r/tax • • 1h ago

Student researching F-1 taxes: did your employer withhold FICA when you were exempt?

1 Upvotes

I’m an international student researching the problems F-1 and OPT students run into, for a school project. Not selling anything. For those in your first 5 calendar years in the US: did your employer ever withhold Social Security and Medicare by mistake? How did you notice? Did you get it back from the employer or the IRS, and how long did it take?


r/tax • • 2h ago

Unsolved Forgot about Traditional IRA and did a Roth Conversion in 2025

1 Upvotes

Ok this is a bit complicated, but here goes.

So I forgot about an old Merrill Edge Traditional IRA that I used to rollover and old employer's 401K into, fully pre-tax. The amount at the end of 2025 was around $1,300. That said, in 2024 I contributed $7,000 to a different Vanguard Traditional IRA. In 2025 while doing taxes for 2024, I realized that my income was too high and I could not deduct the contribution as a result. So I did a Roth conversion of $15,000ish (contribution of $14,000 + earnings of around $1,000) into my new Vanguard Roth IRA.

That said, when filing taxes for 2025, I completely forgot about the pre-tax amount of $1,300 when calculating the taxes for the Roth conversion. My understanding is that pro-rata rule makes it so that I need to pay some taxes on this amount.

Do I need to go and amend the 2025 return? Or can I just convert the pre-tax amount to Roth now, so that pro-rata rule doesn't take effect for 2026 taxes?


r/tax • • 4h ago

Unsolved Realized a mistake was made on previous years that would be in our favor. Can you refile?

2 Upvotes

Me and my ex realized that he had filled out his state taxes wrong. He is military and he is supposed to file under the state listed on his paperwork, but instead has filed under the state we live in. Adding the years up there is potentially over 3-4k that we PAID to the state because it looks like he never paid state tax (technically he didn't but he isn't supposed to). Is there a way to double check this and refile? Is it even worth it?


r/tax • • 4h ago

Unsolved How to handle a W-2 and 1099?

1 Upvotes

My friend has been working some time for amazon flex, which gives a 1099 since its self employed. They recently got a job working at a warehouse which gives a W2 since its not self employed. My question is on how to handle paying for the 1099 taxes and the W2, do you keep them more or less separate as far as payments? Or do they mesh somehow? Also just some explanation on how to handle the quarterly payments for a 1099 would be appreciated. We're both new to handling our own taxes so we don't know too much.


r/tax • • 8h ago

Roth IRA/ Marriage Filling Seperately Question

1 Upvotes

My spouse and I have been filing our taxes jointly the past few years and I have contributed to RothIRA during those years. However, he recently went back to school and we decided we would file tax seperately for this upcoming tax season due to his student loan.

The thing is I have contributed $5000 to Roth IRA this year and just found out if we file tax seperately I couldnt contribute to roth IRA. The account has around $3000 available to withdraw.

What should I do ahead of the tax season to resolve this and not face a penalty?


r/tax • • 8h ago

Unsolved Help with W4 withholdings

1 Upvotes

I'm starting a new position after being at the same company for more than 15 years, so its been a while since I filled one of these out. My spouse and I both work with one salary at a little over 100k and another in the mid 80s. With us married filling jointly. Im trying to use the calculation on the W4 page where it says to find the intersect between the pay which for us is 13,200. Is it saying to withhold that much extra per year, more than a thousand extra a month? We never withheld anything close to that much extra before and didn't owe anything near that ammount. Am I misreading this because that seems like overkill


r/tax • • 8h ago

Help with W4 withholdings

1 Upvotes

I'm starting a new position after being at the same company for more than 15 years, so its been a while since I filled one of these out. My spouse and I both work with her salary at 102k and mine at 87k. With us married filling jointly. Im trying to use the calculation on the W4 page where it says to find the intersect between the pay which for us is 13,200. Is it saying to withhold that much extra per year, more than a thousand extra a month? We never withheld anything close to that much extra before and didn't owe anything near that ammount. Am I misreading this because that seems excessive.


r/tax • • 12h ago

Do I need to file taxes if I have no income for 2026 but I received $52k as a gift from a parent to buy a house?

