r/technology • • Jun 14 '20

Politics GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references

https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
217 Upvotes

342 comments sorted by

95

u/SparkyWolf69 Jun 14 '20

Trunk is the only replacement name I’ll accept

24

u/wastingtoomuchthyme Jun 14 '20

The pro-moss group will lose their minds.

9

u/nyrangers30 Jun 15 '20

This implies everyone now is currently branching from master and merging back into master.

Many people now use the Git Flow model, where master would match what’s in production, and people would branch from the develop branch.

Even though you can use this workflow and call the master branch whatever you want, I think it will lead to confusion, especially from people who’ve heavily used SVN.

14

u/Ninjistile Jun 14 '20

Isn't weird to compare git model to a tree ? I do not have seen many branches merging back into the trunk of a tree in nature.

25

u/reasonably_plausible Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 15 '20

I do not have seen many branches merging back into the trunk of a tree in nature.

That's pretty much only due to the direction that branches grow being away from the trunk. Branches and even trunks of trees can pretty easily merge together.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inosculation

3

u/Ninjistile Jun 15 '20

Wow, didn't know that, thanks

8

u/Nakotadinzeo Jun 15 '20

Won't trees illicit thoughts of lynchings in the same way?

Only idiots would think "master" in this context is in reference to slavery. This is Microsoft trying to be woke.

-5

u/bruce_lees_ghost Jun 15 '20

Only idiots would think we should preserve outdated terminology. “Master” in CS is rooted in distinguishing a primary from a secondary, and indeed using the term “slave” to refer to the secondary.

e.g., master disks having a bootable OS and slave disks having no OS, thus being dependent upon a master.

It’s ignorant sentimentality and cries of oh-so-terrible inconvenience like this that make conservatism look dumb.

You’re probably annoyed and discomforted by my words so far. Think about black software engineers who may have been uncomfortable with the etymology of “master” branches... who’ve worked with it every day... have habituated it to the point where it literally no longer bothers them. Good for them, right? Acting like damn adults.

Why can’t you do the same and accept a less historically charged term?

5

u/Nakotadinzeo Jun 15 '20

You're talking about IDE disks, which did use "slave". They switched to primary and secondary a few years before SATA replaced it. To my knowledge, there is no "slave branch" of a program.

This time, there isn't a "slave". It's just master, which has meaning outside of a slavery context. Your car has a "master cylinder" in the brake system, but no "slave cylinder".

More than that, your defending a token action that does less than nothing for BLM or anything. Microsoft can do this and announce it like it makes their past racism okay and look at all they did.. they did a search and replace in their HTML files.

The use of "master" here clearly means "the main principal codebase", it's not using a definition that makes sense with the slavery usage.

It’s ignorant sentimentality and cries of oh-so-terrible inconvenience like this that make conservatism look dumb.

It makes the left look bad, when alt-libs suddenly decide that something mundane is racist. Wanna get pissed off about something, look at diamonds and tantalum. Those are two things harvested via slave labor today. Your phone, computer, TV and countless electronic work because of tantalum and blood diamonds not only come from enslaved people, but fund warlords. You're profiting from enslaved people, and niggling over this? And I'm not conservative by the way, not everyone who disagrees with you wants to "suck daddy Trump's nipples".

Think about black software engineers who may have been uncomfortable with the etymology of “master” branches... who’ve worked with it every day... have habituated it to the point where it literally no longer bothers them.

I'm pretty sure any black software engineer will be too fixated on the technical definition of the word to make the slavery association to begin with. You're very fixated on racial issues, so you might. As the saying goes, "to a hammer, everything is a nail".

Why can’t you do the same and accept a less historically charged term?

Because it isn't a historically charged term, it's not the rebel flag, the N word, a swastika, or anything like that. It's a word that means "someone who has mastered something" or "primary, principal". In TESV the greaybeards who master the dragon voice use the honorific "master" and live in seclusion, we have master's degrees, and there are people including black people who are "master electricians".

A line must be drawn in where racist and derogatory speech end, because otherwise anything and everything will be racist or harmful to someone. Did you know there are people who are physically repulsed by the word "moist"?

Corporations aren't your friend, they are trying to make you positively associate with their brand at the lowest cost to them as possible for profit. Remember that.

0

u/Betsy-DevOps Jun 15 '20

One of the best lessons a software engineer can learn is "if it ain't broke, don't fix it", which is a far cry different from thinking that we should preserve outdated terminology.

It's worth thinking about the emotional implications of words when you're coming up with something new, but there's a lot of arguments for just using established terminology in cases where it's already established.

