r/survivetheculling • • May 01 '16

Dev Response Support Old Culling Combat

355 Upvotes

The only problems with the original combat system where getting hit through blocks. Other then that everything else was skill based and you could tell if the person you where facing was good or bad. Now everything is a button masher and guessing game where you cannot tell if the person you're facing is good or just rolling there face on the keyboard.

 

  • Return block baiting, this wasn't bad design and the removal of it was only catering to bad players.

 

  • Remove "Shoving times" where if you let down your block you can still be pushed another idea catering to bad/slow reaction timed players.

 

  • Bring back friction in all of its glory so people stop sliding around you like you're in a bare naked oil wrestling match.

 

If i'm forgetting anything feel free to add it below.

  • Just to be clear to the Devs we don't want the entire game reverted only the core combat.

  • Looks like the topic is back everyone :D


r/survivetheculling • • Jul 11 '25

ReviveTheCulling: A Project.

352 Upvotes

Hi!

I am attempting to do what ever it takes to bring back connectivity to The Culling (Origins) OR The Culling Day One Reference.

I've seen two games die in the same fashion. The Culling and Death Garden. The only difference is that I watched the Death Garden community come together and now they have community built servers running while the original servers had shut down.

I'm setting out to do the same thing for The Culling (Origins) and potentially The Culling Day One Reference (depending on if its wanted/possible).

This may be impossible due to factors I'm unaware of, but if Death Garden could, then why not try for The Culling.

So Far the progress I've made is as follows:

  1. Successfully Spoofing the initial backend servers.

    1. I'm able to launch the game and have it hit my own local server at /api, /api/login, /api/authenticated_root (THERE's HOPE)

      1. The inital load works, but the "Play" fails due to websocket issues.

2. Unsuccessfully having the expected websocket to connect. I'm currently trying to figure this out, and this is really critical for getting users "online."

2. I have successfully connected the expected websocket which helps control the “connectivity” of players in the game.

* The next steps will be understanding the matchmaking system and how players connect to it. More updates to come.

It's not a lot, but I'm going to give it a big try. If you or anyone you know has ever had experience in game development, and general software engineering, then this is the time to show up for a game you want to see become community driven.

For those curious. Check out the github. Its all here, and I can try to help explain what I've built so far.

https://github.com/BigNasty000/ReviveTheCulling

[5/9/2026]:

Hi all!

I know it has been an incredibly long time since any type of update from the project I started. To be exact it’s been ALMOST A YEAR 😣

First, I’d like to apologize that I didn’t post more updates along the way here on Reddit. I had joined the long standing discord server and got to work there. Along with an honest answer that not a lot of progress has been made in the path I had originally taken, hence the no updates. I believe my last update even mentioned that I didn’t want to spam this post with “well… still no progress” lol.

I’ve recently noticed quite a few comments on this post asking/assuming that this project is dead, and I’d like to ensure everyone that we are very much still in progress!

So what’s the update then?:

The original path I was taking was incredibly naive and didn’t make a lot of sense. Trying to reverse engineer a game from looking at packets meant that not only would we have to deeply understand the networking code of UE4.15 (which I’m clueless on) but we’d also need to essentially rebuild the entire game engine.

No good.

We do have a different path that’s currently being lead by one of the OG people in the discord! They’ve been putting in some serious technical work on the project, and we are much more certain this path is going to be the way to go.

So what is it?

Instead of attempting to rewrite the entire game engine from scratch, the plan is to use whats already available to us. Currently, you are able to launch an offline game with bots, which means ALL of the game engine is already baked into the client itself. What you can’t do is host and have others connect to you.

Hosting was effectively stripped from the game, as the developers preferred to rely on a dedicated server approach and therefore didn’t need listening servers to be shipped in the final game. So the idea is that we need to reintroduce the ability to start a listen server which would then allow others to connect to you and play together.

This is very much doable BUT requires an incredible amount of technical knowledge about networking, Unreal Engine, and making patches to the executable and game files.

So far, the person working on it was able to get a second client to join a host. There are some slight issues that need to get figured out. But this is HUGE progress compared to what we were originally doing!!!!

