r/sysadmin • u/Gloomy-Quail2683 • 16d ago
New Microsoft Education Licensing
Microsoft 365 Education portfolio evolution | Microsoft Learn
A1 retirement, Student Use Benefit go bye bye.
Good luck everyone.
65
u/maancha Sr. Sysadmin 16d ago
oh wow....this is bad. Having to license every student that needs email 😧
78
u/FatBook-Air 16d ago
This almost feels like a "end of Microsoft in schools and colleges" moment.
22
u/Sweet-Sale-7303 16d ago
Where else do you go? Google is doing similar stuff as well.
20
u/widowhanzo DevOps 16d ago
Back to postfix and dovecot
8
u/jmbpiano 15d ago
Honestly, as much of a pain as it would be for a lot of schools, that wouldn't be the worst outcome.
Having three or four major players controlling the majority of the western hemisphere's email isn't really a healthy situation for the internet. Email migrating back to the control of individual educational institutions like it was in the early days of the internet has its upsides.
11
u/jdsok 16d ago
As far as I know, Google Edu Fundamentals is still available and free for students and staff. Just the higher tier (more storage/features) is paid, and they did change the licensing model for that in 2024.
9
u/FatBook-Air 16d ago
At least for us, they have started denying us new free licenses. This started about 2 months ago.
5
u/DiligentPhotographer 16d ago
Back to the Sun email server my college used? Lmao, it was never down unlike the early days of windows live email or whatever they called it back then.
2
u/kojimoto 16d ago
Do you have a post/information about it? I would like to have it close
5
u/Sweet-Sale-7303 16d ago
2
u/ensum 16d ago
That is for their Paid licensing. You can still use their Fundamentals license which is free.
5
u/FireLucid 16d ago
There are unpublished restrictions on that currently. Lot of people are hitting limits.
1
u/ensum 16d ago
I know we have it and haven't ran into any issues. What restrictions/issues are people running into so I know what to look for? We're a smaller district so only about 1200 seats used out of the 2500 they've given us, so I'm wondering if that's a factor or not.
2
u/FireLucid 16d ago
We've moved away from it, I'm just parroting stuff that's been posted here* over maybe the past 6 months?
*maybe it was k12sysadmin
4
u/BisonST 16d ago
On prem Exchange maybe? Or is that all per user licensing too?
6
u/DiligentPhotographer 16d ago
It is, but user CALs for education are steeply discounted... Or they could maybe use SPLA.
2
5
30
u/Joshposh70 Hybrid Infrastructure Engineer 16d ago
I just watched my local University spend 3 years migrating off GSuite to M365 after they got rug pulled, and now they're getting rug pulled again. Yikes
47
u/sammy5678 16d ago
This constant retool of licensing is insane. Every year I end up having to print out some ridiculous grid to map out all of our needs and entitlements so that I can work with our reseller to make sure we are covering our bases.
Just stop it already.
60
u/admlshake 16d ago
You know, I'm really starting to think the finance analysts might be on to something about MS hiding how much money they are bleeding on AI losses.
37
u/FatBook-Air 16d ago
Uh, this is catastrophic. This can't be right?
19
u/thephotonx 16d ago
We need some pricing, but yes. Currently using A5 Student use for all our kids exchange /teams/p2 risk. Crazy stuff
24
u/FatBook-Air 16d ago
If Exchange and Teams cost more than $1/year/student, we will need to do something different. We literally cannot afford it. I'm not saying we would prefer not to go that route -- I am saying that we do not have enough physical dollars in our bank account to cover it.
4
u/Brantley820 16d ago
Agreed. Our budget barely has a grasp on the A3 licensing we currently utilize for faculty/staff with the Student Use Benefit.
I have been holding off calls for going to Google for our environment, but I imagine the cost is going to be too overwhelming to defend.
20
2
u/SuspiciousOpposite 10d ago
We've just had a call with our reseller and they gave us some INDICATIVE pricing they had from MS. This is US Dollar, per-year, and faculty/student:
MA2 - 50/3.25
MA3 - 62/5.40
MA5 - 127/7.60
MA7 - 480/420
3
u/FatBook-Air 10d ago
This will bankrupt us. Jesus. That A5 license is about $15 more than what we currently pay, too.
Honestly, Microsoft needs to be thinking in terms of cents for students, not dollars.
