r/supplychain • • May 24 '25

Career Development So you are a top performer on your team and want to be a Supply Chain manager? Read this first.

0 Upvotes

I've brainstormed this with AI as an effort to reflect on loosing a 6 figure SCM manager position. Every word is true, but I would like to hear your thoughts.

A lot of professionals who love what they do get stuck when they are promoted to manage people who now do what these newly created managers loved to do. Why is it happening?

I. The Shift in Core Identity and Skillset:

  • From "Doer" to "Enabler": The fundamental change is from personally executing tasks to enabling others to execute tasks. The skills that made someone excellent in their individual contributor role (technical expertise, problem-solving, attention to detail in their craft) are often very different from the skills needed to manage (coaching, delegation, motivation, conflict resolution, strategic thinking, empathy).

  • Loss of Direct Impact/Control: Many professionals derive immense satisfaction from seeing the direct results of their own work. As a manager, their impact becomes more indirect, through the success of their team. This can feel less tangible and less rewarding for those who are used to immediate gratification from their output.

  • Passion vs. Process: They loved the doing – the hands-on work, the creative process, the technical challenge. Management often involves more process, meetings, administration, and dealing with interpersonal dynamics, which might not ignite the same passion.

  • Different Brain Functions: Individual contributor roles often engage specific, deep technical or creative parts of the brain. Management roles demand more of the frontal lobe – planning, organizing, decision-making, emotional intelligence. It's a different kind of mental engagement.

II. The "Myth of the Best Performer":

  • Promotion as a Reward: Often, the highest-performing individual contributors are promoted to management as a reward for their excellence. The assumption is that if they're good at the job, they'll be good at managing people who do the job. This is a flawed assumption.

  • Lack of Management Training: Companies frequently promote individuals without providing adequate training in leadership, communication, HR best practices, performance management, or team building. They're thrown into the deep end and expected to swim.

  • "I Know How to Do It Best": The new manager's deep expertise can become a hindrance. They might struggle to delegate effectively because they believe they can do it better or faster themselves, leading to micromanagement and team disempowerment.

III. The Human and Emotional Toll:

  • Increased Stress and Responsibility: Management brings a whole new layer of stress – responsibility for others' performance and well-being, mediating conflicts, hitting team targets, and often being the buffer between senior leadership and the team.

  • Loneliness at the Top: While still part of a team, managers often find themselves in a more isolated position. They can't always confide in their direct reports, and their peer group might be small.

  • Burnout from "Sandwich" Position: New managers are often caught between the demands of upper management and the needs of their team, leading to significant pressure and potential burnout.

  • Guilt and Frustration: They might feel guilty that they no longer get to do the work they loved, or frustrated that they can't dedicate enough time to it.

  • Erosion of "Flow State": Many professionals experience "flow" when deeply engaged in their craft. Management roles are often more fragmented, with constant interruptions, making it harder to achieve that fulfilling state.

IV. Organizational and Cultural Factors:

  • Limited Career Paths: In many organizations, the only path for advancement for a highly skilled individual contributor is into management. There might not be equally prestigious or financially rewarding "individual contributor specialist" tracks.

  • Emphasis on Hierarchy: Organizational structures often equate success with climbing the management ladder, implicitly devaluing technical or creative expertise that doesn't involve managing people.

  • Poorly Defined Managerial Roles: Sometimes, the expectations for a new manager aren't clearly articulated, leading to confusion and a sense of being overwhelmed.

  • Lack of Support Systems: Insufficient mentorship, peer support groups for new managers, or access to experienced HR guidance can leave new managers feeling adrift.

  • The "Peter Principle": People are promoted to their level of incompetence. In this context, they're promoted until they reach a role (management) where their previous skills are no longer sufficient, and they lack the new ones needed.

V. Misconceptions about Management:

  • "It's Just More Senior": Many new managers see it as a natural progression of their existing role, rather than a fundamentally different one.

  • Underestimating the "People" Element: They might underestimate the complexity and emotional labor involved in managing people, assuming it's simply about assigning tasks.