1

u/bruce_lees_ghost Jun 15 '20

The problem with institutional racism is that it doesn’t look broken to the people it serves. I concede, I don’t actually know anyone who’s offended by the term “master” as used in source control. Maybe it’s not offensive to me or you, but is that a defense for not changing something that may be offensive to others?

I’m honestly fine if it goes either way. I’ll ask my black software developer friends and coworkers what they think and make whatever accommodation without complaining about it.

What I won’t do is stand my ground against people who are legitimately uncomfortable with the terminology and say something like, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

3

u/ToyKeeper Jun 18 '20

There are several things broken about git. This is a step toward fixing one of those things.

Linus Torvalds famously hates version control systems, and designed much of git from that perspective. He didn't follow conventions for what words mean, and it has created a lot of confusion ever since git was first released. Switching from "master" to "trunk" helps, but there's still a lot left to do.

Like, git has no concept of a mainline, and can't have revision numbers, and avoids merges by default, and doesn't even have a proper pull command... because Linus didn't understand a bunch of stuff about how a DVCS works best. He got a lot of things right, but he also got some pretty basic stuff wrong.

Anyway, a lot of the industry stopped using master/slave terminology ten or twenty years ago, so it's good to see that git is catching up. I doubt I'll ever see it adopt the deeper changes I want though, like meaningful node order, a mainline, a network transparent format-agnostic back end, and deeper (and default) support for directory-per-branch workflows.

3

u/ToyKeeper Jun 18 '20 edited Jun 18 '20

Have been wanting it to use "trunk" ever since I first tried git 15 years ago. Calling it "master" always seemed like a bizarre choice.

Then again, I've been wanting Git to change a lot of things, and the others are all much deeper so they'll probably never change. Even just fixing "merge" so it does an actual merge by default is ... non-trivial. Because that breaks the "pull" command. Git doesn't have a real "pull"; it's just a shortcut for a fetch and merge, but it only works if it's a fetch and fast-forward. An actual merge isn't the right operation there, so the "merge" command was implemented to do a fast-forward (instead of a merge) by default.

Would be nice if I could go back to 2004/2005 and have a good long chat with Linus before he built a DVCS... could save us all a bunch of headaches.

4

u/phdoofus Jun 14 '20

That's anti-elephant.

18

u/BroForceOne Jun 15 '20

My head is spinning just thinking of the countless scripts and CI/CD pipelines I've written that never took into account the master branch not being called master anymore someday. Thanks for the job security I guess.

Also there is no slave branch, so master in this context is not a racist term. Why don't we change the name of a Master's degree while we're changing names for out-of-context reasons.

1

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

Also there is no slave branch, so master in this context is not a racist term.

Even if there was, that does make it racist. As far as hard disks go, master/slave terminology has no history in slavery. That meaning was retrofitted by SJWs to push their narrative, and weak minded beta males cowtowed to the demands of Twitter SJWs with blue check marks to retroactively abolish an unrelated term they arbitrarily took issue with one day.

→ More replies (1)

147

u/Uristqwerty Jun 14 '20

Americans seem to be obsessed with slavery. Not so much perpetrating it, but seeing it as such a core part of their history that everything similar is related to it. "Master" doesn't mean "master craftsman", "master's degree", etc. No, it can only mean slave master.

It's fucking dumb to treat language as a static thing, subservient to the distant past, whittled away every time something bad happens out of fear that someone might get traumatic flashbacks to their schooling. It's moronic that everyone must pretend that these specific words are so much worse than the countless forms of violence that permeate popular media and are experienced by an order of magnitude more people on a daily basis.

Most of all, this is elitist self-congratulation, as it obsoletes decades of learning materials that use the old term, so newcomers have a confusing split in their self-education, and the old pros already have the mental models to merely swap one word for another.

58

u/NSWthrowaway86 Jun 15 '20

It really does seem like virtue-signalling.

17

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

That's the whole point. When the Reckoning comes it's their get-out-of-jail-free card.

O Heavenly Father, I cannot be a racist, for you see- I renamed all my master branches to something else!

6

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '20

I briefly went through Github's employee roster on LinkedIn. I didn't see a single black developer, just I think 2 Asians and one Indian. It's 100% virtue signalling.

43

u/Deto Jun 15 '20

It really does seem like change that's done for the benefit of patting each other on the back rather than actually making a positive difference in the world.

