I’ve seen a fair few posts where designers are concerned about their image (pun intended) if they use A.I. art. As a member of a commonly targeted market demographic, to say nothing of any game design experience I have, I hope to put some such minds at ease, or at least provoke some thoughtful discussion.
First of all — A.I. art simplifies, but does not eliminate the artistic process.
Anyone who thinks that the first Stable Diffusion image they generate will (or should) be the one they use in a final draft is, quite simply, dreaming. You’ll either sit there adjusting the parameters and regenerating your image over and over again, or you’ll actually learn how to use an image editing software to clean up the A.I.‘s artificial qualities. Either way, you will spend more time on your project’s artwork than you (personally) would have had to invest by commissioning an artist’s work.
In this way — Using A.I. art trades spent money for invested time.
Put simply, if you use A.I. art, the money you’ll spend up front is reduced, but the number of skills you need to hone increase, so your timeline of project completion will extend. That’s a very real cost that you, as a creator, will pay. Artists, meanwhile, can keep the schedule open and take commissions from those who can afford their expertise. Flip-sidedly, fledgling game designers don’t have to look at illustration as an optional feature exclusive to those who already have money.
A.I. changes the negotiation landscape for artwork by adding a budget option. The existence of that option, in turn, promotes purposeful artistry to a greater level of professional appreciation.
Illustration in a tabletop game is, let’s face it, almost always an auxiliary feature. The mechanics, the balance, the functions of each game piece? All of those are ultimately more vital to a game than its art; but, there’s a reason many a collectors’ edition’s crowning trinket is a book of concept art. The value of good artwork cannot be overstated. The value good artwork adds to its game, likewise, cannot be overstated.
Remember a few years ago when the biggest controversy about community artwork was drama surrounding requests that artists work for “exposure” (i.e. without pay)? Many of those requests — senseless as they truly come across — came from places of need, not greed. Making a game — especially your first game — is often an entirely unilateral investment, on the developer’s part. With A.I. art on the table, even if you’re strapped for funds, there’s no more cause for such a demoralizing request as, “do my work for free.” If your art budget is “exposure,” there’re now competing softwares that will do that work for free!
That said, while I argue that small design operations should and will receive community support despite using A.I. art, I suggest there is a limit to this indulgence.
There’s a huge difference between “need” and “greed,” when it comes to using A.I. artwork.
It’s entirely unacceptable, I contest, for a major company to use A.I. art in their products. It’s arguably unacceptable (I hesitantly append) for any established gaming company to use A.I. art. If the community has helped you by making your game(s) successful, then you should feel obligated to pay it forward. The professional artistic communities need each other.
In general, I offer the rule of thumb: If you can afford to pay an artist, then pay an artist. If not, don’t stress! A.I. art only takes away an opportunity from someone else if opportunity existed in the first place. If your game takes off, just do your best to help out the artistic community in the future. If you do that, it’s a fair bet your use of A.I. will never come back to haunt you.
End of essay.
Edit: General Note: Having come back to this post a day later, I realize and applaud that there are a lot of ardent defenders of artistic integrity in this community! That’s (genuinely) fantastic! I hope you speak with your wallets as confidently as you speak with your keyboards!
I hope I conveyed this originally, but in case I didn’t: my advice to anyone who can afford to commission an artist to work on your project, is to commission an artist! Not only will you end up spending less time stressing about art, nor are you only helping a real person make a living, but you’ll also end up with a higher quality end result than A.I. could ever provide.
That said, there were also a fair number of points that condense to the same core principles, each of which I’d like to address.
Rebuttal: Pay for Art or Don’t Make a Game: I hate to dawdle into insulting territory, but this is a.) heartless, b.) senseless, and c.) unhelpful.
Impudent though this may be, those of you who can’t afford to pay an artist and still insist that you wouldn’t even consider making a game using A.I. art: I know your face can make you angry sometimes, but cutting off your nose will just make things worse.
To those who aren’t making a game but contest A.I. art this way, I’d like you to guess how much a game costs to make (taking into account all stages of production, including labor hours). Then guess how much the visual art adds to that cost. Game design, which, ideally, is an art in and of itself, can become utterly hamstrung by its reliance on the luxury commodity that is professional artistry.
If you’re a small operation, just getting started, you just can’t make that happen, and it’s asinine to suggest that your only alternatives are “get in on the bottom tier” (designing corporate products), or wait until you have the money to pay an artist before you start out. There’s another option readily available. Pandora’s box has been opened. You’re only hurting yourself by denying access to what’s now out of the box.
Rebuttal: A.I. is Theft: With respect to those who argue that A.I. art is immoral because it steals from artists, I’ll gladly hear your argument, but I’m particularly skeptical about this line of thought.
Principally, the idea that A.I. steals from artists is the same as saying that an artist who learned to paint by studying the Renaissance is then stealing the work of artists in those days when their own art reflects these inspirations. Machine learning and A.I. are way more complicated than simple copy/paste mechanics.
Point Recombobulation Ultimately, I made this post to reassure any newcomers out there who are making games but see artwork as a barrier to entry. It’s better to take your shot with the best resources you can muster than to let fear of judgment paralyze you.
End of Response