • • Nov 06 '17

[WSP] WSP: Selling your writing versus loving it

9 Upvotes

So, sorry, but there’s no post on a writing skill today. Instead, I want to talk a little about the balance you’re probably going to face in your writing, and one I’m facing currently:

Sellability of your writing, versus your writing heart

I don’t know if everyone here will come across this problem or have this issue. But if you are hoping to someday publish your work and want sales―so traditional publication―you’re going to have to think about these things. Especially if you are writing genre fiction. And double especially if you are writing young adult genre fiction.


Does your writing sell?

I don’t mean prose. There’s a certain level of skill you get to with you prose and then that’s it. You did it, the prose is solid, you don’t have to worry so much about if you’re showing versus telling or using active or passive language. That’s the good part. The bad part is that there comes a point where every story you write has to be sellable.

I wrote a story and thought I had a great hook for it. But that wasn’t the case. It was almost there, but I had some agents tell me that it needed to be even hookier than I had it.

This is an interesting idea. I wrote the story in my heart and thought well, here the hook is, its solid too and was happy those two things came together.

Now I have to think about the hook again, and how to make it even MORE.

That’s a weird thing to think about. It changes how you think about your writing. Every book you set out to write you have to think, okay, not how am I going to pitch this to an agent, but how would an agent try to sell this to an editor.


How to write the story you love but sell it

Editing. That’s the short answer. You write the story you love because that momentum will carry you through to the end. Writing a book you don’t love is far more complicated than taking a book you do love, and editing it so it's sellable.


What is sellability?

Stakes and motivation. That’s what it all boils down to. What is your character’s motivation, and what are your stories stakes? And are they in a strong enough balance that I can boil it down to about 10 words and someone would get it immediately.

People say this, and I’m sure you’ve heard it. I’ve heard it a hundred + times, but what I felt I learned this weekend was multiply that by ten. It’s like what you think a hook is but super charged.


I guess what I’m trying to say is prepare yourselves. Write the book you love, write the story you want to tell, but prepare yourselves. If you want to sell it, if you want to go the traditional publication route, you have to be ready to take a character and delete it because that might make your book more sellable. You have to take a major plot line and throw it out because that might make your hook have more pop.

Ultimately, we do get to write the stories we love, but we have to edit them down to the stories that will see―hopefully you’ll keep part of what you loved, or you’ll find a new way to love your story, but so far, what I’ve learned, is that you’ll have to give up something.


r/teenswhowrite • • Oct 09 '17

[WSP] [WSP] Dialogue: Tips and Tricks

9 Upvotes

Tips and Tricks on How to Write Strong Dialogue

This is probably my last one on dialogue for awhile, unless there is something specific someone wants me to talk about!


What is Stilted Dialogue?

Stilted is a term that means stiff or unnatural, specifically with regards to speaking or talking. It’s the go to term usually for critiquers when they mean to say that the way your characters are talking sounds unnatural, and you need to work on writing stronger dialogue.


Dos

  • Read it out loud

This is pretty basic, and it’s advice for a lot of writing, not just dialogue. Reading it out loud can highlight stiffness to your dialogue and writing you might not notice otherwise. You can also try getting a good friend to act out a dialogue exchange with you, if you are feeling adventurous. It might help you notice if the back and forth between two characters feels dry or not.

  • Leave out the boring bits

Dialogue in books isn’t exactly like talking in real life. We make small talk all the time, say hello and goodbye, or sometimes go off on tangents and talk about boring things. Cut these parts out. You can write it in the first draft, but in the second, make sure that your dialogue is always serving a purpose.

  • Watch the use of accents

Don’t get so caught up in trying to write an accent that you make it hard for your reader to understand what a character is saying. It’s fine to do some of this, but just be sure to find a balance between the way you want your character to sound, and how hard you are making it for someone to read. Accents are usually harder to read for most than they are to write.

  • Use silence

Someone doesn’t have to be talking all the time. Silence and awkward breaks can be a great way to build tension, express emotion, and help make a dialogue exchange between characters feel natural.

  • Keep a balance between the characters

Make sure that you aren’t completely ignoring some of your characters. Obviously, having scenes where one of your characters does most of the talking is normal, but you don’t want to have a scene with five people and only two ever talk. Normally characters will at least interject here and there, and don’t forget about old Joe sitting in the corner to have him only come in to say one line.

  • Make your characters disagree

If everyone is agreeing, your dialogue is going to get boring. But if they contradict each other, or get argumentative, the tension will be far more exciting to read.


Don’ts

  • Answer every question

This is one the few things a previous writing teacher taught me that I will never forget. She said people don’t talk back and forth perfectly. They ignore what the other person says. They bring up random things depending on what they are thinking about. If character A asks what character B wants for dinner, B likely won’t answer with the place they want to go. They’re far more likely to say something like, “Not that one place.” or “Where do you want to go?”

  • Do the info dialogue dump

It is easy to get to a place in a story where you find your characters need information, and the only way you can give it to them is by having someone else tell them. It happens a lot. And it’s not normally an issue. But every now and then I see scenes where a character goes on and on and on, and ends up just telling a whole lot of information in one big dialogue exchange. Don’t do this! If you have a scene like this, it probably means that you need to sprinkle that information throughout your story, and have some editing to do.

  • Floating heads

Don’t let lines of dialogue float without a connection to a setting and characters. It can be easy to focus on what two characters are saying while you write. That’s okay. But take the time to backtrack and add in some dialogue tags, and other sensory details. Some things you can think about are what body language are your characters presenting? What sounds are surrounding them? What smells? Use these details to connect characters to a place while they chat.

  • Let all your characters sound the same

This is one of the harder things to do well with dialogue, in my opinion. It is natural to make your characters talk like you talk. But people don’t all speak the same. Some people overuse certain words, while another person might never use that word. Think about who your characters are, and how their background might change the way they speak. A boy raised as an orphan on the street who can’t read or write will talk completely different from a boy who was raised with a very formal education.

  • Have your characters repeat information

Sometimes in a story your character needs to tell another what happened in a scene. This can be a tricky thing to navigate around, but generally, you want to avoid having scenes where one character is telling another something the reader already knows. If it’s short, then it’s not a big deal, but if you spend a whole page repeating information your reader knows, you’ll bore your reader to death.

  • use names excessively

People just don’t talk that way a lot. You won’t see things like:

”Joe, bring me a soda.”

”Sure, Mary, what kind?”

”I’ll have a Coke, Joe.”

”Be right there, Mary.”

That’s an exaggerated example, but still, people just don’t say names that often when they talk to each other. They do sometimes, of course, but not repeatedly, and only with pointed purpose.


What other tips and dialogue tricks have you learned? Share them!


If you missed them, here were the other posts I did on dialogue:

Action and tags

Dialogue punctuation