One reason I think this happens, though, is that it's probably very hard to not do something like this once a few people push for it within an organization. If you're against it, then everything thinks you're a secret racist and nobody cares enough to put their career on the line for a battle this silly.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Exactly, absolutely none will benefit from this change except the organisations will look like they did something to help although its just cosmetics.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/krawiecki Jun 15 '20

I dont understand this change but it shouldnt break anything really , master branch is just branch like any other , it doesnt have any special meaning , even now You can rename it if You really want to. Its just a default name for initial branch, just like origin is for remote .

5

u/get_that_updoot Jun 15 '20

Baizuos infecting the workplace.

15

u/haxies Jun 15 '20

“Master” doesn’t mean “master craftsman”, “master’s degree”, etc. No, it can only mean slave master.

well fucking said

0

u/miniTotent Jun 16 '20

Note that master in master/slave is a noun. Someone/something is the master. Not okay.

In master branch or master copy it is an adjective. It is a branch of variety master. Generally okay but I haven’t gone around asking.

Big difference. Maybe we should be careful to say “master branch” and not just “the master”. That’s also as easy as putting a some static text “branch” behind anywhere the branch name is used. Doesn’t actually have to change branch names, doesn’t break what’s there.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/CyberMcGyver Jun 15 '20

"Master" doesn't mean "master craftsman", "master's degree", etc. No, it can only mean slave master.

[Actually in computing it can genuinely refer to master/slave relationship] (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master/slave_(technology))

30

u/jonny_eh Jun 15 '20

Not in this case. It’s more like “master print”, the one that is used to make copies. There’s no “slave” in git, just branches.

7

u/MarkusBerkel Jun 15 '20

This is correct. If “slave” were anywhere in Git’s lexicon, then, yeah, it’s be a problem.

Like in high-availability setups where there are “masters” and “slaves”. They have issues.

Whether or not Linus thought “master” meant “excellent” or “slave owner” is anyone’s guess.

3

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

Whether or not Linus thought “master” meant “excellent” or “slave owner” is anyone’s guess.

He's still alive today.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/beefstake Jun 20 '20

He meant "master" as in "master copy", i.e the copy that all branches are derived from similar to a "master record" in audio world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastering_(audio)

No relation to slavery at all.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (6)

1

u/get_that_updoot Jun 16 '20

In ye old times of ATA hard disks yes....but GIT uses branches and master

0

u/thissexypoptart Jun 15 '20

"Master" doesn't mean "master craftsman", "master's degree", etc. No, it can only mean slave master.

Yes, “master” in “master-slave” totally means master in the sense of “master craftsman” (/s)

60

u/Gogogendogo Jun 14 '20

OK I think this is silly--it was one thing when we referred to hard drives as "master" and "slave," but the word "master" by itself doesn't have to connote slavery. You kind of need the "slave" term to make that connection. I can understand why one might be uncomfortable with the hard drive terminology, but not so much the term master brach.

That said--it's not a hill to die on either. Terms change, none is sacrosanct, and as long as it means the same thing I'm not going to be too bothered by it.

4

u/whosthisdude123 Jun 16 '20 edited Jun 16 '20

Even in the case of master and slave for hard drives or for systems like hadoop, it is valid to use those terms. Those terms are not used to remind anyone of history or to make people discuss slavery or anything like. Technology and science tries (albeit fails a lot) to find a name that describes the circumstances as best possible.

In hadoop for example, there is a node that is in charge of telling the other nodes what data to hold and when executing queries on that data it commands the other nodes to give it the data it needs. It is called the master. The other nodes respond to these queries and store whatever data they are given by the master in the way the master node commands, these are called slaves. These nodes don't have personalities, they are virtual process when we say commands we mean one node sends a series of bits that represent an action that must be taken to another node. So it is a bit ridiculous to say that this is somehow glorifying or exemplifying real world human slavery. It is just an apt description of the way in which this technology functions.

I don't mean to ramble or rant at you, just saw your comment and it got me thinking so I figured I'd give my 2 cents.

1

u/Gogogendogo Jun 16 '20

Interesting, I’m not familiar with Hadoop so I didn’t know about that example. The term does seem to fit and if we can’t come up with a good equivalent then I see the point of keeping it as is. It was never as apt with ATA hard drives to me—I think parent and child would have been better—but ever since SATA came out it’s a moot point anyway.

I think neither side should be hung up too much about terminology. There are real social justice battles to fight out there. This isn’t one of them and if anything distracts from the more significant ones.

5

u/jonny_eh Jun 15 '20

Agreed. Whatever, let’s move on.

11

u/lrc1710 Jun 15 '20

So the fact that I have a Master's Degree now makes me a racist?

20

u/inmatarian Jun 15 '20

git checkout mistress

1

u/platysoup Jun 15 '20

Pack it up, this comment just won the thread.