  • Idealized View of Leadership: They might have an idealized view of what a manager does, not realizing the often mundane, challenging, and emotionally taxing aspects of the role.

In summary, the core issue is a misalignment between the skills, motivations, and satisfactions derived from being a high-performing individual contributor and those required for effective people management. It's not about being "bad" at their job, but rather being placed in a role that demands a completely different set of strengths and brings a different kind of fulfillment.


r/supplychain • • May 16 '24

Veterans Post Locked? Why?

0 Upvotes

Today a veteran asked for a recommendation for an SC cert. As a veteran myself, I wanted to reply, but found out that the post was locked. It's the first time that a post was locked here that I can remember.

As for the comments they were all terrible/borderline offensive and not helpful. Really uncalled for IMHO. I think we can do better as a community than this. Yes, I'm sure he knows to search through the posts here and Google it!

I know some of the posts are a bit redundant. If we let every 'how much should I make' post or 'how to make 6 figures in 6 months' post stay unlocked, surely we can help this vet out and get him on track.

Edit: Looks like it's been deleted or removed. Nice work.


r/supplychain • • Mar 18 '23

Can we get this subreddit to actual supply chain discussion (eg: ops, inv, sales, mkt, logistics)

12 Upvotes

Rant of the day..

This subreddit has become a “how to” rather than a place to discuss actual supply chain issues.

There’s so much information online, please use your resources diligently before asking an open ended question on here..

That’s it, that’s all.. have a good day!


r/supplychain • • Oct 06 '24

Does a supply chain Concentration have hard math classes you need to pass in college?

0 Upvotes

r/supplychain • • Aug 09 '25

Discussion Do any of you who work as a buyer or other roles that require the upmost attention to detail smoke weed? If so do you feel it negatively/positively affects your performance?

0 Upvotes

If there are any of you who do partake did it affect you negatively that you had to quit completely? Did it affect you positively so you just kept it at a minimum?

I’m not a huge smoker I’m more of a social smoker I’ll get with some old friends every 2-3 months or so and we will smoke it up. Besides that I don’t smoke at all. One of my other friends I had met at university works in SCM in the aerospace industry and he is the straight edge type. I told him of my plans to go down to visit some old friends and mentioned how we would be smoking at some point. He told me I’m fucking up by still even smoking even if it’s rarely and just socially and that I will ruin my performance in the long run due to how weed affects short term memory. Saying I won’t be as sharp. Just curious if I am doing myself a disservice smoking and if maybe I would be sharper if I just cut it out completely?


r/supplychain • • Feb 19 '25

Egg shortages and no chicken meat shortage

0 Upvotes

So I don't understand something... 🤔

If eggs are in short supply, why hasn't chicken meat also done the same? Can anyone explain that to me? 🤷‍♂️


r/supplychain • • Mar 27 '25

Discussion We have to get rid of brokers and start working with carriers directly

13 Upvotes

In trucking market brokers don’t do anything than just making money being middleman and taking huge margin in between. All of those words about market being dead is because brokers who don’t t have any assets usually playing with rates thus making carrier companies and hard working truck drivers who actually have assets and have operational costs get paid less. Shippers could actually benefit financially if they would work directly with carrier companies.


r/supplychain • • Mar 19 '23

Discussion Graduating soon with a supply chain degree --- Feeling lost (scared of lost potential)

0 Upvotes

To explain simply without going into too much detail... I would almost confidently say I am ahead of most of my peers in my major. I had two co-ops that look amazing on paper dealing with helping building rockets and procurement for cold chain at a fortune 100. At this point offers are easily to get and I have passed on a lot of good opportunities. The wealth of choice make me feel like I will be depressed with whatever I go with and always regret not doing something else that l lost potential. Part of me feels like I should push myself with consulting, go for the money or go for interest. Here is the honest choice that I have in my hand right now. Either go work for an oil company and make 80,000 to start with a 15,000 starting bonus in a development program in OPS or go help build a new theme park in Orlando and likely make 60,000 for a team that with double in size in two years in sourcing. Lots of room for growth and exactly what I set out to do a year ago. Any opinions story's about first job after graduation would help


r/supplychain • • Mar 20 '20

Make no mistake about supply chains being impacted by COVID-19

Thumbnail
scmr.com
0 Upvotes

r/supplychain • • Jul 07 '21

Discussion Fishcoin initiative aims to solve traceability challenges in first mile for sustainable seafood production