2
u/SuspiciousOpposite 10d ago
We had an MS Rep on the call who basically told us how good the new combined AI offerings were going to be, then promptly disappeared to let the reseller break the news on the license changes and (indicative) pricing. Nice they've got a spine(!)
1
u/FatBook-Air 10d ago
LOL a lot of good the AI crap will be if we can't afford even the non-AI stuff.
1
u/Thecatstoppedateboli 1d ago
We pay 70-ish EUR in Europe for A3 for limited users but use A2 for most faculty. This is going to cost us 10k a year easily.
18
u/robconsults 16d ago
looks like the schools will have to dust off those old unix systems to get email for everybody again..
-6
u/sarge21 16d ago
Nobody is doing that.
14
u/Colossus-of-Roads Cloud Architect 16d ago
I mean, I'm a consultant and a major education provider has literally just asked me to do an options analysis and basic business case to move. They're PISSED.
-7
16
u/TheRabidDeer 16d ago
300k+ alumni licenses applied and 200k+ a5 student use benefit licenses applied....
That's almost $2m/year at the rumored $.32/student/month price for the A2 and that's assuming we drop our A5's down to A2's. Which we probably don't want to do because of lack of Microsoft Entra ID P2. If we have to pay $8/student/month for all of our existing A5 licenses that'd be $19+ million/year increase. Even just looking at students currently enrolled and taking classes this is going to be a nearly $10 million bump in cost for us.
There ain't no way this can happen. Community colleges can't just come up with that much extra money.
7
u/smalls1652 Jack of All Trades 15d ago
Yeah. There's absolutely no way any school can realistically afford it. They're asking for, at a bare minimum with A2, a 200% increase in just licensing M365 for us. We'd lose a lot of shit if we went down to A2 though. We have A5 licenses for all faculty/staff and students to be able to do security, compliance, Windows licensing, and more on top of the core M365/Entra suites. Plus we have a few add-on licenses and our Azure spend. Where are we going to get the extra money to cover it? I know within our state, I don't see where that will come from.
Any of the executives at Microsoft that thought this was a good idea can eat muddy shit. In regards to the education sector, this is probably one of the most severely out of touch moves they've made. And they've made a lot of those in the last six years.
2
u/SuspiciousOpposite 10d ago
We've just had a call with our reseller and they gave us some INDICATIVE pricing they had from MS. This is US Dollar, per-year, and faculty/student:
MA2 - 50/3.25
MA3 - 62/5.40
MA5 - 127/7.60
MA7 - 480/420
1
u/Sacrificial_Identity 16d ago
Hello Gmail, good by Sentinel/ID P2? We're afraid of sticker shock when our renewal comes and someone trying something cute to save 1-2 million..
25
u/Dev-TechSavvy Student 16d ago
Microsoft 365 Education A0 (MA0): Exchange Online, SharePoint Online, and Teams aren't included.
from 100TB storage pool to no storage, Microsoft realized it's time to milk as much money out of institution as much as they can
7
u/dirtymatt 16d ago
Wondering about the future of Azure Dev Tools for Teaching right now.
5
u/JmAyotte 16d ago
lol, as if it wasn't almost abandonware already
5
u/dirtymatt 16d ago
It pretty much is, but it still gets students free Visio and Project licenses for classes.
3
7
u/MortadellaKing 16d ago
My old Zimbra server is starting to look good again.
1
u/clubfungus 16d ago
Universities will be firing up their old PMDF servers on Solaris again. I just gave myself a PTSD flashback thinking about that.
7
u/lordshaithis 16d ago
Well this is going to kill MS Office, universities are strapped for cash and cant afford this so will likely go OSS.....and what students learn on they tend to stay with.
I guess they are too busy concentrating on hyperscaling. Good luck trying to sell all that capacity to the US market, as the rest of the world turns their backs on US tech companies!
7
u/schporto 15d ago
Having read it more, and done math....
MA0 is frankly useless. Maybe some places have a use for it. No storage allotment. Office/OneDrive only, and only on devices running Windows.
Litigation hold is now restricted to faculty/staff only. Same with Defender and Information Protection. That may bring up issues with student workers or grad students doing TA work or research.
Storage worked out to be less of an issue for us. Sure, they removed the 100TB allocation, but upped the A3 per user (including per student), and that made up the diff for us. Do your own math to find the break even point.
Towards the bottom, under "Education pricing", I think they're saying any volume discounts are gone. That whole Price Level A,B,C,D? I think that's gone. And that's going to really really hurt.