1

u/HarryP00tter Jun 16 '20

🥇 Take me poor man's gold

179

u/Smugallo Jun 14 '20

Cmon now it's getting silly

57

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

They already did this 25 years ago renaming master and slave for nomenclature for HDDs to Primary and Secondary.

14

u/Smugallo Jun 15 '20

Interesting, I didn't know this 🤔

1

u/RockSlice Jun 15 '20

To be fair, that was right before SATA came out, which didn't have that limitation.

8

u/jonny_eh Jun 15 '20

But that at least makes sense. In the case of git, the “master” branch is akin to the master print, the thing everything copies from. It’s not even a slavery reference.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

78

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

65

u/SolidMarsupial Jun 14 '20

Next up: master degree holders confirmed racists.

We are reaching unprecedented levels of stupidity.

9

u/ora408 Jun 15 '20

Now this is getting ridiculous

9

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

American slavery didn't happen in any living person's lifetime so anyone offended by this is literally just virtue signalling.

75

u/cryo Jun 14 '20

GitHub is working on replacing the term "master" on its service with a neutral term like "main" to avoid any unnecessary references to slavery, its CEO said on Friday.

Ok, but that’s a git term, not a github term so good luck with that. It’s also very stupid.

33

u/BofaDeezTwoNuts Jun 15 '20

Ok, but that’s a git term, not a github term so good luck with that. It’s also very stupid.

You can name the trunk whatever you want. "Master" is just tradition.

Mine are called Bob.

7

u/spotter Jun 15 '20

I prefer "release_the_kraken" myself. Since that's what gets released. The Kraken.

3

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

Having a verb for a branch name makes no sense whatsoever because branches are inert.

1

u/BofaDeezTwoNuts Jun 17 '20

I'm reading that more as Release: The Kraken.

You know, like how Debian Unstable is Sid or Debian Testing is currently Bullseye.

3

u/cryo Jun 15 '20

Yes you can, but git defaults to master for the first branch. Bob seems like a poor choice of name to me, but whatever works.

1

u/Tell_MeAbout_You Jun 15 '20

I prefer Joe. I can scarcely count the number of times I've fucked Joe over by teaching him something new but he's resilient. I can always convince him to revert to his best manners. Bob though, he's like the resident priest, if someone fucks him over, the whole colony begins rampaging. I remember the last time someone accidentally gave him a change of clothes, but didn't realize they were infested with bugs. They singlehandedly brought down the whole church for a week.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

I wanna see those cicd scripts

218

u/Macshlong Jun 14 '20

This is pretty dumb.

16

u/phdoofus Jun 14 '20

Next up, lynch pins

98

u/mikelieman Jun 14 '20

Words matter. Frankly, I've never been comfortable with the social engineering implications of "submit" buttons.

41

u/OfficialStudyZen Jun 14 '20

Just think of it as consensual, like in BDSM.

The safety word is “cancel”.

7

u/Deto Jun 15 '20

Entering my billing address just got 50% sexier.

3

u/Gendalph Jun 15 '20

I can see where this might break a lot of stuff. And it won't be fun.

Unless GitHub is willing to implement some kind of backwards compatibility, they'll be getting a ton of shit.

2

u/xJRWR Jun 15 '20

I wonder... What can you use for the computer terms of Master > Slave --- Primary and Secondary kind of cover this, but that kind of indicates that they are both master <> master -- I can't think of any good terms to use for a device who is being controlled or doing something based off a controlling unit

9

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

Words matter.

Only to people who let it matter.

Snowflakes need not apply...

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

[deleted]

7

u/LostMyKarmaElSegundo Jun 14 '20

In other countries, they are "Give Way" signs. Same colors and shape though.

9

u/MarblesAreDelicious Jun 15 '20

I ain’t giving nothin! Muh freedoms!! 🇺🇸🦅

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Does Germany still have the "don't yield" (priority road) signs?

1

u/Cosmonaut-77 Jun 15 '20

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priority_signs?wprov=sfti1

Pretty sure Germany uses these with rest of europe, expect ireland.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

OK; the one I was talking about is the "un-canceled diamond".

→ More replies (2)

17

u/need_a_medic Jun 14 '20

I think we should stop using this word. It really hurts the French.

-3

u/mikelieman Jun 14 '20

Yielding is for people who can't accelerate fast enough to merge ahead of the other car...

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Instead, you cause accidents by sideswiping cars.

lol

-41

u/middlesidetopwise Jun 14 '20

Just say All Lives Matter and go full mask off.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

This is a term that has been in computing forever. Master/slave drives used to require jumper changes back in the day.

