r/swingtrading • u/No-Definition-2886 • Dec 22 '24
r/swingtrading • u/[deleted] • Jul 06 '25
Reddit is a behavioral goldmine. Most of you are too rational to see it.
Disclaimer: I am a former pm at Capital Group and had strategic discretion over ~$500m in multi-asset mandates. Prior to that, I worked in multi-asset investing at JPMAM as an analyst on the LDI team focused on pensions. I have been managing my own money for the past 15 years.
For the past 4 months, I’ve been systematically probing Reddit’s investor communities and testing how narrative, tone, and timing shape the crowd’s perception of risk and credibility.
My first chapter focuses on “narrative-driven stocks” like RDDT, HOOD, and PLTR. These are stocks that are on the border of meme, with just enough fundamentals to make them credible growth plays. Each one has a supposedly pre-consensus “narrative” that the market has not recognized (apparently).
I want to explore whether each subred showed distinct behavorial signals. The first experiment was on subred /stocks. Maybe obvious, but each community is very different so don’t expect my findings to generalize to other investing subreds.
These experiments were conducted by injecting posts & comments into the subred at critical inflection points in the news/market cycle (FOMO, tariffs, earnings) and watching the reactions. Metrics I observed: upvote/downvote velocity & ratio, virality velocity, comment depth, shares.
The reactions like comments provided grounds for further testing - which often included an ongoing dialogue with the participants. Many of these injections went viral (>100 upvotes, >50 comments).
Here's what I can share about the audience and behavioral dynamics for /stocks.
Audience:
Demographic
Based on linguistic complexity, decision-making patterns, and sensitivity to tone, I estimate most participants cluster in the 105–115 IQ range. Verbally fluent, socially risk-averse, and often conflict-avoidant under pressure. Many still fall into ego traps when I injected them into conversation. This is likely a liberal estimate un-adjusted for the intellectual nature of the content.
Heavily male, 25-45 years old
Professionals with disposable income but risk-averse and socially conformist
Investment behavior
Obsessed with “value,” “fundamentals,” and long-termism as virtue signaling
Deep aversion to volatility unless mainstream media has already blessed it
Favored tickers: MSFT, AAPL, NVDA (i.e., stocks that CNBC analysts love)
Idiosyncrasies
Mild hero worship (Buffett, Burry)
Skeptical of influencers but paradoxically trust anything that “sounds like CNBC”
Behavioral dynamics from march-present:
1. Polished contrarianism underperforms
High-effort posts with sharp, original analysis often get buried unless they mimic corporate tone. Intellectual honesty is punished unless diluted.
2. Deliberate dissonance triggers oversight
Posts with light trolling or Socratic framing (“why is no one talking about xyz?”) generated more comment engagement than full thesis posts.
3. Disclosure aversion is cultural
Stating “long” or “short” triggered skepticism or auto-moderation. Ironically, emotional neutrality in tone got more traction than transparency.
4. Censorship isn't just moderation - it's peer-enforced
Downvotes are used as social punishment, not disagreement. Posts that made users feel cognitively vulnerable were brigaded regardless of quality.
Tangent: only one of the four dynamics listed above is real. Curious if anyone can guess which - or why I framed them this way ;)
Next steps?
A/B testing across subreds. Injecting contradindicative posts to tease out contrarians to engage them in sub-experiments in comments. Ego traps work well for IQ<120 but what about for a subred like /securityanalysis? Still exploring this area, but prob have to implement some meta-cognitive traps here.