Thumbnail
foodnavigator-asia.com
1 Upvotes

r/supplychain • • Aug 21 '24

Salary expectation

11 Upvotes

I’m graduating in 2026 at Rutgers with 2 co-ops with Johnson and Johnson for transportation and procurement, have a sales business with 85,000 revenue for the last 3 years, and been very involved with my school and have many connections with the deans and such. I say all this as this has been my most relevant experience in the business field. I know people at JnJ that work full time that only had one co-op that are getting paid $75k. What do you believe my starting salary could be if I look around? Any chance 6 figures?


r/supplychain • • Aug 23 '24

Discussion AI in Supply Chain

2 Upvotes

I was going through the shares of AI in different industries, and got to know that AI in Supply Chain is 3.5 Billon dollars and will grow at a CAGR of 38.5% till 2030. Its crazy, whats your view on this?


r/supplychain • • Oct 10 '23

Discussion Do you think blockchain is the future of supply chain management?

0 Upvotes

What first comes to your mind when you hear about Blockchain in the supply chain, what do you think what impact does it have on supply chain management?

What I really think is, that is mind-blowing how this innovation is reshaping the way we handle goods and services from production to delivery.

Blockchain in the supply chain brings unprecedented transparency, traceability, and security to the table.

I was curious about some real-life examples and I bumped into plenty of examples, since 2018, Walmart has been using blockchain to manage their suppliers of leafy greens. Their goal is to ensure the safety of the products they sell and to reduce the time it takes to provide evidence in the event of a claim. Nestlé is also using blockchain tech, as well as Clarins which started using NeuroChain not so long ago to verify the supply chain of its ingredients. SkyCell used blockchain to create smart refrigerated containers for the transport of medicines that are equipped with IoT sensors.

And the list goes on and on.

I'd love to know your thoughts on this. Do you think blockchain is the future of supply chain management, or do you see limitations and challenges that need to be addressed?


r/supplychain • • Jun 01 '20

This could be how “New Normal” will look like !! I am in agreement with most of it 😀! #covid19 #newnormal

3 Upvotes

r/supplychain • • 25d ago

Question / Request AI applications in supply chain (no fluff)

1 Upvotes

Has anyone seen a course/tutorial demonstrating actual applications of AI in supply chain? There's obviously a ton of noise out there, but I want to see an actual use case with tangible outputs.

Has anyone seen this?


r/supplychain • • Mar 26 '25

Education.

0 Upvotes

What’s the best plan for this?

Currently I’m in an accounting undergrad. I like accounting, however SCM pays more. After my undergrad I’m going to get my MAcc. After that, I want to purse an SCM degree. Would it be a good thing to have the MITx MicroMasters in SCM? It’s a 6 course “MicroMasters” from MIT via edX. I also plan to pursue an MSB SCM after. Does that sound like a good plan?


r/supplychain • • Mar 06 '20

Hey guys! I’m done studying for my CSCP exam and am currently willing to share my 2019 APICS CSCP learning system PDFs for $60. The price on Amazon is $200 for these. I have no interest in making profit, just trying to recover my cost. HMU if you’re interested!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/supplychain • • Nov 15 '21

Help!!! Should I become an inventory analyst ?!?