→ More replies (141)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

[deleted]

12

u/xantub Jun 14 '20

Dictionary starts with 'Dic', too sexual, we must rename it to 'Word explanator'.

4

u/whatproblems Jun 15 '20

Too close to exploit. Better just call it word book

1

u/Cdwollan Jun 15 '20

That's very close to boob

2

u/disposable-name Jun 16 '20

"Blockchain" cancelled because slaves were often sold on auction blocks and chained to prevent from escaping.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/UltravioletClearance Jun 15 '20

I don't think you understand how dictionaries or words work if that's your hot take from that definition.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/FractalPrism Jun 15 '20

this is so stupid.

just like magic banning a card with text "destroy all black creatures"
the card makes absolutely no reference to racism or humans or black people, there is no way to misinterpret it as racist.

"Political Correctness is Fascism disguised as manners" -george carlin

6

u/whatproblems Jun 15 '20

Let’s get rid of colors!

5

u/platysoup Jun 15 '20

hOw DaRe YoU cAlL bLaCk PeOpLe CrEaTuReS?!

0

u/Castform5 Jun 15 '20

My brother explained this to me and I was baffled as to why, since it's a white card and it fits the lore of the game, and fantasy in general. Similarly, he explained the fun statistic relating to black being the only color to have the card "murder".

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

In Magic, there are 5 different colors, White, Black, Red, Blue, and Green. A creature can be zero or more of these colors. Black creatures are creatures with black mana as their cost. "evil creatures" makes no sense as a replacement. Black is not used to mean "evil" in magic, but to specifically state a type.

→ More replies (2)

55

u/su-z-six Jun 14 '20

Master/Slave relationship spans far beyond GitHub or even Git. It's not only programming terminology, but also systems, spanning from software systems to social systems.

Next we are going to change Parent/Child to Guardian/Ward. And what about Male/Female connectors? Gender is non-binary, so we should erase the words from the dictionary?

Can't pretend slavery didn't happen. The words transcend the American implementation of it. A master is a master, just like a parent is a parent and a male is a male. These words have definitions. "Main" does not carry the same meaning as "Master".

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Master/Slave relationship spans far beyond GitHub or even Git

Master/Slave relationships don't even extend to git in the first place. They were apparently in BitKeeper, and that's where they stopped as far as git is concerned.

2

u/Betsy-DevOps Jun 15 '20

For real though, I wish they'd figure out some kind of hermaphrodite connectors that are neither male nor female. Something like the old magsafe connectors they used to have on macbooks, except if you really need to you can just stick two laptops right up next to each other and have them connect.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[deleted]

-5

u/marin4rasauce Jun 15 '20

Aren't you the one policing speech by drawing lines in the sand? Words change meaning over time for many reasons. Get with the times, or at least get over yourself.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (10)

42

u/acacia-club-road Jun 14 '20

So "male" and "female" screws, nuts, etc have to all be renamed at Lowe's Hardware?

14

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

my work hasn't been allowed to use the term "grease nipple" for years

14

u/RapedByPlushies Jun 14 '20

external thread v internal thread

1

u/cestcommecalalalala Jun 15 '20

What about plugs?

21

u/Sephran Jun 15 '20

This is unbelievably stupid. Context matters when you are speaking and their's NO WAY when going to github you don't understand that "master" refers to the top branch.

My first thought when reading this was, omgod next they gonna go after harddrives being a master/slave relationship. One is the top over the others. It's not some covert racist term lol.

If your github branch name or comments are racist, then you got much bigger issues at hand then using "master".

I'm all for dealing with racism and the hate issues that are EVERYWHERE, but if you don't understand context of words, then we are FUCKED trying to have a conversation about fixing the issues.

31

u/thehighshibe Jun 14 '20

This is fuckin stupid. What about all the software that uses master/slave terminology, not to mention Git itself?

Edit: so I thought about it, and changing master to main is still stupid because master doesn't automatically link to slavery or whatever, but slave (obviously) does. If they change slave then fine theres no problem with that but changing master is still stupid

2

u/Chknbone Jun 15 '20

Right up front, i'll just say that I don't care either way if they change it. I change master to OG on every repo I set up, so who gives a shit.

But it's wierd to me that you don't mind changing slave, but you do get bent about changing master? Why? It's just a couple characters.

2

u/thehighshibe Jun 15 '20

I'm speaking from personal experience so it might well be different for other people but I have projects in which I've mentioned the master branch, but I've never called any other branch a slave branch just called them by their names. Master doesn't have the same connotations slave does in my head. When I think of slave I think of slavery pretty early on but when I think of master I think of original version. Master just means OG and you gotta stretch to make it mean something else in this context.