I'll be exploring this community in the following months so if you can, please share any insights about vulnerabilities, insecurities, and idiosyncrasies of your peers. thank you.
r/swingtrading • u/Own-Needleworker5872 • Oct 01 '26
Stock Nice End of the month 19m
Currently going into october with 10 shares of cerebras i j picked up today then 550 shares of xndu. Even tho im long terming pulling myself out of the 40 shares of nvda i have at $174.84 and going into mrvl when mrvl hits $210-$220 area
r/swingtrading • u/bpra93 • Sep 13 '22
Short interest STILL HIGH at 108,35% as of august 31 acording to FINRA DATA! SHFs HAVE NOT CLOSE THEIR SHORTS!
r/swingtrading • u/breakoutsHappen • Jul 19 '26
Reversal Bullish: The 10 Japanese Candlestick Patterns That Signal a Bottom
r/swingtrading • u/disclosingNina--1876 • Aug 29 '25
Stock How I use AI to trade options
So I got called out in another post for claiming that I use AI to assist me in making my daily trades and decisions, but not posting my actual wins and losses. AI assists me in understanding and learning.
I do not have a list of wins and losses, I let AI make a daily log for me, which I'm not willing to share in its entirety at this point.
But for those who care, I will show you a completely unedited conversation between myself and AI that I have while I'm watching the charts. This is how I use AI to assist me. I'm not asking it to tell me what to trade or how to trade, I ask it to help me interpret what I'm seeing so that I can make better decisions.
I have also asked about specific indicators and it's taught me how to use those indicators to give me an advantage.
Please don't come for me on the typos in the AI convo, I use talk to text and AI knows what I mean
r/swingtrading • u/TheSetupFactory • Apr 25 '25
Eight leading stocks breaking out
This week we finally saw a bullish change of character both in the major indices and in leading stocks.
A lot of our focus stocks broke out to new highs which is encouraging.
r/swingtrading • u/stockplanner • Jul 04 '21
Is Ford $F Better than Tesla $TSLA for a Small Account
r/swingtrading • u/colchonero0312 • Apr 09 '25
Im PISSED AF
we knew pause would happen and markets would fly. I had been selling my more trash stocks like FL, TRMD, NU, to put as much as possible into my google aapl, nvda, crm, and other solid companies, now im up 15% for the day, and was never nervous on these drops just so angry that my broke ass didnt have more money to buy at the very bottom, i had EVEN gotten another job to try and invest more. well i guess now i just want market to keep flying so i can start to have cash in my portfolio again.
r/swingtrading • u/albertsportsnet1 • 22d ago
META's report told you about GOOGL. Both told you about INTC and AMZN.
Something I noticed this earnings season: each big tech report read through to the next one.
When META fell 7% after its report, AMZN, NVDA, GOOGL and MSFT all fell the same day without reporting anything. GOOGL reported a week later into that, with 0 of 2 mega-cap reports up so far, and dropped 12.6%. By the time INTC and AMZN reported last night it was 0 of 4. INTC is down 30% today even with an EPS beat, while AMZN is only down about 2%, so it's not that every report collapses. It's that the bar was high and the mood was bad, and you could see that before the report.
I built this into my tool: before a stock reports, it shows how the earlier reports in its group went and whether the sector is narrowing. Check my profile if you want to see it. Do you look at the other reports in the group before an earnings play?
r/swingtrading • u/HelpingTraderswin • Jul 16 '25
Options Any interested in a EXCELLENT swing trading subreddit?
Actual charts 📊posted every single day. Growing too fast though. Liked when it was smaller and cozy. Nonetheless Made a killing so far just playing the ideas 💡 posted there. No pay walls for the ideas. Just great ideas posted there. DM me if interested in the name of the subreddit. We all can bank ✅☑️✔️💰
r/swingtrading • u/Infinite_Figure_1079 • Aug 28 '26
Asked AI to make a swing trading basics roadmap. Any good?
If not, what resources would you recommend? I have no plan on using real money any time soon (im a broke graduate), but I figured I may as well learn the basics.
r/swingtrading • u/AffectionateUnion838 • Jan 04 '26
Any female swing traders here? Curious about your experience
Hey everyone! I’m a woman who trades on the side (still learning / improving) and I’ve realized I don’t know many other women in this space.
I’m wondering roughly how many of you here are women? What challenges have you faced as a female swing trader?