2 Upvotes

I will not have any income for 2026 but I received about $52,000 as a gift from a parent so that I could buy a house. From what I researched it looks like I don't have to file a tax return. Am I missing anything or is that accurate that I won't need to file a tax return for 2026? Im in Virginia if that matters at all. Any input is appreciated!


r/tax • • 12h ago

Owe the California Franchise Tax Board roughly $53,000

4 Upvotes

I just filed my taxes for years 2024 and 2025. My spouse and I owe the California Franchise Tax Board roughly $53,000 for years 2019–2025 altogether. I know we made some bad decisions in the past that led us to this bad tax debt we’re currently in. Just curious, does anyone know if the CFTB is easier to deal with than the IRS? How strictly do they look at the financial statements before putting us in a payment plan? Currently, we were paying about $390 a month, but now I’m sure that’ll be changed to a higher amount which we won’t be able to afford since we’re also making higher monthly payments to the IRS. I’ve been on short-term disability (SDI) through Edd for almost a year due to a hip injury and am unable to work. I am getting disability through EDD, not sure if that counts as income. Only my spouse is working. I’m wondering if we will qualify for some type of financial hardship? I heard the FTB lowers your monthly payments if you owe the IRS? Any advice would help!


r/tax • • 13h ago

1040 tax fee price

0 Upvotes

I want to market my tax business to people who are just starting out or don’t want to go to a box chain and I want to be able to give more service for the price that they would get at a chain store. What starting price would you start your services at?


r/tax • • 15h ago

Solo 401(k): Can I contribute less than my signed elective deferral election?

2 Upvotes

I have a single-member LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship and file Schedule C.

I signed an Individual 401(k) Elective Deferral Agreement stating:

"I elect to defer 100% of my compensation per pay period."

Can I contribute less than 100% without signing a new or amended election? Or does the signed election commit me to contributing the elected amount, subject to the applicable limits?

I asked Gemini, which confidently claimed that, for a self-employed owner, “100%” is legally interpreted as "up to 100%" and merely sets a ceiling rather than a binding commitment.

"Yes, you are completely fine. Contributing less than 100% is normal, legal, and requires no correction. Why it's allowed: For a self-employed SMLLC, electing "100% of compensation" sets your maximum allowable ceiling, not a binding commitment. Because your exact income isn't known until your Schedule C is finished, you have full flexibility to contribute any amount from $0 up to your maximum limit. No penalties or forms needed: You do not need to amend your election form, notify the IRS, or fix anything with your Solo 401(k) provider. Just report the actual amount you deposited on Schedule 1 (Form 1040) when you file your taxes."

And

"Yes, 100% sure. Here is why under IRS rules (specifically Treas. Reg. § 1.401(k)-1(a)(6) and IRS Publication 560): Why the form says "100%": For a self-employed individual (SMLLC/sole proprietor), the IRS requires you to make a salary deferral election before the end of your tax year (December 31). Because you don't know your exact net profit on December 31, standard Solo 401(k) forms use "100% of compensation" (or "up to the maximum dollar limit") as a legal placeholder so you don't accidentally lock yourself out of maxing out the plan once your taxes are done. The "Up To" Rule: In IRS plan language, an election of "100%" for a self-employed owner is legally interpreted as "up to 100%". Unlike a W-2 employee where payroll software automatically deducts a fixed percentage from every paycheck, you act as both employer and employee. You have total discretion to deposit less—or nothing at all—when you actually fund the account before your tax filing deadline. When it would be an issue: The only time you have an IRS compliance problem is if you contribute more than your legal limit (an excess contribution), or if you are taxed as an S-Corp (where W-2 payroll deductions must match your written election form). For an SMLLC taxed as a sole proprietorship, contributing less is completely standard practice."

AI is often wrong, so I’m asking here to verify.


r/tax • • 16h ago

Is this level of due diligence normal for a tax attorney handling delinquent Forms 3520?