The progress looks really promising, and we will most definitely have a lot more active updates coming. As a note, and I believe I’ve mentioned this before, but this project is going to take a lot of time. This is not something that will get finished over night and I promise you there is a lot of work being done to make this happen. I can’t really promise a date on new updates, as sometimes nothing new can happen for literally months.

We will absolutely post any new breakthroughs/updates when we can! Thanks for following along with the project and someday we will play this game again!!!!!

EDIT: I’ve removed a lot of the updates from this thread to make sure no one tries to attempt the route of reverse engineering I did. Attempting to read and understand a games packet system is by far one of the worst ways to bring back a game and reverse engineering in general lol (and I got to learn that the hard way hehe oops). The repo will stay around but I’m going to be updating it to make sure everyone knows that portion of the project is no longer moving forward! Though feel free to use it to learn about the matching making / lobby portion! (Just not the game server part lol)


r/survivetheculling • • Mar 05 '16

Dev Response PLEASE don't fuck up.

311 Upvotes

You currently have it all. A really nice fanbase, low amount of bugs, promising content, awesome gameplay, a developer's wet dream. Don't fuck up and add microtransactions, or fuck over the fanbase in some way. Don't be h1z1, payday 2, or dayz. Stick with what you're doing because it's working. Love the game so far, just don't turn into a greedy studio.


r/survivetheculling • • Jul 10 '18

Announcement For everyone that comes here to check if they should buy The Culling 2 - DONT , ITS HORRIBLE

277 Upvotes

The game is very badly optimized. Has tons of bugs. No players. ( Peak 250 , atleast half refunded already ). Do yourself a favor and do not buy this game at all.

Xaviant had a great concept and game with the first Culling. Instead of focussing on that melee BR gameplay they went for a really bad PUBG / H1Z1 clone.

Watch the reviews on steam and see that the 15% positive reviews are pretty much all memes and sarcasme.


r/survivetheculling • • May 30 '16

Dev Response Anthony Kongphan and the Xaviant staff lied about me and destroyed any good standing reputation I had with this community

245 Upvotes

Edit 2 - I'm putting this edit at the top because I feel it's more important. There is a lot of hate being thrown at the devs right now, most of it is not fair and unwarranted. Remember these are the people that made this game which we all enjoy, they work their asses off every day, spend time on weekends responding to all of us(would you want to work on weekends?) and supporting not only the game but the community, and I can't imagine it's an easy job.

Did they screw up a bit? Yeah I don't think they should have banned me and shown special treatment to streamers, but I don't blame them in the slightest for the special treatment just the extent at which it was given. They are a small company who released an early access game(a game with tons more potential and deserves more players). Advertising for this game heavily isn't in the cards I imagine, so right now the only advertisement they can get is from streamers realistically. There is a balance to be maintained between how they interact with streamers and supporting their stream, they have a symbiotic relationship, there is nothing wrong with that it's just the nature of the beast and for us to get upset over the fact that they recognize this is unfair to them and the streamers. The only issue is the balance may have tilted in favor of streamers too far recently. For us to act like people that broadcast their game to thousands of people shouldn't have special interaction with the devs is crazy, it's only natural for them to talk with these people because they have a large following and voice in the community.

I see comments like the devs are trying to kill this game and the devs are doing everything they can to kill this game, this community is filled with a lot of hate and a lot of negativity, negativity that was not present for the first month or so. I won't get too much more into that as to why it happened, but know that the devs only want this game to succeed...it's their job, and they care about the success more than every one of us, and have shown to care about the game and community on a personal level not just a financial one.

Instead of trying to burn down the building and piss on the ashes, let's put out the flames, rebuild, be more positive, and help the game grow and improve.

Also, I'm sure I'm gonna get people pointing to posts I made yesterday about how I specifically called out the devs or how I was helping in fanning the flames, and you might be right. I was pissed. I was pissed and I made posts that might have perpetuated some hate as well. This edit is me trying to make amends and cool things down. If you're reading this post for the first time read the stuff below and read it with this in mind, that I enjoy the game and want the game to improve, I don't want the game to die or any bullshit like that I only want it to get better.


My in game name is demarini. WAIT. Before you automatically assume I'm a stream sniping dickhead who only wants to troll, realize that the only person you have heard that from is Anthony Kongphan, the same person that calls everyone that gives him a close fight, or anyone that finds him in the open, a stream sniper.

I won't discuss my ban specifically, but the events leading up to it. Xaviant staff has told me they handle these matters internally, so I will try to avoid that to the best of my ability to avoid my thread getting locked again. I think this pastebin is still okay, it discusses my side of the story, my point of view of the events, and how lies and rumors led to a good community member being banned.

http://pastebin.com/BBt5h926

It's very long, I put a lot of thought into it, so I'd appreciate you read it.

In this video, Anthony admits that he hast he power to ban someone(though I think this was an exaggeration/joke), but then specifically says Xaviant staff, who I assume was Xentax, had asked him if he wanted me banned. Up until this point I can't imagine anything even close to what I could have done to warrant a ban. Also, dude, your charity event has been going on for a month. What no one is allowed to shoot you with an alarm gun for a month? Get over yourself Anthony a lot of people want to play with you because they enjoy your stream, how you don't see that is beyond me.

Why do I assume it was Xentax? Well he is active in his chat, a moderator of his chat, and he even posted this in his chat. Yep that's right, a Xaviant staff member supported report brigading a player in their community. Wanna know what's funny? I asked him, Xentax, what the deal was. He said I had also received a number of reports outside of Anthony. I assumed it was for a taser build that I was using, but now I see what actually happened.

Another thing is, I have an alt account I got from a gift, I use this account to jump into teams games and make it essentially a 2v1(I still am able to win somewhat frequently, it's more fun this way). This alt account, that is stationary the whole game and on occasion killed by me or someone else, got banned. Can someone explain why an account that has zero inputs when getting in the game gets banned for griefing? As far as they are concerned it could be my quadriplegic brother watching the game. The only explanation is Anthony Kongphan gave the names, and Xentax banned the names.

What are the implications here? Do we have to be super careful when getting in games with streamers now? We can't do anything that might considered annoying against them because they might get us banned? How does this work? Xaviant with this and other bans in my opinion lost a lot of credibility, and a lot of trust. Whenever I see twitch in a name now, even if I don't get unbanned when the ban is up, I will be cautious and play significantly differently. I probably won't use alarm gun, smoke bombs, blow gun, or any weapons that might upset them.


Edit 1: So anthony fanboys are going to come in here and link to this and say that I deleted it because I did something wrong. This is how stupid these people are. They all viewed these comments and started downvoting them(brigading is illegal btw). I was positive for every comment I posted at one point, and then quickly went heavily negative. I deleted the posts because I didn't want to deal with that. They all assume, after brigading my posts, that I deleted them not because their massive brigading, but because of some sort of retraction lol.

Also, when you read the comments nothing is contradictory to what I've said here. I admit, I was using unnecessary and hateful language, but Anthony was ruining any name I had because he was salty over getting killed. I was angry and rightfully so, but that's no excuse for the words I used. BUT the message is still the same. Anthony calls me a stream sniper with no evidence, and I admit to queue sniping but not actively viewing the stream, stream sniping. We need to differentiate those two terms btw.


r/survivetheculling • • Apr 13 '16

Dev Response "The Most Dangerous Game" Match Type

218 Upvotes

"The Most Dangerous Game", also published as "The Hounds of Zaroff", is a short story by Richard Connell. The plot is about a man who captures humans and then sets them free on his island for him to hunt. They get a head start, but virtually no supplies while the hunter has adequate supplies and weapons.

Think of a game type where one (or a small number of) contestants start inside the training facility and get their pick of weapons/supplies to take, and they would exit out of the locked door already in the map. Meanwhile, the remaining contestants start off similarly to how they do already - except without any perks or access to air drops. They would get a 3-5 minute head start to explore, craft, set traps, etc. Game would end when either all the hunters are dead or all the "prey" are hunted. (This would make a great use of the proximity voice chat if that were to be implemented.)

Maybe if this gets enough support the devs will consider adding it?


r/survivetheculling • • Jul 18 '18

Announcement A message from Xaviant

Thumbnail
twitter.com
216 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Mar 31 '16

Discussion Devs, PLEASE re-enable the friction feature!

212 Upvotes

I mentioned this in a post just now, but I really think this has to be said. It's probably being completely overlooked as a contributor to the confusion and general weird feeling combat currently has. It's too slippery. You zoom past enemies too much. Hits and pushes feel insubstantial. Please. Everyone is complaining about the speed of weps, and this and that, but I guarantee it would feel more familiar with the friction back on. It sounds really stupid when I'm asking for it, but it's the only thing I can think of that nobody has really considered.

Edit: "I'm playing ring around the rosie with my enemy more than I'm playing rock paper scissors." Made myself lol.

Symptoms include: Pushes not registering well. Generally harder time reading opponents. Feeling like you are fighting on roller skates. Uncharacteristic attack or push spamming due to confusion/frustration. Pockets full of posies. Frequent 90 degree turns to relocate enemy who somehow ran past you.


r/survivetheculling • • Apr 01 '16

Dev Response [Suggestion] Add the ability to let people kill a player in their game for $4.99.

210 Upvotes

I don't see why this isn't already a thing. There's literally no down sides.

Edit: Not sure why I'm being downvoted, I'm just trying to offer new, original ideas that could make this game unique

Edit 2: Wow! Top of the subreddit! Can we get a dev confirmation about an ETA?


r/survivetheculling • • Mar 14 '16

DEV RESPONSE The Devs for this game are Fucking Legends™

205 Upvotes

This game has been out what, a week? It's already had more updates, more fixes, more server support and more communication than I've seen in DayZ for the last six months. I'm not being hyperbolic, it really has.

If I were the devs, I'd be knee deep in cocaine and hookers; but you guys are balls-to-the-wall working your asses off.

Slow clap.


r/survivetheculling • • Jul 10 '18

Mighty Womble Food for thought - The Culling II may influence future game dev by giving other studios ideas.

200 Upvotes

So I'm one of those Youtuber-type bellends, stinking up the internet these days.

And going purely by view count, it appears I have the second largest Culling related video currently on Youtube. So...yikes. Additionally I've spent about 9-10 years working in software QA before the Youtube gig. First as a regular testing grunt and eventually as a Senior. So I've helped quality assure a whole load of shit. From regular games, to mobile/tablet apps, to enterprise software, to the sort of thing that Xavient is working on at the moment.

I just wanted to chime in on some (maybe interesting) talking points that other may not have yet considered. Because Xavient is doing something that I don't think I've seen another company yet attempt. So it's going to be interesting how it pans out for them and may give other companies ideas - they have attempted to roll in the early-access market twice, with a game that's similar but with tweaks that mimic their competition.

First, there's are several reasons why we're seeing the rise of Battle Royale-style games. And they're not all to do with the inherent popularity of the game-mode:

  • In 2012, the DayZ mod arrived. And what it did was expose a huge market for players interested in an open-world, gather loot, iterative lives style of deathmatch. Because they present situations with a lot more adrenaline and unexpected reversals of fortune - hence an absurd about of replay value compared to your regular deathmatch game. The current glut of Battle Royale games are really just an echo of the initial shock-wave from the DayZ mod entering the market, with no more hero plays, with loot times cut down and battles speed up in order to get to the next life, next iteration. It no longer takes 2 hours to gear up to reach the action, but 10-20 minutes. Faster, faster, more adrenaline, etc. DayZ with the corners cut off.

  • This type of game mode is comparatively cheap to develop. Since you don't need to worry about a whole host of things that other game genres do. You just need to setup basic start conditions, the terrain, the internal player logics such as health, etc, and then the players make the gameplay themselves. This is important. This is why this game mode is so attractive, because you don't need to do as much upfront work as you would normally. A whole load of complexity is off your shoulders.

  • Engine licensing means you can get access to a decent game engine without having to go through the expense of developing it yourself. Keeping costs low.

  • Steam means you don't need to work under a publisher with stringent rules and growth goals. You can cut them out entirely and just connect right to the customers. Again, keeping down costs.

  • "Early access" means there's no real guarantee the project will ever get finished. Or even defines what finished looks like. You can just walk away with the cash the moment you want to and just declare your last working version as 1.0. Nobody is really holding your feet to the fire.

So the above reasons collectively are why we're seeing all of those initial DayZ Mod clones with base building. And then the format getting tightened further with PUBG and Fortnite being the most popular. But it's all for the above reasons. It's cheap and easy.

Now, my point is...thus far no other company has attempted to roll TWICE in the same market. I believe Xaviant is the first.

H1Z1 split their game into a Battle Royale one and a DayZ Epoch'esk one. But that was because of a broken base that wanted very different things, as far as I could tell. And possibly to limit the damage from their loot-crate PR dumpster fire. But Xavient is the first that has abandoned their first roll and has attempted the second, whilst mimicking some elements of their now competition.

Now, I expect they'll fail in this. Their goodwill with their customers is too low for it to succeed. But I bet you anything that other Battle Royale developers are watching this very carefully. And will start to consider doing the same. For I reckon they'll be able to pull it off. They'll be able to add elements of their competitors, call them sequels. Maybe even reuse the same engine and some assets to save money. And they might make a lot of money doing it.

TL;DR - I reckon the Culling II is going to give other developers ideas. With little dollar signs appearing in their eyes.


r/survivetheculling • • Dec 29 '16

Media Random The Culling Bullshittery (part 2)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
200 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Jul 04 '17

If this gets upvoted 100 times, this is officially a spicy wings sub

193 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Mar 24 '16

Media When it comes down to a 1v1...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
186 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Apr 06 '16

Suggestion [Suggestion] Be able to wear both Hats and Balaclavas (Example)

179 Upvotes

Personally i don't see why we can't have both, mix things up a bit. Examples:

Bonnie+Goggles

Cap+Goggles

Cap+Balaclava

Balaclava+Googles

Etc.


r/survivetheculling • • Apr 06 '16

Media I met the Fair Trader

Thumbnail
imgur.com
177 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Mar 09 '16

DEV RESPONSE Don't turn The Culling into a streamer-focused game

173 Upvotes

I say all of this as a streamer, who even got special treatment from the H1Z1 devs (who are nice people, but still).

Publicizing on Twitch is a great idea. Its essentially free advertising and gets a ton of hype surrounding the game. This is totally smart and fine. What isn't fine is if you start ignoring the normal players and start only focusing on the streamers. The streamer tournament, the Lirik flag, the King of the Kappa thing - all of it points to a trend that shouldn't grow any bigger. Even if it is completely innocent, it just naturally creates hostilities. I've seen it before in H1Z1 and I don't want to see it happen here. If you go to the H1Z1 subreddit and even say the word "streamer," you will be called every horrible thing in the book, and I almost don't blame them due to the extremely preferential treatment they get.

I know it is tempting to only deal with streamers because they can relay their opinions to the thousands that watch, but try not to walk down that path too much.

From what I've seen, you guys are super active on this subreddit and tend to respond very frequently so I have high hopes you won't pull an H1Z1. I think most of us here feel the same.

Anyway, that's all I've got. Gonna check out this new update now!


r/survivetheculling • • Apr 29 '16

Suggestion [Idea] Alarm Gun sets a bounty on people

172 Upvotes

Most people sell Alarm Guns as soon as they find them and shooting someone with one serves to annoy them more than anything. What if shooting someone with it puts a bounty on their head, and killing them while the beacon is active gives you an extra 10 FUNC or so? It would make an Alarm Gun build slightly more viable because aggressive people would want the extra FUNC, especially if more than one person in a fight gets shot with one. It could even create fun baits in Teams by shooting your teammates with an alarm gun and mow people down as they come to you to claim the bounty. Maybe the Red Gunner perk itself could include the bounty-setting?


r/survivetheculling • • Apr 13 '16

Suggestion We should be able to re-queue while we spectate after dying.

169 Upvotes

Sometimes when I go back to the main menu I'm taken out of the mood for playing the game. I think it would be great if I could continue to watch the game whilst I queued up again.


r/survivetheculling • • Mar 18 '16

DEV RESPONSE Weapon balance rant after 120 hrs played

167 Upvotes

Now that the taser has been nerfed and some of the air drops have been fixed I think it’s time to discuss a quiet balance issue that’s been lurking behind the meta since day 1. And that balance issue is that blades and spears are better than bludgeons and axes. Almost always. There are four reasons why I think this is true. 1) Bleed is way better than weakness, 2) blades and spears have better perks, 3) blades and spears have better air drops, and 4) blades and spears have better weapons.

First consider this, weakness and almost everything about the the bludgeon/axe perk suite is designed to mitigate incoming damage. For example, a typical axe build using maniac and mangler relies on the 25% damage reduction from holding an axe + the damage reduction eventually caused from draining the opponent's stamina through mangler + the damage reduction applied by the weakness debuff. Sounds like it’ll be taking practically no damage, right? But the blade user isn’t significantly affected by ANY of this because he’s doing the vast majority of his damage unmitigated from bleed.

That’s right, bleed isn’t affected by damage mitigators. You probably already knew this but maybe it hasn’t registered just how broken this is. A player can even get to a whopping 50% damage reduction from a combination like leather hide, tough mother, and iron4skin, then apply a 3 star weakness debuff reducing enemy incoming damage by another 30%, and STILL take maximum damage from bleed. I’ve tested it.

But isn’t there a perk that reduces bleed? Not really. Clotting agent and healthy constitution won’t help you because all the bleed user has to do is get a hit in every 6 seconds or so to reapply the bleed and render the perk useless. You’ll still bleed down at the same rate.

Now, all of this probably wouldn’t matter if bleed didn’t do an absurd amount of damage but even something like a cheap crafted knife striking for 5 will bleed for an additional 12! 70% of the damage coming from a crafted knife comes from bleed. This means that as long as the blade user fights conservatively and gives his bleed a little time to settle in, he should still beat someone with a high tier bludgeon or axe because even though his 5 damage strike might be reduced to 3 (big whoop) he’ll always just bleed the guy to death as long as he’s able to get a strike in every now and then to reapply it, and that’s not hard to do. I realize that reapplying the bleed might mean cutting off some of the damage from the original dot, so you’re not necessarily getting 12 per strike, but I estimate you’re still getting a strike in every 6 seconds or so, enough to keep bleed on despite clotting agent and still get ~50% of your damage through unmitigated.

But doesn’t bleed gets worse relative to weapon damage as the game goes on and players start using higher tier weapons? Sure this is true. But why should bludgeons and axes be at a disadvantage at the crucial early stages of the game when the most melee fighting is happening? And then later in the game when bleed is supposed to mean less the bludgeon and axe guys get handed subpar weapons as a reward for having managed to survive that early game.

This post never got enough attention: https://www.reddit.com/r/survivetheculling/comments/4a4ms0/weapon_stats_may_need_a_little_tweaking/ and it touches on what I’m talking about here. The weapon tiers might as well mean nothing. Compare the stats on the tier 3 items. Why do blades get access to the bowie knife, or the sabre, 6 star weapons, while bludgeons and axes don’t get a single tier 3 weapon with a 3 star rating in either category? Does weapon damage make up for it? I don’t think so. The tier two blades and spears get the same damage as the tier 3 bludgeons and axes and get more stars. It’s stupid. Because of bleed, a weapon like the cleaver (tier 2) with its 3 star wound rating and excellent damage becomes one of the best melee weapons in the game. You can pick it up in a green crate in your first minute in. But other times you’ll get the steel pipe, and do significantly less damage and get a weakness debuff that not only does nothing against the cleaver’s bleed but requires you to get hit in order to even take advantage of the 3 star wound intensity. That just doesn’t seem intuitive to me.

Perks are also better for blades and spears. They have access to more movespeed which is so dominant right now that some are calling for it to be removed from the game. Backstab perks can be devastating. And blades/spears can increase the duration of their already broken bleed ability through bloodbath. Meanwhile axes and bludgeons get underwhelming perks like chopper and basher. None of their damage mitigating perks are effective against bleed, not even clotting agent. And submission/mangler are okay but I mean, they’re countered by a stamina injection. Where’s the injection to counter bleed?

Compare the airdrops. Thank god for the Stalker nerf but there are still problems. The katana is better than the fire axe or the sledgehammer but it’s in the cheapest package. Boar Hunter for a very affordable 85 func is probably the most efficient air drop in the game for doubles. Juggler functions the same as Javelineer but you’re paying more for worse weapons. Most of the bludgeon/axe packages force you to pay for iron4skin, arguably the worst of the 6 injections, while blades and spears get essential utility items like a mantracker, smoke bombs, a medkit, etc...

I would love to see more variety in builds. But right now for every guy I see going bludgeons, there are 5 other guys running blades. It’s always the same old leg day/runs with knives stuff. Crafted spears and crafted knives are everywhere. I honestly think half the people running axes and bludgeons are only doing so out of boredom. But I think with small changes to help out bludgeons and axes or nerfing bleed or buffing weakness you’d see a lot more builds breaking the meta. And a lot more variety to make the game more fun.

Here are my 10 ideas for improving melee weapon balance:

-Improve weakness debuff to lower movespeed in addition to damage reduction.

-Change clotting agent and healthy constitution so that they decrease the rate of bleed rather than the duration.

-Improve chopper and basher.

-Improve the weapon stats on bludgeons and axes.

-Decrease the damage or wound intensity on the cleaver and the javelin.

-Decrease the wound intensity on the crafted knife and the crafted spear.

-Increase the price of Ninja.

-Decrease the price of Hoodlum.

-Decrease the price of Juggler.

-Remove the second survival spear from the boar hunter package and replace it with something else so a player cannot outfit both himself and his teammate with a tier 3 weapon that compliments their perks using the same drop.


r/survivetheculling • • Mar 31 '16

Suggestion I have the Solution to Weapon Balance

154 Upvotes

I would like to keep this brief and to the point. Here are some suggestions that will balance out the weapons:

General:

  • Keep the speed rating affecting jab speed, but change it so that charge speed is the same for all weapons. Make it so that you can do a 75% charged hit after a successful block/shove. This will allow bludgeons and axes to be viable with their "slow but big hits" playstyle.

  • Bring friction back so that combat is less "slippery" than it is now. That way, shoves will be more responsive. Also slightly increasing shove range will help. To balance that, make it so you take slightly more damage if you're hit during a shove.

Weapon Specific:

  • Blades: Keep the speed ratings the same, nerf Run with Knives to 8% speed increase. Now people who run Leg Day (7%) and Run with Knives (8%) will have 15% speed bonus, which is equal to someone that has Explosive Runs/Orange Juice.

  • Spears: Buff Survival Spear to 2 star speed. Allow spears to have slightly more range than any other weapon. This will differentiate spears with knives, rather than having them as an "inferior knife".

  • Bludgeons: Keep them at low speed rating, but allow the Sledgehammer to have a 100% charged hit following a successful block/shove with the Basher Perk. Bludgeons should be slow swinging but hard hitting.

  • Axes: Allow Chopper Perk to give Fireman's axe a 100% charged hit after a successful block/shove. To differentiate axes and bludgeons, allow axes to apply both a bleed AND weakness but at 50% reduced rate. Also notice how I am balancing the end-game bludgeons/axes against the Katana.

Conclusion:

This will end up making the Blades the "Fast and Spammy" weapons. Bludgeons the "slow but hard hitting" weapons with their strong charged attack. Spears with their "slow but long range poke" tactics. Finally, axes with their "slow and hard hitting" style that applies a minor bleed and weakness. Each weapon will feel unique to use.

An alternative suggestion is to add a short cripple effect (1-2 seconds) when hit by bludgeons, while axes retain the weakness effect. The reason is because you cannot craft a bludgeon right away, so they should have some sort of advantage if you do manage to find a bludgeon. You are taking a gamble early-game running bludgeon perks, so there should be higher reward for the risk. I like how knuckle dragger perk plays into this high risk, high reward playstyle.

Hopefully the Devs find this useful. Also upvote if you agree to these suggestions!


r/survivetheculling • • Mar 15 '16

DEV RESPONSE The Culling Patch “The Culling Goes Down Under” Coming March 16!

Thumbnail
steamcommunity.com
153 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Mar 06 '16

I finally won my first game. I can't remember the last game where winning feels this good!

152 Upvotes

I love it!


r/survivetheculling • • Mar 17 '16

Map of The Culling - Most accurate (Made by BIOS)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
145 Upvotes

r/survivetheculling • • Mar 11 '16

The airdrop perk....

145 Upvotes

I know it doesn't really matter, but I don't like how the airdropper perk teleports a drone to the landing pad when every other airdrop is actually flown in from outside the map.

Instead of teleporting the drone and package to the pad why not have the crate come up from inside the pad? The pad is big enough to have a storage compartment underneath it and eject a crate. Just have the top slide open and an elevator lift the crate up.

Then we could rename the Airdropper perk to something like, Prime Delivery, or Overnight Delivery.

Edit: /u/ArrowVulcan made a fantastic animation for us!