r/supermicro • u/BestestBeekeeper • 2d ago
Help / Troubleshooting Super Micro JBOD Fan Control Confirmation
Hello all, I just wanted to confirm my understanding of how this system works to be correct before moving forward.
I have two SuperMicro SC836 JBOD enclosures each with 15 HDD's that spend 95% of their time spun down. Currently I have the fan settings under 'Optimal' for the lowest power consumption.
Given that the drives are spun down so often, I was curious if the fan speeds could be lowered even further, but in my research it seems the that going below 30% has the tendency to stall the fans, leading to a perceived failure on the BMC and forcing everything to go to 100%. Through ipmitools it seems to can adjust this failure threshold to avoid that issue, but I dont know if that is advisable given the stalling problem.
I'm trying to discern how best to move forward here in my extreme ultra overengineering of this system lol.
Do I:
Utilize the ipmitools program to customize fan control further and to even lower speeds, and just monitor/assess if the stalling is a common issue and if it is self addressed or not?
Attempt to customize the fan control so that the fans simply turn off completely when all disks are showing spun down, and switch back to the 'optimal' setting when any disk on the enclosure spins up?
Buy replacement fans that fit the supermicro chassis an are specifically designed for lower rpm and are more efficient for my use case.
Appreciate any thoughts or input from the community on my best option here.