4 Upvotes

We inadvertently missed filing Forms 3520 for foreign gifts received in 2024 and 2025. Upon discovering the oversight, I hired a tax attorney to prepare the delinquent filings and reasonable-cause statements.
The attorney initially reviewed our documentation and indicated that we had a good foundation for reasonable cause.
However, he has since requested an extensive amount of additional information, including several years of US and foreign tax returns, FBARs, foreign bank statements, all communications with our CPA, and other supporting documents. He also wants authorization to contact our CPA directly.
I expected the process to be relatively straightforward, focusing on the missed filings and the explanation for reasonable cause. Instead, it feels like a comprehensive review of our entire tax history.
For those who have been through this process or work in this area, is this level of due diligence typical? Is there a specific reason an attorney would need to examine unrelated foreign account reporting and tax filings when preparing reasonable-cause statements for Forms 3520?
I’m not questioning the attorney’s competence, just trying to understand whether this is standard practice.


r/tax • • 19h ago

$750k W2 wage HENRY: What are the best tax strategies for me?

49 Upvotes

About me:

- Single (42), work in tech, US based in California so they tax me a lot as you can imagine.
- Have 401k and have been maxing that out already.
- I am looking at a solar tax credit strategy
- I have an HSA
- Net worth is around 2m
- No cap gains losses this. Year to harvest

Considering it is November, is there anything else I can do today or prep for 2028?


r/tax • • 23h ago

The $3k deduction is pointless

0 Upvotes

It just occurred to me that using the $3k deduction from a moderately sized loss every year chips away at the loss until you eventually have nothing left. When a big gain comes along, you will have wished you never took all of those $3k deductions over the years.

In other words, capturing a loss to lower a gain is the real benefit of ‘tax loss harvesting’, not the annual $3k reduction in AGI


r/tax • • 1d ago

Unsolved Closing single member s-corp in CA

2 Upvotes

I am a single person S-Corp(doctor) in CA and was looking at ways to close my S-corp by this December as the money coming in after will be negligible to keep it going considering the fees. I was wondering if there is any cpas or websites outside of legalzoom(hate t hem) that do it and whens the last date to do this by.

also is it better to be an LLC after or completely dissolve it?


r/tax • • 1d ago

Discussion Stocks in Computershare for NUA

2 Upvotes

I am not a professional. My cousin is not comfortable with finances, I am to some extent. I am advising her on NUA tax strategy for her 2026 taxes. She is 73 yo and has an inherited 401k which contains ESOP company stock. She took out her exact amount of RMD for 2026. We just rolled the 401k non stock over to a brokerage. The ESOP company stock went to Computershare. For NUA to work, can we keep the company stock in Computershare, which is classified as a transfer agent, or does it need to be moved to a real brokerage account before the end of 2026? And if the stock needs to get out of Computershare, will that move to a brokerage account negate NUA?


r/tax • • 1d ago

Unsolved IRS lost my paper tax return

0 Upvotes

I am a US Citizen. I got married in 2025 to a Vietnamese citizen. We went through the acceptance agent in Vietnam to file our joint return with the IRS and paid almost $700 for their services. I did the paper return in the USA and then gave it to this acceptance agent company when I was in Vietnam. I applied for an extension with the IRS and it was granted since the IRS owes me money.

The IRS website showed my tax return was received and being processed. A couple months later, I got a letter from the IRS saying the ITIN application was put on hold because they needed more information. The acceptance agent forged my wife's signature, so we're guessing this was why. They admitted that to her. We are assuming the IRS compared the signature on the ITIN application to my wife's actual signature on our tax return.

We contacted the acceptance agent and they said they would fix the paperwork since there was a few month deadline on it. Now the acceptance agent has ignored us for about four months. The IRS website now shows it has no record of my 2025 tax return. It also says I'm past my extension. What should I do?


r/tax • • 1d ago

Is it illegal to overpay on purpose?

0 Upvotes

I have a credit card (specifically Amex Hilton Surpass card) where if i spend $15k in 1 calendar year, I get a free night cert. i have ~~3k spend on it atm, so that means im about 12k shy.

this year i have a somewhat significant realized gains. other than that, im just a standard w2 employee.

the bigger chunk of my gains were in Q4, the rest being spread out over Q1-Q3.

using tax estimates, I will owe about $6k MORE.

before this year is over, If i were to make a credit card tax payment of $12k (Yes, i do realize there is a fee. I churn CC often and using it to pay taxes is something i do every year. although this specific scenario is a first for me) and just get the refund back via bank deposit, is this illegal?


r/tax • • 1d ago

SOLVED NTA / KSK2 . causing chaos on the ground

1 Upvotes

KSK2 was supposed to hunt down all those PR holders who had supposedly “never” paid taxes. At this rate, the NTA might well have to fall back on fax machines again… LOL.