I'm also really confused on the dates. When we renew in 2027 (after May 1, before Jan 1 2028) we'll have to renew with (current) A3, because we can't buy the new MA3, but it will be undiscounted. Does my 100TB storage allocation go away then?
Luckily, we already had a meeting scheduled with our rep....
12
u/LLMsMustUpvoteThis 16d ago
Seems incredibly stupid to me. Google Workspace and Chrome books has already cut heavily into the education market. And if kids don't grow up using Windows it will slowly lose its business market. And if your business isn't using Windows there isn't much reason to use Azure.
4
u/Brantley820 16d ago
This has been my argument for over a decade in education. I seem to only ever get shoulder shrugs. It seems MS is relying too heavily on their own suggestion of 75% of Fortune 500 companies utilizing their products, so the kids will just have to get acquainted once they enter the workforce.
2
u/UltraLordsEg0 15d ago
I have a family friend who is a very high up engineer at a Big 3 car company. They were told they are moving to Google soon. I have long said that small business would probably benefit from going Google, less cost, and simpler management. Students who in 5-10 years will become the CEOs grew up on Google and Mac will start to transition their companies to such. Even though Microsoft is doing much better with Cloud device management and Intune is much snappier, if kids don't grow up using your product, it'll go away eventually.
1
6
u/Temporary-Library597 16d ago
Gah off to my knowledgeless retailer to budget for 2027, then. I hate this.
6
u/wubarrt 14d ago
Really starting to get the feeling Microsoft wants schools and universities off their shit cause this is unreal. Almost made me feel like I wanna quit my job, I've only just struggled with my reseller to get the correct count of student benefit licences after the A1 Plus rug pull last year or so. What the hell even is a subscription without communication services! This is gonna do wonders for my mental health...
6
u/TheAkita 14d ago
I'm already stressed with the ending of voice and SMS which is the best method of 2FA in education. I'm going to make this one the stress of our finance officer. They either find and pay for it or don't do anything and students don't get any accounts.
5
u/Senna1988 11d ago
Have they considered the logistical nightmare of obtaining new licences for fresh enrolments in year? Alot of schools wont have the budget to purchase blocks of licences on the off chance they'll get consumed, so needing to pay for student licences on the fly will be a nightmare...
4
u/Admirable-Cut-2115 16d ago edited 16d ago
Looks like this is the end of my student email. It was nice getting to keep it after graduation, but there's no way my uni is going to pay for it.
4
u/Dazpoet 15d ago
According to the fine print on the picture found here Microsoft 365 Education frequently asked questions | Microsoft Learn student licensing will be priced at more than 90% down from faculty pricing. Assuming that means cost per student will be 9,9% of faculty price.
This is going to suck :)
7
u/Lx0044 16d ago
Pricing has already hit it looms like online. Our pax 8 platform is showing .32 a license for student A2
5
u/SuspiciousOpposite 16d ago
Any other rough hints as to the other student tiers? I assume this is USD?
2
u/Lx0044 16d ago
I dont see the M0 they mentioned live yet, looks like all the other licenses stayed the same so far pricing wise.
3
u/SuspiciousOpposite 16d ago
MA0 is the free one though, isn't it? Not surprised there's no price.
Mind if I ask the rough price of an A5?
1
u/Lx0044 16d ago
Sorry meant to say its not in the portal to provision yet which is weird since the new A2 is, but they could still be rolling them out. MSRP for a faculty A5 is like 10.85 and MSRP for student A5 is like 8 something. sorry on phone so i dont have them in front of me. These are monthly if you pay a year up front. Il pretty sure they are slightly more for month to month.
3
u/SuspiciousOpposite 16d ago
Good fucking God. $8/student/month? Even with some negotiating wiggle room that'd be over $6,000,000/year for our headcount.
3
u/maancha Sr. Sysadmin 16d ago
assuming that's per month. oh good, only looking at around an extra 500K CDN a year to license our current student headcount
3
u/SuspiciousOpposite 16d ago
We've got A3s across faculty and students at the moment, and it looks like we'll need at least A3 to keep InTune around.
If MA2 is "only" US$0.32/student/month, that alone represents £200k/year for our student numbers...and we need A3.
3
u/TheRabidDeer 16d ago
$2million for us, just for A2. But then we lose ID P2 for our current A5 licensed students (actively enrolled students).