0 Upvotes

It’s been over a year and a half since I graduated from college. I’m based in the U.S. and my major was in Statistics. My original goal was to get an entry-level data analyst job but I have been unsuccessful in that task. Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to get work experience during my undergrad and I do not have any connections. To make matters worse, this is my first time trying to get a job. I did not realize how competitive today’s job market is. I’m currently looking into the inventory analyst to strengthen my technical skills and gain some experience. With that said, I have few questions: 1) Is it a good idea for me to consider being an inventory analyst as a career? 2) Should I become an inventory clerk before becoming an inventory analyst? Does it matter? 3) Is it hard to break into the inventory analyst field? 4) Is there on the job training for people interested in the inventory analyst field?


r/supplychain • • Jun 16 '25

Is it true that US online shopping wastes 40% of truck space?

0 Upvotes

I was discussing online shopping with ChatGPT, and while I knew the US and China handled things differently, the actual numbers shocked me. Are these stats from ChatGPT generally accurate?

1. Overpackaging Inefficiency

  • The US spends $0.85 per parcel on excessive packaging (vs China's $0.02), using boxes up to 4.2x larger than necessary.

  • This wastes 25-40% of truck space, forcing 30% more delivery trips.

  • China ships 68% of parcels in minimalist plastic mailers, maximizing truck capacity and cutting emissions by 72% per package.

2. Packaging-Defect Return Culture

  • When a package arrives with a damaged box but undamaged contents, 18.7% of US consumers still return it, vs 1.2% do so in China.

  • Each such return: ─ Costs $7.40 (processing + shipping) ─ Generates 6.2kg CO₂ ─ Contributes to 290,000 tons of landfill waste annually.


r/supplychain • • Jul 14 '22

Discussion Is there a gender Gap in Supply Chain? I’ve been Supply Chain for years and now transitioning to a new career. I’m curious on your thoughts as to why Supply Chain is predominantly male. Is it the lack of interest in the field? I’m leaving but entering another predominantly male career path so hmmm

5 Upvotes

r/supplychain • • Oct 04 '21

Discussion When will all these supply chain "experts" face career consequences for the failure of their systems?

81 Upvotes

I've had it with these shortages. Back when globalization was becoming a thing, these supply chain "experts" kept assuring the public that things would continue to run smoothly thanks to these advanced systems - JIT, lean, containerized shipping, and the like. Well look at where we are now. Our supply chains are in shambles thanks to all these single points of failure. The mass adoption of Just-in-Time has come at the cost of resiliency, and shortages of raw materials now have immediate and wide-ranging cascading effects throughout the entire fucking supply chain.

When will these so-called "experts" be held to account for the failure of their systems? If they were actually experts, their systems wouldn't be collapsing like this. I work in systems engineering; if I designed a system with this many single points of failure, I'd be out on my ass for gross incompetence.


r/supplychain • • Apr 04 '26

Discussion Would I be able to work in supply chains as a mentally ill 24 year old?

17 Upvotes

I’m 24 year old mentally ill male, how hard is supply chain?

Hello, I’m 24 and I was working on a degree on finance before I ended up dropping out, due to several factors, and 1 of them being my mental health. I’ve adhd, ocd, anxiety, depression, SzPD and possibly autism + I’m at the prodromal stage of schizophrenia. I’ve tried meds and therapy for 4 years to no avail.

I’ve struggled to keep even very simple jobs, simply getting out of bed, brushing my teeths, showering and eating and commuting take me out, and I was wondering if I truly tried hard and forced myself to work, would I be able to do supply chain?

Also, since I don’t have a degree yet, and I know experience is paramount in this field, are there any entry level degree less careers that I could start with to test my capacity?


r/supplychain • • Mar 06 '24

Discussion Are tattoos acceptable in the Supply Chain industry?

0 Upvotes

As someone who is pursuing a degree in Supply Chain I was curious to know how tattoos are viewed in this industry of work? I do have sleeves that stop at the wrist and many other tattoos that are not visible. Is it like most white collar careers where it’s better not to have any but as long as they can be covered it isn’t as big of a deal? Is it frowned upon if on a hot day I decide to wear a short sleeve button up? I pretty much accepted the fact I may always have to be covered up the moment I got tattoos.

