r/swgemu • • Aug 18 '26

Discussion A Discussion On SWGNFS Changing/Updating Combat Mechanics

0 Upvotes

Folks, we have to talk about combat. We have to talk about attack speed. And frankly, what’s happening here is a disaster. A total disaster.

Star Wars Galaxies had a combat system. A beautiful combat system. Was it perfect? No. Nothing is perfect. But people understood it. People built characters around it. They spent hours getting their weapons, their tapes, their armor, their buffs. They knew what attack speed meant. They knew how the professions worked.

And now people come along and say, “Maybe we should change how attack speed works.” No. Terrible idea. Possibly one of the worst ideas anybody has ever had for Star Wars Galaxies; and believe me, we have seen some bad ideas. We saw the CU. Remember the CU? They came in and said, “We’re going to improve combat. We’re going to streamline it. Everybody’s going to love it.” Nobody knew what was happening. Numbers changed. Mechanics changed. Your character wakes up one morning and suddenly he doesn't know what he's doing anymore. People were furious.

Then we got the NGE. The NGE! They said, “You thought the CU was a big change? Watch this.” Incredible. Professions disappearing. Combat completely different. People logging in looking for their character; they couldn't find their character! “Where's my profession?” Gone. Absolutely gone.

We learned a lesson from this. At least, I thought we learned a lesson. You do not take the fundamental combat mechanics of Star Wars Galaxies and start ripping them apart because somebody thinks they can reinvent the wheel.

And attack speed is fundamental. Attack speed affects everything. Weapons. Templates. Skill choices. Balance. Crafting. Loot. PvP. PvE. Jedi. Bounty Hunters. Everybody.

You change attack speed, and somebody says, “Oh, it's just one little formula.” There is no such thing as one little formula in SWG. You touch one formula and suddenly you've got twelve professions behaving differently, somebody discovers a weapon doing something completely insane, a Jedi is attacking at approximately the speed of light, and three days later we're rewriting half the combat system trying to fix the fix.

We've seen this movie before. It's called The Combat Upgrade. The sequel was called The New Game Enhancements. Neither one reviewed particularly well.

So here's what we're going to do. We're going to protect the combat system. We're going to protect attack speed. We're going to make smart changes. Careful changes. Surgical changes. If something is actually broken, we fix it.

But we're not going to walk into a twenty-year-old combat system with a chainsaw because somebody looked at a spreadsheet for fifteen minutes and decided they had a tremendous new idea.

Because the players know. The veterans especially know. These people have been calculating attack speeds since some of our developers were practically children. They've got spreadsheets. They've got formulas. They've got archived forum posts from 2004 that somehow survived three website migrations and the collapse of half the internet.

You are not going to sneak an attack-speed change past these people. They will find it. Immediately. Some guy will be standing outside the Mos Eisley starport with a stopwatch before the server has been online for ten minutes. And he'll know.

So we're not doing CU 2.0. We're certainly not doing NGE 2.0. We're taking what worked, restoring what was lost, fixing what actually needs fixing, and leaving the foundations alone. That's how you build a great SWG server. Not by replacing Star Wars Galaxies. By understanding why people are still playing Star Wars Galaxies more than twenty years later.

Keep the combat. Keep the attack speed. Keep the professions. Keep the weirdness. Keep the things that made SWG: SWG.

And together, folks, we're going to make combat great again. Thank you. And God bless the Galactic Weaponsmiths.


r/swgemu • • May 25 '15

Which server is closest to original SWG?

0 Upvotes

First off, just to be clear, I am not trying to say one server is better than another. I am simply curious about this since a guy I work with have been talking about this topic quite a bit lately.

I only recently started playing on some of the SWGemu servers and am wondering which server do you all believe is the closest in design to the original pre-cu SWG?

This excludes servers that allow any exploits or mechanics that were not in the original SWG client. Thanks

Edit: Since there a few who are rude enough to downvote a simple question I tried to clarify below, I will post my other replies up here for easier viewing for others not so rude.

1)I appreciate the information on the test server and Suncrusher, though my question was aimed more at active servers, not test servers.