5
3
u/FatBook-Air 16d ago
$0.32 per year?
1
1
u/usernametakenmyass 16d ago
Do you have any pricing for staff A2 licenses? I'm wondering if we can drop from A3.
3
u/MajorInterest2033 16d ago
I'm wondering if this is the initial positioning to scare everyone and when MS eventually "back down" and give free student licenses back, albeit with massively reduced storage compared to what's available today it'll be seen as a win (of sorts)
3
5
u/thedevarious 16d ago
As a predominantly K-12 MSP that exists in the Google Workspace ecosystem. Phew.
Fundamentals remains free for the base product + tools, but paid licensing for any of the newer more advanced features or needs only if a client chooses that platform.
Google W in this scenario. I feel for y'all that have only had to do paid licenses for staff and higher tier stuff on the Student side. Going from $0 to paid. Big oof.
6
u/MajorInterest2033 16d ago
Will be interesting to see if Google keep Fundamentals free or now take the opportunity to follow MS and start charging as well
1
u/vivkkrishnan2005 15d ago
What can they reduce? Everything is online, they have no moat like MS in desktop apps.
1
u/No_Ninja8645 9d ago
Storage, they can mess with storage, and have. We once had unlimited storage, they were the 1st to reduce it to 100TB plus some paltry amount (30GB) per account.
They could lower either the base 100TB or base 30GB per account, charge for what is a double amount of storage in Vault, or impose strict retention limits in Vault - there are things they can do; it's their house, not ours, we are just renting rooms.
0
u/thedevarious 16d ago
I don't expect them to honestly. It makes no sense for them to given they get more incentive elsewhere via Chromebook licensing and other Google licensing, etc.
The biggest change lately was to curb the number of free licenses to a respectable amount based on school size and force schools to better manage active v. archived licenses. Before you could be a school with 500 users and make 5,000 accounts...which didn't make sense really.
But. They built the product, offered it for free and got everyone hooked.
0
u/No_Ninja8645 9d ago
Google is salivating. They will take us all back, and in 2 a 3 years turn up the pricing in a very similar way. Google started this removal of free to EDU benefits about 7 years ago and Microsoft followed, now Microsoft is the one telling Google “hold my beer, taking away free endless storage wasn’t anything, we’re also famous for screwing up licensing models”.
1
u/thedevarious 9d ago
Google is still full features on the Fundamentals (free licensing) and I doubt this changes.
The big items added to Edu+ are enhancements. Not a single productivity app is unavailable for lack of payment. Full stop.
1
u/No_Ninja8645 9d ago
I do not disagree. I am at a state university in CA that just moved from 17 years on Google fundamentals with the last few years on edu enterprise (paid) due to the move to 100TB instead of unlimited storage TO Microsoft 365, we are just finishing up the student migration!
Google did start this reduction in storage, from unlimited to 100TB. There is no saying that they will not remove the 100TB and adopt a MS model of increased storage per paid license. However, Google did, and tends to, simplify the subscriptions, going from 3 or more options to two; versus Ms going from 3 to 4/5. I also can never see Google removing email from any licensing level.
I guess, overall, I am saying that Google will eventually make changes to what they offer and how much it will cost. The instability that this introduces to the basic utility of email in an edu environment may be just the nudge needed to move that basic service back to self provisioned for some institutions- however, where's the talent for that now?
I've been in EDU IT almost 30 years, I've seen us go from providing every application to handing apps off to SaaS providers. With that has come both great tools, but also a commitment to provide them to students for free. I am afraid that is about to change as the costs are becoming unsustainable without raising costs to students or cuts somewhere else.
I can see and support, allowing students to simply use their personal email accounts, but that is a huge cultural change for people that have been in this industry for less than 30 years and have seen that as a norm in previous years.
2
u/OinkyConfidence Windows Admin 16d ago
Wonder what it means for those schools with site licenses that get A1 currently. Will they automatically get A2?
5
u/FatBook-Air 16d ago
You have to pay for them.
1
u/OinkyConfidence Windows Admin 16d ago
Yeah, I figured; I've instructed the schools I work with to reach out to their MS reseller and see what they say. Site licensing for education has always been esoteric and a bit different. So we'll see.
3
u/Dev-TechSavvy Student 16d ago
would they downgrade then to A0 as it is the new no cost offering?