Still I was curious as it would be nice to not have to be covered up 24/7 but it’s by no means something I’d complain about. Since I am trying to get my foot in the door at this stage in my life. I wouldn’t want my tattoos to be a hindrance as I recognize first impressions in many career fields can be a big deal. Is there anyone else in this industry that are also tattooed heavily or already were when they first started?


r/supplychain • • Mar 15 '20

We are witnessing the death of an industry

0 Upvotes

Technology is evolving rapidly and is set to radically change the world in many different ways. One of the new technologies that is set to change the world is autonomous trucking. Autonomous trucking has many benefits and will greatly reduce the cost of transport. But with any great change, there are winners and losers.

One of the biggest losers will be the rail industry. Why is this? Rail as a mode of transport today has certain advantages that allow it to remain relevant to shipers today. Some of these advantages include cheaper rates, and better capacity to move larger volumes. Some more environmentally conscious companies may choose rail for its comparitively lower emissions per ton mile. Rail is also has a much better public reputation as it is perceived to be safer in many cases. Unfortunately (for the railroads) these advantages are under severe threat, and barring any major change, railroads will be made almost completely obsolete in the coming decade. Autonomous trucks eliminate every advantage rail has over trucking, and highlight the disadvantages of rail. Lets look at the reasons why.

Railroads offer two main types of service, carload and intermodal. Carload is cheaper than truck by a bit of a margin in many cases. It mainly handles bulk loads. Unfortunately, carload is hampered by extremely poor, slow service and railroads commonly gouge customers. Carload is dying and has been declining for many years, even without the introduction of autonomous trucks, its days are numbered. Often a truck could do in a matter of days what a railroad could do in a matter of weeks. Cost savings aren't worth it if it grinds your business to a halt. Intermodal, both domestic and international, typically offers better service, but is still slower than trucks, and it only offers a 10-15% cost savings on average, with even that evaporates to almost nothing in a soft trucking market.

So what relevance does this have to our discussion? The reality is that rail exists today as a comprimise, with shippers trading speed, reliability and good service for a reduction in cost. But this will no longer need to be when autonomous trucks enter service. Why? One of the biggest costs in trucking today is drivers and driver related expenses. Eliminate or greatly reduce this and total costs drop massively. Automation will also allow for the optimisation of routes and driving to allow for reduced fuel consumption. This link here provides a lot of great information. Automation in the trucking industry will also be accompanied by electrification. The majority of freight trains are powered by diesel, so not only will electric trucks will not only eliminate the environmental arguement for choosing rail, but they will also make rail more environmentally damaging than trucking. Elon Musk put it best when he unveiled the Tesla Semi, it beats rail. As the CEO of an automaker, he knows what a nightmare dealing with railroads can be.

But as trucking does this, why can't railways adopt automation? The answer is simple, it is much harder to automate railways. The frequent encroachment on right of way, the massively greater stopping distance required in the event of an emergency and the significantly greater liability in the even of an accident will make it so that railways will almost certainly never automate. Even if they do, driver and driver related expenses make up a smaller percentage of rail's overall costs, so if railroads and trucking companies automated completely tommorow, trucks would still be at an advantage.

So what does the future hold? I generally predict rail will go the way of coastal shipping in the US, with ton-miles likely being slashed by more than half in the decade following the commercial introduction of autonomous trucks. By the 2040s/2050s, I would be surprised if there are any railroads still in operation. That is not a bad thing. Railroads are an old technology from the 1830s, bound to a fixed right of way that can no longer serve shipper's needs. It will be like the end of Sears. We may have some fond memories of the chain, but the rise of more specialized retailers and online shopping have killed it off and provide a much better shopping experience in its place. Railroade are on the way out, and that is not a bad thing. In the end, we will all benefit from the advantages autonomous trucks bring.

More good reading:

Autonomous Trucking Company TuSimple Doubles Weekly Runs for UPS

Driverless trucks being tested right now on public roads

Missouri company to deploy 62 two-truck autonomous convoys on existing freight routes

Tesla Semis are cheaper than rail enough of the time to reshape ground freight