I think all the Lightsaber Form trees have problems. I don't mean like 1-2 little nitpicks, I mean I feel like the design team made huge mistakes when putting them together. First off, deciding to go with a different attribute for each tree just because 6 Attributes and 6 Careers and 6 Forms (they forgot about Juyo until the Warrior book) was awful, and they paired up very wrong Attributes with the forms (admittedly, they did get one or two correct).
1 Shii-Cho: This one is probably the most accurate to lore of the trees. It's able to disarm, and good against multiple opponents. No BS "use this stat to attack" ability. My main problem is the lack of the Force Rating Talent; it should be in every lightsaber Tree because you're using your connection to The Force to use the lightsaber.
2 Makashi: Also decent. It is good against a single opponent, and resistant to being disarmed. The problem here is Presence for the attack instead of Agility (you'll see this pop up a number of times). How cool you look doesn't have a place in fighting with a lightsaber (unless all forms get it because they're all awesome). Only a slight tweak or two would fix it. Lacks Force Rating.
3 Soresu: Here's where we start really getting into it. Soresu is, probably more than any other Form, a BRAWN form. The idea behind Soresu is to outlast your opponent by having more Stamina than they do. If Constitution/Stamina/Endurance were an Attribute, that is what it should go off of, but instead we've got Brawn. That's fine, but if you really wanted a style to go off of Intelligence, then that would be Shii-Cho (it requires a much more tactical mind fighting against multiple opponents). I can't stress enough that as Agility is to Ataru, Brawn is to Soresu. Needs Defensive Training, and lacks Force Rating.
4 Ataru: Not much to pick apart here; Agility as the attack stat should be normal, not limited to just one style. Makashi, Shien, Niman, and Juyo all should have Agility as an option for replacing Brawn as the lightsaber attribute. Lacks Force Rating.
5 Shien: Another missed Agility as attack stat, instead it's based off of Cunning. I can almost hear the designers congratulating themselves over the Obi-Wan reference from A New Hope. What they forgot was Anakin only taught Shien, but he actually used Djem So. He taught it to Ahsoka so she could hold off waves of minions while he fought the "important" battles against Dooku or Asajj, or whoever on the other side had a lightsaber. He taught it to Starkiller (Galen Marek) because he knew he'd have to kill him and wanted him to be at a disadvantage (Shien is good against blasters, but not really for lightsaber vs lightsaber). Shien should be a Reflect version of Makashi, but instead the designers thought it would be cool to split it into two "mini-trees" of Djem So and Shien, when both are solid enough to be their own trees. Also get rid of Street Smarts; it makes sense in the context of the time period/career, but as a tree dedicated to smacking blaster bolts away it's out of place. Lacks Force Rating.
6 Niman: Another missed Agility pick, but instead goes with Willpower. Not a terrible choice thematically, but this makes Niman far more potent than it should be, especially with the fact that it is the only tree with the Force Rating Talent. Honestly, it overperforms in its actual fighting capability. According to Wookiepedia, "Overall, Niman had a fairly relaxed focus on bladework, designed as a simple, easily mastered fighting form for Jedi who preferred to devote most of their time to study and diplomacy." Because of that, I'd swap out Niman Technique that allows for it to be used with Agility, and change one Parry, Reflect, Defensive Training (why are there two, Makashi only has one and freaking Soresu has none), and the Sum Djem Talents for more ranked Talents that help with negotiations/diplomacy. It's supposed to be, "the diplomat's form," after all.
7 Juyo: Honestly, I really like the design of this tree. It's got the ability to go to Vaapad. I'd switch the Multiple Opponents Talent for the Force Rating Talent then switch its position with the 25 point Embrace Your Hate.
8 Djem So: Not one of the traditional lightsaber styles, but definitely strong enough on its own to merit a full tree. It's been described as "peace through superior firepower" and is basically a counter attack form that harnesses physical power. This is the style that brought down Dooku. Vader combined it with a little Juyo to become a real monster. I have to admit to a little bias here, Djem So is my personal favorite of all the forms of Lightsaber Combat.
So, this thread isn't just a list of complaints that I'm throwing out. I'm not just whining here. I'm actually planning on doing something. I'm going to make 8 Universal Specializations, hopefully balanced, for each of the lightsaber combat forms I've listed here. I'm going to be allowing them for a game I'll be running in the future (based during the timeline of the SWTOR MMO).
I know the game doesn't "need" this; it's perfectly functional as is. I'm not trying to say the game's broken, but I really think these can be done "better." Also, I know the rule on page 152 of the Force and Destiny core book says you've got to have the Talent that lets you make Lightsaber (Intelligence) checks if you try to use Defensive Circle or Strategic Form, but since it really only applies to Soresu Technique (seriously, that's the only one), I'm going to ignore it and say they have to be made with the characteristic listed even if you can't normally make Lightsaber (Intelligence) checks.
I'm actually finished designing about 4.5/5 of them; mostly all I'm doing is rearranging Talents (and adding and subtracting some) so this is more of a test to see if other people are as interested in having more accurate trees for the different forms as I am. Does anyone else feel like I do about this? Is anyone interested in giving feedback? Thanks for your time reading this. Hope you're interested in what I'm putting together.