4
u/maancha Sr. Sysadmin 16d ago
Problem is no email on that tier. Need min A2 realistically for your student head count
1
u/OinkyConfidence Windows Admin 16d ago
Which means a far greater cost than before I'm sure too! 👀
2
u/Dev-TechSavvy Student 16d ago
do we have the newer pricing available somewhere or not? cuz the link doesn't mention newer pricing at all
1
u/OinkyConfidence Windows Admin 16d ago
We do not. Microsoft thought wise to, I don't know, NOT share replacement pricing. For, you know, reasons.
3
u/OinkyConfidence Windows Admin 16d ago
Got to wonder. But what about the Teams, Exchange, OneDrive, etc., that's in A1? I guess we'll see.
2
1
u/xXNorthXx 15d ago
MA0 it looks like. Basically they get the desktop apps but no real cloud services.
1
1
u/Bubbagump210 15d ago
We are pretty reliant on A1 Office 365 licenses for faculty. Part timers, subs, etc are on A1s. So what does this mean? Those become A2s for email, office apps, OneDrive etc??
1
1
u/West_Recognition_760 14d ago
Maybe office.eu will have a better solution for schools. is it the new Office!
1
u/Realistic_Fun2103 13d ago
Are any of you that are affected by this considering migrating to Google Workspace for Education? I’m still waiting to see official prices on things but based on what I’ve seen this could be the thing that finally makes us walk away from Microsoft.
1
u/intense_username 13d ago
As you mentioned, I too need to see prices as well before doing anything major. We have a few apps that Chromebooks don’t support so we’d have to retool some of our curriculum, but thanks to this news we plan to do a deep dive with running numbers and projections and see what would be required to do a switch if it came down to it.
It’s pretty ballsy of Microsoft to do this. They’re not the darling of the educational world that they think they are, so them providing an attractive license option was pretty important. Them eliminating it just underscores how disconnected they are in this aspect.
1
u/Snaky115 6d ago
Oh boy, this is annoying, i don't wanna hear the euro price for A2...
Fortunately i don't need much, so what would be a cheap combo to keep the Microsoft email exchange going for a 600 student school, about 70 faculty? Not many in faculty actually use MS, maybe only half. Hmmmm.
What a mess ive inherited 2 years ago, eh.
1
u/Thecatstoppedateboli 1d ago
Same, waiting for EU pricing. You do need defender p1 and intune though and intune is only included in A3
1
u/Snaky115 1d ago
I am only planning to directly continue the free A1, so paid A2 it is, to some extent. (Unless i am wrong, i'm mostly a rookie to education shenanigans)
Thank heavens my school's digital footprint has fallen in last 2 years after COVID, so i can just consider ditching MS entirely to some other free solution, even if it means making MORE tutorials.
1
u/Infamous-Echidna4141 16d ago
As a reminder, Microsoft posted record profits last quarter. I'd love to see the reasoning behind all this.
1
u/MalletNGrease 🛠 Network & Systems Admin 15d ago
I think they want to pivot datacenter resources to other business segments. Azure has been having capacity problems for a while.
Dropping EDU wouldn't affect their bottom line very much.
1
1
u/sorean_4 15d ago
60k lay offs, higher prices, increased licensing costs = more profit, higher shareholder value.
0
u/xXNorthXx 15d ago
Because they can…..unfortunately
0
u/mkosmo Permanently Banned 15d ago
Or, you know, capacity. Or something like that. Not everything has to be poorly intentioned.
0
u/xXNorthXx 15d ago
How to milk existing assets for more profit. Either they pay more or we pull back capacity/capabilities to avoid hardware upgrades.
0
-13
u/whythehellnote 16d ago
You chose a central provider, you chose closed source technology, you chose vendor locking with a single provider.
You reap what you sow.
6
u/Zncon 16d ago
You can't blame people for picking something when it's the only choice. If a school system can't afford this they sure as hell can't afford the IT staff to maintain a full stack of OSS tools and their own hardware, while giving anywhere near the level of service that's expected these days.
-6
u/1stUserEver 15d ago
Schools use Google. This won’t affect many. More for college students.
6
u/BWMerlin 15d ago
Maybe in your neck of the woods, over here it is mainly Microsoft and very rarely Google used in schools.


93
u/SuspiciousOpposite 16d ago
100TB base storage gone, left with 150GB per faculty license and 12GB per student license.
Absolute scenes. This is going to be costly