" Tax Agency's new system "KSK2" has been delayed for over a month, causing chaos on the ground

Column

November 12, 2026 5:00[Members-only article]

The National Tax Agency's Comprehensive National Tax Management System (KSK2) will continue to take longer than usual to issue tax certificates in November, more than a month after its first day of operation on September 24, 2026, prolonging the impact. The National Tax Workers' Union Confederation (National Tax Workers' Union), which includes employees from tax offices, the National Tax Bureau, and the National Tax Agency across the country, is increasingly calling for solutions to the problems that arose when KSK2 was introduced.

The comprehensive national tax management system is based on the National Tax Bureaus, Okinawa National Tax Office, and tax offices across the country... "

https://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXZQOUC308BY0Q6A031C2000000/?n_cid=SNSTW005&n_tw=1794702740


r/tax • • 1d ago

Can my self-employed spouse write off her own LLC health plan if she's eligible for my employer's subsidized insurance?

4 Upvotes

I recently started a new job that offers group health insurance through a PEO (Insperity/UnitedHealthcare). My employer covers 100% of my employee-only premium and subsidizes the dependent tiers (adding my wife and two kids runs roughly $600–$1,050/month pre-tax depending on the plan).

My wife is self-employed with her own LLC. We've been talking to an independent health insurance broker who is pitching a separate medically underwritten group plan (Ameristead Health) for my wife and kids. The broker keeps telling us she should go with that plan because she can write off the premiums as a self-employed tax deduction through her business.

From everything I've read on IRC § 162(l) and IRS Form 7206, a self-employed person cannot claim the Self-Employed Health Insurance Deduction for any month in which they are eligible to participate in an employer-subsidized health plan—including through a spouse's employer, regardless of whether she actually enrolls.

A few quick questions to make sure I'm not missing a loophole:

  1. Am I reading § 162(l) right? Even if she turns down my employer's plan and buys a plan designed for business owners/LLCs, is the deduction 100% off the table as soon as my employer's coverage becomes available to her?

  2. Does the fact that Ameristead is structured as a self-funded group plan for LLCs/sole proprietors change anything for the IRS? (I'm assuming the IRS only cares about her eligibility for my employer's plan, not how her separate plan is structured.)

  3. Is there any scenario where splitting coverage makes sense financially? We don't qualify for ACA subsidies, and the sticker prices are within a couple hundred dollars of each other—except my employer plan is pre-tax via Section 125 and has half the family deductible.

Appreciate any sanity checks before we push back on the broker.

(And yes I used AI to write this to ensure I got the terminology right. I gave it the situation the way I understand it and then had it format and rewrite it for you fine folks. So sue me (please don’t)),


r/tax • • 1d ago

Roth Conversions in the 35% bracket - what would you do in this situation?

16 Upvotes

Looking for a sanity check on my reasoning here.
Context:

  1. Client has a $7M pre-tax IRA and spouse has multi million IRA as well.

  2. They will begin taking RMDs in just a few years which will push them into the 35% bracket. They are at the beginning of 24% bracket this year.

  3. They spend less than their anticipated retirement income (including RMDs).

  4. They have kids named as beneficiaries on their pre-tax and Roth IRA. Kids are all working.

  5. Holistiplan shows that filling up to the final IRMAA bracket will be a net negative if clients live to 90 if we don’t adjust the pre-tax account to their terminal tax rate. If we adjust for a common terminal tax rate for the beneficiaries’ state and/or extend longevity to 100 (representative of how the Roth account grows for 10 years after it’s been inherited by beneficiaries), the math is in favor of converting up to final IRMAA.

Most likely options:
We could fill the 24% bracket or fill most of the 35% bracket up until the final IRMAA bracket (with buffer).

My question:
Assuming you can’t ask the client questions about their estate intent and have to make a decision with the above information, **what do you do?**

My thoughts:
The aggressive conversion makes sense because the clients aren’t projected to spend everything down in their lifetime and their named beneficiaries imply some level of estate intent. If they live until 90, the higher conversion makes sense in the projection’s math (even with conservative portfolio growth rate assumptions). If they pass away earlier, the conversion makes even more sense because now the pre-tax inherited IRA would have to be emptied in 10 yrs by beneficiaries during their high earning years. We have a short window before conversions are less meaningful, so I’m in favor of taking advantage of it now.

