I have an aging barnes and noble nook HD+ running CM 11 (android 4.4.2) and i feel like it's time to upgrade but I'm having trouble picking one. I've done a ton of research and experimented with many in stores. I've narrowed down my choices to the iPad mini retina, samsung galaxy tab pro 8.4, Sony xperia tablet z2 and the upcoming z3 compact. I've come up with a list of pros and cons for each tablet to help me decide using all the information I could find from reddit, reviews, forums and my own personal experience but I'm still having trouble so I thought maybe some people here could help me out. I have played with all of these tablets in stores except for the tab pro 8.4
iPad mini retina - pros: screen, 4:3 aspect ratio great for reading and overall portrait mode use, build quality, very light form factor, a lot of tablet optimized apps, smooth and reliable os, battery life is awesome in usage and standby, lots of 3rd party accessories, good price ($275 currently but I don't know how long that will last), reliable os updates from apple, dual band MIMO wifi, most powerful tablet gpu on the market making it great for gaming and videos (maybe except for the tegra k1 but I haven't tried any devices with it so idk) Cons - no microsd support, no console emulator apps such as for ds or psp (HUGE con for me because I do a lot of ds gaming on my current tablet), aspect ratio not really ideal for videos
Samsung galaxy tab pro 8.4: pros - great super hd and bright screen so it's usable outdoors (super clear lcd), microsd support, very light form factor, emulator support, 16:10 aspect ratio good for watching movies, has a physical home button which i like (one of the few if not only android manufacturer to do this; dumb physical back and menu buttons next to the home button can apparently be disabled with root), dual band MIMO wifi, comes with all the Samsung perks like free google play credit etc. if I buy from best buy, good price ($280 from best buy) Cons - reports saying it's "top heavy" and not comfortable to hold in portrait mode for lengthy time periods, performance is inconsistent/laggy due to samsung's magazine ux overlay and touchwiz bullshit interface (idk if there are any stable custom roms for it or if a alternative launcher would really solve all problems), processor is pretty good (snapdragon 800) but not the most current, super high pixel count (2560x1600) is taxing on the CPU/gpu and lowers battery life and performance (I have also heard reports that many apps aren't designed or such a high resolution screen and as a result look weird on it), inconsistent reports on battery life ( battery size is small as well - 4800 mAh vs >6000 mAh for the iPad mini retina), cheap build quality with plastic fake leather back, bottom left or right corner overheats through the back if doing processor intensive tasks (similar to my nook hd+), limited amount of 3rd party accessories, unsure about OS updates from Samsung (not a great track record for Samsung on tablet updates but could be wrong), lithium ion battery which lasts less charging cycles than li-poly, speakers are shitty and poorly positioned
Sony xperia tablet z2: pros - fantastic build quality (super light, impossibly thin, overall well made), water and dust proof, sony skin on android is light in comparison to others like lg & samsung and adds some usefulness, microsd support, emulator support, great full hd screen with sony's proprietary triluminos display technology, not too pixel dense - 1920x1200 - which is less taxing on the cpu/gpu and doesnt bother performance/battery life as much (don't care much for pixel count wars going on between manufacturers as I have a 23 inch 1080p monitor and laptop that is 1366x768 and those look fine to me. 1080p on a 10 inch screen is more than enough), 16:10 aspect ratio good for watching movies, battery life is good during usage and even better with sony's battery optimizations and ultra stamina mode, very powerful SoC (snapdragon 801) which is one of the newest and should be able to handle the most intensive tasks along with 3 GB ram, 6000 mAh lithium-polymer battery, front facing speakers Cons: super expensive ($475+ for 16 gb version, ~$532 for 32 gb; nearly the cost of an iPad mini retina and galaxy tab pro 8.4 combined), matte plastic back susceptible to fingerprints which looks dirty, annoying to open covers which seal the microsd and micro USB ports that make it water/dust proof, extremely slow to charge when connected to the micro USB port (magnetic charging dock sold separately by Sony which charges fast but costs $45+. Only comes as a dock and not as a conventional cable so also impractical to take on the go), reports on inconsistent wifi performance with occasional dropped signal even though it had dual band wifi with 802.1 ac (maybe Sony fixed this with a software update?), screen does not get super bright so it's hard but not impossible to use outside, speakers are a bit muffled and don't get very loud or much bass (waterproofing probably has something to do with it), limited number of 3rd party accessories, numerous reports that sony's skin is still makes the tablet lag occasionally even with such impressive specs, standby battery life is terrible in comparison to its battery life during usage according to some reviews (again maybe fixed in a software update hopefully?), giant bezels (bezels make it easier to hold without touching the screen so I guess more of a pro and con)
Sony xperia tablet z3 compact: pros - same specs and design as z2 except in a smaller form factor with an 8 inch screen, very light and thin just like the z2, comes with ps4 remote play (I don't have a ps4 so pretty irrelevant to me), side bezels look much smaller in comparison to the z2 (hopefully doesn't make it harder to hold in portrait) Cons - probably the same as the z2 (hopefully Sony has fixed any wifi issues that may have plagued the z2 and also has made the screen brighter), very expensive as well (last I heard the European price converted to US dollars when it launches will be around ~$432, no us launch price set yet)
I tried to keep the pros and cons of each device as unbiased and objective as possible. I am aware of these other tablets - the nexus 7, 9 (upcoming) & 10, lg g pad 8.3, samsung galaxy tab s and note series, nvidia shield, mi pad 7.9, asus tf701 and memo pad series, acer iconia tab 8, dell venue 8 7000 and others in venue series, and amazon HDX series - all of which I have eliminated from consideration for different reasons. No windows 8.1 tablet recommendations please as I already have a windows 8.1 laptop to do all my work on. If i was missing any information on or wrong about any of these please let me know. Thanks!