r/sysadmin • • Nov 28 '16

Don’t Build Private Clouds

https://m.subbu.org/dont-build-private-clouds-9a54b3d30c8b#.jnhncimg7
0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

11

u/ZAFJB Nov 28 '16

Don't tell me what to do. You have no idea what my specific requirements are.

5

u/omers Security / Email Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

That's my biggest issue with his thesis; He's using number of servers as the primary metric for who should be in the cloud with very little else considered... Not to mention talking in absolutes in a very grey area.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

TL;DR : Don't own your data, it's so cumbersome! I'm sure net neutrality and unmetered connections are here to stay! Cloud providers have never had a large breach! Such secure!

10

u/_Dave My business card says "Systems Engineer" Nov 28 '16

If you have less than a thousand servers, you shouldn't have any and should be signing up for all the cloud services

Paraphrased, of course, but this might be the worst thing I'll read all week

4

u/_benwa not much of a coffee drinker Nov 28 '16

Week just started friend, it can always get worse

4

u/repisntbackup Nov 28 '16

At my last job, private cloud made much more sense than public due to the high RAM requirements of the VMs. A vm with 4 cores and around 24GB of ram would cost ~$450/month in azure or AWS. Multiply that by 150 VMs needed and we're looking at $73,656 a month. At that price its better to invest in blades and a colo. The public cloud isn't cost effective for RAM intensive VMs, especially if you need a lot of them.

1

u/ziltan Nov 29 '16

our test machines that we deploy has those requirements too, 4 cores and 24-32gb ram, we use VMware and run them in our private cloud because of the crazy cost per month of AWS and Azure

1

u/au_travail Jan 23 '17

A vm with 4 cores and around 24GB of ram would cost ~$450/month in azure or AWS.

$128.72/month with Google Cloud Platform according to https://cloud.google.com/compute/pricing#custommachinetypepricing

1

u/repisntbackup Jan 23 '17

I would be running a Windows server OS which adds about $116.80, 50GB of storage for $8.5, then the load balancing for $20, then egress traffic for $70.

There would be a good discount by paying up front, or reserving instances, but at a certain point buying the hardware is cheaper. Because this would be for a 24/7 healthcare company, usage isn't super elastic so scaling down at night isn't the most helpful.

The cloud is excellent for flexibility, but for saving money not always

2

u/jmp242 Nov 28 '16

Yes, if you want to change capex into opex go to public cloud. However, there are a lot of assumptions he's making - the biggest IMO is the 4 year server lifetime. That may be the common service contract length, and maybe you really want an active service contract. However, in reality major vendors like IBM/Lenovo or Dell make servers that tend to work as built for at least 8 years, often 10. If your server does one task internally, you very well could run it for 8-10 years.

The other issue I always see is that you can't have a big fileshare in the sky effectively. For some file types, Box and box sync or the like work OK. But no one I know actually has all their files primary storage be Box. Much of it is access speed and inability to access directly in many cases. When we're pushing 10Gbit to a fileserver, our internet connection isn't going to keep up. I have no idea what Box can realistically ingest ... Then you've got backup - at least for us, Box doesn't do dailies or give us access to employees storage area when they leave.

I think you just move your work to the legal / purchasing teams as they try and get equivalent services from the cloud, and you'll notice part of it is totally changing your culture - and not just ITs. What if your company culture is currently working? Sometimes capex is a lot cheaper than mass employee re-learning and reworking their workflows.

1

u/IshmaelDS Jack of All Trades Nov 28 '16

FYI Box should allow you to transfer all of a left employees data to another user. (I have done this multiple times with my ex employees data under my contract) Also when I last tried Box choked on 10K plus files trying to be synced to the cloud, essentially syncing never finished, ever.

1

u/jmp242 Nov 28 '16

Ahh, my problem is I don't have the box contract, that's central IT so for us we have no access.

1

u/IshmaelDS Jack of All Trades Nov 28 '16

Ouch, that sucks, should really be an automated process that sends it to whoever is taking over their workload.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '16

What an idiot

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Yeah, I have so much desk room now that I don't have that damn cumbersome PC with it's triple-head 27" monitors and power to run multiple VMs.

My iPad has email, it'll do.