2

u/Chknbone Jun 15 '20

I can understand that totally.

But if the company wants to change. Let them, it's their call after all and you could just rename your repo back to Master if you feel so connected to it? That way Github gets the PR boost, and you(not YOU you, but everyone that wants to call it master) can. Win win, yes?

0

u/nyrangers30 Jun 15 '20

According to the article, git is considering renaming it as well. Hopefully they work together on the renaming, because whatever they decide with should be the same to avoid any confusion.

49

u/jameslawrence1 Jun 14 '20

How bloody stupid. These companies want to be seen to be doing the right thing. When they're all that afraid of backlash from political correctness you know the world has gone mad.

17

u/wrtbwtrfasdf Jun 14 '20

It is a really shit dynamic. I'm all for equal rights, but stuff like this is weird and excessive.

-21

u/Leavingbehind Jun 14 '20

Actually it does matter. While it will irk people for a while, you’ll get past the discomfort of renaming and the words will be used less in conversation. I understand your frustration, but it’s actually a reasonable choice. I worked with Nat (the CEO) for three years and he’s an incredibly smart, switched on and empathic guy. This isn’t about changing because of political backlash, this is taking the opportunity in the current climate to make a choice that benefits people by removing a bad inference.

13

u/jameslawrence1 Jun 15 '20

Bull. It's an attempt by people who want to be offended to disrupt the system. We've become nambi-pambi. Draw a line and get over it and the quicker we do we'll take pride again in some common sense and morality.

There are literally hundreds of words I can think of which are demeaning. Hundreds of television shows which are offensive. Hundreds of things in this world that others will not like but the current climate doesn't just push good agendas in this world, it pushes bad ones too and have no doubt there are forces in this world right now pushing for change beyond that of what should be considered acceptable.

We're talking about words and lines of code which have been practiced for years without malicious meaning or intent.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

1984 was not intended to be a how-to, you fascist piece of shit.

-4

u/mrcoolguy1_1 Jun 15 '20

github changing some technical terms = fascism lmao what the fuck

8

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Seeking to remove words from use to prevent thoughtcrime is totalitarianism with a colouring of fascism.

Thanks for keeping up with the class!

1

u/mrcoolguy1_1 Jun 18 '20

just finished 1984 turns out you’re still wrong

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/Leavingbehind Jun 15 '20

It’s a private platform, they can change what they want. So suck it up buttercup

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

No, we're not gonna suck it up, slave.

lol

9

u/onairmastering Jun 15 '20

So what, now I'm not a mastering engineer who delivers Masters?

1

u/Ghost-of-Sanity Jun 15 '20

Same boat. I’ll grab an oar. Crap...

4

u/Viper_ACR Jun 15 '20

This honestly seems dumb.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Wait, so what if you have a masters degree? Does that mean you have connotations to slavery? Fucking no it doesn't what kind of PR move are they trying to acomplish here?

19

u/Ninjistile Jun 14 '20

I suggest Dictator or emperor. It sounds more fun :)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

Not sure about merging/pushing to and pulling from dictator/emperor. Haha

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

“Formal” and “fucking casuals”

16

u/JohnShart Jun 14 '20

Call it "bater"

Also, anyone who's offended by the word "master" probably deserves it. Fucking grow a pair.

3

u/nyrangers30 Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20

git branch -m master

Now we can make believe this announcement never happened.

3

u/dont_forget_canada Jun 15 '20

just for new repos only or does this somehow effect existing ones too? Assume not since it would break a lot of automation.

27

u/Ninjistile Jun 14 '20

To be serious, it's pretty sad. According to this: https://www.thefreedictionary.com/master The meaning of Master has nothing to do with race. Of course it is just an example but same goes for Slave.

When you work in computer science, you just work with the meaning of the words. Nobody thinks about history or "racially-loaded" things.

It's also awful because it makes you use meaningless word. When you have an object which is the master of another, it's because it has full control of the latter. Other words cannot convey all of these meanings.

In fact, the only things that make those terms related to racism are those who say it is without knowing all the science behind.

17

u/wrtbwtrfasdf Jun 14 '20

Microsoft's "woke" first year interns got together and approached github's marketing dept with this idea I'm guessing.

4

u/OS6aDohpegavod4 Jun 14 '20

The other thing is, they're changing the name for the Git master branch too, which isn't even about master / slave relationships. It's more like "master craftsman" or "the master sword".

Idiotic.