2)Clearly Basilisk is the only main test server and the others are considered otherwise because of the list on the right side of this subreddit that lists them as active servers and not test servers. Please keep the topic on track, thanks.

3)Whoa, easy on the name-calling(should have guessed w/ a name like toiletjocky)? Do you regularly talk that way to strangers asking questions? Is it really that difficult to answer a simple question here? Those who have posted are trying to re-define how the mods here have listed the servers and get defensive when I point that out? Wow...

4)I never claimed to suddenly know anything actually(Timbab). I clearly said I was pointing out what was posted for all to see on the right side of the page. There is no 'sudden knowledge' in that. I asked for opinions on active server content, I never asked for a meta discussion about classification of active server versus test server. It is unfortunate that out of all the posts here in this thread, not one has managed to stay on topic. (I have been nothing but polite here on this thread and I fail to see why you seem to feel the need to be condescending and encourage 'toiletjocky's rude behavior.)

5)To clarify, I am not the one who originally said Basilisk was a test server if you scroll up. I was basing my information off of what was initially being said here, but apparently there is alot of BS being thrown around today.

6)I added my comments to the main post because others were trolling and downvoting simply because they disagreed(which reddit discourages doing) and I was not the one calling names so I fail to see how you somehow come to the conclusion that I was the one being a 'shithead' as you so politely put it.

I asked a simple question and it got blown way out of proportion thanks to the obviously large amount of trolls on this subreddit. If anyone needs to move on it is you(GottaP) because if you don't like my post, stop bumping it up by trolling.

Summary: Apparently Reddit really is dead when a person cannot ask a simple question about anything without being attacked by trolls to the degree where a civilized conversation cannot be held when those same trolls revert to immature name-calling and nonsensical comments encouraged by a like-minded condescending mod.

Which by the way, no, I will not be deleting my thread and if it were deleted by a mod it will only prove my point about this subreddit. I do however hold out hope that I might be proven wrong and my question might be answered in a decent manner.


r/swgemu • • May 25 '19

Pikeman Basilisk PvP Friday Night 5.24.19

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Oct 12 '17

Please.. no more new EMUs.

0 Upvotes

Pretty sure that most players feel the same way I do.. The population continues to dilute with every new entry, and the odds of success are astronomically low. There is so much emotion and hard work invested by admins and developers to more often than not see their private servers die off..

New players, pick from one of the three (pre-CU) and enjoy the ride.

*****Aftermath: [Cesta Admin]

*2.5x combat | 5x crafting XP *POP: 160-180 high @8pm eastern, AVG 90. *A+ admins *Great community *NGE content *Original TEF system that can turn one battle into a server wide battle royal.

*Great performance RIG

****Infinity:

*Very fast paced *A+ Admins *Tons of custom content *Great performance RIG

***Relics of Corvantis:

*A+ community *Some customs content *HOME of Progar


r/swgemu • • Jan 09 '22

SWGEmu Autobanning for multiple household accounts

0 Upvotes

I was extremely excited to play on Finalizer, but the stupid automated banbot banned my fiancee's account for the 3rd time in the 10 years we've been playing on SWGEMU. Every time: this takes days or weeks to remedy.

They manually have to address it each time, and I have to dig up my disks from whatever box they are stored in every single time. Seriously: there are better ways to do this guys. They should have this information saved somewhere after the first ban, but could have us register the necessary information without needing human staff involved at all.

Sadly, I expected their system to ruin my time, and dug our dusty copies out in preparation for this, but I'm just so disappointed and infuriated to be in this situation again, after being assured the last time that it would be the final autoban.

Honestly, if this is happening a lot on Finalizer and no-one is knocking these tickets out, it could be a long time before access is restored.

Venting here on Reddit because I'd hate to make the presumably burnt-out volunteers feel worse. Seriously though, if it takes me 3 more weeks to get on Finalizer because of this, I will literally never let it go.