Hoping to find my crowd and learn from your experiences!
r/swingtrading • u/casedooog • Feb 19 '21
CRSR is failing to make the swing
CRSR looked like a slam dunk of a swing trade but now the chart isn’t looking so hot! At least it seems to have found a floor around $38.50 Anyone else waiting for the “W” in the chart
I like the stonk
CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR
CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR
CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR CRSR
r/swingtrading • u/bpra93 • Oct 25 '22
New York Supreme Court reinstates all employees fired for being unvaccinated, orders backpay $SPY
r/swingtrading • u/aboredtrader • Apr 02 '25
Strategy 99% of Trading Indicators Are BS
When I first started trading stocks 5 years ago, I probably spent a good part of a year searching far and wide for the perfect indicators – like many new traders, I was sure that it was one of the keys to profitability.
What I eventually came to realise was that 99% of indicators I came across were absolute BS – in fact, I realised that indicators were the least important part of becoming a successful trader.
There’s a whole host of problems with indicators:
You falsely convince yourself that something is taking place on a chart because your indicator is giving off a signal.
The vast majority of indicators are lagging behind (they tell you what has already happened, NOT what is happening and certainly NOT what will happen).
Most indicators provide the same data but in a slightly different format which leads to confusion if you overlap multiple indicators.
You end up over-reliant on indicators and essentially “can’t the forest for the trees”.
I’m not saying it’s not possible to use an indicator effectively but in my opinion, it’s not necessary because regardless of which indicators you use, ultimately it’s how you interpret the data that matters.
You don’t need RSI to tell you if a stock has relative strength; you don’t need Stochastics to tell you when a reversal might happen; and you don’t need MACD to tell you if a stock might be overbought or oversold - all of this data is shown on the chart itself.

You can literally see when price is in an uptrend and how strong the trend is, simply by looking at the angle at which the price is moving, and how much volume there is at certain stages of the trend.
If you really want to become a profitable trader, you should be focusing on the following instead:
Risk Management & Position Sizing – If you manage this properly, you can trade the worst setup and still survive. You might not become profitable, but at least you won’t suffer a big drawdown or worse, blow up your account.
Trade Management – When you’re in a trade, you’re more susceptible to making irrational decisions. This is where believing in your system and consistently following specific rules play a crucial role. It’s the only way to gather reliable data.
Post Trade Analysis – It’s essential to log all your trades in a trading journal such as Edgewonk or TraderSync (Excel is fine too but requires more manual work) because once you have the important data all laid out, you must analyse it at the end of the day, week and month. Only then can you can then go through the process of elimination and refinement.
Trading Psychology – Different traders will have varying opinions regarding this topic but I personally believe that for most traders without any underlying psychological issues, mental and emotional issues in trading can be resolved by having a profitable system that you can follow. Managing your psyche while trying to create a profitable system is a slow, step-by-step process, and it really helps to be a logical and an analytical person (which is why you should focus on measurable results).
-----------------------------------
Each of every one of the above aspects deserves an entire post to themselves, but I’ve briefly covered them so that you don’t focus too much of your time on technical indicators.
Having said all of this, you might think I trade naked charts – I don’t. In fact, there are 3 indicators I use as part of an overall strategy to consistently profit from the markets.
I explain all of this and more in my video – https://youtu.be/QtOgWbCju10?si=wSJwkZNTz4IyNCPR
Many of you may know this already, but it’s important to drive these points home. Thanks for reading and if you have any questions, just comment below and I’ll do my best to answer them all!
r/swingtrading • u/WhaleTank_Crypto • Aug 26 '21
When Bitcoin Breaks $50K Resistance Level - Next Stop $100K?
r/swingtrading • u/Emeregencetheory43 • Feb 25 '21
Buy the Dip
Treasury bonds yield up = sell off. Market will recover buying pullback RIOT. Fed computer system crashed for 3 hours! This helps bitcoin. Fuck the suits they will come around if the, People, say so. Collective power superior to suit power!! Bitcoin, psychedelic freedom, and capitalising space IS the future. And AI in drones, hive minds. Orwellian or not? Maybe both?
r/swingtrading • u/fotfddtodairsizr • Jul 04 '26
It’s impossible to lose money swing trading
I’m looking to lightly swing trade.