3

u/columbo222 Jun 14 '20

When I was learning about sound control equipment, I thought the terms "master" and "slave" were super weird. Yeah I'm used to it now but it was still a bit jarring at first. There's nothing wrong with changing them for the next generation of learners, in fact I really welcome it.

16

u/jmnugent Jun 14 '20

But why?.. Solely because it makes some small percentage of people .... "uncomfortable" ?.. that's just silly. Do we have to go through and sanitize everything in the world just to make sure nobody ever gets "triggered" by some unexpected coincidence or mention ?

-9

u/columbo222 Jun 14 '20

We don't necessarily need to, no, but when a company or group like github decides to make a change like this, we should respond with "hey OK, cool" instead of getting up in arms about it.

15

u/jmnugent Jun 14 '20

I don't tend to react with "Hey, OK cool" to ideas that are nonsensical or stupid. But maybe that's just me. (doesn't seem like it's just me, given the other responses in this thread).

→ More replies (13)

1

u/wrtbwtrfasdf Jun 14 '20

companies will never be your friends

-6

u/swistak84 Jun 14 '20

Why not? I couldn't care less, but if someone finds it offensive, I'm ok with changing it because ... I couldn't care less.

It's just a name for a main branch, it can be you know ... "main", one letter less to type.

I thought I's silly at first, but honestly, why not? I'm struggling to find any argument to keep "master" as a main branch outside "it has always been this way" (since when Git came).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Lol dude There are so many things in the world that reminds people of their horrible past (non US centric) doesn't mean you should remove all words in dictionary

-5

u/Ninjistile Jun 14 '20

I strongly disagree even more because of the students. Programming is really not obvious. When you learn it (same for other things) you need powerful meaning. Those words are made for this.

I hope (but I don't think it's the case) that people that suggest it know what they are talking about. If those word have been chosen it's not for nothing.

6

u/columbo222 Jun 14 '20

If people are going to struggle with programming because they replace the word "master" with (for example) "primary," they're gonna have a WHOOOOOLE lot of problems. Show someone with no programming experience a chunk of code and they're not going to understand the first thing about it. Immediate comprehension for the uninitiated has never been a feature of programming.

2

u/Ninjistile Jun 15 '20

I didn't say it is. That's why we should use meaningful terms... To make it easier...

13

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

This is getting very stupid... the war on words needs to go away.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Keep fighting the speech police. Call these nannies out whenever you get the chance

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

The “progressives” can’t control your thoughts without limiting your words.

6

u/acacia-club-road Jun 14 '20

They'll also need to check words in the music recording industry where master and slave finished products are available.

7

u/Diendkzhnd Jun 15 '20

Stupid, panicking politics. All we ever get. STUPID.

9

u/Justausername1234 Jun 14 '20

I want to promote the use of "principal" as a replacement. It has a similar etymology, originating from a latin word meaning authority figure, and it means the same thing, authoritative or main copy. Most importantly, principal branch sounds cooler than main branch.

13

u/NSWthrowaway86 Jun 15 '20

principal

This implies a heirarchial relationship with a power imbalance.

I'm not sure this is permissible in the current climate.

push

This implies a violent, non-consensual act.

pull

This implies a violent, non-consensual act, actively reducing the ability to social distance.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

[deleted]

4

u/ProcyonHabilis Jun 15 '20

Too many syllables, I'd prefer main personally. The context is different enough that I would be surprised if it got confused with things like main methods. No way would I ever say "push to principle" or "merge principle into the branch", it's just too awkward.

1

u/jstrickler Jun 15 '20

How about "prime" ??

4

u/NSWthrowaway86 Jun 15 '20

This has to be a joke.

4

u/Veritas_et_Fortitudo Jun 15 '20

Yet another ultra dumb take.

So my master's degree is racist now... like wft people, just stop

7

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

I suggest master/puppet.

0

u/Viper_ACR Jun 15 '20

Master of puppets

6

u/bonecrusher32 Jun 14 '20

Makes me think of all of the old ide hard drives that were run master or slave.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Well, pretending a word is a problem beats the shit out of actually doing something.

Assholes.

6

u/CraigTheIrishman Jun 15 '20

It's not about doing good, it's about feeling good.

2

u/BlackIce_ Jun 15 '20

I wonder what will happen to Jenkins after all this.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

This is most idiotic news that i read today.

2

u/lunaticneko Jun 15 '20

Software analysts who depend on keyword detection and have been using "master" as a literal: *(screams)

Chad devs who pre-assign str masterbranch_name = "master": *(smirks)

2

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

Music can no longer be remastered, because I can probably find at least one verified and actual black person who will post on Twitter to attest they are offended by this, and that's all the evidence I need to go on a neverending crusade against various words. And if I don't do this, I'm wasting my blue check mark.

