r/tasker • u/Present-Breakfast700 • Sep 26 '23
Why is tasker not open source
Genuine question. With the community tasker has, I feel like it being open source would be a huge improvement to the app and it's functionality. The app could still be paid, with only source being available to those who have paid for the app
3
u/PxD7Qdk9G Sep 26 '23
How does this benefit the person who created and owns it?
-3
u/Present-Breakfast700 Sep 26 '23
a better app, more engaged community and less workload
2
u/PxD7Qdk9G Sep 26 '23
How do you stop people from ripping it off?
-3
u/Present-Breakfast700 Sep 26 '23
what's the point?
5
u/PxD7Qdk9G Sep 26 '23
Clearly it has value. When people have an opportunity to rip it off, they will. There will be competing products, and clones that exist just to spread malware.
2
u/lareya Direct-Purchase User Sep 27 '23
the dev is a family man and has mouths to feed. That's the point!
4
15
u/Nerfed_Pi Sep 27 '23
Android is open-source, and it hasn't gotten any better, Google has only made it worse, and anything anyone has improved on open-source wise Google has made a point to destroy it. João u/joaomgcd has done more with Tasker alone than Google or any other app developer has for their apps, his support and communication for the apps he's made for the Tasker community are priceless, He's a app developer and deserves a source of income for his work, most the auto apps plug-ins were developed back before he took over Tasker development from Pent, and some of the features have been integrated where appropriate, Not everyone will need every features the auto apps offer and will just take up otherwise needed space, so having add-ons is a great option and will save on cost for the end user I'm sure u/Ratchet_Guy would agree especially those that use it on a fire stick. Just to support João I have purchased some I don't use often and subscribe on a few, Any time I've reached out to him he has replied quickly and has updated the app on bug's I reported to him, he has sent me and others test fixes before rolling out just to make sure we were all good, you wont get that from free open-source. This, to me, is priceless, and he deserves every penny. If you want free and open-source, you're in luck, there's plenty of outdated options you can recode to your needs.
2
u/Different_Ad_7089 Sep 27 '23
Though I guess it would be nice for the people to also help code if they wanted to
1
u/Nerfed_Pi Sep 28 '23 edited Nov 12 '23
Fair enough, you can suggest improvements and share directly with João, if reasonable enough and he can do it he'll add it no questions asked, if you look through enough post João has added what alot of users have suggested/requested. He has posted open source plug-in code to get a dev going to help or build a plug-in to be involved, and we even have other open-source plug-ins from other devs. As advanced as Tasker is and what it's capable of doing, it being open-source will ultimately spell the end as Google will block the 💩 out of it. Maybe if when João chooses to retire, he may post the code as open-source or pass the torch to another skilled developer who shares the same passion as Pent and João himself dose.
10
3
u/DutchOfBurdock Sep 27 '23
It's a product with lots of time and effort put into it; proprietary and intellectual.
It's like how Vimto doesn't share the recipe for their squash, or the Colonel does with their secret recipe in KFC. If they did, they'd lose their unique product.
3
u/Complex-Rest-900 Sep 26 '23
Tasker will die because Google will lock everything up in 2 more editions of android. They kill every reason we didn't buy an iPhone. No need to think about open source. To me, best question is why auto tools are not incorporated in tasker within one price. Imagine a way to develop a kid app that had all the capabilities of auto input, auto notification, etc, and tasker specific tasks, without plugins. Then, open a separate app store for tasker projects and kid apps. That is how tasker development would accelerate . Does anyone know how many tasker users are out there?
5
u/Datk-Zide Sep 26 '23
That's a very true, but sad fact! Google is going the way of apple by locking down so much ! I've been a user since Penn created it or ran it. Back then it was truly unlimited access but I only pushed what I understood and what I figured out, but like all good things it to will come to an end.
4
u/EllaTheCat Samsung M31 - android 12. I depend on Tasker. Sep 27 '23
I too think Google is an existential threat to Tasker.
fwiw I'm an open source advocate
Have you got a business plan, spreadsheets, capital to run a business, entrepreneurial ability, Joao's customer satisfaction reputation?
i think the list of advantages you present isn't grounded in any reality at all, other than "it's open source so magic happens"
My daydream? The tasker experts roll their own android-like OS, and we have to blow away android to have Tasker, but at least it wlll work like Apple because the platform would be under their control. Maybe a Chinese or Indian sugar daddy is needed.
1
1
u/ElevenBeers Sep 29 '23
As allways, the problem is probably monetization. Don't get me wrong - tasker is one of the few closed source apps I use regularly. I paid for it and would pay the dev of an FOSS project equally ( or higher) for it. But I am not everyone.
Well, Jao could of course could still offer it for pay on play. However, when it's FOSS you can always build it yourself (and seeing what kind of users this app attracts, that's not to far of a stretch for many). And you can allways fork FOSS - making it aviable for free.
It's a shame not more people advecate for FOSS AND pay the developers a fair price. But that's how it is. Jao is at least a good developer and I trust him and his app to a degree, even though tasker could in fact mess around my phone to quite an extend. This actually troubles me, because I usually wouldn't want an have to have almost complete control (if it chose to) over my device, if it is closed source. But I'll have to trust the dev on this one. At lesst again, he pretty much has a crystal clear reputation in over a decade. It's not like I'm giving Google, facebook or whatever control. (Oh hell no)
Ps: Fuck Google. No, I do not have play services and whatever else running on my device. No double standard there. R Pps: Android is FOSS, the reason it's not getting any better in many parts is because the source is under complete control of Google. They don't really care about "naked" android. They are interested in the closed source experience users (usually) get.
1
0
Sep 26 '23
[deleted]
1
u/obey_kush Sep 26 '23
I agree with almost everything with the exception of "injecting malicious code via pull request" the probability of this is low and assumes Joao or someone else interested in the development wouldn't audit and discuss the code before merging it to production.
0
5
u/Nirmitlamed Direct-Purchase User Sep 27 '23
You need to think from the prespective of the developer. Would you give your app source code that you know a lot of people would want to clone your app and make a money out of it or just make it free?