Finally got my girl excited to play some SWG again and the Banbot took her down. Now she's just so sad y'all... and this might go on for days or weeks... AGAIN. How many times do we need to go through the verification process to be spared this pain?!


r/swgemu • • Sep 28 '22

Gameplay Jedi Council Member PvP - Finalizer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • May 10 '19

Welcome to Publish 10 | Basilisk PvP | Imperial Victory

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Nov 18 '22

Gameplay Finalizer Base Defense

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Dec 29 '23

Creative Meme Monday - SWG Boomer edition

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Jun 17 '20

Star Wars Galaxies: The Pre-CU Gameplay Problem

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Apr 21 '24

Creative JRO Recruitment Video for Finalizer Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Jan 28 '18

Basilisk PvP - The (C)ounter Gank on Dathomir

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Oct 27 '16

SWGEmu Server Admins Please Read

0 Upvotes

I am writing this to inform you of a dangerous player among us. I'm sure many of you have already dealt with this individual, but a public warning was needed in my opinion. He filed a DMCA against my server, as well as two others that I know of.

He goes by the name "DarkShado" "DarkShad" or "Just". In game names were TheHunter and MadScientist. His real name is REACTED. Email: REDACTED. He has major social disfunction to say the least.

He is rude, condescending, demanding, and trolls constantly. Once this behavior led to a ban (after several days of warnings from players and admin), he proceeded to file a false DMCA claim against my server.

Upon doing further research, it seems that I am far from the first individual who this has happened to. He has been a wrecking ball across the internet since 1995.

Feel free to PM me, or visit my server's forum at swganarchyrising.com and read the thread in the general forum for more details.

Save yourself. Ban without question upon first sight. Do not interact.


r/swgemu • • Sep 18 '22

Finalizer Huge PvP on Finalizer - Ft Jedi

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Apr 03 '15

Bloodfin has preliminary space!

Thumbnail
facebook.com
1 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Jun 15 '16

Remove all Server advertisement and promotion that don't comply to the Core3 ToS

3 Upvotes

Since I have been asked to cite my sources

"The GNU Affero General Public License is designed specifically to ensure that, in such cases, the modified source code becomes available to the community. It requires the operator of a network server to provide the source code of the modified version running there to the users of that server. Therefore, public use of a modified version, on a publicly accessible server, gives the public access to the source code of the modified version."

https://opensource.org/licenses/AGPL-3.0

As well as...

"In an attempt to prevent further fragmentation of SWG community and to ensure that everything is free and available to everyone, SWGEmu is ready to remove any time restrictions from our Engine3 for all those that go open source and make all their stuff available to any and all SWG Emulator communities. Further more we are changing the license of Core3 to AGPL as well, which in turn will force everyone using our code to either go open source or stop using our code."

http://www.swgemu.com/forums/showthread.php?t=159544

This is the SWGemu subreddit, so shouldnt we be trying to promote the work that the SWGemu team is doing with Core3 and the work other servers are doing within the rules set up for Core3?

The mods of this subreddit should take a look at what servers are in compliance and servers that are not and remove ALL advertisement and promotion for those servers until they comply to the rules. I know <Server removed to not seem biased but its third in the right> is the hot button topic here, and its a well known fact they do not have an open repository. I also know <Server also removed to not seem biased but you can tell who it was by the comments> does not share its custom content as well.

If they chose to go and do things on their own, then they can find a place to advertise that does not carry the SWGemu name, as they are spitting in the face of the dev team.


r/swgemu • • Aug 16 '23

Finalizer Kor Vella PvP | Finalizer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Dec 31 '18

Bas PvP | 5 Imps beat 10 Rebs | Featuring Jedi!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Jul 19 '22

Finalizer Return - Finalizer PvP Ft. Jedi !

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Jul 08 '17

Bloodfin right this second has 560 players on it, they just freshly wiped server with new build, very vannila pre cu www.bloodfin.net

0 Upvotes

Bloodfin right this second has 560 players on it, they just freshly wiped server with new build, very vannila pre cu www.bloodfin.net


r/swgemu • • Mar 17 '19

Rifle PvP vs Jedi Knights - Basilisk PvP Server - SWGEmu

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • May 12 '15

The amazing ‘Star Wars Galaxies’ Jedi mode that never was

Thumbnail
swtorstrategies.com
4 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Mar 24 '18

So uh DARK going to hold the project ransom now?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/swgemu • • Apr 11 '18

Big Group PvP, Theed | Infinity (PvP Server)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes