r/supplychain • u/kabzik • May 24 '25
Career Development So you are a top performer on your team and want to be a Supply Chain manager? Read this first.
I've brainstormed this with AI as an effort to reflect on loosing a 6 figure SCM manager position. Every word is true, but I would like to hear your thoughts.
A lot of professionals who love what they do get stuck when they are promoted to manage people who now do what these newly created managers loved to do. Why is it happening?
I. The Shift in Core Identity and Skillset:
From "Doer" to "Enabler": The fundamental change is from personally executing tasks to enabling others to execute tasks. The skills that made someone excellent in their individual contributor role (technical expertise, problem-solving, attention to detail in their craft) are often very different from the skills needed to manage (coaching, delegation, motivation, conflict resolution, strategic thinking, empathy).
Loss of Direct Impact/Control: Many professionals derive immense satisfaction from seeing the direct results of their own work. As a manager, their impact becomes more indirect, through the success of their team. This can feel less tangible and less rewarding for those who are used to immediate gratification from their output.
Passion vs. Process: They loved the doing – the hands-on work, the creative process, the technical challenge. Management often involves more process, meetings, administration, and dealing with interpersonal dynamics, which might not ignite the same passion.
Different Brain Functions: Individual contributor roles often engage specific, deep technical or creative parts of the brain. Management roles demand more of the frontal lobe – planning, organizing, decision-making, emotional intelligence. It's a different kind of mental engagement.
II. The "Myth of the Best Performer":
Promotion as a Reward: Often, the highest-performing individual contributors are promoted to management as a reward for their excellence. The assumption is that if they're good at the job, they'll be good at managing people who do the job. This is a flawed assumption.
Lack of Management Training: Companies frequently promote individuals without providing adequate training in leadership, communication, HR best practices, performance management, or team building. They're thrown into the deep end and expected to swim.
"I Know How to Do It Best": The new manager's deep expertise can become a hindrance. They might struggle to delegate effectively because they believe they can do it better or faster themselves, leading to micromanagement and team disempowerment.
III. The Human and Emotional Toll:
Increased Stress and Responsibility: Management brings a whole new layer of stress – responsibility for others' performance and well-being, mediating conflicts, hitting team targets, and often being the buffer between senior leadership and the team.
Loneliness at the Top: While still part of a team, managers often find themselves in a more isolated position. They can't always confide in their direct reports, and their peer group might be small.
Burnout from "Sandwich" Position: New managers are often caught between the demands of upper management and the needs of their team, leading to significant pressure and potential burnout.
Guilt and Frustration: They might feel guilty that they no longer get to do the work they loved, or frustrated that they can't dedicate enough time to it.
Erosion of "Flow State": Many professionals experience "flow" when deeply engaged in their craft. Management roles are often more fragmented, with constant interruptions, making it harder to achieve that fulfilling state.
IV. Organizational and Cultural Factors:
Limited Career Paths: In many organizations, the only path for advancement for a highly skilled individual contributor is into management. There might not be equally prestigious or financially rewarding "individual contributor specialist" tracks.
Emphasis on Hierarchy: Organizational structures often equate success with climbing the management ladder, implicitly devaluing technical or creative expertise that doesn't involve managing people.
Poorly Defined Managerial Roles: Sometimes, the expectations for a new manager aren't clearly articulated, leading to confusion and a sense of being overwhelmed.
Lack of Support Systems: Insufficient mentorship, peer support groups for new managers, or access to experienced HR guidance can leave new managers feeling adrift.
The "Peter Principle": People are promoted to their level of incompetence. In this context, they're promoted until they reach a role (management) where their previous skills are no longer sufficient, and they lack the new ones needed.
V. Misconceptions about Management:
"It's Just More Senior": Many new managers see it as a natural progression of their existing role, rather than a fundamentally different one.
Underestimating the "People" Element: They might underestimate the complexity and emotional labor involved in managing people, assuming it's simply about assigning tasks.
Idealized View of Leadership: They might have an idealized view of what a manager does, not realizing the often mundane, challenging, and emotionally taxing aspects of the role.
In summary, the core issue is a misalignment between the skills, motivations, and satisfactions derived from being a high-performing individual contributor and those required for effective people management. It's not about being "bad" at their job, but rather being placed in a role that demands a completely different set of strengths and brings a different kind of fulfillment.