Nothing wrong with converting less (definitely less sticker shock for the client), but I just see a better overall impact to the family wealth with the higher conversion, and am struggling to see a better option.

Anyone have a different perspective on this?


r/tax • • 1d ago

Discussion Can my mom claim me as a dependent if I pay my own tuition? (19, moving in with her mid-year)

5 Upvotes

US, tax year 2027. I'm 19. I'll work full-time in Florida until about July 1, 2027, then move into my mom's house in Ohio and be a full-time college student from August.

She'd give me free rent and food from July on. I'd pay my own tuition (about $7,000 for fall), plus my car, phone and personal costs, from savings I earned in Florida.

Questions:

  1. If I move in July 1 and I'm a full-time student August through December, do I pass the residency and student tests for her to claim me as a qualifying child?

  2. For the support test, does tuition I pay from my savings count as support I provided? Do savings I don't spend count at all?

  3. If she pays part of my tuition from her own money, does that count as her support?

  4. Who should take the American Opportunity Credit, her or me?

The reason I'm asking: Ohio in-state tuition depends partly on whether a parent claimed you on the previous year's return. Thanks!


r/tax • • 1d ago

Foreign-owned US single-member LLC – Steamworks requires LLC name on tax form, but IRS treats it as disregarded. What are my options?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm a Turkish citizen currently living in Washington State on F-1 OPT. I own 100% of Convo Labs LLC, a Washington State single-member LLC that I established to develop and publish video games.

Here's my situation:

  • My LLC is legally registered in Washington and has its own EIN and business bank account.

  • I haven't elected corporate taxation, so my understanding is that my LLC is disregarded for federal income tax purposes.

  • I've filed Washington Department of Revenue quarterly business tax returns, but haven't made a federal corporate tax election.

  • I'm currently onboarding as a Steamworks developer to publish games through my LLC.

The problem:

Steamworks requires the legal partner name, bank payee name, and tax reporting name to match exactly.

I registered as Convo Labs LLC and provided my business bank account. However, during the tax interview, the system generated Form W-8ECI under my personal name.

I mistakenly entered my LLC's EIN instead of my personal taxpayer identification number.

Steam Support confirmed that this combination fails verification. They also explained that their single-member LLC registration option only supports their W-9 workflow, not W-8 forms.

They suggested that I register personally, using my personal name for the Steamworks account, bank account, and tax reporting.

However, I want to keep Convo Labs LLC as the legal publishing entity and receive payments through its business bank account.

My questions:

  1. Is there a legitimate way for a foreign-owned disregarded single-member LLC to complete Steamworks onboarding entirely under the LLC's name?

  2. Would electing C corporation tax treatment using IRS Form 8832 resolve this mismatch? What additional tax and filing obligations would that create?

  3. Is there another tax documentation or entity structure that would allow the LLC to remain the legal publisher without an unnecessary corporate tax election?

  4. Has anyone dealt with this situation specifically with Steamworks, Valve, or another U.S. digital distribution platform?

I'm not looking to misrepresent my tax status. I want to understand my legitimate options before changing anything.

Any insight from CPAs, tax professionals, or developers who have dealt with this would be appreciated.

Thanks!


r/tax • • 1d ago

Looking for Some Guidance on US Tax Opportunities

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I wanted to get some suggestions from people working in the US tax and accounting industry.
For someone based in India with an Enrolled Agent (EA) credential and around 3 years of experience working with US tax returns, what would be the best way to connect with US CPA firms or accounting practices looking for additional tax preparation support?

I’ve worked on individual tax returns (Form 1040), business tax returns, FBAR preparation, tax research and compliance by communicating with IRS as well as State authorities , tax preparation software such as CCH and pro series.

I’d be interested in understanding which platforms, communities or networks are useful for finding remote or contract opportunities with US-based firms.

Also, if anyone happens to know of any firms currently looking for someone with this background, I’d really appreciate any leads or recommendations.
Thanks in advance!