2

u/AU_Thach Jun 15 '20

We used the term slave back in the day with tech. I have seen some things use it in the last few years and it’s been hard to use it bc I feel like someone will overhear me.

2

u/phantaz232 Jun 16 '20

This is the stupidest thing i've ever heard

7

u/ThoriatedFlash Jun 14 '20

Seems weird that people would associate the master branch with slavery, but someone must have and complained about it. Of all the places to fight for social justice, someone thought if only GitHub would stop using labels of oppression, then the world would be a better place. It really doesn't matter to me, but I will probably accidentally push to master for a while after the change, like when you use the previous year for the date in early January...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

git branch -m master

3

u/ThinkingGoldfish Jun 15 '20

I got a Master's degree....does that make me a slave driver?

2

u/lunaticneko Jun 15 '20

Yes. You are qualified. Congratulations!

9

u/monchota Jun 14 '20

This is an example of going too far thus causing more problems.

-9

u/itimetravelwell Jun 14 '20

“More problems” can you expand on that in anyway shape or form?

1

u/Fuzzlechan Jun 15 '20

A lot of people have automated deploy scripts (or any kind of script) set up to use the master branch. Anyone that does is going to have to rewrite and then test those scripts meaning at least a few hours, minimum, of dev time down the drain. For something that's a non-issue.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

My company is doing the same. Master/slave are going to be Leader/follower in new firmwares.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Wow this insults me because my family was screwed over by the leader of the cult they followed /s

3

u/emanuel19861 Jun 14 '20

Brings back memories of ribbon cables, and pins to switch from...

Oh no, no, no, no!

3

u/Leiryn Jun 15 '20

Well that #2 in my list of reasons I won't use github

3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

This is like banning knives because they can be used to do harm. Even though 99.9% of people use it to prepare themselves a meal. Bad people will continue using knives to do harm, good people will need to find an alternative and give up what they are used to "because it's the right thing to do".

Is the Bible the next? It promotes light as good and darkness as evil. I think the Bible is really racist. I think it would only be fair to change the Bible.

3

u/columbo222 Jun 14 '20

This is like banning knives because they can be used to do harm.

No it's not. This is such a stupid analogy. No one is banning github or banning any functions in github.

A better analogy would be something like if knives were called "oriental slicers" and someone said "hey why don't we call them knives instead."

I think the Bible is really racist. I think it would only be fair to change the Bible.

Sounds good to me

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

We are trying to ban the use of the word "master" which is the exact correct analogy. And we do it just because a few people tend to relate it to slavery.

1

u/drouel Jun 15 '20

youll need to back to the author for permission

0

u/gurenkagurenda Jun 15 '20

Is the Bible the next? It promotes light as good and darkness as evil. I think the Bible is really racist. I think it would only be fair to change the Bible.

r/selfawarewolves?

2

u/joseflamas Jun 15 '20

Fucking Microsoft, they fucking ruin everything

1

u/Ghochemix Jun 15 '20

I thought they were doing OK until now.

1

u/ComeAsYR Jun 15 '20

Since when the technical terms are politic related?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

NOOOOO MY AUTOMATION IS BROKE

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

UUIDs are the answer

1

u/afro_samaurai Jun 15 '20

This is dumb

-1

u/need_a_medic Jun 14 '20

I am not familiar with this website ZDNet, is it like theonion?

13

u/jmnugent Jun 14 '20

Technology website that's been around since 1991 (almost 30 years).

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

Why not just replace “slave” with “puppet”? One too many syllables?

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

Main is a good replacement

11

u/entitysix Jun 14 '20

Main has a lot of meanings already.

-2

u/mikelieman Jun 14 '20

Ok, I'll say it. Replace the "master" branch with "rope", because then you can...

$ git push rope

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

How trendy.

The meritocratic, skills-based tech center-of-gravity will move clear out of the "woke West".

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

Parent/child works elsewhere

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

What about children who grew up without parents? If we want to nitpick words this one is also bad because some people might develop negative feelings associated with this combo.

-10

u/hatorad3 Jun 15 '20

Wow, the self-righteous entitlement because “hur dur this is what it’s always been called”

If you’re so personally but hurt that they’re changing the name of the default branch to something other than “master”, then fucking make a “master” branch yourself. Just don’t let any black coworkers see it because soon, they’ll know that you just really need to use “master” to describe the branch of your code that doesn’t build properly and probably never will.

-2

u/marianapt3 Jun 15 '20

Should be primary, secondary, etc