r/sustainability • u/Tiny-Pomegranate7662 • 6h ago
Hot Take: It's better to live in arid areas and pipe / truck stuff in vs wet temperate biodiverse locations
There's essentially a trade off: places where it's easy to live, temperate climates, plenty of water, fertile soils, are often prime habitat and very biodiverse locations. The most obvious N America examples would be Mexico and Central America or Appalachia / Piedmont or California / PNW.
Conversely places like the Southwest, Rockies, or Plains that require more energy to heat / cool and have to have produce and water brought in on the surface seem a lot more unsustainable.
But my take is that the footprint on these harsher locations is better because the energy / materials needed to support human settlement is offset by disrupting much less sensitive habitat with development.
The transport cost of food is pretty minimal in comparison WHAT the food consumed actually is. There's been a perpetual decry of the American West being 'unsustainably' piping in water, but nowhere has ever ran out of water outside of local wells. Atlanta probably has it's food shipped distance as much as Albuquerque. Homes have gotten drastically more efficient and with solar power and batteries, heating and AC costs will be much less fossil dependent. So essentially living in Las Vegas or Boise or South Dakota is more sustainable than El Salvador or Chattanooga, assuming the person has the same consumption in both.
Conversely deforestation has been horrendously difficult to stop, habitat regeneration very slow and takes multiple generations to get back to old growth, Fragmentation continues etc.
For habitat comparisons, there's more acres of Ponderosa / Juniper / grass / sage land than there is the entirety of Central America and Appalachia combined, and the latter have exponentially more species, the former has a couple hundred of the same ones across millions of acres.