Edit: It’s very likely Mojang will be removing TNT duping and sand duping at some point. When they do, they will very likely add a new feature to help fill the roles of these very useful glitches. The goal of this post is to discuss a possible intentional feature they can add to help replace the role of TNT duping when they likely eventually patch it.
Edit 2: my craft recipe ideas got deleted some how. Adding them back
How would everyone feel about the solution to Mojang phasing out the TNT duplication glitch, being a change in the TNT recipe to something that is automatic and renewable?
Mojang is going to phase out the TNT duplication glitch whether we like it or not. I was thinking, what would be the best way to phase it out, but give a reasonable replacement solution?
The best answer I can think of is, change the TNT recipe to ingredients that are all ideally automatically renewable. Or at least renewable. Then also allow dispensers to be pushed by pistons.
For the recipe, I was thinking of some ideas:
#1: gunpowder x 5, paper x 4
#2 gunpowder x 5, paper x 2, bees wax x 2
#3 gunpowder x 5, paper x 2, resin x 2
Historically, dynamite was wrapped in treated paper, which did include wax and resin. If its #1 or # 2, it would make TNT entirely automatically renewable. If #3, it would be entirely renewable, but resin is manual, although seemingly very easy to get mass quantities manually.
The only downside is this would make TNT more difficult to obtain early game. I know sometimes players like to grab a couple of pieces early game to mess with friends or for PVP matches.
What do you think? How can Mojang phase out TNT duplication while still providing a reasonably similar, intentional replacement?