Specifically put 10K in Alphabet or QQQ in a light dip, wait till it is up 10% (could be days, weeks, months) then sell, then repeat a few times a year to make 5K profit.
Is this realistic?
If there is a crash I would just hold my position long term as this is spare money I don’t need. If it works out, eventually I would only swing trade with the profits I have made and put the original capital in my savings.
I don’t know any technical things but since my swing trading plan is so chill/flexible I figure it’s almost impossible to lose money. The stocks I’d be swing trading - I already hold them as long term investments that I won’t sell for decades anyway, so in a market downturn I will just hold my swing trade long term instead.
I genuinely can’t see how I could lose money which can’t make sense so..
my question is:
What is the hole in my plan? Am I missing something obvious?
Any course recommendations or app recommendations or and technical skills I should look into/self study?
I’m a newbie so please no unhelpful comments I’m trying to learn and see any holes in my plan. Thanks!
r/swingtrading • u/TearRepresentative56 • Mar 02 '26
TRUMP SAYS IRAN OPERATION IS “WELL AHEAD OF SCHEDULE”. Basically, Trump realises he miscalculated the timing of the attack and is trying to placate markets before cash open.
What was initially said to be a 4 day attack, then turned to 4 weeks in Trump's comments yesterday, yet we are supposed to believe things are "well ahead of schedule"?
I'm not so sure. Reports were surfacing yesterday that Trump was furious that Israeli missiles were still flying after what was supposed to only be a 48 hour period. i.e. from Friday night when the attacks started to Monday morning (before the market opens). That timeline makes most sense for what I think Trump wanted (Venezuela situation), but that expectation has proven a miscalculation.
Not a political statement, I am British and do not support either US political party. Just an observation as I see it from reports I've been reading.
r/swingtrading • u/flamingokandy • Aug 08 '26
Day trading isn't a real career for 99% of people, so why do so many still fall for it?
We often see on reels that trading is a great way to earn money. You just need a laptop and some trading knowledge, but the actual data tells a completely different story.
SEBI's reports on Indian F&O and intraday markets showed that around 90% of retail traders are losing money. And the stats were clear: the more frequently people trade, the worse they perform.
So the question is, why are people still running towards becoming a trader?
Is it just social media gurus selling a fake lifestyle, or are people genuinely convinced that they'll be able to make it to the top 1%?
For anyone who's been trading for a while, what's your opinion on this?
r/swingtrading • u/IP_1618033 • Feb 02 '25
Daily Discussion Trading is the best and hardest job in the world
Trading is the best and hardest job in the world for making easy money, but if you can master the skill (discipline, strategy, psychology), then it will change your life....
r/swingtrading • u/TearRepresentative56 • Mar 05 '25
Some thoughts on the market as we tap the 200D MA yday, and following Trump's presidential address. Market manipulation? Probably. My (hopefully) interesting take.
Now, firstly, let's look at the fact that yesterday, the Nasdaq tapped its 200d SMA but held above. SPX pretty much tapped its 200d SMA as well.
If we look at Nasdaq's chart since 2023, we see that since the start of 2023, after the bottoming of the 2022 bear market, every time we have tapped the 200d SMA, we have bounced higher.

And yesterday's' wild reversal to hold the 200d SMA does look again like traders will again try to defend this level which points to a possible bounce here, although quant and I's theory of lower lows through March OPEX still holds.
If you step back from this and try to use your critical thinking brain, don't you think it was convenient timing that we got this unexpected news from Lutnick yesterday that suddenly, Trump is considering relief for USMCA compliant goods and that we can get some tariff relief as early as today.
It is again a clear attempt from these insiders here to manipulate the market using news on the tape as their instrument.
And if you are naive and think that this government insiders doesn't use news to manipulate markets, think about it:
Trump launches his meme coin at the time of inauguration, profiting billions from the move. Clearly insider trading
Trump announces a Crypto strategic reserve whilst BTC is at support and Solana is at support, including the 5 cryptocurrencies in the reserve that Trump personally is invested in. Insider trading?
Look at the fact that last week, after the market was set to open higher on Thursday and pose a breakout, Trump comes out with more tariff news, even though Bessent 45 minutes ago had mentioned there'\'s no update expected on tariff news.
Look at the price action of the Market on Friday following that Zelenskyy argument, where suddenly a surge of buyers step in in order to salvage the weekly technicals of the market.
I mean firstly, this is probably a sign that sooner or later, Trump will release some news to support his buddy Musk's TSLA share price, but the timing isn't right yet.
Now the question then is, what is the goal of this market manipulation?
This is where I admit I am using conjecture here rather than data so bare that in mind.
My argument however, is that the answer came in what Bessent clearly admitted yesterday.
Bessent said on Fox News that they are set on bringing interest rates down.
The only problem, however with that, is that Trump\s tariffs are leading to rising inflation expectations which will show up in inflation numbers in the future, which will restrict the Fed's ability to cut.
So they have worked out that they have to do something else to get the Fed to cut. And the answer for that, is in weakening the stock market.
By doing so, they can tighten financial conditions via the negative wealth effect.
This is the idea that with the market lower, people's assets and net worth is lower. This means that people will have less disposable income to spend and consumer sentiment will be lower, thus lower spending.
In doing so, they can basically restrict the growth of the economy, but in an orderly way, rather than causing a straight up crash/severe recession,
With restricted growth, they can then encourage the Fed to cut rates. Now they know that the biggest holding in people's portfolios is what? Tech, So they have to target tech., Which is why no news can come yet to support Musk's TSLA.
To an extent their strategy is working. Economic sentiment numbers are falling, and the chances of interest rate cuts coming this year has increased from 1 in mid February to 3 now.

But the thing is, Trump cares about the market right. It's one of his gages of success. So he doesn't want to CRASH the market as such. Which is why I think they stepped in hard last Friday to defend the technicals, and which is why Trump is trying to defend the 200d MA at first. It probably could break later, but Trump doesn't want the market to crash by just knifing through it with no buyers stepping in.
As mentioned in our whole thesis for price action into March OPEX, Trump wants these oscillations but a trend lower. That way he can stop volatility expansion too much too fast which can risk crashing the market.
Anyway, let's get back to the fact that we bounced above the 200d SMA.
Well, I want to remind you of what we said yesterday. A squeeze requires a catalyst, especially when the momentum is as bearish as it is right now.
And right now, we have quite a few potential catalysts.
Firstly, the fact that Lutnick said we can get tariff walk back today.
Secondly, the fact that Trump's SOTU speech, where he said that he'd received a letter from Zleneksyy saying Ukraine was ready to negotiate.
This is a big deal. Ukraine peace means oil prices come down a lot, which is a big net positive for inflation and can again force the Fed to cut, which is the ultimate goal.
We also have the NFP tomorrow.
So we do have a potential stage set for a squeeze, BUT it won't be easy.
The damage to the technicals of SPX won't be easy to immediately repair.
Why do I say that?
well because now we are below key EMAs like 9, 21 and 50.
All of these EMAs are also sloping downwards now.
This all points to the fact that they will be resistance points for the market now.
If we look at Nasdaq to highlight that

See how we are below all the EMAs. And most are sloping downwards.
That means we could potentially get a squeeze up to 21k or just above, on good positive news, but to reverse the trend entirely higher won't be easy.
As such, it again points to a potential for what quant and I are saying which is lower highs into a lower low into March OPEX.
Anyway, just some thoughts for you. Interesting reading perhaps. Let me know what you think.
--------
Note: If you want access to insights like this posted daily, please join 14,000 traders benefiting from my free trading community, https://tradingedge.club or follow me on Reddit r/tradingedge